Guest guest Posted December 19, 2008 Report Share Posted December 19, 2008 Dear Seniors, Mother-in-law and daughter-in-law relations projected in Indian TV serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have peace of mind. This is first time I came across such a query, I do not know how to proceed, which houses should be analyzed. So I request senior members to throw some light and guide me regarding how to proceed in the matter. Regards Subhash Ektare Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 20, 2008 Report Share Posted December 20, 2008 Dear Subhashji, Strained relationship between in-laws is not uncommon in Indian society. This type of query is however uncommon. You have come across such a query for the first time and it may be also first time for many of us.Seniors and experienced members like TWji may be having some confirmed KP rules The rules must have been mentioned in any of the 6 KP Readers and unfortunately I have missed. I shall be greatly obliged if sny one gives a reference..Let us await till they respond. However I am trying to find out what can be done for study. I would request you to provide the birth data of the daughter-in-law to enable me to coroborate with my process of study. Thanking you. Dr. Luther Rath. Subhash <subhash_ektare Sent: Friday, December 19, 2008 4:18:35 PM Required guidance Dear Seniors, Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have peace of mind. This is first time I came across such a query, I do not know how to proceed, which houses should be analyzed. So I request senior members to throw some light and guide me regarding how to proceed in the matter. Regards Subhash Ektare Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 20, 2008 Report Share Posted December 20, 2008 Dear Subhash, In regards to what house/s should be analyzed for mother-in-law: A good start would be to consider the 10th house. This is the 4th house from 7th hse of spouse. 4th hse representing Mother. From there I will look forward to how KP system delineates a chart in this matter. As Always, Uttara , " Subhash " <subhash_ektare wrote: > > > Dear Seniors, > > > > Mother-in-law and daughter-in-law relations projected in Indian TV > serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her > relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have > peace of mind. This is first time I came across such a query, I do not > know how to proceed, which houses should be analyzed. So I request > senior members to throw some light and guide me regarding how to proceed > in the matter. > > > > Regards > > Subhash Ektare > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 21, 2008 Report Share Posted December 21, 2008 Dear M Uttaraphalguni, I do not know if I can address your so. I wish to know your good name. Eagerly waiting for your analysis. With regards. Dr. Luther Rath muttaraphalguni <muttaraphalguni Sent: Saturday, December 20, 2008 10:01:40 PM Re: Required guidance Dear Subhash,In regards to what house/s should be analyzed for mother-in-law:A good start would be to consider the 10th house. This is the 4thhouse from 7th hse of spouse. 4th hse representing Mother.From there I will look forward to how KP system delineates a chart inthis matter.As Always,Uttara@gro ups.com, "Subhash" <subhash_ektare@ ...> wrote:>> > Dear Seniors,> > > > Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV> serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her> relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have> peace of mind. This is first time I came across such a query, I do not> know how to proceed, which houses should be analyzed. So I request> senior members to throw some light and guide me regarding how to proceed> in the matter.> > > > Regards> > Subhash Ektare> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 21, 2008 Report Share Posted December 21, 2008 , " muttaraphalguni " <muttaraphalguni wrote: > > > Dear Subhash, > > In regards to what house/s should be analyzed for mother-in-law: > > A good start would be to consider the 10th house. This is the 4th > house from 7th hse of spouse. 4th hse representing Mother. > > From there I will look forward to how KP system delineates a chart in > this matter. > > As Always, > > Uttara > > > , " Subhash " <subhash_ektare@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Seniors, > > > > > > > > Mother-in-law and daughter-in-law relations projected in Indian TV > > serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her > > relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have > > peace of mind. This is first time I came across such a query, I do not > > know how to proceed, which houses should be analyzed. So I request > > senior members to throw some light and guide me regarding how to proceed > > in the matter. > > > > > > > > Regards > > > > Subhash Ektare > > > Dear Subhashji, I happen to have analysed many horoscopes to know relationships between persons.Prof.Krishnamurthiji has given clues for relations between husband and wife e.g..if sl of any bhava signifies 6,8,12 as well as is in 6,8,12 from that bhava that bhava suffers,Further if sl of Asc and sl of 10th bhava are in 6,8,12 from each other their relationship suffers.This is also observed when D/B/A lords of such individuals(in their individual horoscopes) are in 6,8,12 position from each other.Even if rashi lords of relevant bhavas are in such a position relation between the persons represented by the bhavas gets strained.Whether strain is permanent or temporary depends on whether this is due to position in horoscope or running Dasha. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 21, 2008 Report Share Posted December 21, 2008 Dear Mr.Subash and Luther Rath, I like to put my views on this. What ever may be the problem? the querient needs relief.In this case from Mother in Law. In horary, Judge the 11th cusp sublord it should signify the lagna and the 9th house. Further more if it signifies 5th house it is a terrfic period for the mother in law and Also judge the 6th house sublord it should signify 6th house or 11 the house. If this also is favorable then the fructification of the matter guareented soon. If the above rule is satisfied proceed. During the conjoined period (Dasa /Bhukthi )of the significators of 6th house and 11th house the matter will start to fructify and during the anthara of the occupant or lord of the 11th house it will fetch final result. With Regards, Ramkumar.--- On Sat, 20/12/08, Luther Rath <rathluther wrote: Luther Rath <rathlutherRe: Required guidance Date: Saturday, 20 December, 2008, 8:41 AM Dear Subhashji, Strained relationship between in-laws is not uncommon in Indian society. This type of query is however uncommon. You have come across such a query for the first time and it may be also first time for many of us.Seniors and experienced members like TWji may be having some confirmed KP rules The rules must have been mentioned in any of the 6 KP Readers and unfortunately I have missed. I shall be greatly obliged if sny one gives a reference..Let us await till they respond. However I am trying to find out what can be done for study. I would request you to provide the birth data of the daughter-in- law to enable me to coroborate with my process of study. Thanking you. Dr. Luther Rath. Subhash <subhash_ektare@ >@gro ups.comFriday, December 19, 2008 4:18:35 PM Required guidance Dear Seniors, Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have peace of mind. This is first time I came across such a query, I do not know how to proceed, which houses should be analyzed. So I request senior members to throw some light and guide me regarding how to proceed in the matter. Regards Subhash Ektare Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Invite them now. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2008 Report Share Posted December 22, 2008 Dear Dr. Luther Rath, Please address me as Uttara. This is my name I use on Jyotish forums. It is my ASC star Lord - Uttaraphalguni, and I have used it for years. People on forums recognise me as Uttara. I do not have any birth details for this inquiry to make an analysis. Further, I am humbly a new student here on KP. I have used KP in the past only as including for prediction in Vedic, its Nakshatras Star Lords. Other than that I am here to learn this system or to understand it better. As Always, Uttara , Luther Rath <rathluther wrote: > > Dear M Uttaraphalguni, > I do not know if I can address your so. I wish to know your good name. > Eagerly waiting for your analysis. > With regards. > Dr. Luther Rath > > > > > ________________________________ > muttaraphalguni <muttaraphalguni > > Saturday, December 20, 2008 10:01:40 PM > Re: Required guidance > > > > Dear Subhash, > > In regards to what house/s should be analyzed for mother-in-law: > > A good start would be to consider the 10th house. This is the 4th > house from 7th hse of spouse. 4th hse representing Mother. > > From there I will look forward to how KP system delineates a chart in > this matter. > > As Always, > > Uttara > > @gro ups.com, " Subhash " <subhash_ektare@ ...> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Seniors, > > > > > > > > Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV > > serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her > > relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have > > peace of mind. This is first time I came across such a query, I do not > > know how to proceed, which houses should be analyzed. So I request > > senior members to throw some light and guide me regarding how to proceed > > in the matter. > > > > > > > > Regards > > > > Subhash Ektare > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2008 Report Share Posted December 22, 2008 4th house is for mother, 9th for mother. Use this to fix MOTHER IN Law Whether she is mother of father raichur anant mumbai --- On Sun, 21/12/08, hattangadi_suresh <hattangadi_suresh wrote: > hattangadi_suresh <hattangadi_suresh > Re: Required guidance > > Sunday, 21 December, 2008, 4:17 PM > , > " muttaraphalguni " > <muttaraphalguni wrote: > > > > > > Dear Subhash, > > > > In regards to what house/s should be analyzed for > mother-in-law: > > > > A good start would be to consider the 10th house. > This is the 4th > > house from 7th hse of spouse. 