Guest guest Posted March 4, 2007 Report Share Posted March 4, 2007 Hi Raj, I think if you want to credit this chart you'll have to bring out the astrological and historical justifications in detail, the significant events, and provide predictions as done recently in the 21 Cn chart. My two cents: 1) the natal promise of this chart does not match the USA, the most powerful, influential and wealthy nation in the world. A quick inspection of the strength of the Sun, and exact affliction to SLP's in this chart is enough to raise both eyebrows. Additionally Mars in H12 will take the entity to conflicts, but ultimately losses in/due to battles. There would also be constant unrest within the land with alot of violent, explosive natural disasters, constantly. Also the nature of the Cp ascendant - the USA is not a servant of any nation. These are just a few points. The character does not match. 2) In order to move forward on a merger between companies, you have to sign the initial paperwork. The time you start this determines how well the merger process go. The deal isn't done, i.e. the new company isn't created, born, until the final signatures are on by the key parties. Historically, this is parallel and should be given due consideration. I hope this helps. Best regards, Vyas Munidas PS: You should be using the LMT instead of -5 - " rkchadha " <rkctech <SAMVA > Sunday, March 04, 2007 9:06 PM New USA chart proposal Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 pm. Yet I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel strongly about. I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was established the USA became a country of group of states united under one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) when the articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am proposing for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains the character of USA and some of the important historical events. Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual pursuits and scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of justice and liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, in the martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. Together these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the Sun-sign is Scorpio. Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms that both Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken place when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn rising chart. I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look at this chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a final chart for USA. Thanks Raj Chadha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2007 Report Share Posted March 4, 2007 Hello dear Mr. Chadha, When we are searching the truth one has to be objective in one's analysis/approach without being attached to any of the charts including the one proposed by the person his/her ownself. Natal promise in the chart is first of all important and then the transit influences and the sub periods help up in identifying the results. I personally and others will certainly explore the truth in the chart proposed by you in comparison to the proposals already with us. Best wishes. - " rkchadha " <rkctech <SAMVA > Monday, March 05, 2007 7:36 AM New USA chart proposal | Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: | | There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an | appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels | strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 pm. Yet | I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which | contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel | strongly about. | | I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of | 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification | of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in | fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was | established the USA became a country of group of states united under | one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) when the | articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, | Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical | events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is | almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am proposing | for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the | elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains | the character of USA and some of the important historical events. | | | Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The | placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra | shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual pursuits and | scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of justice and | liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, in the | martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and | history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on | Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance | accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. Together | these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and | conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities | and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows | its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more | powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the | Sun-sign is Scorpio. | | Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, | 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and | MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms that both | Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer | 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken place | when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn | rising chart. | | I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to | 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look at this | chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a | final chart for USA. | | Thanks | | Raj Chadha | | | | | | | Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2007 Report Share Posted March 5, 2007 Hello Raj, Just a few days ago you suggested the following: " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA because the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and many others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 and not July 4... " Now you propose: " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. " Please note that I have been looking at different charts for many years, including studying their natal promise and making predictions. So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More recently, I have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB on this list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA chart. As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a given chart, it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is retained, the emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must develop a minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are doing this in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and accurate predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not enough. If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the work, including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be pleased to consider that offering. Best wishes, Thor SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech wrote: > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 pm. Yet > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel > strongly about. > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in > fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was > established the USA became a country of group of states united under > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) when the > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am proposing > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains > the character of USA and some of the important historical events. > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual pursuits and > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of justice and > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, in the > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. Together > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms that both > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken place > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn > rising chart. > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look at this > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a > final chart for USA. > > Thanks > > Raj Chadha > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2007 Report Share Posted March 5, 2007 My dear Raj November 15, 1777 is the date marking the birth of the TEXT of the first U.S.A. constitution, that constitution of March 1, 1781 known as the Aticles of Confederation. The proposed radix for this 1777 date may be valid for constitutional questions where conflicting textual interpretations were in dispute, during the era from November 1777 until July 1788. But that is all. The TEXT matters, of course. But only as a TEXT. This first TEXT died in Congress on July 2, 1788, at a few minutes past 3:00 p.m. Dead as a door nail, as the saying goes in Maryland. We shouldn't confuse it with the government enacted under the first constitution, on March 1, 1781, nor should we confuse it with the date that the UNION formed, which union sponsored that first government, AND ALSO sponsored the second, current, government, the "federal government" formed on April 30, 1789. The UNION was born on February 2, 1781. This same UNION is still in existence today. This union is older than the federal government, because it gave birth to the federal government [As parent to child. And, indeed, a very naughty child it has become, as judged by President Bush's nefarious efforts to turn over things throughout the Middle East, and alienate loyal American patriots such as this writer.] With my best wishes, John cosmologer <cosmologer wrote: Hello Raj,Just a few days ago you suggested the following:"In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA becausethe country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and manyothers agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 and notJuly 4..."Now you propose:"Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental Congress."Please note that I have been looking at different charts for manyyears, including studying their natal promise and making predictions.So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More recently, Ihave enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB on thislist with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA chart. As for your claim that I have "emotional attachment" to a given chart,it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is retained, theemotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must develop aminimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find themotivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are doing thisin our spare time. So, the process is always objective and accuratepredictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not enough.If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the work,including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make thepredictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be pleased toconsider that offering. Best wishes,ThorSAMVA , "rkchadha" <rkctech wrote:>> Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others:> > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an> appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels> strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 pm. Yet> I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which> contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel> strongly about.> > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of> 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification> of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in> fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was> established the USA became a country of group of states united under> one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) when the> articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York,> Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical> events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is> almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am proposing> for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the> elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains> the character of USA and some of the important historical events.> > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The> placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra> shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual pursuits and> scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of justice and> liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, in the> martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and> history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on> Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance> accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. Together> these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and> conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities> and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows> its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more> powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the> Sun-sign is Scorpio.> > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001,> 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and> MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms that both> Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer> 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken place> when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn> rising chart.> > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to> 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look at this> chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a> final chart for USA.> > Thanks> > Raj Chadha> Bored stiff? Loosen up...Download and play hundreds of games for free on Games. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2007 Report Share Posted March 5, 2007 Dear Raj Chadha, As Mr. John TWB said: November 15, 1777 is the date marking the birth of the TEXT of the first U.S.A. constitution, that constitution of March 1, 1781 known as the Articles of Confederation. It will be interesting to see how it is expressed in the US rectified chart. The operational dasha was MO/MO/RA/KE/JU. Except for transit Rahu, all the remaining operational planets were well placed in transit, and all of them are connected with the H9/H3 axis. The natal Moon (Administration), L9 (Law, Constitution) in H3 (writing), was strong in transit and over MEP7 (cooperative bodies representing the people in toto like Parliament, Senate, Congress, etc.) closely aspecting MEP1 ( general condition of the country as a whole). Natal Rahu (transformation, manipulation) is placed exactly over MEP9 (Law, Constitution), disposed by the Moon. In transit, Rahu was under the close aspect of transit Mars (action, significator of H3) and over natal Sun (the Government, significator of H1 and H9) and natal Jupiter ( Law, Constitution, significator of H9). Transit Rahu was aspecting exactly transit Mercury (written documents), L11 (future plans ) in H9 (Law, Constitution), and transit Saturn (democracy), L4 (general and political stability, law and order ) in H11 (future plans). Natal Ketu is associated with initiatives as it is placed exactly over MEP3 (writing). In transit, Ketu was conjunct with Mars (significator for H3 of writing ), L6 (judicial functioning), aspected by Saturn (democracy), L4 (general and political stability, law and order), and in mutual aspect with natal Sun and natal Jupiter. Jupiter (Law, Constitution), L2 (status and relationships within the country) in H8 ( end of existing government), is aspected by Rahu, Ketu and Mars. In transit, Jupiter is well placed in H10 (executive, parliament, administration), disposed by the Sun in H1 (general condition of the country as a whole). It seems the US rectified chart, which I call the seed moment for everything else in US after independence, explains well the significance of that especial moment on the national level. My dear friend, I agree that for you and many others it may seem that I have some kind of personal attachment to this chart. Even our dear was the first to mention it in a written form. Believe me or not, that word/feeling was never in my mind/heart. Many list members may remember that I am always the first to eliminate any personally proposed rectified mundane chart whenever I see that another one would explain the national events and that country in a better way. The last substitution was with the chart of my own country. It may also seem that I have been too much time looking to the other countries, and neglecting my own...but this is the nature of our people in Portugal, as the Sun, L12, is exactly conjunct with Mercury, L1, over MEP10, aspecting MEP4. We always think that the others are better than us...and like that we have been trying to improve since June 24, 1128, and I am sure we still have a lot to learn... Best wishes, Jorge On 3/5/07, rkchadha <rkctech wrote: Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others:There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feelsstrongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 pm. YetI would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, whichcontains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel strongly about.I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratificationof confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in fact it should be the time and date when the confederation wasestablished the USA became a country of group of states united underone government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) when thearticles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historicalevents of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which isalmost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am proposing for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only theelements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explainsthe character of USA and some of the important historical events.Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Librashows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual pursuits andscientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of justice and liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, in themartial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength andhistory of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu onMercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. Togetherthese planets show why its economy is tied with the wars andconflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamitiesand disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever morepowerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here theSun-sign is Scorpio.Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM andMMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms that bothSun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken placewhen Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricornrising chart.I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look at thischart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting afinal chart for USA.ThanksRaj Chadha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2007 Report Share Posted March 5, 2007 Hello Thor: Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, 1776. At that time I had not seen 1777 chart. I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am doing now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. Pleas e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What I mean was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I now feel that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do my work and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The honorable members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. Thanks, you are an insipiration. Raj SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer wrote: > > Hello Raj, > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA because > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and many > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 and not > July 4... " > > Now you propose: > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. " > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for many > years, including studying their natal promise and making predictions. > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More recently, I > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB on this > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA chart. > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a given chart, > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is retained, the > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must develop a > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are doing this > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and accurate > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not enough. > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the work, > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be pleased to > consider that offering. > > Best wishes, > > Thor > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 pm. Yet > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel > > strongly about. > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in > > fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was > > established the USA became a country of group of states united under > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) when the > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am proposing > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains > > the character of USA and some of the important historical events. > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual pursuits and > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of justice and > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, in the > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. Together > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms that both > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken place > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn > > rising chart. > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look at this > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a > > final chart for USA. > > > > Thanks > > > > Raj Chadha > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2007 Report Share Posted March 5, 2007 Jorge: It is good to know that you are receptive and flexible. I appreciate your monumental efforts. July 2, 1776 may be a seed time. But the seed time may not be taken as birth time. It is like accepting as union time between a man and a woman as a birth time of a child. In astrology we work with the time of the birth of a child. Raj SAMVA , " Jorge Angelino " <jorge.angelino wrote: > > *Dear Raj Chadha,* > ** > *As Mr. John TWB said:* > ** > *November 15, 1777 is the date marking the birth of the TEXT of the first > U.S.A. constitution, that constitution of March 1, 1781 known as the > Articles of Confederation.* > ** > *It will be interesting to see how it is expressed in the US rectified > chart. * > ** > *The operational dasha was MO/MO/RA/KE/JU. * > > *Except for transit Rahu, all the remaining operational planets were well > placed in transit, and all of them are connected with the H9/H3 axis. * > > *The natal Moon* (Administration), *L9 *(Law, Constitution) *in H3* (writing), > *was strong in transit and over MEP7* (cooperative bodies representing the > people in toto like Parliament, Senate, Congress, etc.) *closely aspecting > MEP1* (general condition of the country as a whole). > > *Natal Rahu* (transformation, manipulation) *is placed exactly over MEP9* (Law, > Constitution), *disposed by the Moon. In transit, Rahu was under the close > aspect of transit Mars* (action, significator of H3) *and over natal Sun* (the > Government, significator of H1 and H9) *and natal Jupiter* (Law, > Constitution, significator of H9). *Transit Rahu was aspecting exactly > transit Mercury *(written documents), *L11 *(future plans) *in H9* (Law, > Constitution), *and transit Saturn* (democracy), *L4* (general and political > stability, law and order) *in H11* (future plans). > > *Natal Ketu is associated with initiatives as it is placed exactly over MEP3 > * (writing). *In transit, Ketu was conjunct with Mars *(significator for H3 > of writing), * L6* (judicial functioning), *aspected by Saturn* (democracy), > *L4 *(general and political stability, law and order), *and in mutual aspect > with natal Sun and natal Jupiter.* > > *Jupiter *(Law, Constitution), *L2 *(status and relationships within the > country) *in H8* (end of existing government), *is aspected by Rahu, Ketu > and Mars. In transit, Jupiter is well placed in H10* (executive, parliament, > administration), *disposed by the Sun in H1* (general condition of the > country as a whole). > > *It seems the US rectified chart, which I call the seed moment for > everything else in US after independence, explains well the significance of > that especial moment on the national level. * > ** > *My dear friend, I agree that for you and many others it may seem that I > have some kind of personal attachment to this chart. Even our dear Professor > Choudhry was the first to mention it in a written form. Believe me or not, > that word/feeling was never in my mind/heart. Many list members may remember > that I am always the first to eliminate any personally proposed rectified > mundane chart whenever I see that another one would explain the national > events and that country in a better way. The last substitution was with the > chart of my own country. It may also seem that I have been too much time > looking to the other countries, and neglecting my own...but this is the > nature of our people in Portugal, as the Sun, L12, is exactly conjunct with > Mercury, L1, over MEP10, aspecting MEP4. We always think that the others are > better than us...and like that we have been trying to improve since June 24, > 1128, and I am sure we still have a lot to learn...