Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Feminist historian on tantric kali sadhana

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Namaste.

 

Excerpt from our review of the book --

Renowned Goddess of Desire; Women, Sex and Speech in Tantra

by Loriliai Biernacki

 

 

Do tantric writings glorify women as embodied divinity? Or do they instead treat

women as a resource for the male practitioner? The answers to these two

questions are yes and yes, according to feminist historian Loriliai Biernacki.

Her point is that not all tantras are the same - they're 'by no means uniform in

their attitude towards women...' (p 30)

 

Biernacki indicates (pp 8-9) that she was favorably surprised by what is said

about women in a particular group of Sanskrit texts, which in her view express

'a particular strand of Tantra' (p10). Texts of this strand include the

_Brihannila Tantra_, which is the primary text used in Biernacki's study. These

texts describe a way of worshipping and living which is called in Sanskrit the

_Kali sadhana_; or, as Bieracki translates, the 'Kali Practice'...(p 31)

 

According to this particular strand of Tantra, women as a group are powerful

beings, with natural aptitude for use of mantras either to bless or curse. (p

45) They can be excellent gurus. (p 46) Men in the path of Kali Practice are

instructed to honour women -- all women, regardless of their age, or appearance,

or ancestry, or character -- to honour women not only in ritual, but also in

daily life...

 

 

 

The rest of this book review can be found at

http://home.pacific.net.au/~ferment/bier.html

 

Om Santih

Colin of Ferment

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Howdy Colin. That was a informative review. Loriliai's book seems like a worthwhile read, but i was more interested in the Tantric texts you mentioned. It is a good 'to read' list if they are available. I finally had a good look at the ferment website the other day and saw the photos. Funny thing is people never look like you would imagine them to, which is probably a good thing. Its actually quite well set up and generally good for a gander. Otherwise not a lot out of the ordinary happening down here. One question, me and my friends from Esoteric Bookshop in Murrumbeena were discussing the whole Ouija board thang and came to a concensus that they are too unpredictable and sometimes not safe to use. Now Spellcraft have just included one in the latest edition with a how to use guide. Wot do u think about this? Is it Ok or irresponsible, given that there are much safer methods of divination available. Anyways thanks again, Cheers, Blessed Be and Om

Kali-ma.colin777au <colinr wrote: Namaste.Excerpt from our review of the book --Renowned Goddess of Desire; Women, Sex and Speech in Tantra by Loriliai BiernackiDo tantric writings glorify women as embodied divinity? Or do they instead treat women as a resource for the male practitioner? The answers to these two questions are yes and yes, according to feminist historian Loriliai Biernacki. Her point is that not all tantras are the same - they're 'by no means uniform in their attitude towards women...'

(p 30) Biernacki indicates (pp 8-9) that she was favorably surprised by what is said about women in a particular group of Sanskrit texts, which in her view express 'a particular strand of Tantra' (p10). Texts of this strand include the _Brihannila Tantra_, which is the primary text used in Biernacki's study. These texts describe a way of worshipping and living which is called in Sanskrit the _Kali sadhana_; or, as Bieracki translates, the 'Kali Practice'...(p 31)According to this particular strand of Tantra, women as a group are powerful beings, with natural aptitude for use of mantras either to bless or curse. (p 45) They can be excellent gurus. (p 46) Men in the path of Kali Practice are instructed to honour women -- all women, regardless of their age, or appearance, or ancestry, or character -- to honour women not only in ritual, but also in daily life...The rest of this book review can be found athttp://home.pacific.net.au/~ferment/bier.htmlOm SantihColin of Ferment

 

Find a better answer, faster with the new 7 Search - Start Here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Kali_Ma , Shane Gray <geminiacal999 wrote:

>

> Howdy Colin. That was a informative review. Loriliai's book seems like a

worthwhile read, but i was more interested in the Tantric texts you mentioned.

It is a good 'to read' list if they are available. I finally had a good look at

the ferment website the other day and saw the photos. Funny thing is people

never look like you would imagine them to, which is probably a good thing. Its

actually quite well set up and generally good for a gander.

 

Howdy Shane. I wonder how you imagined we'd look?

 

Anyway, thanks for your comment on the website. I will put a copy of what

you've written on one of our feedback sections, assuming that's ok with you.

 

Regarding availability of the Tantric texts mentioned in my review... An easy

one to get hold of is the Devi Mahatmyam. You can get an inexpensive copy of

Jagadiswarananda's translation (which is quite literal and reliable) through the

Vedanta Book Agency in Sydney. Their address is PO Box 817, Strathfield NSW 2135

or you can phone them on 02 9745 4320.