4th hse representing > Mother. > > > > From there I will look forward to how KP system > delineates a chart in > > this matter. > > > > As Always, > > > > Uttara > > > > > > , " Subhash " > <subhash_ektare@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > Dear Seniors, > > > > > > > > > > > > Mother-in-law and daughter-in-law relations > projected in Indian TV > > > serials are well known. One of my clients is > suffering from her > > > relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to > know when she can have > > > peace of mind. This is first time I came across > such a query, I do not > > > know how to proceed, which houses should be > analyzed. So I request > > > senior members to throw some light and guide me > regarding how to > proceed > > > in the matter. > > > > > > > > > > > > Regards > > > > > > Subhash Ektare > > > > > > Dear Subhashji, > I happen to have analysed many horoscopes to know > relationships > between persons.Prof.Krishnamurthiji has given clues for > relations > between husband and wife e.g..if sl of any bhava signifies > 6,8,12 as > well as is in 6,8,12 from that bhava that bhava > suffers,Further if sl > of Asc and sl of 10th bhava are in 6,8,12 from each other > their > relationship suffers.This is also observed when D/B/A lords > of such > individuals(in their individual horoscopes) are in 6,8,12 > position > from each other.Even if rashi lords of relevant bhavas are > in such a > position relation between the persons represented by the > bhavas gets > strained.Whether strain is permanent or temporary depends > on whether > this is due to position in horoscope or running Dasha. > > > --- > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2008 Report Share Posted December 22, 2008 Dear Friends, If the significator of 10th house for the mother-in-law is also significator of 11 and 1, there will be harmony (KP Reader III) during DBA jointly signifying 11,1 and it is better, if 10 is also signified. (If the significator of 1st is also significator of 10, 6 and 8, they will be enemies.) Regards,tw , Luther Rath <rathluther wrote:>> Dear Subhashji,> Strained relationship between in-laws is not uncommon in Indian society. This type of query is however uncommon. You have come across such a query for the first time and it may be also first time for many of us.Seniors and experienced members like TWji may be having some confirmed KP rules The rules must have been mentioned in any of the 6 KP Readers and unfortunately I have missed. I shall be greatly obliged if sny one gives a reference..Let us await till they respond. However I am trying to find out what can be done for study. I would request you to provide the birth data of the daughter-in-law to enable me to coroborate with my process of study.> Thanking you.> Dr. Luther Rath.> > > > > ________________________________> Subhash subhash_ektare > Friday, December 19, 2008 4:18:35 PM> Required guidance> > > Dear Seniors,> > Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have peace of mind. This is first time I came across such a query, I do not know how to proceed, which houses should be analyzed. So I request senior members to throw some light and guide me regarding how to proceed in the matter.> > Regards> Subhash Ektare> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2008 Report Share Posted December 22, 2008 Dear Tw ji,I hope we can generalize this rule for predictive purpose as follows ? -If the significator of any house is also significator of 1 and 11, there will be harmony with the person represented by that house (especially during dasa period of the significator). If the significator of any house is also significator of 6 and 8, there will be enmity with the person represented by that house (especially during dasa period of the significator).I think this has been taken from the article " Choice of Friends (Friend or Foe) " in the third reader. Though in the original article, 6th house was treated as a positive house. In fact, positive houses are 1,2,3,6,10,11 and negative houses are 4,5,7,8,9,12 .. in other words general KP positive and negative houses. Based on it, I suggest that instead of taking house 6 and 8, we should take house 8 and 12 as primary houses for enmity. Also for the article I understand that the Mother in law will be having significator of 6 and 8 house in daughter in law's chart as her ruling planets, as they are not going very