* > ** > *Best wishes,* > ** > *Jorge > * > > On 3/5/07, rkchadha <rkctech wrote: > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 pm. Yet > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel > > strongly about. > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in > > fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was > > established the USA became a country of group of states united under > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) when the > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am proposing > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains > > the character of USA and some of the important historical events. > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual pursuits and > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of justice and > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, in the > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. Together > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms that both > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken place > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn > > rising chart. > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look at this > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a > > final chart for USA. > > > > Thanks > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2007 Report Share Posted March 5, 2007 Prof Choudhry:I will certainly appreciate if you take some time to look at this chart, and offer your comments. I feel that the strength and placement of all planets have a strong correspondence with the historical events of USA. Your comments will certainly move the discussion in the right direction.ThanksRaj Chadhasiha wrote: Hello dear Mr. Chadha, When we are searching the truth one has to be objective in one's analysis/approach without being attached to any of the charts including the one proposed by the person his/her ownself. Natal promise in the chart is first of all important and then the transit influences and the sub periods help up in identifying the results. I personally and others will certainly explore the truth in the chart proposed by you in comparison to the proposals already with us. Best wishes. - "rkchadha" <rkctech > <SAMVA > Monday, March 05, 2007 7:36 AM New USA chart proposal | Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: | | There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an | appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels | strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 pm. Yet | I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which | contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel | strongly about. | | I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of | 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification | of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in | fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was | established the USA became a country of group of states united under | one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) when the | articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, | Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical | events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is | almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am proposing | for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the | elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains | the character of USA and some of the important historical events. | | | Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The | placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra | shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual pursuits and | scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of justice and | liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, in the | martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and | history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on | Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance | accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. Together | these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and | conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities | and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows | its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more | powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the | Sun-sign is Scorpio. | | Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, | 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and | MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms that both | Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer | 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken place | when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn | rising chart. | | I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to | 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look at this | chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a | final chart for USA. | | Thanks | | Raj Chadha | | | | | | | Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2007 Report Share Posted March 5, 2007 Hello dear Mr. Raj Chadha, I have kept this chart for my study and observations and as soon as I can, I will revert on this, separately. Best wishes. - Raj Cgadha SAMVA Tuesday, March 06, 2007 12:13 AM Re: New USA chart proposal Prof Choudhry:I will certainly appreciate if you take some time to look at this chart, and offer your comments. I feel that the strength and placement of all planets have a strong correspondence with the historical events of USA. Your comments will certainly move the discussion in the right direction.ThanksRaj Chadhasiha wrote: Hello dear Mr. Chadha,When we are searching the truth one has to be objective in one's analysis/approach without being attached to any of the charts including the one proposed by the person his/her ownself. Natal promise in the chart is first of all important and then the transit influences and the sub periods help up in identifying the results. I personally and others will certainly explore the truth in the chart proposed by you in comparison to the proposals already with us.Best wishes.- "rkchadha" <rkctech ><SAMVA >Monday, March 05, 2007 7:36 AM New USA chart proposal| Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others:|| There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an| appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels| strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 pm. Yet| I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which| contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel| strongly about.|| I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of| 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification| of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in| fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was| established the USA became a country of group of states united under| one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) when the| articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York,| Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical| events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is| almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am proposing| for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the| elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains| the character of USA and some of the important historical events.||| Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The| placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra| shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual pursuits and| scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of justice and| liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, in the| martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and| history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on| Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance| accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. Together| these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and| conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities| and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows| its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more| powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the| Sun-sign is Scorpio.|| Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001,| 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and| MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms that both| Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer| 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken place| when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn| rising chart.|| I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to| 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look at this| chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a| final chart for USA.|| Thanks|| Raj Chadha||||||| Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2007 Report Share Posted March 5, 2007 Dear Raj, Thank you for the kind words. I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what John TWB shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical angle that motivates your investigations at this point. When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the charts you are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider some main points, which were explained by thus in a message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: " The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US in the international affairs, its commanding position in the intellectual properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive attitude including use of force in international affairs, the conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic peace felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the nation, the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of state, and important intervention in foreign policy around the world. The identification of the past events through sub periods or triple transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the proposed chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any planet in the sixth house. " will revert on the chart identified by you. I also look forward to hear what he will say about it. Finally, you should also consider the 21° Cancer rising SAMVA USA chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your understanding of the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest you the least that finds that this chart meets the above requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to predict the ongoing developments? Best wishes, Thor SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech wrote: > > Hello Thor: > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, 1776. At > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am doing > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. Pleas > e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What I mean > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I now feel > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do my work > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The honorable > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > Raj > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA because > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and many > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 and not > > July 4... " > > > > Now you propose: > > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. " > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for many > > years, including studying their natal promise and making predictions. > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More recently, I > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB on this > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA chart. > > > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a given chart, > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is retained, the > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must develop a > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are doing this > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and accurate > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not enough. > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the work, > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be pleased to > > consider that offering. > > > > Best wishes, > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 pm. Yet > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel > > > strongly about. > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in > > > fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was > > > established the USA became a country of group of states united under > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) when the > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am proposing > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical events. > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual pursuits and > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of justice and > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, in the > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. Together > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms that both > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken place > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn > > > rising chart. > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look at this > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2007 Report Share Posted March 5, 2007 Dear Thor: 1777 chart in fact shows all the requirements you put forward. International affairs are seen from 7H. 7L is strong and well placed. 7H is aspected by MBP. Thus it has commanding position in international affairs. 5H shows intellactual properties. Again unafflicted and strong Moon is residing here. The sign of intellact Libra is also strong with exalted Saturn and 9L in the 10H. Therefore USA has been in the forefront of scientific discoveries and command respect for that. These two planets are on MEP's, therefore they influence five houses beneficially. Financial strength is seen from 2H, 5H the planets Moon and Venus. 2L is exalted, wp and on MEP. Venus although slightly weak, but still placed in 10H, in its own MTS. Moon is again wp, strong and unafflicted. 9L in the 10H is an additional advantage. Both Mercury and Saturn are afflicted by Rahu from the 6H, that shows why every financial boom invited cheaters and manipulators, and why they ended with stock market crashes. Its assertive attitude and the use of force in international affairs come from Mars in Sagittarius in the 12H on MEP. It also aspect 3H of communication and literary pursuits. It also aspects the 6H, which according to you govern aggressive and assertive attitude. There is no need of having a MTS in this house. The presence of Rahu and aspect of Mars are more than enough. Both mars and Rahu produce conflicts. The combination of Mars and Ketu in 12H shows why USA got involved in wars in foreign lands. As I indicated before, 12L in the 8H shows natural disasters. Sun here is a relatively weak. This combined with the affliction of 9L Mercury, make its leaders succeptible to attacks by its own people. Both Sun and Jupiter are FM's and they do not afflict any planet or house. But whenever they form cc/ca in transit, they produce disasters. On 12/7/1941 both FM's Sun and Jupiter were aspecting each other closely. Rahu was afflicting from 8H's MEP. The period was Jup/Ven. On 9/11/2001, Mars and Ketu were together in the 12H. Six planets were present in the malefic houses and FM's Sun and Jupiter were transiting over the MEP's. The period was Ven/Jup. Therefore USA faced deadly attacks on its soil. I will produce more data like that shortly. And I will show you that this chart has both natal, transit and dasha requirements for being the chart of the country USA. But I will first wait for Prof Choudhry's point of view on this chart. Please note that I am not averse to Cancer 21 degree chart or any other chart at all. The interesting point is that 1777 chart also like 1781 chart show the present stock market problems, because of the stationary Rahu/Ketu axis at 22 degrees on the 2H and 8H MEP's. Best wishes. Raj Chadha SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer wrote: > > Dear Raj, > > Thank you for the kind words. > > I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what John TWB > shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the > events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical angle that > motivates your investigations at this point. > > When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the charts you > are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider some > main points, which were explained by thus in a > message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: > > " The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US in the > international affairs, its commanding position in the intellectual > properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive > attitude including use of force in international affairs, the > conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic peace > felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the nation, > the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of state, > and important intervention in foreign policy around the world. The > identification of the past events through sub periods or triple > transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ > aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the proposed > chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any planet > in the sixth house. " > > will revert on the chart identified by you. I also > look forward to hear what he will say about it. > > Finally, you should also consider the 21° Cancer rising SAMVA USA > chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your understanding of > the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest you the > least that finds that this chart meets the above > requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to predict the > ongoing developments? > > Best wishes, > > Thor > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > Hello Thor: > > > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, 1776. At > > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am doing > > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. Pleas > > e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What I mean > > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I now feel > > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do my work > > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The honorable > > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > > > Raj > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA because > > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and many > > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 and not > > > July 4... " > > > > > > Now you propose: > > > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. " > > > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for many > > > years, including studying their natal promise and making predictions. > > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More recently, I > > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB on this > > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA chart. > > > > > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a given chart, > > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is retained, the > > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must develop a > > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are doing this > > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and accurate > > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not enough. > > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the work, > > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be pleased to > > > consider that offering. > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an > > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels > > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 > pm. Yet > > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which > > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel > > > > strongly about. > > > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of > > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification > > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in > > > > fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was > > > > established the USA became a country of group of states united under > > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) > when the > > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, > > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical > > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is > > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am > proposing > > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the > > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains > > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical events. > > > > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The > > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra > > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual > pursuits and > > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of > justice and > > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, > in the > > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and > > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on > > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance > > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. > Together > > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities > > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows > > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more > > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the > > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, > > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and > > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms > that both > > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer > > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken > place > > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn > > > > rising chart. > > > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to > > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look > at this > > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a > > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2007 Report Share Posted March 5, 2007 Hello dear Mr. Chadha, Weakness of Venus XL, close affliction of nodes to houses influences and close affliction of Rahu from sixth house to Saturn IIL and exact affliction to Mercury IXL besides placement of Mars IVL in the twelfth house and Jupiter XIIL in the eighth house does not allow me to say that this chart merits consideration as the chart for USA. Best wishes. - " rkchadha " <rkctech <SAMVA > Tuesday, March 06, 2007 4:14 AM Re: New USA chart proposal Dear Thor: 1777 chart in fact shows all the requirements you put forward. International affairs are seen from 7H. 7L is strong and well placed. 7H is aspected by MBP. Thus it has commanding position in international affairs. 5H shows intellactual properties. Again unafflicted and strong Moon is residing here. The sign of intellact Libra is also strong with exalted Saturn and 9L in the 10H. Therefore USA has been in the forefront of scientific discoveries and command respect for that. These two planets are on MEP's, therefore they influence five houses beneficially. Financial strength is seen from 2H, 5H the planets Moon and Venus. 2L is exalted, wp and on MEP. Venus although slightly weak, but still placed in 10H, in its own MTS. Moon is again wp, strong and unafflicted. 