 

Woodroffe's book Hymns to the Goddess is obtainable as a paperback through

Amazon at

http://www.amazon.com/Hymns-Goddess-Hymn-Kali-Woodroffe/dp/8185988161

 

The Kularnava Tantra is a slightly trickier question. There is a Motilal

Banarsidass edition by Avalon, Pandit and Vidyaratna, which does _not_ provide

the full text in English. What it does contain is

* an _abridged_ English translation by M.P.Pandit,

* a short discussion of the text by Woodroffe,

* the complete text in Sanskrit

You can get it thru Amazon at

http://www.amazon.com/Kularnava-Tantra-Arthur-Avalon/dp/8120809734

 

An apparently complete English translation of the Kularnava Tantra (with

accompanying Sanskrit text) has been made by Ram Kumar Rai and published by

Prachya Prakashan of Varanasi. Haven't actually read this one myself, so cannot

comment on how satisfactory the translation is. The following website provides

information and a means to buy a copy

http://www.exoticindiaart.com/book/details/IDI580/

 

I don't think many of the other tantras mentioned by Biernacki are available in

English. Except the comparatively short Yoni Tantra, of which there is a

translation on the web at

http://www.religiousworlds.com/mandalam/ftp/yoni.pdf

 

> Otherwise not a lot out of the ordinary happening down here. One question, me

and my friends from Esoteric Bookshop in Murrumbeena were discussing the whole

Ouija board thang and came to a concensus that they are too unpredictable and

sometimes not safe to use. Now Spellcraft have just included one in the latest

edition with a how to use guide. Wot do u think about this? Is it Ok or

irresponsible, given that there are much safer methods of divination available.

 

Interesting question. I've neither used an ouija board, nor done much research

on them; but I do know they have been around for a while, which suggests to me

that there's a constituency of people who find them useful. I have also heard

anecdotes about people getting seriously troubled by messages that reached them

via an ouija board... Then again, haven't people also been troubled by messages

that reached them through the internet? Does that mean we shouldn't use the

internet?

 

>given that there are much safer methods of divination available.

 

What forms of divination would you recommend?

 

May the Goddess bless your path,

Om Shantih

Colin

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Hey colin thanks for the reply. Its funny i had this impression of you being one of those business, conservative looking or sort of nerdy academic pagans with glasses and stuff. Bet you find that funny. Ta for the info on the tantras. My preferred form of divination is the pendulum which is simply a medium through which My higher self/Kali can give me guidance. And yes i have heard of Pendulums being hijacked by mischevious spiritual beings but i've had nothing but a genuine feeling of connection when using it and Ma' has actually encouraged me to use it to chat with her, i believe as a means of connection as much as providing me answers to my questions no matter how inane they sometimes are. I've not really had much experience with Tarot, runes and other forms of divination, but in regards to Ouija i have heard of rather disturbing accounts of people attracting unwanted attention. Having said that practitioners of Voodoo and similar traditions have been using them for

yonks and seem to know how to deal with them and the spirits they contact through them. I just think that coz u have no control of who your contacting that they are tools best left to those folk with a lot of spirit experience. Other forms of div. seem to have less problems in this regard, which i understand from having discussions with Taroists etc. Anyway bye for now, B B and Om Kali-Ma, Shane.colin777au <colinr wrote: Kali_Ma , Shane Gray

<geminiacal999 wrote: > > Howdy Colin. That was a informative review. Loriliai's book seems like a worthwhile read, but i was more interested in the Tantric texts you mentioned. It is a good 'to read' list if they are available. I finally had a good look at the ferment website the other day and saw the photos. Funny thing is people never look like you would imagine them to, which is probably a good thing. Its actually quite well set up and generally good for a gander. Howdy Shane. I wonder how you imagined we'd look? Anyway, thanks for your comment on the website. I will put a copy of what you've written on one of our feedback sections, assuming that's ok with you. Regarding availability of the Tantric texts mentioned in my review... An easy one to get hold of is the Devi Mahatmyam. You can get an inexpensive copy of Jagadiswarananda's translation (which is quite literal and reliable) through the Vedanta Book