well. Dear Subhash ji, can you please check and confirm if you also have horoscope of mother in law? Now coming to the question, when she will have peace of mind? I think general KP rules should be applicable here. One should check dasa period when there is no signification of 8 and 12. As she is troubled by her mother in law, she should be running dasa of 8, 12, and 10th house presently. Subhash ji, can you check and confirm this as well? It will be an interesting case study. Thanks & Regards,Punit PandeyOn Mon, Dec 22, 2008 at 10:32 PM, tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear Friends, If the significator of 10th house for the mother-in-law is also significator of 11 and 1, there will be harmony (KP Reader III) during DBA jointly signifying 11,1 and it is better, if 10 is also signified. (If the significator of 1st is also significator of 10, 6 and 8, they will be enemies.) Regards,tw , Luther Rath <rathluther wrote:>> Dear Subhashji,> Strained relationship between in-laws is not uncommon in Indian society. This type of query is however uncommon. You have come across such a query for the first time and it may be also first time for many of us.Seniors and experienced members like TWji may be having some confirmed KP rules The rules must have been mentioned in any of the 6 KP Readers and unfortunately I have missed. I shall be greatly obliged if sny one gives a reference..Let us await till they respond. However I am trying to find out what can be done for study. I would request you to provide the birth data of the daughter-in-law to enable me to coroborate with my process of study. > Thanking you.> Dr. Luther Rath.> > > > > ________________________________> Subhash subhash_ektare > Friday, December 19, 2008 4:18:35 PM> Required guidance> > > Dear Seniors,> > Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have peace of mind. This is first time I came across such a query, I do not know how to proceed, which houses should be analyzed. So I request senior members to throw some light and guide me regarding how to proceed in the matter. > > Regards> Subhash Ektare> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2008 Report Share Posted December 22, 2008 Dear Punit Pandey ji,It is from KP Reader III pp 228-229 (Old Edition, Part 2 p 71) under "'Brothers and Sisters, Brother to become hostile". Regards,tw , "Punit Pandey" <punitp wrote:>> Dear Tw ji,> > I hope we can generalize this rule for predictive purpose as follows ? -> > - If the significator of any house is also significator of 1 and 11,> there will be harmony with the person represented by that house (especially> during dasa period of the significator).> - If the significator of any house is also significator of 6 and 8, there> will be enmity with the person represented by that house (especially during> dasa period of the significator).> > I think this has been taken from the article "Choice of Friends (Friend or> Foe)" in the third reader. Though in the original article, 6th house was> treated as a positive house. In fact, positive houses are 1,2,3,6,10,11 and> negative houses are 4,5,7,8,9,12 .. in other words general KP positive and> negative houses. Based on it, I suggest that instead of taking house 6 and> 8, we should take house 8 and 12 as primary houses for enmity. Also for the> article I understand that the Mother in law will be having significator of 6> and 8 house in daughter in law's chart as her ruling planets, as they are> not going very well. Dear Subhash ji, can you please check and confirm if> you also have horoscope of mother in law?> > Now coming to the question, when she will have peace of mind? I think> general KP rules should be applicable here. One should check dasa period> when there is no signification of 8 and 12. As she is troubled by her mother> in law, she should be running dasa of 8, 12, and 10th house presently.> Subhash ji, can you check and confirm this as well? It will be an> interesting case study.> > Thanks & Regards,> > Punit Pandey> > > On Mon, Dec 22, 2008 at 10:32 PM, tw853 tw853 wrote:> > > Dear Friends,> >> > If the significator of 10th house for the mother-in-law is also> > significator of 11 and 1, there will be harmony (KP Reader III) during DBA> > jointly signifying 11,1 and it is better, if 10 is also signified. (If> > the significator of 1st is also significator of 10, 6 and 8, they will be> > enemies.)> >> >> >> > Regards,> >> >> > tw> >> >> > , Luther Rath rathluther@ wrote:> > >> > > Dear Subhashji,> > > Strained relationship between in-laws is not uncommon in Indian society.> > This type of query is however uncommon. You have come across such a query> > for the first time and it may be also first time for many of us.Seniors and> > experienced members like TWji may be having some confirmed KP rules The> > rules must have been mentioned in any of the 6 KP Readers and unfortunately> > I have missed. I shall be greatly obliged if sny one gives a reference..Let> > us await till they respond. However I am trying to find out what can be done> > for study. I would request you to provide the birth data of the> > daughter-in-law to enable me to coroborate with my process of study.