9L in the 10H is an additional advantage. Both Mercury and Saturn are afflicted by Rahu from the 6H, that shows why every financial boom invited cheaters and manipulators, and why they ended with stock market crashes. Its assertive attitude and the use of force in international affairs come from Mars in Sagittarius in the 12H on MEP. It also aspect 3H of communication and literary pursuits. It also aspects the 6H, which according to you govern aggressive and assertive attitude. There is no need of having a MTS in this house. The presence of Rahu and aspect of Mars are more than enough. Both mars and Rahu produce conflicts. The combination of Mars and Ketu in 12H shows why USA got involved in wars in foreign lands. As I indicated before, 12L in the 8H shows natural disasters. Sun here is a relatively weak. This combined with the affliction of 9L Mercury, make its leaders succeptible to attacks by its own people. Both Sun and Jupiter are FM's and they do not afflict any planet or house. But whenever they form cc/ca in transit, they produce disasters. On 12/7/1941 both FM's Sun and Jupiter were aspecting each other closely. Rahu was afflicting from 8H's MEP. The period was Jup/Ven. On 9/11/2001, Mars and Ketu were together in the 12H. Six planets were present in the malefic houses and FM's Sun and Jupiter were transiting over the MEP's. The period was Ven/Jup. Therefore USA faced deadly attacks on its soil. I will produce more data like that shortly. And I will show you that this chart has both natal, transit and dasha requirements for being the chart of the country USA. But I will first wait for Prof Choudhry's point of view on this chart. Please note that I am not averse to Cancer 21 degree chart or any other chart at all. The interesting point is that 1777 chart also like 1781 chart show the present stock market problems, because of the stationary Rahu/Ketu axis at 22 degrees on the 2H and 8H MEP's. Best wishes. Raj Chadha SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer wrote: > > Dear Raj, > > Thank you for the kind words. > > I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what John TWB > shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the > events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical angle that > motivates your investigations at this point. > > When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the charts you > are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider some > main points, which were explained by thus in a > message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: > > " The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US in the > international affairs, its commanding position in the intellectual > properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive > attitude including use of force in international affairs, the > conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic peace > felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the nation, > the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of state, > and important intervention in foreign policy around the world. The > identification of the past events through sub periods or triple > transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ > aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the proposed > chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any planet > in the sixth house. " > > will revert on the chart identified by you. I also > look forward to hear what he will say about it. > > Finally, you should also consider the 21° Cancer rising SAMVA USA > chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your understanding of > the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest you the > least that finds that this chart meets the above > requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to predict the > ongoing developments? > > Best wishes, > > Thor > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > Hello Thor: > > > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, 1776. At > > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am doing > > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. Pleas > > e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What I mean > > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I now feel > > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do my work > > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The honorable > > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > > > Raj > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA because > > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and many > > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 and not > > > July 4... " > > > > > > Now you propose: > > > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. " > > > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for many > > > years, including studying their natal promise and making predictions. > > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More recently, I > > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB on this > > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA chart. > > > > > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a given chart, > > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is retained, the > > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must develop a > > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are doing this > > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and accurate > > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not enough. > > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the work, > > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be pleased to > > > consider that offering. > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about finding an > > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels > > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 > pm. Yet > > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which > > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel > > > > strongly about. > > > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of > > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the ratification > > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. But in > > > > fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was > > > > established the USA became a country of group of states united under > > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) > when the > > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, > > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the historical > > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, which is > > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am > proposing > > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the > > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it explains > > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical events. > > > > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The > > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra > > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual > pursuits and > > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of > justice and > > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, > in the > > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and > > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on > > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance > > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. > Together > > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural calamities > > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn shows > > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more > > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the > > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, > > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun (FM and > > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms > that both > > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in Cancer > > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken > place > > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn > > > > rising chart. > > > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like Jorge to > > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look > at this > > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before accepting a > > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 6, 2007 Report Share Posted March 6, 2007 Dear Mr. Choudhry and Thor: Your analysis does have a few points. But I am sure you will agree with me that USA is not a perfect country. It has its due share of tragedies and weaknesses. The chart for USA should show them. The Nov1777 chart shows them better than Feb1781 charts. I would like to submit a few more points for your consideration. I hope you re-valuate the merit of this chart in totallity. Influenza epidemic of 1918 killed more than 100,000 American people. The period according to the chart I propose was Rahu/Jup. Both are FM's and both are badly placed. In transit Jupiter was in the sign Gemini, placed in 6H in the sign of lungs. The great depression (1930-1933) occured during the periods of Rahu/Mars and Jup/Jup. Rahu, Mars and Jup all are badly placed, and affects so many houses and planets, creating worst of the atmosphere. 1962 Cuban missile episode occured in Sat/Rahu, once again Rahu on 6H MEP shows it clearly. President Kennedy and Dr. King killed in the sixties. The period was Sat/Rahu and Sat/Jup. Once again Rahu afflicting Saturn, and FM Jupiter in 8H explains everything very nicely. Watergate episode and Opec oil embargo, which created most frustrating days in USA occured in Mer/Sun period. Sun being the MMP produced its effects and hurt the president of the country. Coming back to the natal chart, USA is a litigious society. People are always ready to sue each other. It is dominated by lawyers. In the chart I recommend, majority of planets are in signs Libra and Sagittarius. Both these signs are connected with law. USA is a sincere and trustworthy friend to certain countries. Sincerity and loyality are hallmark qualities of Capricorn ascendant more than any other sign. Ascendants Cancer or Virgo are too soft ascendants for a country like USA. Even Scorpio is not appropriate, because Scorpio will wait for an appropriate time to take revenge. Crocodile (the symbol for Capricorn) on the other hand lay dormant near the riverbanks and will not react unless provoked. But once provoked, it reacts ferocioulsy without waiting. It then completely annhilates the enemy. Look what happenend after Pearl harbor. And what is happeneing after Sept 11. Based on this simple fact I predict that USA will not rest untill it eliminates Al-Qaida completely. It does not matter who the president is, George Bush or any democrat. As I said in the beginning, please consider the merit of the chart in its entirity, not just the strengths of the planets. Thank you for being so understanding and patient. Raj Chadha SAMVA , <siha wrote: > > > Hello dear Mr. Chadha, > > Weakness of Venus XL, close affliction of nodes to houses influences and > close affliction of Rahu from sixth house to Saturn IIL and exact affliction > to Mercury IXL besides placement of Mars IVL in the twelfth house and > Jupiter XIIL in the eighth house does not allow me to say that this chart > merits consideration as the chart for USA. > > Best wishes. > > > > > > - > " rkchadha " <rkctech > <SAMVA > > Tuesday, March 06, 2007 4:14 AM > Re: New USA chart proposal > > > > Dear Thor: > > 1777 chart in fact shows all the requirements you put forward. > > International affairs are seen from 7H. 7L is strong and well placed. > 7H is aspected by MBP. Thus it has commanding position in > international affairs. > > 5H shows intellactual properties. Again unafflicted and strong Moon is > residing here. The sign of intellact Libra is also strong with exalted > Saturn and 9L in the 10H. Therefore USA has been in the forefront of > scientific discoveries and command respect for that. These two planets > are on MEP's, therefore they influence five houses beneficially. > > Financial strength is seen from 2H, 5H the planets Moon and Venus. 2L > is exalted, wp and on MEP. Venus although slightly weak, but still > placed in 10H, in its own MTS. Moon is again wp, strong and > unafflicted. 9L in the 10H is an additional advantage. Both Mercury > and Saturn are afflicted by Rahu from the 6H, that shows why every > financial boom invited cheaters and manipulators, and why they ended > with stock market crashes. > > Its assertive attitude and the use of force in international affairs > come from Mars in Sagittarius in the 12H on MEP. It also aspect 3H of > communication and literary pursuits. It also aspects the 6H, which > according to you govern aggressive and assertive attitude. There is no > need of having a MTS in this house. The presence of Rahu and aspect of > Mars are more than enough. Both mars and Rahu produce conflicts. The > combination of Mars and Ketu in 12H shows why USA got involved in wars > in foreign lands. > > As I indicated before, 12L in the 8H shows natural disasters. Sun here > is a relatively weak. This combined with the affliction of 9L Mercury, > make its leaders succeptible to attacks by its own people. > > Both Sun and Jupiter are FM's and they do not afflict any planet or > house. But whenever they form cc/ca in transit, they produce disasters. > > On 12/7/1941 both FM's Sun and Jupiter were aspecting each other > closely. Rahu was afflicting from 8H's MEP. The period was Jup/Ven. On > 9/11/2001, Mars and Ketu were together in the 12H. Six planets were > present in the malefic houses and FM's Sun and Jupiter were transiting > over the MEP's. The period was Ven/Jup. Therefore USA faced deadly > attacks on its soil. > > I will produce more data like that shortly. And I will show you that > this chart has both natal, transit and dasha requirements for being > the chart of the country USA. But I will first wait for Prof > Choudhry's point of view on this chart. Please note that I am not > averse to Cancer 21 degree chart or any other chart at all. The > interesting point is that 1777 chart also like 1781 chart show the > present stock market problems, because of the stationary Rahu/Ketu > axis at 22 degrees on the 2H and 8H MEP's. > > Best wishes. > > Raj Chadha > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > Thank you for the kind words. > > > > I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what John TWB > > shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the > > events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical angle that > > motivates your investigations at this point. > > > > When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the charts you > > are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider some > > main points, which were explained by thus in a > > message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: > > > > " The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US in the > > international affairs, its commanding position in the intellectual > > properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive > > attitude including use of force in international affairs, the > > conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic peace > > felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the nation, > > the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of state, > > and important intervention in foreign policy around the world. The > > identification of the past events through sub periods or triple > > transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ > > aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the proposed > > chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any planet > > in the sixth house. " > > > > will revert on the chart identified by you. I also > > look forward to hear what he will say about it. > > > > Finally, you should also consider the 21° Cancer rising SAMVA USA > > chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your understanding of > > the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest you the > > least that finds that this chart meets the above > > requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to predict the > > ongoing developments? > > > > Best wishes, > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > Hello Thor: > > > > > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, 1776. At > > > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > > > > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am doing > > > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. Pleas > > > e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What I mean > > > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I now feel > > > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do my work > > > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The honorable > > > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > > > > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > > > > > Raj > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > > > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA because > > > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and many > > > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 and not > > > > July 4... " > > > > > > > > Now you propose: > > > > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. " > > > > > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for many > > > > years, including studying their natal promise and making > predictions. > > > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More > recently, I > > > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB on this > > > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA chart. > > > > > > > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a given > chart, > > > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is retained, the > > > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must develop a > > > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are doing this > > > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and accurate > > > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not enough. > > > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the work, > > > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > > > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be pleased to > > > > consider that offering. > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about > finding an > > > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels > > > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 > > pm. Yet > > > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, which > > > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel > > > > > strongly about. > > > > > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the choice of > > > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the > ratification > > > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. > But in > > > > > fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was > > > > > established the USA became a country of group of states united > under > > > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) > > when the > > > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, > > > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the > historical > > > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, > which is > > > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am > > proposing > > > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not only the > > > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it > explains > > > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical events. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. The > > > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in Libra > > > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual > > pursuits and > > > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of > > justice and > > > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, > > in the > > > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and > > > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on > > > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance > > > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. > > Together > > > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural > calamities > > > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn > shows > > > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more > > > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. Here the > > > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, > > > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun > (FM and > > > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms > > that both > > > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in > Cancer > > > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken > > place > > > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the Capricorn > > > > > rising chart. > > > > > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like > Jorge to > > > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look > > at this > > > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before > accepting a > > > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 6, 2007 Report Share Posted March 6, 2007 Dear Raj, To get real consideration a set of predictions needs to be made against the chart. Please feel free to make the predictions. Best wishes, Thor SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech wrote: > > Dear Mr. Choudhry and Thor: > > Your analysis does have a few points. But I am sure you will agree > with me that USA is not a perfect country. It has its due share of > tragedies and weaknesses. The chart for USA should show them. The > Nov1777 chart shows them better than Feb1781 charts. I would like to > submit a few more points for your consideration. I hope you re-valuate > the merit of this chart in totallity. > > Influenza epidemic of 1918 killed more than 100,000 American people. > The period according to the chart I propose was Rahu/Jup. Both are > FM's and both are badly placed. In transit Jupiter was in the sign > Gemini, placed in 6H in the sign of lungs. > > The great depression (1930-1933) occured during the periods of > Rahu/Mars and Jup/Jup. Rahu, Mars and Jup all are badly placed, and > affects so many houses and planets, creating worst of the atmosphere. > > 1962 Cuban missile episode occured in Sat/Rahu, once again Rahu on 6H > MEP shows it clearly. President Kennedy and Dr. King killed in the > sixties. The period was Sat/Rahu and Sat/Jup. Once again Rahu > afflicting Saturn, and FM Jupiter in 8H explains everything very nicely. > > Watergate episode and Opec oil embargo, which created most frustrating > days in USA occured in Mer/Sun period. Sun being the MMP produced its > effects and hurt the president of the country. > > Coming back to the natal chart, USA is a litigious society. People are > always ready to sue each other. It is dominated by lawyers. In the > chart I recommend, majority of planets are in signs Libra and > Sagittarius. Both these signs are connected with law. > > USA is a sincere and trustworthy friend to certain countries. > Sincerity and loyality are hallmark qualities of Capricorn ascendant > more than any other sign. > > Ascendants Cancer or Virgo are too soft ascendants for a country like > USA. Even Scorpio is not appropriate, because Scorpio will wait for an > appropriate time to take revenge. Crocodile (the symbol for Capricorn) > on the other hand lay dormant near the riverbanks and will not react > unless provoked. But once provoked, it reacts ferocioulsy without > waiting. It then completely annhilates the enemy. Look what happenend > after Pearl harbor. And what is happeneing after Sept 11. Based on > this simple fact I predict that USA will not rest untill it eliminates > Al-Qaida completely. It does not matter who the president is, George > Bush or any democrat. > > As I said in the beginning, please consider the merit of the chart in > its entirity, not just the strengths of the planets. > > Thank you for being so understanding and patient. > > Raj Chadha > > > SAMVA , <siha@> wrote: > > > > > > Hello dear Mr. Chadha, > > > > Weakness of Venus XL, close affliction of nodes to houses influences > and > > close affliction of Rahu from sixth house to Saturn IIL and exact > affliction > > to Mercury IXL besides placement of Mars IVL in the twelfth house and > > Jupiter XIIL in the eighth house does not allow me to say that this > chart > > merits consideration as the chart for USA. > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > > > > > - > > " rkchadha " <rkctech@> > > <SAMVA > > > Tuesday, March 06, 2007 4:14 AM > > Re: New USA chart proposal > > > > > > > > Dear Thor: > > > > 1777 chart in fact shows all the requirements you put forward. > > > > International affairs are seen from 7H. 7L is strong and well placed. > > 7H is aspected by MBP. Thus it has commanding position in > > international affairs. > > > > 5H shows intellactual properties. Again unafflicted and strong Moon is > > residing here. The sign of intellact Libra is also strong with exalted > > Saturn and 9L in the 10H. Therefore USA has been in the forefront of > > scientific discoveries and command respect for that. These two planets > > are on MEP's, therefore they influence five houses beneficially. > > > > Financial strength is seen from 2H, 5H the planets Moon and Venus. 2L > > is exalted, wp and on MEP. Venus although slightly weak, but still > > placed in 10H, in its own MTS. Moon is again wp, strong and > > unafflicted. 