Agency in Sydney. Their address is PO Box 817, Strathfield NSW 2135 or you can phone them on 02 9745 4320. Woodroffe's book Hymns to the Goddess is obtainable as a paperback through Amazon at http://www.amazon.com/Hymns-Goddess-Hymn-Kali-Woodroffe/dp/8185988161 The Kularnava Tantra is a slightly trickier question. There is a Motilal Banarsidass edition by Avalon, Pandit and Vidyaratna, which does _not_ provide the full text in English. What it does contain is * an _abridged_ English translation by M.P.Pandit, * a short discussion of the text by Woodroffe, * the complete text in Sanskrit You can get it thru Amazon at http://www.amazon.com/Kularnava-Tantra-Arthur-Avalon/dp/8120809734 An apparently complete English

translation of the Kularnava Tantra (with accompanying Sanskrit text) has been made by Ram Kumar Rai and published by Prachya Prakashan of Varanasi. Haven't actually read this one myself, so cannot comment on how satisfactory the translation is. The following website provides information and a means to buy a copy http://www.exoticindiaart.com/book/details/IDI580/ I don't think many of the other tantras mentioned by Biernacki are available in English. Except the comparatively short Yoni Tantra, of which there is a translation on the web at http://www.religiousworlds.com/mandalam/ftp/yoni.pdf > Otherwise not a lot out of the ordinary happening down here. One question, me and my friends from Esoteric Bookshop in Murrumbeena were discussing the whole Ouija board thang and came to a

concensus that they are too unpredictable and sometimes not safe to use. Now Spellcraft have just included one in the latest edition with a how to use guide. Wot do u think about this? Is it Ok or irresponsible, given that there are much safer methods of divination available. Interesting question. I've neither used an ouija board, nor done much research on them; but I do know they have been around for a while, which suggests to me that there's a constituency of people who find them useful. I have also heard anecdotes about people getting seriously troubled by messages that reached them via an ouija board... Then again, haven't people also been troubled by messages that reached them through the internet? Does that mean we shouldn't use the internet? >given that there are much safer methods of divination available. What forms of divination would you recommend? May the Goddess bless your path, Om Shantih Colin

 

Find a better answer, faster with the new 7 Search - Start Here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Hey Shane.

 

>Its funny i had this impression of you being one of those business,

conservative looking or sort of nerdy academic pagans with glasses and stuff.

Bet you find that funny.

 

You're right, in a way -- I do spend a lot of time reading, not to mention

writing. Haven't had to get glasses yet, but quite likely will one day.

 

>My preferred form of divination is the pendulum which is simply a medium

through which My higher self/Kali can give me guidance.

 

I like the way you expressed that. Perhaps there is a sense in which each of us

has his/her own source of guidance, as is suggested by the phrase 'My higher

self'...

 

Reflecting on my own experiences and those of others, I've come to think that

Kali has a different face or voice - a different aspect - for each of Her

mystics. The Sanskrit term ishta devata comes to mind...

 

How do you see the relation between this form of guidance and the thought

processes of your everyday self? Does divination replace thinking, or do they

work together?

 

Om Shantih

Colin

 

 

Kali_Ma , Shane Gray <geminiacal999 wrote:

>

> Hey colin thanks for the reply. Its funny i had this impression of you being

one of those business, conservative looking or sort of nerdy academic pagans

with glasses and stuff. Bet you find that funny. Ta for the info on the tantras.

My preferred form of divination is the pendulum which is simply a medium through

which My higher self/Kali can give me guidance. And yes i have heard of

Pendulums being hijacked by mischevious spiritual beings but i've had nothing

but a genuine feeling of connection when using it and Ma' has actually

encouraged me to use it to chat with her, i believe as a means of connection as

much as providing me answers to my questions no matter how inane they sometimes

are. I've not really had much experience with Tarot, runes and other forms of

divination, but in regards to Ouija i have heard of rather disturbing accounts

of people attracting unwanted attention. Having said that practitioners of

Voodoo and similar traditions have been using them for

> yonks and seem to know how to deal with them and the spirits they contact

through them. I just think that coz u have no control of who your contacting

that they are tools best left to those folk with a lot of spirit experience.

Other forms of div. seem to have less problems in this regard, which i

understand from having discussions with Taroists etc. Anyway bye for now, B B

and Om Kali-Ma, Shane.

>

> colin777au <colinr wrote: --- In

Kali_Ma , Shane Gray <geminiacal999@> wrote:

> >

> > Howdy Colin. That was a informative review. Loriliai's book seems like a

worthwhile read, but i was more interested in the Tantric texts you mentioned.

It is a good 'to read' list if they are available. I finally had a good look at

the ferment website the other day and saw the photos. Funny thing is people

never look like you would imagine them to, which is probably a good thing. Its

actually quite well set up and generally good for a gander.

>

> Howdy Shane. I wonder how you imagined we'd look?

>

> Anyway, thanks for your comment on the website. I will put a copy of what

you've written on one of our feedback sections, assuming that's ok with you.

