Comparision of Astrodienst, KPAstro 3.1, JHora 7.02, JHora 7.03 & JHora 7.32

February 4, 2009

Dear Friends,1. Having JHora 7.02 & JHora 7.03 installed in 2 computers, for curiosity JHora 7.32 is just downloaded in the 3rd computer and comparison is made as under.

G. Singh, 03-02-1962, 10:13:35 am (GMT+5:30), Ludhiana, 30N54, 75E51,

Sid. Time 18:38:32, KPNA 23:14:15

Cuspal and Planetary Positions

Cp

Pl

Astrodienst

Nirayana

KPAstro

3.1

JHora

7.02

JHora

7.03

JHora

7.32

1

350-51-21

2

026-07-49

3

052-26-55

052-26-54

4

075-36-45

075-36-44

075-36-45

5

100-01-54

100-01-53

100-01-54

6

130-21-51

130-21-50

130-21-51

Su

290-38-22

290-38-43

290-38-53

Mo

265-35-47

265-35-48

265-35-50

265-35-58

Ma

277-43-15

277-43-14

277-43-53

Me

295-45-10

295-45-09

295-44-55

295-45-05

Ju

294-56-40

294-57-10

294-57-20

Ve

292-15-57

292-15-56

292-16-41

292-16-51

Sa

280-21-19

280-21-46

280-21-56

Ra

115-01-06

115-01-16

Differerces (in sec) from Astrodienst

Cp

Pl

KP

Astro

JHora

7,02

JHora

7.03

JHora

7,32

1

0

2

0

3

-1

4

-1

0

5

-1

0

6

-1

0

Su

0

+23

+33

Mo

0

+01

+03

+11

Ma

-1

+38

+48

Me

-1

-15

-5

Ju

0

+30

+40

Ve

-1

+44

+54

Sa

0

+27

+37

Ra

0

+10

Dhanabalan is right that cuspal positions are the same by both JHora 7.02 & 7.32 but planetary positions are 10 seconds higher by JHora 7.32 (2009) than JHora 7.02.(2005).JHora users may check and give practical comment.Regards,tw

