Guest guest Posted March 28, 2009 Report Share Posted March 28, 2009 Dear SrimanI have not been giving my opinion, rather I'm simply repeating the big picture of Vedanta from Srimad Bhagavatam and Bhagavad-Gita. You want answers direct from God, then read Gita and listen to the questions and answers between Arjuna (you) and God (Krishna). You can read the Gita Press version, or on line here http://www.asitis.com/ Please take your answers straight from the mouth of God, "Sri Bhagavan-uvacha..."As to the destinations of other saints you mention, some of whom are Advaita-vadins, and they would merge in Brahma-jyoti if perfected, others are devotees who are Dvaita-vadins, and if perfect they would enter the Spiritual World. Just as, from here we know NOT what is in Spiritual World, so from there we know NOT what is material world.Heaven and Hell are in the Material Existence and both are temporary.Bhagavad-Gita is the supreme PROOF of every Hindu...Y/s,RichardRichard Shaw Brown, PGMusician, Designer, Gemologist & Authorwww.richardshawbrown.com--- On Sat, 28/3/09, kishore kishore <mydearindian wrote:kishore kishore <mydearindianRe: My question still asking me..do u have answer?."Richard Shaw Brown" <rsbj66Saturday, 28 March, 2009, 12:57 AMDear Borther Richard,  Thanks for your kind response.  Richard, With God blessings I am sure you might have got strong evidence about vaikuntha. That's why you are so confident and sure on what you are claiming/beleiving and its existence. However, to get that confidence I must have evidence. My “will†alone can’t help I need God’s wish too. Please pray to God on behalf of me to send a message to me.  Can you provide me any strong evidence and prove it that those who ever did sadhana is there in vaikuntha? Do you know where the soul of Ramana Maharshi is now? Are you sure that he is in Vaikuntha only? Any evidence can be shown? Do you know where Mother Teresa soul is? Is she in heaven or hell or in vaikuntha? Do you know where Lord Buddha’s place is? Is he in vaikuntha or in is he in material world? Or is he in heaven? Where is the evidence? Can show me where swami Vivekananda soul is residing?  where is the evidence for vaikuntha?  Richard, I completely agree with you that Sadhana or Tapssu is the only way to enter into Spiritual world... However, to know the infinity I must sacrifice all material interests and should spend much time in sadhana. I am okay to do it. But you are telling that after entering into vaikuntha we will forget material world and we will not be getting any queries on God. Well, may be vaikuntha is his own another world where we will be speechless by looking at God  Richard, I am ready to sacrifice anything for God. I must talk to him. This is my life ambition. However, I know that it is difficult path. Before I get into it I must have answers for all these questions. Life is very precious. Without strong evidence I can’t choose any path blindly. I believe in God’s existence.  I spoke with many yogis who claim that they daily interact with God. I asked them is that a two way interaction with God or one-way. They told it is twoway. Then I requested them to talk to God and put across my issue before God. I mean I requested them to talk to God and ask “why did God think of running this show which is infinity/eternal? I told them I would meet them tomorrow morning and be ready with the answer. They said something senseless and escaped from my question. Some told me that I have to get that answer myself and they can’t ask God my question. Then how can I believe their words. When they say that they talk to angels or Gods then they must be able to ask my question also. Am I wrong?  Have a nice & productive day, With Best wishes, M.kishore.  If you don't like to read this E-mail then please mention in subject line "REMOVE".--- On Fri, 27/3/09, Richard Shaw Brown <rsbj66 wrote: Richard Shaw Brown <rsbj66Re: My question still asking me..do u have answer?."kishore kishore" <mydearindianCc: "Sacred Group Group" <sacred-objects >Friday, 27 March, 2009, 2:34 PM Dear Kishore,Bhagavan and His unlimited shaktis, such as spiritual shakti (Vaikuntha), his jiva shakti (us), and his material shakti (Maya) have always been in existance. There was never a beginning. It is sanatan, always like this. If there is no beginning, then where is the question of WHY? The only question of WHY is why are YOU here? You have the power to choose Sadhana and exit this maya at death. So ask yourself WHY you are here?Y/s,RichardRichard Shaw Brown, PGMusician, Designer, Gemologist & Authorwww.richardshawbrown.com--- On Fri, 27/3/09, kishore kishore <mydearindian wrote: kishore kishore <mydearindianMy question still asking me..do u have answer?.rsbj66Date: Friday, 27 March, 2009, 4:36 AM Dear Brother Richard,  Again my same old question is hitting my mind?   Please advice me a divine living person to clear my query. If you can clear it then it would be great otherwise introduce me a living saint who can clear my question.  Below is my same old question.  Bhagavat Gita, Bible, The Prophet and all other sacred books of all different religions did not tell why God wanted to create this universe?  In GITA Krishna says that he does not have starting and ending. He says he is everything. He says he only knows Himself. Why is he that much complicated? What is his origin.  Without knowing why GOD is created all these activities how can I accept him as God? I know that I am making a sensible question. If you think my question is non-sense then kindly let me know in which way it is non-sense.  In King of Baharat story Bharat very sweetly explained that material sense is non-sense and he explained the importance of soul. But he did not explain why Lord created people and universe and what is his motto behind this universe. I appreciate Bharat for knowing God. But did God tell Bharat anything about his origin?  If your answer is -à God created this universe for his own happiness then how can I understand him? If creating a false game is his happieness then how can I pray him and in which way I must understand him.  1 Why Arjuna did not ask Lord Krishna about the origin of Supreme Lord? Supreme Lord told that he does not have any origin and Arjuna simply agreed? Well again why did he agree on it?  2 According to Bible Satan was there when God was there but god did not kill the satan because he wants people to choose God with free will. I don’t understand this. If God killed Satan then every one would know only God. Just to recognize him he did not kill Satan. What kind of plan it is and why? No one knows. Is it not a selfish plan to seek reorganization? I am not humanizing God here but still why God intended t create it.  3 Lord Buddha realized God and he told about different karmas. He says if anyone does good karma then for them there is a separate world and if anyone does more good karma then there is a world of angels like that he kept on explaining his knowledge. But sad thing is he also did not explain why this many things created by God and what is his motto. He claims that he got enlightenment then why did he not tell about that secret.  4 Ramana Maharshi told one must ask to oneself “ Nan evearu†in tamil. I mean he says that one must ask “who am I “. If really I come to know that I am a soul then also my question remains same. What is the need to create it (soul) ...Ramana Maharshi did not tell and passed away, why?    I read Bahagavat Gita several Times. Lord Krishna says that he is the main origin for everything and he says he does everything. Even a single sloka of Gita did not answer my question. My question is why Lord Krishna created all these things and what is the benefit he is going to get by creating all these things.  God did not tell in any scripture why God thought to create this universe but he keep telling in all scriptures that he is everything.  And the saints who got real knowledge of God also did not tell and did not ask why their God had created this universe, instead of that everyone realized him and praised him only.  I agree that God is very good and sweet. Do you know any scripture in this world which can answer my question?  If you did not understand my question then kindly ask me again. I will try to explain my question again. Have a nice & productive day, With Best wishes, M.kishore.  If you don't like to read this E-mail then please mention in subject line "REMOVE". Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Invite them now. New Email addresses available on Get the Email name you've always wanted on the new @ymail and @rocketmail.Hurry before someone else does! Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Invite them now. Get your new Email address! Grab the Email name you've always wanted before someone else does! size=1> Get your new Email address! Grab the Email name you've always wanted before someone else does! Get your preferred Email name! Now you can @ymail.com and @rocketmail.com. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.