>

> Regarding availability of the Tantric texts mentioned in my review... An easy

one to get hold of is the Devi Mahatmyam. You can get an inexpensive copy of

Jagadiswarananda's translation (which is quite literal and reliable) through the

Vedanta Book Agency in Sydney. Their address is PO Box 817, Strathfield NSW 2135

or you can phone them on 02 9745 4320.

>

> Woodroffe's book Hymns to the Goddess is obtainable as a paperback through

Amazon at

> http://www.amazon.com/Hymns-Goddess-Hymn-Kali-Woodroffe/dp/8185988161

>

> The Kularnava Tantra is a slightly trickier question. There is a Motilal

Banarsidass edition by Avalon, Pandit and Vidyaratna, which does _not_ provide

the full text in English. What it does contain is

> * an _abridged_ English translation by M.P.Pandit,

> * a short discussion of the text by Woodroffe,

> * the complete text in Sanskrit

> You can get it thru Amazon at

> http://www.amazon.com/Kularnava-Tantra-Arthur-Avalon/dp/8120809734

>

> An apparently complete English translation of the Kularnava Tantra (with

accompanying Sanskrit text) has been made by Ram Kumar Rai and published by

Prachya Prakashan of Varanasi. Haven't actually read this one myself, so cannot

comment on how satisfactory the translation is. The following website provides

information and a means to buy a copy

> http://www.exoticindiaart.com/book/details/IDI580/

>

> I don't think many of the other tantras mentioned by Biernacki are available

in English. Except the comparatively short Yoni Tantra, of which there is a

translation on the web at

> http://www.religiousworlds.com/mandalam/ftp/yoni.pdf

>

> > Otherwise not a lot out of the ordinary happening down here. One question,

me and my friends from Esoteric Bookshop in Murrumbeena were discussing the

whole Ouija board thang and came to a concensus that they are too unpredictable

and sometimes not safe to use. Now Spellcraft have just included one in the

latest edition with a how to use guide. Wot do u think about this? Is it Ok or

irresponsible, given that there are much safer methods of divination available.

>

> Interesting question. I've neither used an ouija board, nor done much

research on them; but I do know they have been around for a while, which

suggests to me that there's a constituency of people who find them useful. I

have also heard anecdotes about people getting seriously troubled by messages

that reached them via an ouija board... Then again, haven't people also been

troubled by messages that reached them through the internet? Does that mean we

shouldn't use the internet?

>

> >given that there are much safer methods of divination available.

>

> What forms of divination would you recommend?

>

> May the Goddess bless your path,

> Om Shantih

> Colin

 

> Find a better answer, faster with the new 7 Search - Start Here.

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Hey Colin how goes thangs.1) Div. does not replace thinking, well for me it doesn't. I'm sure that here are folks out there who use Div. techniques as a quick fix/answer type of thing but i would consider that more then a tad negligent.In fact my Pendulum divining is as much a way for me to maintain a close relationship with Ma' as it is a Q+A session. Sometimes i get answers i don't expect which spurs me into thinking about my questions in different ways. Some of my Q's are often trivial or at least not uber-deep and mystic in nature and Ma' is just as happy to answer those Q's as she is the more esoteric stuff. 2) I reckon it makes plenty sense that Divinity presents itself in a manner that suits the induvidual: what better way to encourage a closer personnel relationship. 3) My Higher self is that part of me which knows duality not, and is therefore Kali: Undifferentiated and absolute. 4) Did u ever think the idea of us as manifested divinity

worshipping divinity was funny and a bit narcissistic? Pieces of God worshipping Itself, i love that idea. 5) My house has been recieving a unusual amount of spirit activity of late which i div'ed about and its got somethin to do with Ma's energies. Do u get alot of spookies visitin u? Thats it for now: B.B, Om Kali and Byyeee for now, Shane.colin777au <colinr wrote: Hey Shane. >Its funny i had this impression of you being one of those business, conservative looking or sort of

nerdy academic pagans with glasses and stuff. Bet you find that funny. You're right, in a way -- I do spend a lot of time reading, not to mention writing. Haven't had to get glasses yet, but quite likely will one day. >My preferred form of divination is the pendulum which is simply a medium through which My higher self/Kali can give me guidance. I like the way you expressed that. Perhaps there is a sense in which each of us has his/her own source of guidance, as is suggested by the phrase 'My higher self'... Reflecting on my own experiences and those of others, I've come to think that Kali has a different face or voice - a different aspect - for each of Her mystics. The Sanskrit term ishta devata comes to mind... How do you see the relation between this form of guidance and the thought processes of your everyday self? Does divination replace thinking, or do they work together? Om