9L in the 10H is an additional advantage. Both Mercury > > and Saturn are afflicted by Rahu from the 6H, that shows why every > > financial boom invited cheaters and manipulators, and why they ended > > with stock market crashes. > > > > Its assertive attitude and the use of force in international affairs > > come from Mars in Sagittarius in the 12H on MEP. It also aspect 3H of > > communication and literary pursuits. It also aspects the 6H, which > > according to you govern aggressive and assertive attitude. There is no > > need of having a MTS in this house. The presence of Rahu and aspect of > > Mars are more than enough. Both mars and Rahu produce conflicts. The > > combination of Mars and Ketu in 12H shows why USA got involved in wars > > in foreign lands. > > > > As I indicated before, 12L in the 8H shows natural disasters. Sun here > > is a relatively weak. This combined with the affliction of 9L Mercury, > > make its leaders succeptible to attacks by its own people. > > > > Both Sun and Jupiter are FM's and they do not afflict any planet or > > house. But whenever they form cc/ca in transit, they produce disasters. > > > > On 12/7/1941 both FM's Sun and Jupiter were aspecting each other > > closely. Rahu was afflicting from 8H's MEP. The period was Jup/Ven. On > > 9/11/2001, Mars and Ketu were together in the 12H. Six planets were > > present in the malefic houses and FM's Sun and Jupiter were transiting > > over the MEP's. The period was Ven/Jup. Therefore USA faced deadly > > attacks on its soil. > > > > I will produce more data like that shortly. And I will show you that > > this chart has both natal, transit and dasha requirements for being > > the chart of the country USA. But I will first wait for Prof > > Choudhry's point of view on this chart. Please note that I am not > > averse to Cancer 21 degree chart or any other chart at all. The > > interesting point is that 1777 chart also like 1781 chart show the > > present stock market problems, because of the stationary Rahu/Ketu > > axis at 22 degrees on the 2H and 8H MEP's. > > > > Best wishes. > > > > Raj Chadha > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > > > Thank you for the kind words. > > > > > > I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what John TWB > > > shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the > > > events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical angle that > > > motivates your investigations at this point. > > > > > > When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the charts you > > > are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider some > > > main points, which were explained by thus in a > > > message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: > > > > > > " The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US in the > > > international affairs, its commanding position in the intellectual > > > properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive > > > attitude including use of force in international affairs, the > > > conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic peace > > > felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the nation, > > > the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of state, > > > and important intervention in foreign policy around the world. The > > > identification of the past events through sub periods or triple > > > transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ > > > aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the proposed > > > chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any planet > > > in the sixth house. " > > > > > > will revert on the chart identified by you. I also > > > look forward to hear what he will say about it. > > > > > > Finally, you should also consider the 21° Cancer rising SAMVA USA > > > chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your understanding of > > > the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest you the > > > least that finds that this chart meets the above > > > requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to predict the > > > ongoing developments? > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Hello Thor: > > > > > > > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, 1776. At > > > > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > > > > > > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am > doing > > > > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. > Pleas > > > > e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What I mean > > > > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I > now feel > > > > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do my work > > > > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The honorable > > > > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > > > > > > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > > > > > > > Raj > > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > > > > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > > > > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA because > > > > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and > many > > > > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 and not > > > > > July 4... " > > > > > > > > > > Now you propose: > > > > > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. " > > > > > > > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for many > > > > > years, including studying their natal promise and making > > predictions. > > > > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More > > recently, I > > > > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB on this > > > > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA chart. > > > > > > > > > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a given > > chart, > > > > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is retained, the > > > > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must develop a > > > > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > > > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are > doing this > > > > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and > accurate > > > > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > > > > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not enough. > > > > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the > work, > > > > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > > > > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be pleased to > > > > > consider that offering. > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about > > finding an > > > > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels > > > > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 > > > pm. Yet > > > > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, > which > > > > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel > > > > > > strongly about. > > > > > > > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the > choice of > > > > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the > > ratification > > > > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. > > But in > > > > > > fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was > > > > > > established the USA became a country of group of states united > > under > > > > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) > > > when the > > > > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, > > > > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the > > historical > > > > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, > > which is > > > > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am > > > proposing > > > > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not > only the > > > > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it > > explains > > > > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical > events. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. > The > > > > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in > Libra > > > > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual > > > pursuits and > > > > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of > > > justice and > > > > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, > > > in the > > > > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military strength and > > > > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of Rahu on > > > > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance > > > > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. > > > Together > > > > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > > > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural > > calamities > > > > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn > > shows > > > > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more > > > > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. > Here the > > > > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, 9/11/2001, > > > > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun > > (FM and > > > > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms > > > that both > > > > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in > > Cancer > > > > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also taken > > > place > > > > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the > Capricorn > > > > > > rising chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like > > Jorge to > > > > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look > > > at this > > > > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before > > accepting a > > > > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 6, 2007 Report Share Posted March 6, 2007 Thor: I will. Please give me a few days. Raj Chadha SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer wrote: > > Dear Raj, > > To get real consideration a set of predictions needs to be made > against the chart. Please feel free to make the predictions. > > Best wishes, > > Thor > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > Dear Mr. Choudhry and Thor: > > > > Your analysis does have a few points. But I am sure you will agree > > with me that USA is not a perfect country. It has its due share of > > tragedies and weaknesses. The chart for USA should show them. The > > Nov1777 chart shows them better than Feb1781 charts. I would like to > > submit a few more points for your consideration. I hope you re-valuate > > the merit of this chart in totallity. > > > > Influenza epidemic of 1918 killed more than 100,000 American people. > > The period according to the chart I propose was Rahu/Jup. Both are > > FM's and both are badly placed. In transit Jupiter was in the sign > > Gemini, placed in 6H in the sign of lungs. > > > > The great depression (1930-1933) occured during the periods of > > Rahu/Mars and Jup/Jup. Rahu, Mars and Jup all are badly placed, and > > affects so many houses and planets, creating worst of the atmosphere. > > > > 1962 Cuban missile episode occured in Sat/Rahu, once again Rahu on 6H > > MEP shows it clearly. President Kennedy and Dr. King killed in the > > sixties. The period was Sat/Rahu and Sat/Jup. Once again Rahu > > afflicting Saturn, and FM Jupiter in 8H explains everything very nicely. > > > > Watergate episode and Opec oil embargo, which created most frustrating > > days in USA occured in Mer/Sun period. Sun being the MMP produced its > > effects and hurt the president of the country. > > > > Coming back to the natal chart, USA is a litigious society. People are > > always ready to sue each other. It is dominated by lawyers. In the > > chart I recommend, majority of planets are in signs Libra and > > Sagittarius. Both these signs are connected with law. > > > > USA is a sincere and trustworthy friend to certain countries. > > Sincerity and loyality are hallmark qualities of Capricorn ascendant > > more than any other sign. > > > > Ascendants Cancer or Virgo are too soft ascendants for a country like > > USA. Even Scorpio is not appropriate, because Scorpio will wait for an > > appropriate time to take revenge. Crocodile (the symbol for Capricorn) > > on the other hand lay dormant near the riverbanks and will not react > > unless provoked. But once provoked, it reacts ferocioulsy without > > waiting. It then completely annhilates the enemy. Look what happenend > > after Pearl harbor. And what is happeneing after Sept 11. Based on > > this simple fact I predict that USA will not rest untill it eliminates > > Al-Qaida completely. It does not matter who the president is, George > > Bush or any democrat. > > > > As I said in the beginning, please consider the merit of the chart in > > its entirity, not just the strengths of the planets. > > > > Thank you for being so understanding and patient. > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > SAMVA , <siha@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > Hello dear Mr. Chadha, > > > > > > Weakness of Venus XL, close affliction of nodes to houses influences > > and > > > close affliction of Rahu from sixth house to Saturn IIL and exact > > affliction > > > to Mercury IXL besides placement of Mars IVL in the twelfth house and > > > Jupiter XIIL in the eighth house does not allow me to say that this > > chart > > > merits consideration as the chart for USA. > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > - > > > " rkchadha " <rkctech@> > > > <SAMVA > > > > Tuesday, March 06, 2007 4:14 AM > > > Re: New USA chart proposal > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor: > > > > > > 1777 chart in fact shows all the requirements you put forward. > > > > > > International affairs are seen from 7H. 7L is strong and well placed. > > > 7H is aspected by MBP. Thus it has commanding position in > > > international affairs. > > > > > > 5H shows intellactual properties. Again unafflicted and strong Moon is > > > residing here. The sign of intellact Libra is also strong with exalted > > > Saturn and 9L in the 10H. Therefore USA has been in the forefront of > > > scientific discoveries and command respect for that. These two planets > > > are on MEP's, therefore they influence five houses beneficially. > > > > > > Financial strength is seen from 2H, 5H the planets Moon and Venus. 2L > > > is exalted, wp and on MEP. Venus although slightly weak, but still > > > placed in 10H, in its own MTS. Moon is again wp, strong and > > > unafflicted. 9L in the 10H is an additional advantage. Both Mercury > > > and Saturn are afflicted by Rahu from the 6H, that shows why every > > > financial boom invited cheaters and manipulators, and why they ended > > > with stock market crashes. > > > > > > Its assertive attitude and the use of force in international affairs > > > come from Mars in Sagittarius in the 12H on MEP. It also aspect 3H of > > > communication and literary pursuits. It also aspects the 6H, which > > > according to you govern aggressive and assertive attitude. There is no > > > need of having a MTS in this house. The presence of Rahu and aspect of > > > Mars are more than enough. Both mars and Rahu produce conflicts. The > > > combination of Mars and Ketu in 12H shows why USA got involved in wars > > > in foreign lands. > > > > > > As I indicated before, 12L in the 8H shows natural disasters. Sun here > > > is a relatively weak. This combined with the affliction of 9L Mercury, > > > make its leaders succeptible to attacks by its own people. > > > > > > Both Sun and Jupiter are FM's and they do not afflict any planet or > > > house. But whenever they form cc/ca in transit, they produce > disasters. > > > > > > On 12/7/1941 both FM's Sun and Jupiter were aspecting each other > > > closely. Rahu was afflicting from 8H's MEP. The period was Jup/Ven. On > > > 9/11/2001, Mars and Ketu were together in the 12H. Six planets were > > > present in the malefic houses and FM's Sun and Jupiter were transiting > > > over the MEP's. The period was Ven/Jup. Therefore USA faced deadly > > > attacks on its soil. > > > > > > I will produce more data like that shortly. And I will show you that > > > this chart has both natal, transit and dasha requirements for being > > > the chart of the country USA. But I will first wait for Prof > > > Choudhry's point of view on this chart. Please note that I am not > > > averse to Cancer 21 degree chart or any other chart at all. The > > > interesting point is that 1777 chart also like 1781 chart show the > > > present stock market problems, because of the stationary Rahu/Ketu > > > axis at 22 degrees on the 2H and 8H MEP's. > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > > > > > Thank you for the kind words. > > > > > > > > I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what > John TWB > > > > shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the > > > > events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical > angle that > > > > motivates your investigations at this point. > > > > > > > > When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the > charts you > > > > are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider > some > > > > main points, which were explained by thus in a > > > > message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: > > > > > > > > " The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US in the > > > > international affairs, its commanding position in the intellectual > > > > properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive > > > > attitude including use of force in international affairs, the > > > > conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic > peace > > > > felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the > nation, > > > > the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of state, > > > > and important intervention in foreign policy around the world. The > > > > identification of the past events through sub periods or triple > > > > transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ > > > > aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the proposed > > > > chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any planet > > > > in the sixth house. " > > > > > > > > will revert on the chart identified by you. I > also > > > > look forward to hear what he will say about it. > > > > > > > > Finally, you should also consider the 21° Cancer rising SAMVA USA > > > > chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your > understanding of > > > > the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest > you the > > > > least that finds that this chart meets the above > > > > requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to predict the > > > > ongoing developments? > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Hello Thor: > > > > > > > > > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, > 1776. At > > > > > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > > > > > > > > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am > > doing > > > > > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. > > Pleas > > > > > e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What > I mean > > > > > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I > > now feel > > > > > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do > my work > > > > > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The > honorable > > > > > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > > > > > > > > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > > > > > > > > > Raj > > > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > > > > > > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > > > > > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA > because > > > > > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and > > many > > > > > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 > and not > > > > > > July 4... " > > > > > > > > > > > > Now you propose: > > > > > > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental > Congress. " > > > > > > > > > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for > many > > > > > > years, including studying their natal promise and making > > > predictions. > > > > > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More > > > recently, I > > > > > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB > on this > > > > > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a given > > > chart, > > > > > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is > retained, the > > > > > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must > develop a > > > > > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > > > > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are > > doing this > > > > > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and > > accurate > > > > > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not > enough. > > > > > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the > > work, > > > > > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > > > > > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be > pleased to > > > > > > consider that offering. > > > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about > > > finding an > > > > > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels > > > > > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 > > > > pm. Yet > > > > > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, > > which > > > > > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel > > > > > > > strongly about. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the > > choice of > > > > > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the > > > ratification > > > > > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. > > > But in > > > > > > > fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was > > > > > > > established the USA became a country of group of states united > > > under > > > > > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) > > > > when the > > > > > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, > > > > > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the > > > historical > > > > > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, > > > which is > > > > > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am > > > > proposing > > > > > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not > > only the > > > > > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it > > > explains > > > > > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical > > events. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. > > The > > > > > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in > > Libra > > > > > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual > > > > pursuits and > > > > > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of > > > > justice and > > > > > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, > > > > in the > > > > > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military > strength and > > > > > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of > Rahu on > > > > > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance > > > > > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. > > > > Together > > > > > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > > > > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural > > > calamities > > > > > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn > > > shows > > > > > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more > > > > > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. > > Here the > > > > > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, > 9/11/2001, > > > > > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun > > > (FM and > > > > > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms > > > > that both > > > > > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in > > > Cancer > > > > > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also > taken > > > > place > > > > > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the > > Capricorn > > > > > > > rising chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like > > > Jorge to > > > > > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look > > > > at this > > > > > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before > > > accepting a > > > > > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2007 Report Share Posted March 8, 2007 Dear Thor: In this note I am going to give you and the LIST my future predictions from the chart I proposed for USA(Nov 15, 1777, 12:25 EST, York, PA). But before that I am going to provide you some more evidence in favor of this chart. I will urge you to print out this chart and keep it before you read the following. In my last message I mentioned that the great depression occurred in Rah/Mars and Jup/Jup. During this entire period Saturn, the 2L, was in 12H, which contributed significantly towards the worst financial period in the history of USA. This supports that the ascendant of USA should be Capricorn. Between Jan 1966 and Aug 1982, the DJIA dropped from 995 to 777, and the inflation as measured by consumer price index increased from 95 to 308. Combine these two factors, you will see that the value of the investments dropped by about 75% in 16 and ½ years. This corresponds exactly to the main period of Mercury, which ran from Oct 1966 to Oct 1983. Please note that Mercury is conjunct 2L Saturn representing wealth and both are afflicted by Rahu from the sixth house of financial solvency. Therefore the value of money deteriorated throughout this period. No other chart will give you this kind of correlation for such a broad period of time. The major period of Ketu started after that which brought great bull market between 1983 and 1990. Although Ketu is badly placed, it is conjunct MBP Mars, and aspected closely by 2L, FB, Saturn from the 10H. Of course there was a stock market crash during this time, which by the way, occurred in Ketu/Jupiter period, as Jupiter is 12L representing losses. Then came the major period of Venus, which started in Oct 1990. Venus has a minor weakness due to infancy, but it is well placed in the 10H in its own MTS. Venus represents wealth. During its own sub-period, DJIA advanced from roughly 2900 to 3800. There was no significant gain in DJIA during Ven/Sun period as Sun is MMP and weak although well placed. Then came the best period of Ven/Moon from Feb 1995 to Oct 1996. The DJIA advanced from 3900 to 6600 (77% gain). Moon is the strongest planet in this chart. This advance continued in Ven/Mars period along with a minor correction in 1997. The DJIA ended at roughly 8000. Mars is also aspected by 2L Saturn from 10H. During Venus/Rahu period (Dec 1997 to Dec 2000) things went crazy after a brief correction in 1998. This is typical of Rahu, it gives short-lived exponential gains. Along with that came the manipulations (Rahu) of Enron, Adelphia, Worldcom, mutual funds and dot-com companies, etc. Then came the Jupiter sub-period (Dec 2000 to Aug 2003), which brought painful losses, stock market correction, weak dollar, Sep 11 attack etc. You see Jupiter after all is 12L in 8H. It was during this period USA went into Afghanistan and Iraq without proper justification. During Ven/Sat period, the stock market recovered a bit, but the inflation increased due to the cost of war, and oil prices. During this period the real estate prices soared because 2L Saturn aspects 4H and is aspected by Rahu. Now USA is going through Ven/Mer period since 10/25/2006. Mercury is 9L (religion) afflicted by Rahu (foreign countries) in 6H (conflict). No wonder USA got involved in religious conflict in Iraq. This period will go until Aug 2009. Here are my predictions: USA will have a recession during 2007-2008. In fact the recession has already started. This is because of the sub-period of Mercury, which causes inflation, recessions and expenditures on war due to the aspect of Rahu from the 6H. This aspect will also create significant problems for the leadership as Rahu aspects 10H also. Because this aspect is from 6H, it will cause credit problems to many Americans and you will see a lot of real estate foreclosures. End of August 2007 may bring a tragic incident on the scene. Real estate prices will fall until the end of 2008, and start recovering in 2009 and 2010. USA will not pull out of Iraq or Afghanistan before the end of 2009. Rather, it is highly probable that this war may widen in 2007 or 2008. But in the end USA will be able to minimize the terrorist threats to its mainland and its interests abroad. This can happen just after Venus/Ketu starts in Aug 2009. The major period of Sun from Oct 2010 to Oct 2016, will bring many difficulties for USA, its leaders and its financial system, although there will be recoveries during Sun/Moon and Sun/Venus periods. Natural disasters such as earthquakes and hurricanes are also highly probable during this period as Sun is MMP. Energy crisis will push Americans to make use of Solar Energy. New economic boom will start with the advent of Moon major-period in 2016. I once again request to look ino this chart. Thanks Raj SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer wrote: > > Dear Raj, > > To get real consideration a set of predictions needs to be made > against the chart. Please feel free to make the predictions. > > Best wishes, > > Thor > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > Dear Mr. Choudhry and Thor: > > > > Your