, "tw853" <tw853 wrote:>> > Dear Dhanabalan,> > > > > It's interesting and pl see the comparison of SW results below and you> may check and add JHora 7.32 results.> > > > Regards,> > > > tw> > > > 1. To be comparable to the cuspal and planetary positions of Astrodienst> (www.astro.com <http://www.astro.com/> ), provider and user of Swiss> epemeris, the lat. & long. of Ludhiana is adjusted to the same position> used by Astrodienst and JHora and also shown by Google Earth, ie. 30N54,> 75E51.> > > > 2. For 03-02-1962, 10:13:35 am (GMT+5:30), 30N54, 75E51, the Sid. Time> 18:38:32 is the same by Astrodienst, KPAstro 3.1 and JHora 7.02 (2005> disk form the provider).> > > > 3. In the table below, the Sayana positions of Astrodienst are converted> into Nirayana positions by abstracting the KPNA 23:14:15. By using the> same ayanamsa and birth details, the results of KPAstro 3.1 and JHora> 7.02 results are compared to the Astrodienst Nirayan results. The> differences (in seconds) are shown in RED color. [in JHora, by adjusting> Custom (user defined) ayanamsa to 5min:12.87sec less than Lahiri> ayanamsa, the KPNA 23:14:15 is got.]> > > > > > > Astrodienst> > Sayana> > Astrodienst> > Nirayana> > KPAstro> > 3.1> > JHora> > 7.02> > > > KP> > Astro> > > > JHora> > 1> > 014-05-36> > 350-51-21> > 350-51-21> > 350-51-21> > > > 0> > > > 0> > 2> > 049-22-04> > 026-07-49> > 026-07-49> > 026-07-49> > > > 0> > > > 0> > 3> > 075-41-10> > 052-26-55> > 052-26-54> > 052-26-54> > > > -1> > > > -1> > 4> > 098-51-00> > 075-36-45> > 075-36-44> > 075-36-45> > > > -1> > > > 0> > 5> > 123-16-09> > 100-01-54> > 100-01-53> > 100-01-54> > > > -1> > > > 0> > 6> > 153-36-06> > 130-21-51> > 130-21-50> > 130-21-51> > > > -1> > > > 0> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Su> > 313-52-37> > 290-38-22> > 290-38-22> > 290-38-43> > > > 0> > > > +23> > Mo> > 288-50-02> > 265-35-47> > 265-35-47> > 265-35-48> > > > 0> > > > +01> > Ma> > 300-57-30> > 277-43-15> > 277-43-14> > 277-43-53> > > > -1> > > > +38> > Me> > 318-59-25> > 295-45-10> > 295-45-09> > 295-44-55> > > > -1> > > > -15> > Ju> > 318-10-55> > 294-56-40> > 294-56-40> > 294-57-10> > > > 0> > > > +30> > Ve> > 315-30-12> > 292-15-57> > 292-15-56> > 292-16-41> > > > -1> > > > +44> > Sa> > 303-35-34> > 280-21-19> > 280-21-19> > 280-21-46> > > > 0> > > > +27> > Ra> > 138-15-21> > 115-01-06> > 115-01-06> > 115-01-06> > > > 0> > > > 0> > > > 4. As usual, the results of Astrodient and KPAstro 3.1 are the same, > not more than 1 second difference in both cuspal and planetary> positions.> > > > > , Dhanabalan R r.dhanabalan@> wrote:> >> > Dear TinWin> > It seems that the Jagannatha Hora 7.32 has some mistakes in handling> ayanamsa in planetary positions. For the same ayanamsa, the lagna> position for Jagannatha Hora 7.02 and 7.32 are same but there is 10> seconds difference in all planets position in 7.32. According to me,> Jagannatha Hora 7.02 is OK.> > Values in 7.02 agrees with KP ASTRO 3. Values in 7.32 is not agreeble> to KP ASTRO 3.> > Even Shadbala calculation also, there are differences. Shadbala values> in version 7.02 is OK. Version 7.32 has to be checked further for its> reliability to use.> >> > Comparision of Mr.Singh chart uploaded in file.> > SINGH> > Jagannatha Hora 7.02> >> > Natal Chart> >> > February 3, 1962> > Time: 10:13:35> > Time Zone: 5:30:00 (East of GMT)> > Place: 75 E 53' 00", 30 N 54' 00"> > Sunrise: 7:18:56> > Ayanamsa: 23-14-14.87> > Sidereal Time: 18:38:40> >> > Body Longitude> >> > Sun - PK 20 Makar 38' 22.43"> > Moon - AmK 25 Dhanu 35' 47.49"> > Mars - DK 7 Makar 43' 15.09"> > Mercury ® - AK 25 Makar 45' 09.73"> > Jupiter - BK 24 Makar 56' 40.30"> > Venus - MK 22 Makar 15' 56.73"> > Saturn - GK 10 Makar 21' 19.43"> > Rahu 25 Kark 01' 06.39"> > Ketu 25 Makar 01' 06.39"> >> > House Cusp> >> > 1st 20 Meen 54' 14.92"> > 2nd 26 Mesh 10' 04.35"> > 3rd 22 Vrish 28' 48.71"> > 4th 15 Mith 38' 35.38"> > 5th 10 Kark 03' 56.28"> > 6th 10 Simh 24' 21.59"> >> >> > Jagannatha Hora 7.32> >> > Natal Chart> >> > February 3, 1962> > Time: 10:13:35> > Time Zone: 5:30:00 (East of GMT)> > Place: 75 E 53' 00", 30 N 54' 00"> > Sunrise: 7:17:36> > Ayanamsa: 23-14-15.35> > Sidereal Time: 18:38:40> >> > Body Longitude> >> > Sun - PiK 20 Cp 38' 32.11"> > Moon - AmK 25 Sg 35' 57.17"> > Mars - GK 7 Cp 43' 24.78"> > Mercury ® - AK 25 Cp 45' 19.41"> > Jupiter - BK 24 Cp 56' 49.98"> > Venus - MK 22 Cp 16' 06.42"> > Saturn - PK 10 Cp 21' 29.12"> > Rahu - DK 25 Cn 01' 16.07"> > Ketu 25 Cp 01' 16.07"> >> > House Cusp> >> > 1st 20 Pi 54' 14.44"> > 2nd 26 Ar 10' 03.86"> > 3rd 22 Ta 28' 48.23"> > 4th 15 Ge 38' 34.90"> > 5th 10 Cn 03' 55.80"> > 6th 10 Le 24' 21.11"> >> > Dhanabalan> >>