> > > Thanking you.> > > Dr. Luther Rath.> > >> > >> > >> > >> > > ________________________________> > > Subhash subhash_ektare@> > > > > > Friday, December 19, 2008 4:18:35 PM> > > Required guidance> > >> > >> > > Dear Seniors,> > >> > > Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV> > serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her relations> > with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have peace of mind.> > This is first time I came across such a query, I do not know how to proceed,> > which houses should be analyzed. So I request senior members to throw some> > light and guide me regarding how to proceed in the matter.> > >> > > Regards> > > Subhash Ektare> > >> > > >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2008 Report Share Posted December 22, 2008 Dear Tw ji,Appreciate the reference. Thanks & Regards,Punit PandeyOn Tue, Dec 23, 2008 at 12:17 AM, tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear Punit Pandey ji,It is from KP Reader III pp 228-229 (Old Edition, Part 2 p 71) under " 'Brothers and Sisters, Brother to become hostile " . Regards,tw , " Punit Pandey " <punitp wrote:>> Dear Tw ji, > > I hope we can generalize this rule for predictive purpose as follows ? -> > - If the significator of any house is also significator of 1 and 11,> there will be harmony with the person represented by that house (especially > during dasa period of the significator).> - If the significator of any house is also significator of 6 and 8, there> will be enmity with the person represented by that house (especially during > dasa period of the significator).> > I think this has been taken from the article " Choice of Friends (Friend or> Foe) " in the third reader. Though in the original article, 6th house was > treated as a positive house. In fact, positive houses are 1,2,3,6,10,11 and> negative houses are 4,5,7,8,9,12 .. in other words general KP positive and> negative houses. Based on it, I suggest that instead of taking house 6 and > 8, we should take house 8 and 12 as primary houses for enmity. Also for the> article I understand that the Mother in law will be having significator of 6> and 8 house in daughter in law's chart as her ruling planets, as they are > not going very well. Dear Subhash ji, can you please check and confirm if> you also have horoscope of mother in law?> > Now coming to the question, when she will have peace of mind? I think> general KP rules should be applicable here. One should check dasa period > when there is no signification of 8 and 12. As she is troubled by her mother> in law, she should be running dasa of 8, 12, and 10th house presently.> Subhash ji, can you check and confirm this as well? It will be an > interesting case study.> > Thanks & Regards,> > Punit Pandey> > > On Mon, Dec 22, 2008 at 10:32 PM, tw853 tw853 wrote: > > > Dear Friends,> >> > If the significator of 10th house for the mother-in-law is also> > significator of 11 and 1, there will be harmony (KP Reader III) during DBA> > jointly signifying 11,1 and it is better, if 10 is also signified. (If > > the significator of 1st is also significator of 10, 6 and 8, they will be> > enemies.)> >> >> >> > Regards,> >> >> > tw> > > >> > , Luther Rath rathluther@ wrote:> > >> > > Dear Subhashji,> > > Strained relationship between in-laws is not uncommon in Indian society. > > This type of query is however uncommon. You have come across such a query> > for the first time and it may be also first time for many of us.Seniors and> > experienced members like TWji may be having some confirmed KP rules The > > rules must have been mentioned in any of the 6 KP Readers and unfortunately> > I have missed. I shall be greatly obliged if sny one gives a reference..Let> > us await till they respond. However I am trying to find out what can be done > > for study. I would request you to provide the birth data of the> > daughter-in-law to enable me to coroborate with my process of study.> > > Thanking you.> > > Dr. Luther Rath. > > >> > >> > >> > >> > > ________________________________> > > Subhash subhash_ektare@> > > > > > Friday, December 19, 2008 4:18:35 PM> > > Required guidance> > >> > >> > > Dear Seniors,> > >> > > Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV > > serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her relations> > with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have peace of mind.> > This is first time I came across such a query, I do not know how to proceed, > > which houses should be analyzed. So I request senior members to throw some> > light and guide me regarding how to proceed in the matter.