analysis does have a few points. But I am sure you will agree > > with me that USA is not a perfect country. It has its due share of > > tragedies and weaknesses. The chart for USA should show them. The > > Nov1777 chart shows them better than Feb1781 charts. I would like to > > submit a few more points for your consideration. I hope you re-valuate > > the merit of this chart in totallity. > > > > Influenza epidemic of 1918 killed more than 100,000 American people. > > The period according to the chart I propose was Rahu/Jup. Both are > > FM's and both are badly placed. In transit Jupiter was in the sign > > Gemini, placed in 6H in the sign of lungs. > > > > The great depression (1930-1933) occured during the periods of > > Rahu/Mars and Jup/Jup. Rahu, Mars and Jup all are badly placed, and > > affects so many houses and planets, creating worst of the atmosphere. > > > > 1962 Cuban missile episode occured in Sat/Rahu, once again Rahu on 6H > > MEP shows it clearly. President Kennedy and Dr. King killed in the > > sixties. The period was Sat/Rahu and Sat/Jup. Once again Rahu > > afflicting Saturn, and FM Jupiter in 8H explains everything very nicely. > > > > Watergate episode and Opec oil embargo, which created most frustrating > > days in USA occured in Mer/Sun period. Sun being the MMP produced its > > effects and hurt the president of the country. > > > > Coming back to the natal chart, USA is a litigious society. People are > > always ready to sue each other. It is dominated by lawyers. In the > > chart I recommend, majority of planets are in signs Libra and > > Sagittarius. Both these signs are connected with law. > > > > USA is a sincere and trustworthy friend to certain countries. > > Sincerity and loyality are hallmark qualities of Capricorn ascendant > > more than any other sign. > > > > Ascendants Cancer or Virgo are too soft ascendants for a country like > > USA. Even Scorpio is not appropriate, because Scorpio will wait for an > > appropriate time to take revenge. Crocodile (the symbol for Capricorn) > > on the other hand lay dormant near the riverbanks and will not react > > unless provoked. But once provoked, it reacts ferocioulsy without > > waiting. It then completely annhilates the enemy. Look what happenend > > after Pearl harbor. And what is happeneing after Sept 11. Based on > > this simple fact I predict that USA will not rest untill it eliminates > > Al-Qaida completely. It does not matter who the president is, George > > Bush or any democrat. > > > > As I said in the beginning, please consider the merit of the chart in > > its entirity, not just the strengths of the planets. > > > > Thank you for being so understanding and patient. > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > SAMVA , <siha@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > Hello dear Mr. Chadha, > > > > > > Weakness of Venus XL, close affliction of nodes to houses influences > > and > > > close affliction of Rahu from sixth house to Saturn IIL and exact > > affliction > > > to Mercury IXL besides placement of Mars IVL in the twelfth house and > > > Jupiter XIIL in the eighth house does not allow me to say that this > > chart > > > merits consideration as the chart for USA. > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > - > > > " rkchadha " <rkctech@> > > > <SAMVA > > > > Tuesday, March 06, 2007 4:14 AM > > > Re: New USA chart proposal > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor: > > > > > > 1777 chart in fact shows all the requirements you put forward. > > > > > > International affairs are seen from 7H. 7L is strong and well placed. > > > 7H is aspected by MBP. Thus it has commanding position in > > > international affairs. > > > > > > 5H shows intellactual properties. Again unafflicted and strong Moon is > > > residing here. The sign of intellact Libra is also strong with exalted > > > Saturn and 9L in the 10H. Therefore USA has been in the forefront of > > > scientific discoveries and command respect for that. These two planets > > > are on MEP's, therefore they influence five houses beneficially. > > > > > > Financial strength is seen from 2H, 5H the planets Moon and Venus. 2L > > > is exalted, wp and on MEP. Venus although slightly weak, but still > > > placed in 10H, in its own MTS. Moon is again wp, strong and > > > unafflicted. 9L in the 10H is an additional advantage. Both Mercury > > > and Saturn are afflicted by Rahu from the 6H, that shows why every > > > financial boom invited cheaters and manipulators, and why they ended > > > with stock market crashes. > > > > > > Its assertive attitude and the use of force in international affairs > > > come from Mars in Sagittarius in the 12H on MEP. It also aspect 3H of > > > communication and literary pursuits. It also aspects the 6H, which > > > according to you govern aggressive and assertive attitude. There is no > > > need of having a MTS in this house. The presence of Rahu and aspect of > > > Mars are more than enough. Both mars and Rahu produce conflicts. The > > > combination of Mars and Ketu in 12H shows why USA got involved in wars > > > in foreign lands. > > > > > > As I indicated before, 12L in the 8H shows natural disasters. Sun here > > > is a relatively weak. This combined with the affliction of 9L Mercury, > > > make its leaders succeptible to attacks by its own people. > > > > > > Both Sun and Jupiter are FM's and they do not afflict any planet or > > > house. But whenever they form cc/ca in transit, they produce > disasters. > > > > > > On 12/7/1941 both FM's Sun and Jupiter were aspecting each other > > > closely. Rahu was afflicting from 8H's MEP. The period was Jup/Ven. On > > > 9/11/2001, Mars and Ketu were together in the 12H. Six planets were > > > present in the malefic houses and FM's Sun and Jupiter were transiting > > > over the MEP's. The period was Ven/Jup. Therefore USA faced deadly > > > attacks on its soil. > > > > > > I will produce more data like that shortly. And I will show you that > > > this chart has both natal, transit and dasha requirements for being > > > the chart of the country USA. But I will first wait for Prof > > > Choudhry's point of view on this chart. Please note that I am not > > > averse to Cancer 21 degree chart or any other chart at all. The > > > interesting point is that 1777 chart also like 1781 chart show the > > > present stock market problems, because of the stationary Rahu/Ketu > > > axis at 22 degrees on the 2H and 8H MEP's. > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > > > > > Thank you for the kind words. > > > > > > > > I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what > John TWB > > > > shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the > > > > events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical > angle that > > > > motivates your investigations at this point. > > > > > > > > When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the > charts you > > > > are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider > some > > > > main points, which were explained by thus in a > > > > message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: > > > > > > > > " The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US in the > > > > international affairs, its commanding position in the intellectual > > > > properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive > > > > attitude including use of force in international affairs, the > > > > conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic > peace > > > > felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the > nation, > > > > the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of state, > > > > and important intervention in foreign policy around the world. The > > > > identification of the past events through sub periods or triple > > > > transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ > > > > aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the proposed > > > > chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any planet > > > > in the sixth house. " > > > > > > > > will revert on the chart identified by you. I > also > > > > look forward to hear what he will say about it. > > > > > > > > Finally, you should also consider the 21° Cancer rising SAMVA USA > > > > chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your > understanding of > > > > the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest > you the > > > > least that finds that this chart meets the above > > > > requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to predict the > > > > ongoing developments? > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Hello Thor: > > > > > > > > > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, > 1776. At > > > > > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > > > > > > > > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am > > doing > > > > > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. > > Pleas > > > > > e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What > I mean > > > > > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I > > now feel > > > > > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do > my work > > > > > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The > honorable > > > > > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > > > > > > > > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > > > > > > > > > Raj > > > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > > > > > > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > > > > > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA > because > > > > > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and > > many > > > > > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 > and not > > > > > > July 4... " > > > > > > > > > > > > Now you propose: > > > > > > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental > Congress. " > > > > > > > > > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for > many > > > > > > years, including studying their natal promise and making > > > predictions. > > > > > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More > > > recently, I > > > > > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB > on this > > > > > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a given > > > chart, > > > > > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is > retained, the > > > > > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must > develop a > > > > > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > > > > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are > > doing this > > > > > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and > > accurate > > > > > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not > enough. > > > > > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the > > work, > > > > > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > > > > > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be > pleased to > > > > > > consider that offering. > > > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about > > > finding an > > > > > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge feels > > > > > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about 2/2/1781, 5:05 > > > > pm. Yet > > > > > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, > > which > > > > > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron Grimes feel > > > > > > > strongly about. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the > > choice of > > > > > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the > > > ratification > > > > > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of USA. > > > But in > > > > > > > fact it should be the time and date when the confederation was > > > > > > > established the USA became a country of group of states united > > > under > > > > > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) > > > > when the > > > > > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in York, > > > > > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the > > > historical > > > > > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, > > > which is > > > > > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am > > > > proposing > > > > > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not > > only the > > > > > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it > > > explains > > > > > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical > > events. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. > > The > > > > > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in > > Libra > > > > > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual > > > > pursuits and > > > > > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of > > > > justice and > > > > > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP of 12H, > > > > in the > > > > > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military > strength and > > > > > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of > Rahu on > > > > > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial exuberance > > > > > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. > > > > Together > > > > > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > > > > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural > > > calamities > > > > > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of Saturn > > > shows > > > > > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever more > > > > > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. > > Here the > > > > > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, > 9/11/2001, > > > > > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun > > > (FM and > > > > > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms > > > > that both > > > > > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn as in > > > Cancer > > > > > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also > taken > > > > place > > > > > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the > > Capricorn > > > > > > > rising chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like > > > Jorge to > > > > > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to please look > > > > at this > > > > > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before > > > accepting a > > > > > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2007 Report Share Posted March 9, 2007 Dear Raj, has already given you his view on this chart. In my experience, when I have asked for s advice and he has given it, the advice has stood the test of time. I therefore heed his advice. Additionally, if he has given the view that this particular chart does not have merit, we cannot expect him to spend his precious time on such an exercise. His attention is in great demand and he spends his time and energy where it is of most benefit, normally helping people with pressing real life problems. However, I am willing to go along with you for the sake of the exercise of making the prediction. It is an impressive effort by you in its own right. That said, I think it would be useful if you explain a bit more precisely what astrological factors are behind each prediction, including natal promise and period and transit influences. We can then more easily assess if the prediction is based on a correct assessment of the astrological factors. If so, the time must then pass for it to be shown to be right or wrong. Best wishes, Thor SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech wrote: > > Dear Thor: > > In this note I am going to give you and the LIST my future predictions > from the chart I proposed for USA(Nov 15, 1777, 12:25 EST, York, PA). > But before that I am going to provide you some more evidence in favor > of this chart. I will urge you to print out this chart and keep it > before you read the following. > > In my last message I mentioned that the great depression occurred in > Rah/Mars and Jup/Jup. During this entire period Saturn, the 2L, was in > 12H, which contributed significantly towards the worst financial > period in the history of USA. This supports that the ascendant of USA > should be Capricorn. > > Between Jan 1966 and Aug 1982, the DJIA dropped from 995 to 777, and > the inflation as measured by consumer price index increased from 95 to > 308. Combine these two factors, you will see that the value of the > investments dropped by about 75% in 16 and ½ years. This corresponds > exactly to the main period of Mercury, which ran from Oct 1966 to Oct > 1983. Please note that Mercury is conjunct 2L Saturn representing > wealth and both are afflicted by Rahu from the sixth house of > financial solvency. Therefore the value of money deteriorated > throughout this period. No other chart will give you this kind of > correlation for such a broad period of time. > > The major period of Ketu started after that which brought great bull > market between 1983 and 1990. Although Ketu is badly placed, it is > conjunct MBP Mars, and aspected closely by 2L, FB, Saturn from the > 10H. Of course there was a stock market crash during this time, which > by the way, occurred in Ketu/Jupiter period, as Jupiter is 12L > representing losses. > > Then came the major period of Venus, which started in Oct 1990. Venus > has a minor weakness due to infancy, but it is well placed in the 10H > in its own MTS. Venus represents wealth. During its own sub-period, > DJIA advanced from roughly 2900 to 3800. There was no significant gain > in DJIA during Ven/Sun period as Sun is MMP and weak although well > placed. Then came the best period of Ven/Moon from Feb 1995 to Oct > 1996. The DJIA advanced from 3900 to 6600 (77% gain). Moon is the > strongest planet in this chart. This advance continued in Ven/Mars > period along with a minor correction in 1997. The DJIA ended at > roughly 8000. Mars is also aspected by 2L Saturn from 10H. During > Venus/Rahu period (Dec 1997 to Dec 2000) things went crazy after a > brief correction in 1998. This is typical of Rahu, it gives > short-lived exponential gains. Along with that came the manipulations > (Rahu) of Enron, Adelphia, Worldcom, mutual funds and dot-com > companies, etc. Then came the Jupiter sub-period (Dec 2000 to Aug > 2003), which brought painful losses, stock market correction, weak > dollar, Sep 11 attack etc. You see Jupiter after all is 12L in 8H. It > was during this period USA went into Afghanistan and Iraq without > proper justification. During Ven/Sat period, the stock market > recovered a bit, but the inflation increased due to the cost of war, > and oil prices. During this period the real estate prices soared > because 2L Saturn aspects 4H and is aspected by Rahu. > > Now USA is going through Ven/Mer period since 10/25/2006. Mercury is > 9L (religion) afflicted by Rahu (foreign countries) in 6H (conflict). > No wonder USA got involved in religious conflict in Iraq. This period > will go until Aug 2009. > > Here are my predictions: > > USA will have a recession during 2007-2008. In fact the recession has > already started. This is because of the sub-period of Mercury, which > causes inflation, recessions and expenditures on war due to the aspect > of Rahu from the 6H. This aspect will also create significant problems > for the leadership as Rahu aspects 10H also. Because this aspect is > from 6H, it will cause credit problems to many Americans and you will > see a lot of real estate foreclosures. End of August 2007 may bring a > tragic incident on the scene. > > Real estate prices will fall until the end of 2008, and start > recovering in 2009 and 2010. > > USA will not pull out of Iraq or Afghanistan before the end of 2009. > Rather, it is highly probable that this war may widen in 2007 or 2008. > But in the end USA will be able to minimize the terrorist threats to > its mainland and its interests abroad. This can happen just after > Venus/Ketu starts in Aug 2009. > > The major period of Sun from Oct 2010 to Oct 2016, will bring many > difficulties for USA, its leaders and its financial system, although > there will be recoveries during Sun/Moon and Sun/Venus periods. > Natural disasters such as earthquakes and hurricanes are also highly > probable during this period as Sun is MMP. Energy crisis will push > Americans to make use of Solar Energy. > > New economic boom will start with the advent of Moon major-period in 2016. > > I once again request to look ino this chart. > > Thanks > > Raj > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > To get real consideration a set of predictions needs to be made > > against the chart. Please feel free to make the predictions. > > > > Best wishes, > > > > Thor > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Mr. Choudhry and Thor: > > > > > > Your analysis does have a few points. But I am sure you will agree > > > with me that USA is not a perfect country. It has its due share of > > > tragedies and weaknesses. The chart for USA should show them. The > > > Nov1777 chart shows them better than Feb1781 charts. I would like to > > > submit a few more points for your consideration. I hope you re-valuate > > > the merit of this chart in totallity. > > > > > > Influenza epidemic of 1918 killed more than 100,000 American people. > > > The period according to the chart I propose was Rahu/Jup. Both are > > > FM's and both are badly placed. In transit Jupiter was in the sign > > > Gemini, placed in 6H in the sign of lungs. > > > > > > The great depression (1930-1933) occured during the periods of > > > Rahu/Mars and Jup/Jup. Rahu, Mars and Jup all are badly placed, and > > > affects so many houses and planets, creating worst of the atmosphere. > > > > > > 1962 Cuban missile episode occured in Sat/Rahu, once again Rahu on 6H > > > MEP shows it clearly. President Kennedy and Dr. King killed in the > > > sixties. The period was Sat/Rahu and Sat/Jup. Once again Rahu > > > afflicting Saturn, and FM Jupiter in 8H explains everything very > nicely. > > > > > > Watergate episode and Opec oil embargo, which created most frustrating > > > days in USA occured in Mer/Sun period. Sun being the MMP produced its > > > effects and hurt the president of the country. > > > > > > Coming back to the natal chart, USA is a litigious society. People are > > > always ready to sue each other. It is dominated by lawyers. In the > > > chart I recommend, majority of planets are in signs Libra and > > > Sagittarius. Both these signs are connected with law. > > > > > > USA is a sincere and trustworthy friend to certain countries. > > > Sincerity and loyality are hallmark qualities of Capricorn ascendant > > > more than any other sign. > > > > > > Ascendants Cancer or Virgo are too soft ascendants for a country like > > > USA. Even Scorpio is not appropriate, because Scorpio will wait for an > > > appropriate time to take revenge. Crocodile (the symbol for Capricorn) > > > on the other hand lay dormant near the riverbanks and will not react > > > unless provoked. But once provoked, it reacts ferocioulsy without > > > waiting. It then completely annhilates the enemy. Look what happenend > > > after Pearl harbor. And what is happeneing after Sept 11. Based on > > > this simple fact I predict that USA will not rest untill it eliminates > > > Al-Qaida completely. It does not matter who the president is, George > > > Bush or any democrat. > > > > > > As I said in the beginning, please consider the merit of the chart in > > > its entirity, not just the strengths of the planets. > > > > > > Thank you for being so understanding and patient. > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , <siha@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello dear Mr. Chadha, > > > > > > > > Weakness of Venus XL, close affliction of nodes to houses influences > > > and > > > > close affliction of Rahu from sixth house to Saturn IIL and exact > > > affliction > > > > to Mercury IXL besides placement of Mars IVL in the twelfth > house and > > > > Jupiter XIIL in the eighth house does not allow me to say that this > > > chart > > > > merits consideration as the chart for USA. > > > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > - > > > > " rkchadha " <rkctech@> > > > > <SAMVA > > > > > Tuesday, March 06, 2007 4:14 AM > > > > Re: New USA chart proposal > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor: > > > > > > > > 1777 chart in fact shows all the requirements you put forward. > > > > > > > > International affairs are seen from 7H. 7L is strong and well > placed. > > > > 7H is aspected by MBP. Thus it has commanding position in > > > > international affairs. > > > > > > > > 5H shows intellactual properties. Again unafflicted and strong > Moon is > > > > residing here. The sign of intellact Libra is also strong with > exalted > > > > Saturn and 9L in the 10H. Therefore USA has been in the forefront of > > > > scientific discoveries and command respect for that. These two > planets > > > > are on MEP's, therefore they influence five houses beneficially. > > > > > > > > Financial strength is seen from 2H, 5H the planets Moon and > Venus. 2L > > > > is exalted, wp and on MEP. Venus although slightly weak, but still > > > > placed in 10H, in its own MTS. Moon is again wp, strong and > > > > unafflicted. 