Shantih Colin Kali_Ma , Shane Gray <geminiacal999 wrote: > > Hey colin thanks for the reply. Its funny i had this impression of you being one of those business, conservative looking or sort of nerdy academic pagans with glasses and stuff. Bet you find that funny. Ta for the info on the tantras. My preferred form of divination is the pendulum which is simply a medium through which My higher self/Kali can give me guidance. And yes i have heard of Pendulums being hijacked by mischevious spiritual beings but i've had nothing but a genuine feeling of connection when using it and Ma' has actually encouraged me to use it to chat with her, i believe as a means of connection as much as providing me answers to my questions no matter how inane they sometimes are. I've not really had much experience with Tarot, runes and other forms of divination, but in regards to

Ouija i have heard of rather disturbing accounts of people attracting unwanted attention. Having said that practitioners of Voodoo and similar traditions have been using them for > yonks and seem to know how to deal with them and the spirits they contact through them. I just think that coz u have no control of who your contacting that they are tools best left to those folk with a lot of spirit experience. Other forms of div. seem to have less problems in this regard, which i understand from having discussions with Taroists etc. Anyway bye for now, B B and Om Kali-Ma, Shane. > > colin777au <colinr wrote: Kali_Ma , Shane Gray <geminiacal999@> wrote: > > > > Howdy Colin. That was a informative review. Loriliai's book seems like a worthwhile read, but i was more interested in the Tantric texts you mentioned. It

is a good 'to read' list if they are available. I finally had a good look at the ferment website the other day and saw the photos. Funny thing is people never look like you would imagine them to, which is probably a good thing. Its actually quite well set up and generally good for a gander. > > Howdy Shane. I wonder how you imagined we'd look? > > Anyway, thanks for your comment on the website. I will put a copy of what you've written on one of our feedback sections, assuming that's ok with you. > > Regarding availability of the Tantric texts mentioned in my review... An easy one to get hold of is the Devi Mahatmyam. You can get an inexpensive copy of Jagadiswarananda's translation (which is quite literal and reliable) through the Vedanta Book Agency in Sydney. Their address is PO Box 817, Strathfield NSW 2135 or you can phone them on 02 9745 4320. > > Woodroffe's book Hymns to the Goddess is

obtainable as a paperback through Amazon at > http://www.amazon.com/Hymns-Goddess-Hymn-Kali-Woodroffe/dp/8185988161 > > The Kularnava Tantra is a slightly trickier question. There is a Motilal Banarsidass edition by Avalon, Pandit and Vidyaratna, which does _not_ provide the full text in English. What it does contain is > * an _abridged_ English translation by M.P.Pandit, > * a short discussion of the text by Woodroffe, > * the complete text in Sanskrit > You can get it thru Amazon at > http://www.amazon.com/Kularnava-Tantra-Arthur-Avalon/dp/8120809734 > > An apparently complete English translation of the Kularnava Tantra (with accompanying Sanskrit text) has been made by Ram Kumar Rai and

published by Prachya Prakashan of Varanasi. Haven't actually read this one myself, so cannot comment on how satisfactory the translation is. The following website provides information and a means to buy a copy > http://www.exoticindiaart.com/book/details/IDI580/ > > I don't think many of the other tantras mentioned by Biernacki are available in English. Except the comparatively short Yoni Tantra, of which there is a translation on the web at > http://www.religiousworlds.com/mandalam/ftp/yoni.pdf > > > Otherwise not a lot out of the ordinary happening down here. One question, me and my friends from Esoteric Bookshop in Murrumbeena were discussing the whole Ouija board thang and came to a concensus that they are too unpredictable and sometimes not safe to

use. Now Spellcraft have just included one in the latest edition with a how to use guide. Wot do u think about this? Is it Ok or irresponsible, given that there are much safer methods of divination available. > > Interesting question. I've neither used an ouija board, nor done much research on them; but I do know they have been around for a while, which suggests to me that there's a constituency of people who find them useful. I have also heard anecdotes about people getting seriously troubled by messages that reached them via an ouija board... Then again, haven't people also been troubled by messages that reached them through the internet? Does that mean we shouldn't use the internet? > > >given that there are much safer methods of divination available. > > What forms of divination would you recommend? > > May the Goddess bless your path, > Om Shantih > Colin > >

> > > > > > Find a better answer, faster with the new 7 Search - Start Here. >

 

Win a MacBook Air or iPod touch with 7- Find out more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...