> > >> > > Regards> > > Subhash Ektare > > >> > > >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2008 Report Share Posted December 22, 2008 Respected TW ji, I knew that you are the only person who will definately find some reference in KP readers regarding this unusual querry. Hats off to your memory and system of tracking references. I have one boubt to be cleared. When you say about the significator of 10 or 1, does it mean the sub lord or the strongest of the significators of that perticular house? Hope to hear from you. Regards Subhash Ektare tw853 <tw853 Sent: Monday, December 22, 2008 10:47:59 AM Re: Required guidance Dear Punit Pandey ji,It is from KP Reader III pp 228-229 (Old Edition, Part 2 p 71) under "'Brothers and Sisters, Brother to become hostile". Regards,tw@gro ups.com, "Punit Pandey" <punitp wrote:>> Dear Tw ji,> > I hope we can generalize this rule for predictive purpose as follows ? -> > - If the significator of any house is also significator of 1 and 11,> there will be harmony with the person represented by that house (especially> during dasa period of the significator) .> - If the significator of any house is also significator of 6 and 8, there> will be enmity with the person represented by that house (especially during> dasa period of the significator) .> > I think this has been taken from the article "Choice of Friends (Friend or> Foe)" in the third reader. Though in the original article, 6th house was> treated as a positive house. In fact, positive houses are 1,2,3,6,10,11 and> negative houses are 4,5,7,8,9,12 .. in other words general KP positive and> negative houses. Based on it, I suggest that instead of taking house 6 and> 8, we should take house 8 and 12 as primary houses for enmity. Also for the> article I understand that the Mother in law will be having significator of 6> and 8 house in daughter in law's chart as her ruling planets, as they are> not going very well. Dear Subhash ji, can you please check and confirm if> you also have horoscope of mother in law?> > Now coming to the question, when she will have peace of mind? I think> general KP rules should be applicable here. One should check dasa period> when there is no signification of 8 and 12. As she is troubled by her mother> in law, she should be running dasa of 8, 12, and 10th house presently.> Subhash ji, can you check and confirm this as well? It will be an> interesting case study.> > Thanks & Regards,> > Punit Pandey> > > On Mon, Dec 22, 2008 at 10:32 PM, tw853 tw853 wrote:> > > Dear Friends,> >> > If the significator of 10th house for the mother-in-law is also> > significator of 11 and 1, there will be harmony (KP Reader III) during DBA> > jointly signifying 11,1 and it is better, if 10 is also signified. (If> > the significator of 1st is also significator of 10, 6 and 8, they will be> > enemies.)> >> >> >> > Regards,> >> >> > tw> >> >> > @gro ups.com, Luther Rath rathluther@ wrote:> > >> > > Dear Subhashji,> > > Strained relationship between in-laws is not uncommon in Indian society.> > This type of query is however uncommon. You have come across such a query> > for the first time and it may be also first time for many of us.Seniors and> > experienced members like TWji may be having some confirmed KP rules The> > rules must have been mentioned in any of the 6 KP Readers and unfortunately> > I have missed. I shall be greatly obliged if sny one gives a reference..Let> > us await till they respond. However I am trying to find out what can be done> > for study. I would request you to provide the birth data of the> > daughter-in- law to enable me to coroborate with my process of study.> > > Thanking you.> > > Dr. Luther Rath.> > >> > >> > >> > >> > > ____________ _________ _________ __> > > Subhash subhash_ektare@> > > @gro ups.com> > > Friday, December 19, 2008 4:18:35 PM> > > Required guidance> > >> > >> > > Dear Seniors,> > >> > > Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV> > serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her relations> > with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have peace of mind.> > This is first time I came across such a query, I do not know how to proceed,> > which houses should be analyzed. So I request senior members to throw some> > light and guide me regarding how to proceed in the matter.