9L in the 10H is an additional advantage. Both Mercury > > > > and Saturn are afflicted by Rahu from the 6H, that shows why every > > > > financial boom invited cheaters and manipulators, and why they ended > > > > with stock market crashes. > > > > > > > > Its assertive attitude and the use of force in international affairs > > > > come from Mars in Sagittarius in the 12H on MEP. It also aspect > 3H of > > > > communication and literary pursuits. It also aspects the 6H, which > > > > according to you govern aggressive and assertive attitude. There > is no > > > > need of having a MTS in this house. The presence of Rahu and > aspect of > > > > Mars are more than enough. Both mars and Rahu produce conflicts. The > > > > combination of Mars and Ketu in 12H shows why USA got involved > in wars > > > > in foreign lands. > > > > > > > > As I indicated before, 12L in the 8H shows natural disasters. > Sun here > > > > is a relatively weak. This combined with the affliction of 9L > Mercury, > > > > make its leaders succeptible to attacks by its own people. > > > > > > > > Both Sun and Jupiter are FM's and they do not afflict any planet or > > > > house. But whenever they form cc/ca in transit, they produce > > disasters. > > > > > > > > On 12/7/1941 both FM's Sun and Jupiter were aspecting each other > > > > closely. Rahu was afflicting from 8H's MEP. The period was > Jup/Ven. On > > > > 9/11/2001, Mars and Ketu were together in the 12H. Six planets were > > > > present in the malefic houses and FM's Sun and Jupiter were > transiting > > > > over the MEP's. The period was Ven/Jup. Therefore USA faced deadly > > > > attacks on its soil. > > > > > > > > I will produce more data like that shortly. And I will show you that > > > > this chart has both natal, transit and dasha requirements for being > > > > the chart of the country USA. But I will first wait for Prof > > > > Choudhry's point of view on this chart. Please note that I am not > > > > averse to Cancer 21 degree chart or any other chart at all. The > > > > interesting point is that 1777 chart also like 1781 chart show the > > > > present stock market problems, because of the stationary Rahu/Ketu > > > > axis at 22 degrees on the 2H and 8H MEP's. > > > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for the kind words. > > > > > > > > > > I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what > > John TWB > > > > > shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the > > > > > events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical > > angle that > > > > > motivates your investigations at this point. > > > > > > > > > > When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the > > charts you > > > > > are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider > > some > > > > > main points, which were explained by thus in a > > > > > message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: > > > > > > > > > > " The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US in the > > > > > international affairs, its commanding position in the intellectual > > > > > properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive > > > > > attitude including use of force in international affairs, the > > > > > conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic > > peace > > > > > felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the > > nation, > > > > > the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of > state, > > > > > and important intervention in foreign policy around the > world. The > > > > > identification of the past events through sub periods or triple > > > > > transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ > > > > > aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the > proposed > > > > > chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any > planet > > > > > in the sixth house. " > > > > > > > > > > will revert on the chart identified by you. I > > also > > > > > look forward to hear what he will say about it. > > > > > > > > > > Finally, you should also consider the 21° Cancer rising SAMVA USA > > > > > chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your > > understanding of > > > > > the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest > > you the > > > > > least that finds that this chart meets the > above > > > > > requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to > predict the > > > > > ongoing developments? > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello Thor: > > > > > > > > > > > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, > > 1776. At > > > > > > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am > > > doing > > > > > > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. > > > Pleas > > > > > > e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What > > I mean > > > > > > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I > > > now feel > > > > > > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do > > my work > > > > > > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The > > honorable > > > > > > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj > > > > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > > > > > > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA > > because > > > > > > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and > > > many > > > > > > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 > > and not > > > > > > > July 4... " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Now you propose: > > > > > > > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental > > Congress. " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for > > many > > > > > > > years, including studying their natal promise and making > > > > predictions. > > > > > > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More > > > > recently, I > > > > > > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB > > on this > > > > > > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA > chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a > given > > > > chart, > > > > > > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is > > retained, the > > > > > > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must > > develop a > > > > > > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > > > > > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are > > > doing this > > > > > > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and > > > accurate > > > > > > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not > > enough. > > > > > > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the > > > work, > > > > > > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > > > > > > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be > > pleased to > > > > > > > consider that offering. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about > > > > finding an > > > > > > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge > feels > > > > > > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about > 2/2/1781, 5:05 > > > > > pm. Yet > > > > > > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, > > > which > > > > > > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron > Grimes feel > > > > > > > > strongly about. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the > > > choice of > > > > > > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the > > > > ratification > > > > > > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of > USA. > > > > But in > > > > > > > > fact it should be the time and date when the > confederation was > > > > > > > > established the USA became a country of group of states > united > > > > under > > > > > > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) > > > > > when the > > > > > > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in > York, > > > > > > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the > > > > historical > > > > > > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, > > > > which is > > > > > > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am > > > > > proposing > > > > > > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not > > > only the > > > > > > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it > > > > explains > > > > > > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical > > > events. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. > > > The > > > > > > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in > > > Libra > > > > > > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual > > > > > pursuits and > > > > > > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of > > > > > justice and > > > > > > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP > of 12H, > > > > > in the > > > > > > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military > > strength and > > > > > > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of > > Rahu on > > > > > > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial > exuberance > > > > > > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. > > > > > Together > > > > > > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > > > > > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural > > > > calamities > > > > > > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of > Saturn > > > > shows > > > > > > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever > more > > > > > > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. > > > Here the > > > > > > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, > > 9/11/2001, > > > > > > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun > > > > (FM and > > > > > > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms > > > > > that both > > > > > > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn > as in > > > > Cancer > > > > > > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also > > taken > > > > > place > > > > > > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the > > > Capricorn > > > > > > > > rising chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like > > > > Jorge to > > > > > > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to > please look > > > > > at this > > > > > > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before > > > > accepting a > > > > > > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2007 Report Share Posted March 12, 2007 Dear Thor: Most of my predictions are based on the current sub-period of Mercury (aspected by Rahu on 6H), as I already explained in the last note. I think USA will pull it troops after Venu/Ketu period begins in August 2009. Ketu stands for withdrawal, it aspects 4H (Home) and it conjuncts Mars (military). Therefore it will withdraw its military from Iraq after Aug 2009. You may have to wait until that period to convince yourself of the validity of this chart. I think SAMVA first accepted July2, 1776 chart, then Feb1781 chart too hastily, without due diligence. Now it finds itself in an awkward situation to accept the third chart. Therefore you guys are reluctant to accept it. But that is OK with me. It takes time for the truth to come out. Best wishes cosmologer <cosmologer wrote: Dear Raj, has already given you his view on this chart. In my experience, when I have asked for s advice and he has given it, the advice has stood the test of time. I therefore heed his advice. Additionally, if he has given the view that this particular chart does not have merit, we cannot expect him to spend his precious time on such an exercise. His attention is in great demand and he spends his time and energy where it is of most benefit, normally helping people with pressing real life problems. However, I am willing to go along with you for the sake of the exercise of making the prediction. It is an impressive effort by you in its own right. That said, I think it would be useful if you explain a bit more precisely what astrological factors are behind each prediction, including natal promise and period and transit influences. We can then more easily assess if the prediction is based on a correct assessment of the astrological factors. If so, the time must then pass for it to be shown to be right or wrong. Best wishes, Thor SAMVA , "rkchadha" <rkctech wrote: > > Dear Thor: > > In this note I am going to give you and the LIST my future predictions > from the chart I proposed for USA(Nov 15, 1777, 12:25 EST, York, PA). > But before that I am going to provide you some more evidence in favor > of this chart. I will urge you to print out this chart and keep it > before you read the following. > > In my last message I mentioned that the great depression occurred in > Rah/Mars and Jup/Jup. During this entire period Saturn, the 2L, was in > 12H, which contributed significantly towards the worst financial > period in the history of USA. This supports that the ascendant of USA > should be Capricorn. > > Between Jan 1966 and Aug 1982, the DJIA dropped from 995 to 777, and > the inflation as measured by consumer price index increased from 95 to > 308. Combine these two factors, you will see that the value of the > investments dropped by about 75% in 16 and ½ years. This corresponds > exactly to the main period of Mercury, which ran from Oct 1966 to Oct > 1983. Please note that Mercury is conjunct 2L Saturn representing > wealth and both are afflicted by Rahu from the sixth house of > financial solvency. Therefore the value of money deteriorated > throughout this period. No other chart will give you this kind of > correlation for such a broad period of time. > > The major period of Ketu started after that which brought great bull > market between 1983 and 1990. Although Ketu is badly placed, it is > conjunct MBP Mars, and aspected closely by 2L, FB, Saturn from the > 10H. Of course there was a stock market crash during this time, which > by the way, occurred in Ketu/Jupiter period, as Jupiter is 12L > representing losses. > > Then came the major period of Venus, which started in Oct 1990. Venus > has a minor weakness due to infancy, but it is well placed in the 10H > in its own MTS. Venus represents wealth. During its own sub-period, > DJIA advanced from roughly 2900 to 3800. There was no significant gain > in DJIA during Ven/Sun period as Sun is MMP and weak although well > placed. Then came the best period of Ven/Moon from Feb 1995 to Oct > 1996. The DJIA advanced from 3900 to 6600 (77% gain). Moon is the > strongest planet in this chart. This advance continued in Ven/Mars > period along with a minor correction in 1997. The DJIA ended at > roughly 8000. Mars is also aspected by 2L Saturn from 10H. During > Venus/Rahu period (Dec 1997 to Dec 2000) things went crazy after a > brief correction in 1998. This is typical of Rahu, it gives > short-lived exponential gains. Along with that came the manipulations > (Rahu) of Enron, Adelphia, Worldcom, mutual funds and dot-com > companies, etc. Then came the Jupiter sub-period (Dec 2000 to Aug > 2003), which brought painful losses, stock market correction, weak > dollar, Sep 11 attack etc. You see Jupiter after all is 12L in 8H. It > was during this period USA went into Afghanistan and Iraq without > proper justification. During Ven/Sat period, the stock market > recovered a bit, but the inflation increased due to the cost of war, > and oil prices. During this period the real estate prices soared > because 2L Saturn aspects 4H and is aspected by Rahu. > > Now USA is going through Ven/Mer period since 10/25/2006. Mercury is > 9L (religion) afflicted by Rahu (foreign countries) in 6H (conflict). > No wonder USA got involved in religious conflict in Iraq. This period > will go until Aug 2009. > > Here are my predictions: > > USA will have a recession during 2007-2008. In fact the recession has > already started. This is because of the sub-period of Mercury, which > causes inflation, recessions and expenditures on war due to the aspect > of Rahu from the 6H. This aspect will also create significant problems > for the leadership as Rahu aspects 10H also. Because this aspect is > from 6H, it will cause credit problems to many Americans and you will > see a lot of real estate foreclosures. End of August 2007 may bring a > tragic incident on the scene. > > Real estate prices will fall until the end of 2008, and start > recovering in 2009 and 2010. > > USA will not pull out of Iraq or Afghanistan before the end of 2009. > Rather, it is highly probable that this war may widen in 2007 or 2008. > But in the end USA will be able to minimize the terrorist threats to > its mainland and its interests abroad. This can happen just after > Venus/Ketu starts in Aug 2009. > > The major period of Sun from Oct 2010 to Oct 2016, will bring many > difficulties for USA, its leaders and its financial system, although > there will be recoveries during Sun/Moon and Sun/Venus periods. > Natural disasters such as earthquakes and hurricanes are also highly > probable during this period as Sun is MMP. Energy crisis will push > Americans to make use of Solar Energy. > > New economic boom will start with the advent of Moon major-period in 2016. > > I once again request to look ino this chart. > > Thanks > > Raj > > > SAMVA , "cosmologer" <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > To get real consideration a set of predictions needs to be made > > against the chart. Please feel free to make the predictions. > > > > Best wishes, > > > > Thor > > > > > > SAMVA , "rkchadha" <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Mr. Choudhry and Thor: > > > > > > Your analysis does have a few points. But I am sure you will agree > > > with me that USA is not a perfect country. It has its due share of > > > tragedies and weaknesses. The chart for USA should show them. The > > > Nov1777 chart shows them better than Feb1781 charts. I would like to > > > submit a few more points for your consideration. I hope you re-valuate > > > the merit of this chart in totallity. > > > > > > Influenza epidemic of 1918 killed more than 100,000 American people. > > > The period according to the chart I propose was Rahu/Jup. Both are > > > FM's and both are badly placed. In transit Jupiter was in the sign > > > Gemini, placed in 6H in the sign of lungs. > > > > > > The great depression (1930-1933) occured during the periods of > > > Rahu/Mars and Jup/Jup. Rahu, Mars and Jup all are badly placed, and > > > affects so many houses and planets, creating worst of the atmosphere. > > > > > > 1962 Cuban missile episode occured in Sat/Rahu, once again Rahu on 6H > > > MEP shows it clearly. President Kennedy and Dr. King killed in the > > > sixties. The period was Sat/Rahu and Sat/Jup. Once again Rahu > > > afflicting Saturn, and FM Jupiter in 8H explains everything very > nicely. > > > > > > Watergate episode and Opec oil embargo, which created most frustrating > > > days in USA occured in Mer/Sun period. Sun being the MMP produced its > > > effects and hurt the president of the country. > > > > > > Coming back to the natal chart, USA is a litigious society. People are > > > always ready to sue each other. It is dominated by lawyers. In the > > > chart I recommend, majority of planets are in signs Libra and > > > Sagittarius. Both these signs are connected with law. > > > > > > USA is a sincere and trustworthy friend to certain countries. > > > Sincerity and loyality are hallmark qualities of Capricorn ascendant > > > more than any other sign. > > > > > > Ascendants Cancer or Virgo are too soft ascendants for a country like > > > USA. Even Scorpio is not appropriate, because Scorpio will wait for an > > > appropriate time to take revenge. Crocodile (the symbol for Capricorn) > > > on the other hand lay dormant near the riverbanks and will not react > > > unless provoked. But once provoked, it reacts ferocioulsy without > > > waiting. It then completely annhilates the enemy. Look what happenend > > > after Pearl harbor. And what is happeneing after Sept 11. Based on > > > this simple fact I predict that USA will not rest untill it eliminates > > > Al-Qaida completely. It does not matter who the president is, George > > > Bush or any democrat. > > > > > > As I said in the beginning, please consider the merit of the chart in > > > its entirity, not just the strengths of the planets. > > > > > > Thank you for being so understanding and patient. > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , <siha@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello dear Mr. Chadha, > > > > > > > > Weakness of Venus XL, close affliction of nodes to houses influences > > > and > > > > close affliction of Rahu from sixth house to Saturn IIL and exact > > > affliction > > > > to Mercury IXL besides placement of Mars IVL in the twelfth > house and > > > > Jupiter XIIL in the eighth house does not allow me to say that this > > > chart > > > > merits consideration as the chart for USA. > > > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > - > > > > "rkchadha" <rkctech@> > > > > <SAMVA > > > > > Tuesday, March 06, 2007 4:14 AM > > > > Re: New USA chart proposal > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor: > > > > > > > > 1777 chart in fact shows all the requirements you put forward. > > > > > > > > International affairs are seen from 7H. 7L is strong and well > placed. > > > > 7H is aspected by MBP. Thus it has commanding position in > > > > international affairs. > > > > > > > > 5H shows intellactual properties. Again unafflicted and strong > Moon is > > > > residing here. The sign of intellact Libra is also strong with > exalted > > > > Saturn and 9L in the 10H. Therefore USA has been in the forefront of > > > > scientific discoveries and command respect for that. These two > planets > > > > are on MEP's, therefore they influence five houses beneficially. > > > > > > > > Financial strength is seen from 2H, 5H the planets Moon and > Venus. 2L > > > > is exalted, wp and on MEP. Venus although slightly weak, but still > > > > placed in 10H, in its own MTS. Moon is again wp, strong and > > > > unafflicted. 9L in the 10H is an additional advantage. Both Mercury > > > > and Saturn are afflicted by Rahu from the 6H, that shows why every > > > > financial boom invited cheaters and manipulators, and why they ended > > > > with stock market crashes. > > > > > > > > Its assertive attitude and the use of force in international affairs > > > > come from Mars in Sagittarius in the 12H on MEP. It also aspect > 3H of > > > > communication and literary pursuits. It also aspects the 6H, which > > > > according to you govern aggressive and assertive attitude. There > is no > > > > need of having a MTS in this house. The presence of Rahu and > aspect of > > > > Mars are more than enough. Both mars and Rahu produce conflicts. The > > > > combination of Mars and Ketu in 12H shows why USA got involved > in wars > > > > in foreign lands. > > > > > > > > As I indicated before, 12L in the 8H shows natural disasters. > Sun here > > > > is a relatively weak. This combined with the affliction of 9L > Mercury, > > > > make its leaders succeptible to attacks by its own people. > > > > > > > > Both Sun and Jupiter are FM's and they do not afflict any planet or > > > > house. But whenever they form cc/ca in transit, they produce > > disasters. > > > > > > > > On 12/7/1941 both FM's Sun and Jupiter were aspecting each other > > > > closely. Rahu was afflicting from 8H's MEP. The period was > Jup/Ven. On > > > > 9/11/2001, Mars and Ketu were together in the 12H. Six planets were > > > > present in the malefic houses and FM's Sun and Jupiter were > transiting > > > > over the MEP's. The period was Ven/Jup. Therefore USA faced deadly > > > > attacks on its soil. > > > > > > > > I will produce more data like that shortly. And I will show you that > > > > this chart has both natal, transit and dasha requirements for being > > > > the chart of the country USA. But I will first wait for Prof > > > > Choudhry's point of view on this chart. Please note that I am not > > > > averse to Cancer 21 degree chart or any other chart at all. The > > > > interesting point is that 1777 chart also like 1781 chart show the > > > > present stock market problems, because of the stationary Rahu/Ketu > > > > axis at 22 degrees on the 2H and 8H MEP's. > > > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > SAMVA , "cosmologer" <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for the kind words. > > > > > > > > > > I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what > > John TWB > > > > > shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the > > > > > events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical > > angle that > > > > > motivates your investigations at this point. > > > > > > > > > > When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the > > charts you > > > > > are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider > > some > > > > > main points, which were explained by thus in a > > > > > message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: > > > > > > > > > > "The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US in the > > > > > international affairs, its commanding position in the intellectual > > > > > properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive > > > > > attitude including use of force in international affairs, the > > > > > conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic > > peace > > > > > felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the > > nation, > > > > > the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of > state, > > > > > and important intervention in foreign policy around the > world. The > > > > > identification of the past events through sub periods or triple > > > > > transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ > > > > > aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the > proposed > > > > > chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any > planet > > > > > in the sixth house." > > > > > > > > > > will revert on the chart identified by you. I > > also > > > > > look forward to hear what he will say about it. > > > > > > > > > > Finally, you should also consider the 21° Cancer rising SAMVA USA > > > > > chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your > > understanding of > > > > > the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest > > you the > > > > > least that finds that this chart meets the > above > > > > > requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to > predict the > > > > > ongoing developments? > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , "rkchadha" <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello Thor: > > > > > > > > > > > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, > > 1776. At > > > > > > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am > > > doing > > > > > > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. > > > Pleas > > > > > > e do not be offended by my words "emotional attachment". What > > I mean > > > > > > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I > > > now feel > > > > > > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do > > my work > > > > > > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The > > honorable > > > > > > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj > > > > > > SAMVA , "cosmologer" <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > > > > > > "In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA > > because > > > > > > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and > > > many > > > > > > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 > > and not > > > > > > > July 4..." > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Now you propose: > > > > > > > "Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental > > Congress." > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for > > many > > > > > > > years, including studying their natal promise and making > > > > predictions. > > > > > > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More > > > > recently, I > > > > > > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB > > on this > > > > > > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA > chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > As for your claim that I have "emotional attachment" to a > given > > > > chart, > > > > > > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is > > retained, the > > > > > > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must > > develop a > > > > > > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > > > > > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are > > > doing this > > > > > > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and > > > accurate > > > > > > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not > > enough. > > > > > > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the > > > work, > > > > > > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > > > > > > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be > > pleased to > > > > > > > consider that offering. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , "rkchadha" <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about > > > > finding an > > > > > > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge > feels > > > > > > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about > 2/2/1781, 5:05 > > > > > pm. Yet > > > > > > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, > > > which > > > > > > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron > Grimes feel > > > > > > > > strongly about. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the > > > choice of > > > > > > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the > > > > ratification > > > > > > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of > USA. > > > > But in > > > > > > > > fact it should be the time and date when the > confederation was > > > > > > > > established the USA became a country of group of states > united > > > > under > > > > > > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) > > > > > when the > > > > > > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in > York, > > > > > > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the > > > > historical > > > > > > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, > > > > which is > > > > > > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am > > > > > proposing > > > > > > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not > > > only the > > > > > > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it > > > > explains > > > > > > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical > > > events. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. > > > The > > > > > > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in > > > Libra > > > > > > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual > > > > > pursuits and > > > > > > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of > > > > > justice and > > > > > > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP > of 12H, > > > > > in the > > > > > > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military > > strength and > > > > > > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of > > Rahu on > > > > > > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial > exuberance > > > > > > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. > > > > > Together > > > > > > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > > > > > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural > > > > calamities > > > > > > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of > Saturn > > > > shows > > > > > > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever > more > > > > > > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. > > > Here the > > > > > > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, > > 9/11/2001, > > > > > > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun > > > > (FM and > > > > > > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms > > > > > that both > > > > > > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn > as in > > > > Cancer > > > > > > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also > > taken > > > > > place > > > > > > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the > > > Capricorn > > > > > > > > rising chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like > > > > Jorge to > > > > > > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to > please look > > > > > at this > > > > > > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before > > > > accepting a > > > > > > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2007 Report Share Posted March 12, 2007 Dear Raj, Thank you for the explanation of the basis of your predictions. It is still not well brought out by you, and lacks completely any analysis of the natal promise. As a result, it is hard to discuss your predictions on the basis of SA. The predictions could just as well have been made on the basis of a news report. In view of that, I propose we just let your predictions stand as is. Your comments about the lack of due diligence work concerning the SAMVA USA chart are way off the mark. Either you have been away from the SAMVA list or are forgetting all the evidence that has been placed before list members eyes. As for your own due diligence regarding your claims, such work is completely non-existent. If you want to be taken seriously on SAMVA, I suggest you refrain from making such absurd claims and increase your own positive contribution. Best wishes, Thor SAMVA , Raj Cgadha <rkctech wrote: > > Dear Thor: > > Most of my predictions are based on the current sub-period of Mercury (aspected by Rahu on 6H), as I already explained in the last note. I think USA will pull it troops after Venu/Ketu period begins in August 2009. Ketu stands for withdrawal, it aspects 4H (Home) and it conjuncts Mars (military). Therefore it will withdraw its military from Iraq after Aug 2009. You may have to wait until that period to convince yourself of the validity of this chart. > > I think SAMVA first accepted July2, 1776 chart, then Feb1781 chart too hastily, without due diligence. Now it finds itself in an awkward situation to accept the third chart. Therefore you guys are reluctant to accept it. But that is OK with me. > It takes time for the truth to come out. > > > Best wishes > > > cosmologer <cosmologer wrote: Dear Raj, > > has already given you his view on this chart. In my > experience, when I have asked for s advice and he > has given it, the advice has stood the test of time. I therefore heed > his advice. Additionally, if he has given the view that this > particular chart does not have merit, we cannot expect him to spend > his precious time on such an exercise. His attention is in great > demand and he spends his time and energy where it is of most benefit, > normally helping people with pressing real life problems. However, I > am willing to go along with you for the sake of the exercise of making > the prediction. It is an impressive effort by you in its own right. > That said, I think it would be useful if you explain a bit more > precisely what astrological factors are behind each prediction, > including natal promise and period and transit influences. We can then > more easily assess if the prediction is based on a correct assessment > of the astrological factors. If so, the time must then pass for it to > be shown to be right or wrong. > > Best wishes, > > Thor > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > Dear Thor: > > > > In this note I am going to give you and the LIST my future predictions > > from the chart I proposed for USA(Nov 15, 1777, 12:25 EST, York, PA). > > But before that I am going to provide you some more evidence in favor > > of this chart. I will urge you to print out this chart and keep it > > before you read the following. > > > > In my last message I mentioned that the great depression occurred in > > Rah/Mars and Jup/Jup. During this entire period Saturn, the 2L, was in > > 12H, which contributed significantly towards the worst financial > > period in the history of USA. This supports that the ascendant of USA > > should be Capricorn. > > > > Between Jan 1966 and Aug 1982, the DJIA dropped from 995 to 777, and > > the inflation as measured by consumer price index increased from 95 to > > 308. Combine these two factors, you will see that the value of the > > investments dropped by about 75% in 16 and � years. This corresponds > > exactly to the main period of Mercury, which ran from Oct 1966 to Oct > > 1983. Please note that Mercury is conjunct 2L Saturn representing > > wealth and both are afflicted by Rahu from the sixth house of > > financial solvency. Therefore the value of money deteriorated > > throughout this period. No other chart will give you this kind of > > correlation for such a broad period of time. > > > > The major period of Ketu started after that which brought great bull > > market between 1983 and 1990. Although Ketu is badly placed, it is > > conjunct MBP Mars, and aspected closely by 2L, FB, Saturn from the > > 10H. Of course there was a stock market crash during this time, which > > by the way, occurred in Ketu/Jupiter period, as Jupiter is 12L > > representing losses. > > > > Then came the major period of Venus, which started in Oct 1990. Venus > > has a minor weakness due to infancy, but it is well placed in the 10H > > in its own MTS. Venus represents wealth. During its own sub-period, > > DJIA advanced from roughly 2900 to 3800. There was no significant gain > > in DJIA during Ven/Sun period as Sun is MMP and weak although well > > placed. Then came the best period of Ven/Moon from Feb 1995 to Oct > > 1996. The DJIA advanced from 3900 to 6600 (77% gain). Moon is the > > strongest planet in this chart. This advance continued in Ven/Mars > > period along with a minor correction in 1997. The DJIA ended at > > roughly 8000. Mars is also aspected by 2L Saturn from 10H. During > > Venus/Rahu period (Dec 1997 to Dec 2000) things went crazy after a > > brief correction in 1998. This is typical of Rahu, it gives > > short-lived exponential gains. Along with that came the manipulations > > (Rahu) of Enron, Adelphia, Worldcom, mutual funds and dot-com > > companies, etc. Then came the Jupiter sub-period (Dec 2000 to Aug > > 2003), which brought painful losses, stock market correction, weak > > dollar, Sep 11 attack etc. You see Jupiter after all is 12L in 8H. It > > was during this period USA went into Afghanistan and Iraq without > > proper justification. During Ven/Sat period, the stock market > > recovered a bit, but the inflation increased due to the cost of war, > > and oil prices. During this period the real estate prices soared > > because 2L Saturn aspects 4H and is aspected by Rahu. > > > > Now USA is going through Ven/Mer period since 10/25/2006. Mercury is > > 9L (religion) afflicted by Rahu (foreign countries) in 6H (conflict). > > No wonder USA got involved in religious conflict in Iraq. This period > > will go until Aug 2009. > > > > Here are my predictions: > > > > USA will have a recession during 2007-2008. In fact the recession has > > already started. This is because of the sub-period of Mercury, which > > causes inflation, recessions and expenditures on war due to the aspect > > of Rahu from the 6H. This aspect will also create significant problems > > for the leadership as Rahu aspects 10H also. Because this aspect is > > from 6H, it will cause credit problems to many Americans and you will > > see a lot of real estate foreclosures. End of August 2007 may bring a > > tragic incident on the scene. > > > > Real estate prices will fall until the end of 2008, and start > > recovering in 2009 and 2010. > > > > USA will not pull out of Iraq or Afghanistan before the end of 2009. > > Rather, it is highly probable that this war may widen in 2007 or 2008. > > But in the end USA will be able to minimize the terrorist threats to > > its mainland and its interests abroad. This can happen just after > > Venus/Ketu starts in Aug 2009. > > > > The major period of Sun from Oct 2010 to Oct 2016, will bring many > > difficulties for USA, its leaders and its financial system, although > > there will be recoveries during Sun/Moon and Sun/Venus periods. > > Natural disasters such as earthquakes and hurricanes are also highly > > probable during this period as Sun is MMP. Energy crisis will push > > Americans to make use of Solar Energy. > > > > New economic boom will start with the advent of Moon major-period in > 2016. > > > > I once again request to look ino this chart. > > > > Thanks > > > > Raj > > > > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > > > To get real consideration a set of predictions needs to be made > > > against the chart. Please feel free to make the predictions. > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear Mr. Choudhry and Thor: > > > > > > > > Your analysis does have a few points. But I am sure you will agree > > > > with me that USA is not a perfect country. It has its due share of > > > > tragedies and weaknesses. The chart for USA should show them. The > > > > Nov1777 chart shows them better than Feb1781 charts. I would like to > > > > submit a few more points for your consideration. I hope you > re-valuate > > > > the merit of this chart in totallity. > > > > > > > > Influenza epidemic of 1918 killed more than 100,000 American people. > > > > The period according to the chart I propose was Rahu/Jup. Both are > > > > FM's and both are badly placed. In transit Jupiter was in the sign > > > > Gemini, placed in 6H in the sign of lungs. > > > > > > > > The great depression (1930-1933) occured during the periods of > > > > Rahu/Mars and Jup/Jup. Rahu, Mars and Jup all are badly placed, and > > > > affects so many houses and planets, creating worst of the > atmosphere. > > > > > > > > 1962 Cuban missile episode occured in Sat/Rahu, once again Rahu > on 6H > > > > MEP shows it clearly. President Kennedy and Dr. King killed in the > > > > sixties. The period was Sat/Rahu and Sat/Jup. Once again Rahu > > > > afflicting Saturn, and FM Jupiter in 8H explains everything very > > nicely. > > > > > > > > Watergate episode and Opec oil embargo, which created most > frustrating > > > > days in USA occured in Mer/Sun period. Sun being the MMP > produced its > > > > effects and hurt the president of the country. > > > > > > > > Coming back to the natal chart, USA is a litigious society. > People are > > > > always ready to sue each other. It is dominated by lawyers. In the > > > > chart I recommend, majority of planets are in signs Libra and > > > > Sagittarius. Both these signs are connected with law. > > > > > > > > USA is a sincere and trustworthy friend to certain countries. > > > > Sincerity and loyality are hallmark qualities of Capricorn ascendant > > > > more than any other sign. > > > > > > > > Ascendants Cancer or Virgo are too soft ascendants for a country > like > > > > USA. Even Scorpio is not appropriate, because Scorpio will wait > for an > > > > appropriate time to take revenge. Crocodile (the symbol for > Capricorn) > > > > on the other hand lay dormant near the riverbanks and will not react > > > > unless provoked. But once provoked, it reacts ferocioulsy without > > > > waiting. It then completely annhilates the enemy. Look what > happenend > > > > after Pearl harbor. And what is happeneing after Sept 11. Based on > > > > this simple fact I predict that USA will not rest untill it > eliminates > > > > Al-Qaida completely. It does not matter who the president is, George > > > > Bush or any democrat. > > > > > > > > As I said in the beginning, please consider the merit of the > chart in > > > > its entirity, not just the strengths of the planets. > > > > > > > > Thank you for being so understanding and patient. > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , <siha@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello dear Mr. Chadha, > > > > > > > > > > Weakness of Venus XL, close affliction of nodes to houses > influences > > > > and > > > > > close affliction of Rahu from sixth house to Saturn IIL and exact > > > > affliction > > > > > to Mercury IXL besides placement of Mars IVL in the twelfth > > house and > > > > > Jupiter XIIL in the eighth house does not allow me to say that > this > > > > chart > > > > > merits consideration as the chart for USA. > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > - > > > > > " rkchadha " <rkctech@> > > > > > <SAMVA > > > > > > Tuesday, March 06, 2007 4:14 AM > > > > > Re: New USA chart proposal > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor: > > > > > > > > > > 1777 chart in fact shows all the requirements you put forward. > > > > > > > > > > International affairs are seen from 7H. 7L is strong and well > > placed. > > > > > 7H is aspected by MBP. Thus it has commanding position in > > > > > international affairs. > > > > > > > > > > 5H shows intellactual properties. Again unafflicted and strong > > Moon is > > > > > residing here. The sign of intellact Libra is also strong with > > exalted > > > > > Saturn and 9L in the 10H. Therefore USA has been in the > forefront of > > > > > scientific discoveries and command respect for that. These two > > planets > > > > > are on MEP's, therefore they influence five houses beneficially. > > > > > > > > > > Financial strength is seen from 2H, 5H the planets Moon and > > Venus. 2L > > > > > is exalted, wp and on MEP. Venus although slightly weak, but still > > > > > placed in 10H, in its own MTS. Moon is again wp, strong and > > > > > unafflicted. 9L in the 10H is an additional advantage. Both > Mercury > > > > > and Saturn are afflicted by Rahu from the 6H, that shows why every > > > > > financial boom invited cheaters and manipulators, and why they > ended > > > > > with stock market crashes. > > > > > > > > > > Its assertive attitude and the use of force in international > affairs > > > > > come from Mars in Sagittarius in the 12H on MEP. It also aspect > > 3H of > > > > > communication and literary pursuits. It also aspects the 6H, which > > > > > according to you govern aggressive and assertive attitude. There > > is no > > > > > need of having a MTS in this house. The presence of Rahu and > > aspect of > > > > > Mars are more than enough. Both mars and Rahu produce > conflicts. The > > > > > combination of Mars and Ketu in 12H shows why USA got involved > > in wars > > > > > in foreign lands. > > > > > > > > > > As I indicated before, 12L in the 8H shows natural disasters. > > Sun here > > > > > is a relatively weak. This combined with the affliction of 9L > > Mercury, > > > > > make its leaders succeptible to attacks by its own people. > > > > > > > > > > Both Sun and Jupiter are FM's and they do not afflict any > planet or > > > > > house. But whenever they form cc/ca in transit, they produce > > > disasters. > > > > > > > > > > On 12/7/1941 both FM's Sun and Jupiter were aspecting each other > > > > > closely. Rahu was afflicting from 8H's MEP. The period was > > Jup/Ven. On > > > > > 9/11/2001, Mars and Ketu were together in the 12H. Six planets > were > > > > > present in the malefic houses and FM's Sun and Jupiter were > > transiting > > > > > over the MEP's. The period was Ven/Jup. Therefore USA faced deadly > > > > > attacks on its soil. > > > > > > > > > > I will produce more data like that shortly. And I will show > you that > > > > > this chart has both natal, transit and dasha requirements for > being > > > > > the chart of the country USA. But I will first wait for Prof > > > > > Choudhry's point of view on this chart. Please note that I am not > > > > > averse to Cancer 21 degree chart or any other chart at all. The > > > > > interesting point is that 1777 chart also like 1781 chart show the > > > > > present stock market problems, because of the stationary Rahu/Ketu > > > > > axis at 22 degrees on the 2H and 8H MEP's. > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for the kind words. > > > > > > > > > > > > I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what > > > John TWB > > > > > > shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the > > > > > > events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical > > > angle that > > > > > > motivates your investigations at this point. > > > > > > > > > > > > When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the > > > charts you > > > > > > are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider > > > some > > > > > > main points, which were explained by thus > in a > > > > > > message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: > > > > > > > > > > > > " The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US > in the > > > > > > international affairs, its commanding position in the > intellectual > > > > > > properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive > > > > > > attitude including use of force in international affairs, the > > > > > > conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic > > > peace > > > > > > felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the > > > nation, > > > > > > the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of > > state, > > > > > > and important intervention in foreign policy around the > > world. The > > > > > > identification of the past events through sub periods or triple > > > > > > transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ > > > > > > aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the > > proposed > > > > > > chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any > > planet > > > > > > in the sixth house. " > > > > > > > > > > > > will revert on the chart identified by you. I > > > also > > > > > > look forward to hear what he will say about it. > > > > > > > > > > > > Finally, you should also consider the 21� Cancer rising > SAMVA USA > > > > > > chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your > > > understanding of > > > > > > the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest > > > you the > > > > > > least that finds that this chart meets the > > above > > > > > > requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to > > predict the > > > > > > ongoing developments? > > > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello Thor: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, > > > 1776. At > > > > > > > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what > I am > > > > doing > > > > > > > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen > interest. > > > > Pleas > > > > > > > e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What > > > I mean > > > > > > > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I > > > > now feel > > > > > > > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do > > > my work > > > > > > > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The > > > honorable > > > > > > > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj > > > > > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> > wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > > > > > > > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA > > > because > > > > > > > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. > I and > > > > many > > > > > > > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 > > > and not > > > > > > > > July 4... " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Now you propose: > > > > > > > > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental > > > Congress. " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for > > > many > > > > > > > > years, including studying their natal promise and making > > > > > predictions. > > > > > > > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More > > > > > recently, I > > > > > > > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB > > > on this > > > > > > > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA > > chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a > > given > > > > > chart, > > > > > > > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is > > > retained, the > > > > > > > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must > > > develop a > > > > > > > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > > > > > > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are > > > > doing this > > > > > > > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and > > > > accurate > > > > > > > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not > > > enough. > > > > > > > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to > do the > > > > work, > > > > > > > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then > make the > > > > > > > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be > > > pleased to > > > > > > > > consider that offering. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about > > > > > finding an > > > > > > > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge > > feels > > > > > > > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about > > 2/2/1781, 5:05 > > > > > > pm. Yet > > > > > > > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another > chart, > > > > which > > > > > > > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron > > Grimes feel > > > > > > > > > strongly about. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the > > > > choice of > > > > > > > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the > > > > > ratification > > > > > > > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of > > USA. > > > > > But in > > > > > > > > > fact it should be the time and date when the > > confederation was > > > > > > > > > established the USA became a country of group of states > > united > > > > > under > > > > > > > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM > to 2PM) > > > > > > when the > > > > > > > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in > > York, > > > > > > > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the > > > > > historical > > > > > > > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to > be12:25pm, > > > > > which is > > > > > > > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart > I am > > > > > > proposing > > > > > > > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not > > > > only the > > > > > > > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it > > > > > explains > > > > > > > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical > > > > events. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of > Cancer 21. > > > > The > > > > > > > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and > Mercury in > > > > Libra > > > > > > > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual > > > > > > pursuits and > > > > > > > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of > > > > > > justice and > > > > > > > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP > > of 12H, > > > > > > in the > > > > > > > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military > > > strength and > > > > > > > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of > > > Rahu on > > > > > > > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial > > exuberance > > > > > > > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended > abruptly. > > > > > > Together > > > > > > > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the > wars and > > > > > > > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural > > > > > calamities > > > > > > > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of > > Saturn > > > > > shows > > > > > > > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever > > more > > > > > > > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. > > > > Here the > > > > > > > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, > > > 9/11/2001, > > > > > > > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter > and Sun > > > > > (FM and > > > > > > > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This > confirms > > > > > > that both > > > > > > > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn > > as in > > > > > Cancer > > > > > > > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also > > > taken > > > > > > place > > > > > > > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the > > > > Capricorn > > > > > > > > > rising chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like > > > > > Jorge to > > > > > > > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to > > please look > > > > > > at this > > > > > > > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before > > > > > accepting a > > > > > > > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2007 Report Share Posted March 12, 2007 Hi Raj, My two cents... Personally, I never accepted the Sc chart for the USA and I don't think that any purist SA member who reviewed it thought it was inline through assessment by SA principles. The Cn chart shows best natal promise so far, matches perfectly with the country, and the events match properly without any stretch. This chart you are proposing does not bare the natal promise by SA and the historical events surrounding it, importantly, do not place it as significant. This has been adequately discussed by , Thor, John TWB and myself. If someone isn't using SA strictly, they they may find it significant through natal promise and meaningful prediction through such a chart where there is none. So, an open question to you: Are you using SA strictly? Best regards, Vyas Munidas - " Raj Cgadha " <rkctech <SAMVA > Monday, March 12, 2007 2:04 PM Re: Re: New USA chart proposal Dear Thor: Most of my predictions are based on the current sub-period of Mercury (aspected by Rahu on 6H), as I already explained in the last note. I think USA will pull it troops after Venu/Ketu period begins in August 2009. Ketu stands for withdrawal, it aspects 4H (Home) and it conjuncts Mars (military). Therefore it will withdraw its military from Iraq after Aug 2009. You may have to wait until that period to convince yourself of the validity of this chart. I think SAMVA first accepted July2, 1776 chart, then Feb1781 chart too hastily, without due diligence. Now it finds itself in an awkward situation to accept the third chart. Therefore you guys are reluctant to accept it. But that is OK with me. It takes time for the truth to come out. Best wishes cosmologer <cosmologer wrote: Dear Raj, has already given you his view on this chart. In my experience, when I have asked for s advice and he has given it, the advice has stood the test of time. I therefore heed his advice. Additionally, if he has given the view that this particular chart does not have merit, we cannot expect him to spend his precious time on such an exercise. His attention is in great demand and he spends his time and energy where it is of most benefit, normally helping people with pressing real life problems. However, I am willing to go along with you for the sake of the exercise of making the prediction. It is an impressive effort by you in its own right. That said, I think it would be useful if you explain a bit more precisely what astrological factors are behind each prediction, including natal promise and period and transit influences. We can then more easily assess if the prediction is based on a correct assessment of the astrological factors. If so, the time must then pass for it to be shown to be right or wrong. Best wishes, Thor SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech wrote: > > Dear Thor: > > In this note I am going to give you and the LIST my future predictions > from the chart I proposed for USA(Nov 15, 1777, 12:25 EST, York, PA). > But before that I am going to provide you some more evidence in favor > of this chart. I will urge you to print out this chart and keep it > before you read the following. > > In my last message I mentioned that the great depression occurred in > Rah/Mars and Jup/Jup. During this entire period Saturn, the 2L, was in > 12H, which contributed significantly towards the worst financial > period in the history of USA. This supports that the ascendant of USA > should be Capricorn. > > Between Jan 1966 and Aug 1982, the DJIA dropped from 995 to 777, and > the inflation as measured by consumer price index increased from 95 to > 308. Combine these two factors, you will see that the value of the > investments dropped by about 75% in 16 and ½ years. This corresponds > exactly to the main period of Mercury, which ran from Oct 1966 to Oct > 1983. Please note that Mercury is conjunct 2L Saturn representing > wealth and both are afflicted by Rahu from the sixth house of > financial solvency. Therefore the value of money deteriorated > throughout this period. No other chart will give you this kind of > correlation for such a broad period of time. > > The major period of Ketu started after that which brought great bull > market between 1983 and 1990. Although Ketu is badly placed, it is > conjunct MBP Mars, and aspected closely by 2L, FB, Saturn from the > 10H. Of course there was a stock market crash during this time, which > by the way, occurred in Ketu/Jupiter period, as Jupiter is 12L > representing losses. > > Then came the major period of Venus, which started in Oct 1990. Venus > has a minor weakness due to infancy, but it is well placed in the 10H > in its own MTS. Venus represents wealth. During its own sub-period, > DJIA advanced from roughly 2900 to 3800. There was no significant gain > in DJIA during Ven/Sun period as Sun is MMP and weak although well > placed. Then came the best period of Ven/Moon from Feb 1995 to Oct > 1996. The DJIA advanced from 3900 to 6600 (77% gain). Moon is the > strongest planet in this chart. This advance continued in Ven/Mars > period along with a minor correction in 1997. The DJIA ended at > roughly 8000. Mars is also aspected by 2L Saturn from 10H. During > Venus/Rahu period (Dec 1997 to Dec 2000) things went crazy after a > brief correction in 1998. This is typical of Rahu, it gives > short-lived exponential gains. Along with that came the manipulations > (Rahu) of Enron, Adelphia, Worldcom, mutual funds and dot-com > companies, etc. Then came the Jupiter sub-period (Dec 2000 to Aug > 2003), which brought painful losses, stock market correction, weak > dollar, Sep 11 attack etc. You see Jupiter after all is 12L in 8H. It > was during this period USA went into Afghanistan and Iraq without > proper justification. During Ven/Sat period, the stock market > recovered a bit, but the inflation increased due to the cost of war, > and oil prices. During this period the real estate prices soared > because 2L Saturn aspects 4H and is aspected by Rahu. > > Now USA is going through Ven/Mer period since 10/25/2006. Mercury is > 9L (religion) afflicted by Rahu (foreign countries) in 6H (conflict). > No wonder USA got involved in religious conflict in Iraq. This period > will go until Aug 2009. > > Here are my predictions: > > USA will have a recession during 2007-2008. In fact the recession has > already started. This is because of the sub-period of Mercury, which > causes inflation, recessions and expenditures on war due to the aspect > of Rahu from the 6H. This aspect will also create significant problems > for the leadership as Rahu aspects 10H also. Because this aspect is > from 6H, it will cause credit problems to many Americans and you will > see a lot of real estate foreclosures. End of August 2007 may bring a > tragic incident on the scene. > > Real estate prices will fall until the end of 2008, and start > recovering in 2009 and 2010. > > USA will not pull out of Iraq or Afghanistan before the end of 2009. > Rather, it is highly probable that this war may widen in 2007 or 2008. > But in the end USA will be able to minimize the terrorist threats to > its mainland and its interests abroad. This can happen just after > Venus/Ketu starts in Aug 2009. > > The major period of Sun from Oct 2010 to Oct 2016, will bring many > difficulties for USA, its leaders and its financial system, although > there will be recoveries during Sun/Moon and Sun/Venus periods. > Natural disasters such as earthquakes and hurricanes are also highly > probable during this period as Sun is MMP. Energy crisis will push > Americans to make use of Solar Energy. > > New economic boom will start with the advent of Moon major-period in 2016. > > I once again request to look ino this chart. > > Thanks > > Raj > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > To get real consideration a set of predictions needs to be made > > against the chart. Please feel free to make the predictions. > > > > Best wishes, > > > > Thor > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Mr. Choudhry and Thor: > > > > > > Your analysis does have a few points. But I am sure you will agree > > > with me that USA is not a perfect country. It has its due share of > > > tragedies and weaknesses. The chart for USA should show them. The > > > Nov1777 chart shows them better than Feb1781 charts. I would like to > > > submit a few more points for your consideration. I hope you re-valuate > > > the merit of this chart in totallity. > > > > > > Influenza epidemic of 1918 killed more than 100,000 American people. > > > The period according to the chart I propose was Rahu/Jup. Both are > > > FM's and both are badly placed. In transit Jupiter was in the sign > > > Gemini, placed in 6H in the sign of lungs. > > > > > > The great depression (1930-1933) occured during the periods of > > > Rahu/Mars and Jup/Jup. Rahu, Mars and Jup all are badly placed, and > > > affects so many houses and planets, creating worst of the atmosphere. > > > > > > 1962 Cuban missile episode occured in Sat/Rahu, once again Rahu on 6H > > > MEP shows it clearly. President Kennedy and Dr. King killed in the > > > sixties. The period was Sat/Rahu and Sat/Jup. Once again Rahu > > > afflicting Saturn, and FM Jupiter in 8H explains everything very > nicely. > > > > > > Watergate episode and Opec oil embargo, which created most frustrating > > > days in USA occured in Mer/Sun period. Sun being the MMP produced its > > > effects and hurt the president of the country. > > > > > > Coming back to the natal chart, USA is a litigious society. People are > > > always ready to sue each other. It is dominated by lawyers. In the > > > chart I recommend, majority of planets are in signs Libra and > > > Sagittarius. Both these signs are connected with law. > > > > > > USA is a sincere and trustworthy friend to certain countries. > > > Sincerity and loyality are hallmark qualities of Capricorn ascendant > > > more than any other sign. > > > > > > Ascendants Cancer or Virgo are too soft ascendants for a country like > > > USA. Even Scorpio is not appropriate, because Scorpio will wait for an > > > appropriate time to take revenge. Crocodile (the symbol for Capricorn) > > > on the other hand lay dormant near the riverbanks and will not react > > > unless provoked. But once provoked, it reacts ferocioulsy without > > > waiting. It then completely annhilates the enemy. Look what happenend > > > after Pearl harbor. And what is happeneing after Sept 11. Based on > > > this simple fact I predict that USA will not rest untill it eliminates > > > Al-Qaida completely. It does not matter who the president is, George > > > Bush or any democrat. > > > > > > As I said in the beginning, please consider the merit of the chart in > > > its entirity, not just the strengths of the planets. > > > > > > Thank you for being so understanding and patient. > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , <siha@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello dear Mr. Chadha, > > > > > > > > Weakness of Venus XL, close affliction of nodes to houses influences > > > and > > > > close affliction of Rahu from sixth house to Saturn IIL and exact > > > affliction > > > > to Mercury IXL besides placement of Mars IVL in the twelfth > house and > > > > Jupiter XIIL in the eighth house does not allow me to say that this > > > chart > > > > merits consideration as the chart for USA. > > > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > - > > > > " rkchadha " <rkctech@> > > > > <SAMVA > > > > > Tuesday, March 06, 2007 4:14 AM > > > > Re: New USA chart proposal > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor: > > > > > > > > 1777 chart in fact shows all the requirements you put forward. > > > > > > > > International affairs are seen from 7H. 7L is strong and well > placed. > > > > 7H is aspected by MBP. Thus it has commanding position in > > > > international affairs. > > > > > > > > 5H shows intellactual properties. Again unafflicted and strong > Moon is > > > > residing here. The sign of intellact Libra is also strong with > exalted > > > > Saturn and 9L in the 10H. Therefore USA has been in the forefront of > > > > scientific discoveries and command respect for that. These two > planets > > > > are on MEP's, therefore they influence five houses beneficially. > > > > > > > > Financial strength is seen from 2H, 5H the planets Moon and > Venus. 2L > > > > is exalted, wp and on MEP. Venus although slightly weak, but still > > > > placed in 10H, in its own MTS. Moon is again wp, strong and > > > > unafflicted. 9L in the 10H is an additional advantage. Both Mercury > > > > and Saturn are afflicted by Rahu from the 6H, that shows why every > > > > financial boom invited cheaters and manipulators, and why they ended > > > > with stock market crashes. > > > > > > > > Its assertive attitude and the use of force in international affairs > > > > come from Mars in Sagittarius in the 12H on MEP. It also aspect > 3H of > > > > communication and literary pursuits. It also aspects the 6H, which > > > > according to you govern aggressive and assertive attitude. There > is no > > > > need of having a MTS in this house. The presence of Rahu and > aspect of > > > > Mars are more than enough. Both mars and Rahu produce conflicts. The > > > > combination of Mars and Ketu in 12H shows why USA got involved > in wars > > > > in foreign lands. > > > > > > > > As I indicated before, 12L in the 8H shows natural disasters. > Sun here > > > > is a relatively weak. This combined with the affliction of 9L > Mercury, > > > > make its leaders succeptible to attacks by its own people. > > > > > > > > Both Sun and Jupiter are FM's and they do not afflict any planet or > > > > house. But whenever they form cc/ca in transit, they produce > > disasters. > > > > > > > > On 12/7/1941 both FM's Sun and Jupiter were aspecting each other > > > > closely. Rahu was afflicting from 8H's MEP. The period was > Jup/Ven. On > > > > 9/11/2001, Mars and Ketu were together in the 12H. Six planets were > > > > present in the malefic houses and FM's Sun and Jupiter were > transiting > > > > over the MEP's. The period was Ven/Jup. Therefore USA faced deadly > > > > attacks on its soil. > > > > > > > > I will produce more data like that shortly. And I will show you that > > > > this chart has both natal, transit and dasha requirements for being > > > > the chart of the country USA. But I will first wait for Prof > > > > Choudhry's point of view on this chart. Please note that I am not > > > > averse to Cancer 21 degree chart or any other chart at all. The > > > > interesting point is that 1777 chart also like 1781 chart show the > > > > present stock market problems, because of the stationary Rahu/Ketu > > > > axis at 22 degrees on the 2H and 8H MEP's. > > > > > > > > Best wishes. > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Dear Raj, > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for the kind words. > > > > > > > > > > I think it would be helpful to you if consider carefully what > > John TWB > > > > > shared with you earlier today about the historical nature of the > > > > > events of interest to you, as it seems to be the historical > > angle that > > > > > motivates your investigations at this point. > > > > > > > > > > When you get around to analysing the natal potential of the > > charts you > > > > > are looking at for the USA it might be useful to you to consider > > some > > > > > main points, which were explained by thus in a > > > > > message on SAMVA on 21 January 2007 at 16.24: > > > > > > > > > > " The natal chart has to show the commanding position of US in the > > > > > international affairs, its commanding position in the intellectual > > > > > properties in the world, its financial strength, its assertive > > > > > attitude including use of force in international affairs, the > > > > > conflicts raised by its assertive attitude, problems in domestic > > peace > > > > > felt by its citizens, setbacks in the matter of wealth of the > > nation, > > > > > the number of assassination made on the life of the heads of > state, > > > > > and important intervention in foreign policy around the > world. The > > > > > identification of the past events through sub periods or triple > > > > > transit influences comes next to the natal chart. The assertive/ > > > > > aggressive attitude is governed by the sixth house. In the > proposed > > > > > chart there is no MT sign in the sixth house nor there is any > planet > > > > > in the sixth house. " > > > > > > > > > > will revert on the chart identified by you. I > > also > > > > > look forward to hear what he will say about it. > > > > > > > > > > Finally, you should also consider the 21° Cancer rising SAMVA USA > > > > > chart, before rejecting it out of hand based on your > > understanding of > > > > > the historical developments at this time. Doesn't it interest > > you the > > > > > least that finds that this chart meets the > above > > > > > requirements and recent evens also suggest it is able to > predict the > > > > > ongoing developments? > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello Thor: > > > > > > > > > > > > Please disregard my last message in which I favored Jul 2, > > 1776. At > > > > > > that time I had not seen 1777 chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > I am sure you have looked at a lot of charts, just as what I am > > > doing > > > > > > now. I know you have intellactual objectivity and keen interest. > > > Pleas > > > > > > e do not be offended by my words " emotional attachment " . What > > I mean > > > > > > was that you feel strongly for the Feb 1981 chart. Likewise I > > > now feel > > > > > > that the 1777 chart has a lot of promise. And yes, I will do > > my work > > > > > > and present this board my arguments based on SA only. The > > honorable > > > > > > members like you are free to accept or discard my arguments. > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks, you are an insipiration. > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj > > > > > > SAMVA , " cosmologer " <cosmologer@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello Raj, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Just a few days ago you suggested the following: > > > > > > > " In my view nobody should ever consider 1781 chart for USA > > because > > > > > > > the country had already existed and operated since 1776. I and > > > many > > > > > > > others agree with you that the date should be July 2, 1776 > > and not > > > > > > > July 4... " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Now you propose: > > > > > > > " Nov 15, 1777 in York, Pennsylvania by the continental > > Congress. " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Please note that I have been looking at different charts for > > many > > > > > > > years, including studying their natal promise and making > > > > predictions. > > > > > > > So far, many charts have been explored and discarded. More > > > > recently, I > > > > > > > have enjoyed the support of the scholarly work of John TWB > > on this > > > > > > > list with regard to the historical basis of the SAMVA USA > chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > As for your claim that I have " emotional attachment " to a > given > > > > chart, > > > > > > > it is not true. When the intellectual objectivity is > > retained, the > > > > > > > emotional attachment is held at bay. That said, one must > > develop a > > > > > > > minimum degree of interest in the subject matter to find the > > > > > > > motivation to do the work. This is not a paid job. We are > > > doing this > > > > > > > in our spare time. So, the process is always objective and > > > accurate > > > > > > > predictions are the sole basis of choosing a chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Likewise, unsubstantiated claims for the validity are not > > enough. > > > > > > > If you are convinced of what you propose, feel free to do the > > > work, > > > > > > > including reading of natal promise as per SA and then make the > > > > > > > predictions, and present it here on SAMVA. We would be > > pleased to > > > > > > > consider that offering. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > SAMVA , " rkchadha " <rkctech@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Thor, Jorge, , and others: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > There have been a lot of discussions on this board about > > > > finding an > > > > > > > > appropriate chart for the country USA. I know that Jorge > feels > > > > > > > > strongly about 7/2/1776, 4:49pm, and Thor about > 2/2/1781, 5:05 > > > > > pm. Yet > > > > > > > > I would like all of you to consider seriously another chart, > > > which > > > > > > > > contains all the elements Jorge, Thor and even Ron > Grimes feel > > > > > > > > strongly about. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I have studied all the arguments on this board about the > > > choice of > > > > > > > > 2/2/1781 and 3/3/1781, that it was the last vote or the > > > > ratification > > > > > > > > of confederation that can only the beginning or birth of > USA. > > > > But in > > > > > > > > fact it should be the time and date when the > confederation was > > > > > > > > established the USA became a country of group of states > united > > > > under > > > > > > > > one government. That time was the meeting time (11AM to 2PM) > > > > > when the > > > > > > > > articles of confederation was passed on Nov 15, 1777 in > York, > > > > > > > > Pennsylvania by the continental Congress. Considering the > > > > historical > > > > > > > > events of the USA I rectify the time of birth to be12:25pm, > > > > which is > > > > > > > > almost in the middle of the meeting. Here is the chart I am > > > > > proposing > > > > > > > > for USA, and I will describe briefly now how it shows not > > > only the > > > > > > > > elements you people feel so strongly about but also how it > > > > explains > > > > > > > > the character of USA and some of the important historical > > > events. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Here the rising degree is Capricorn 21 instead of Cancer 21. > > > The > > > > > > > > placement and strength of Moon, Saturn, Venus and Mercury in > > > Libra > > > > > > > > shows the financial prowess of the country, intellectual > > > > > pursuits and > > > > > > > > scientific achievements, and adoption of the principles of > > > > > justice and > > > > > > > > liberty for all. The placement of Mars and Ketu on MEP > of 12H, > > > > > in the > > > > > > > > martial sign of Sagittarius indicates its military > > strength and > > > > > > > > history of fighting wars on foreign lands. The aspect of > > Rahu on > > > > > > > > Mercury and Saturn shows why every era of financial > exuberance > > > > > > > > accompanied with manipulation and fraud, and ended abruptly. > > > > > Together > > > > > > > > these planets show why its economy is tied with the wars and > > > > > > > > conflicts. 12L is in the 8H indicating continuous natural > > > > calamities > > > > > > > > and disasters. Capricorn ascendant and the strength of > Saturn > > > > shows > > > > > > > > its ability to fight back such disasters and emerge ever > more > > > > > > > > powerfully. Many people feel that USA has Scorpio nature. > > > Here the > > > > > > > > Sun-sign is Scorpio. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Transit studies of most devastating dates (12/7/1941, > > 9/11/2001, > > > > > > > > 10/25/1929, 10/19/1987) show cc/ca of either Jupiter and Sun > > > > (FM and > > > > > > > > MMP) or Mars and Ketu (both violent planets). This confirms > > > > > that both > > > > > > > > Sun and Jupiter are FM's for USA not Jupiter and Saturn > as in > > > > Cancer > > > > > > > > 21degree chart. Assassinations of its presidents have also > > taken > > > > > place > > > > > > > > when Sun was severely afflicted and badly placed in the > > > Capricorn > > > > > > > > rising chart. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I know Thor is emotionally attached to 2/2/1781 chart like > > > > Jorge to > > > > > > > > 7/2/1776 chart. But I humbly request all of you to > please look > > > > > at this > > > > > > > > chart and evaluate and compare with other charts before > > > > accepting a > > > > > > > > final chart for USA. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Raj Chadha > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.