> > >> > > Regards> > > Subhash Ektare> > >> > > >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2008 Report Share Posted December 23, 2008 Message forwarded Subhash Ektare ----- Forwarded Message ----Subhash Ektare <subhash_ektarePunit Pandey <punitpMonday, December 22, 2008 11:40:17 AMRe: Re: Required guidance Dear Punit ji and respected TW ji Your way of approach is commendable. Punit ji, for reference I am hereby giving the birth details of the lady since this is an interesting case. DOB 18 Aug 1975 TOB 21:00 Hrs POB New Delhi 28 N 36 77 E 12 Asc Pisc 15-13-45 KP Ayanamsha 23-25-12 Unfortunately I am not having birth details of her mother- in-law. I will try to get it and post it when available. Regards, Subhash Ektare Punit Pandey <punitp Cc: Subhash <subhash_ektareMonday, December 22, 2008 10:32:27 AMRe: Re: Required guidanceDear Tw ji,I hope we can generalize this rule for predictive purpose as follows ? - If the significator of any house is also significator of 1 and 11, there will be harmony with the person represented by that house (especially during dasa period of the significator). If the significator of any house is also significator of 6 and 8, there will be enmity with the person represented by that house (especially during dasa period of the significator).I think this has been taken from the article "Choice of Friends (Friend or Foe)" in the third reader. Though in the original article, 6th house was treated as a positive house. In fact, positive houses are 1,2,3,6,10,11 and negative houses are 4,5,7,8,9,12 .. in other words general KP positive and negative houses. Based on it, I suggest that instead of taking house 6 and 8, we should take house 8 and 12 as primary houses for enmity. Also for the article I understand that the Mother in law will be having significator of 6 and 8 house in daughter in law's chart as her ruling planets, as they are not going very well. Dear Subhash ji, can you please check and confirm if you also have horoscope of mother in law?Now coming to the question, when she will have peace of mind? I think general KP rules should be applicable here. One should check dasa period when there is no signification of 8 and 12. As she is troubled by her mother in law, she should be running dasa of 8, 12, and 10th house presently. Subhash ji, can you check and confirm this as well? It will be an interesting case study. Thanks & Regards,Punit Pandey On Mon, Dec 22, 2008 at 10:32 PM, tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear Friends, If the significator of 10th house for the mother-in-law is also significator of 11 and 1, there will be harmony (KP Reader III) during DBA jointly signifying 11,1 and it is better, if 10 is also signified. (If the significator of 1st is also significator of 10, 6 and 8, they will be enemies.) Regards, tw , Luther Rath <rathluther wrote:>> Dear Subhashji,> Strained relationship between in-laws is not uncommon in Indian society. This type of query is however uncommon. You have come across such a query for the first time and it may be also first time for many of us.Seniors and experienced members like TWji may be having some confirmed KP rules The rules must have been mentioned in any of the 6 KP Readers and unfortunately I have missed. I shall be greatly obliged if sny one gives a reference..Let us await till they respond. However I am trying to find out what can be done for study. I would request you to provide the birth data of the daughter-in-law to enable me to coroborate with my process of study.> Thanking you.> Dr. Luther Rath.> > > > > ________________________________> Subhash subhash_ektare > > Friday, December 19, 2008 4:18:35 PM> Required guidance> > > Dear Seniors,> > Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her relations with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have peace of mind. This is first time I came across such a query, I do not know how to proceed, which houses should be analyzed. So I request senior members to throw some light and guide me regarding how to proceed in the matter.> > Regards> Subhash Ektare> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2008 Report Share Posted December 24, 2008 Dear Friends, 1. Female, 18/08/1975, 21:00 IST, Delhi, 28N36, 77E12, KPNA 23:25:36, Asc Pi 15:13:37, Venus Dasa bal 1Y:0M:23D (KPAstro 3.0) 2. 10CSL Me+(6,4-7) is in star Ve(6,3-8) and sub Ma+(2,2-9). No planet is in star Ve, which is sub lord of 3,5,9,10,11. Me is closely conj with Ve in 6th house. There is strong signification of 6 (enmity) and also 8 (quarrel), 11 (harmony), 9 (negotiable). 10 is defunct due to 9 in sub level. 3. 1CSL Ju(1,1-10) is in star Ke(2,9,5,6,3,8) and sub Ve(6,3-8). The 6,8 signification is strong. 4. Thus it appears no harmony but may not like enemy. 5. Current running Dasa is Rahu and Bhukti is Mercury till 13/03/2010. Ra+ is in 8 and no planet in star Ra, which is sub lord of 6. Ra is in star Ju(1,1-10) and agent of Ma+(2,2-9) and in own sub Ra( 8,6,1,10,2,9). With no planet in its star and being in own star, Ra is a strong significator of negative 8 and 6, along with positive 1,10 signification. Bhukti lord Me is as discussed above. 6. In my opinion, harmony may not foreseen in Rahu Dasa (12/09/1999 to 12/09/2017) 7. Maneka Gandhi, 26/08/1956, 05:00 IST, Delhi, 28N39, 77E13 (Pre-Eminent Horoscopes by V.K. Agrawal p 95-6), KPNA 23:09:42, Asc Cn 26:40:43, Ketu Dasa bal 6Y:8M;30D (KPAstro 3.0) 8. 10CSL Sa(4,7-8) is own star and sub Sa(4,7-8). 4 and 8 are undesirable. 1CSL Ju(1,6-9) is in star Ve (11,4-11) and sub Mo(9,1). But not enemy. Marriage and Sanjay's death happened in Venus Dasa. Ve(11,4-11) is in star Ju(1,6-9) and sub Sa(4,7-8). 9. It may be justified by the rule. Regards, tw , Subhash Ektare <subhash_ektare wrote: > > Respected TW ji, > > I knew that you are the only person who will definately find > some reference in KP readers regarding this unusual querry. > Hats off to your memory and system of tracking references. > > I have one boubt to be cleared. When you say about the > significator of 10 or 1, does it mean the sub lord or the > strongest of the significators of that perticular house? Hope > to hear from you. > > Regards > Subhash Ektare > > > > > ________________________________ > tw853 <tw853 > > Monday, December 22, 2008 10:47:59 AM > Re: Required guidance > > > Dear Punit Pandey ji, > > It is from KP Reader III pp 228-229 (Old Edition, Part 2 p 71) under " 'Brothers and Sisters, Brother to become hostile " . > > Regards, > > tw > > > @gro ups.com, " Punit Pandey " <punitp@> wrote: > > > > Dear Tw ji, > > > > I hope we can generalize this rule for predictive purpose as follows ? - > > > > - If the significator of any house is also significator of 1 and 11, > > there will be harmony with the person represented by that house (especially > > during dasa period of the significator) . > > - If the significator of any house is also significator of 6 and 8, there > > will be enmity with the person represented by that house (especially during > > dasa period of the significator) . > > > > I think this has been taken from the article " Choice of Friends (Friend or > > Foe) " in the third reader. Though in the original article, 6th house was > > treated as a positive house. In fact, positive houses are 1,2,3,6,10,11 and > > negative houses are 4,5,7,8,9,12 .. in other words general KP positive and > > negative houses. Based on it, I suggest that instead of taking house 6 and > > 8, we should take house 8 and 12 as primary houses for enmity. Also for the > > article I understand that the Mother in law will be having significator of 6 > > and 8 house in daughter in law's chart as her ruling planets, as they are > > not going very well. Dear Subhash ji, can you please check and confirm if > > you also have horoscope of mother in law? > > > > Now coming to the question, when she will have peace of mind? I think > > general KP rules should be applicable here. One should check dasa period > > when there is no signification of 8 and 12. As she is troubled by her mother > > in law, she should be running dasa of 8, 12, and 10th house presently. > > Subhash ji, can you check and confirm this as well? It will be an > > interesting case study. > > > > Thanks & Regards, > > > > Punit Pandey > > > > > > On Mon, Dec 22, 2008 at 10:32 PM, tw853 tw853@ wrote: > > > > > Dear Friends, > > > > > > If the significator of 10th house for the mother-in-law is also > > > significator of 11 and 1, there will be harmony (KP Reader III) during DBA > > > jointly signifying 11,1 and it is better, if 10 is also signified. (If > > > the significator of 1st is also significator of 10, 6 and 8, they will be > > > enemies.) > > > > > > > > > > > > Regards, > > > > > > > > > tw > > > > > > > > > @gro ups.com, Luther Rath rathluther@ wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear Subhashji, > > > > Strained relationship between in-laws is not uncommon in Indian society. > > > This type of query is however uncommon. You have come across such a query > > > for the first time and it may be also first time for many of us.Seniors and > > > experienced members like TWji may be having some confirmed KP rules The > > > rules must have been mentioned in any of the 6 KP Readers and unfortunately > > > I have missed. I shall be greatly obliged if sny one gives a reference..Let > > > us await till they respond. However I am trying to find out what can be done > > > for study. I would request you to provide the birth data of the > > > daughter-in- law to enable me to coroborate with my process of study. > > > > Thanking you. > > > > Dr. Luther Rath. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ____________ _________ _________ __ > > > > Subhash subhash_ektare@ > > > > @gro ups.com > > > > Friday, December 19, 2008 4:18:35 PM > > > > Required guidance > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Seniors, > > > > > > > > Mother-in-law and daughter-in- law relations projected in Indian TV > > > serials are well known. One of my clients is suffering from her relations > > > with her mother-in-law. She wanted to know when she can have peace of mind. > > > This is first time I came across such a query, I do not know how to proceed, > > > which houses should be analyzed. So I request senior members to throw some > > > light and guide me regarding how to proceed in the matter. > > > > > > > > Regards > > > > Subhash Ektare > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.