[Jagannath] Prashna

[Guest guest]

Dear Vijay,

 

> Does the person who is asking expect all who are present in the

> class to

> attempt it? Does all of them attempt to answere?

> If so, will they do it then, or postpone it? If it is done

> there and

> then itself, your example do not serve the purpose. If they

> choose

> to pospone to attempt to answere, whoom will the native

> approach

> afterwards? One or all of them?

>

> What I am trying to say is, though a question is directed to a

>

> collection of astrologers, the native might have to resort to

> a single

> astrologer. Your example do not serve the purpose of

> contradicting this

> statement.

 

Let me clarify my question further.

 

Suppose someone with great faith in Sanjay AND his students walks

in to SJVC towards the end of a class and poses a question.

Suppose he did not explicitly say who he wants to answer it. Is

it not a genuine prasna because of that?

 

If one took a position that a genuine prasna would have to be

posed to a single astrologer, that solves the riddle. But I am

not convinced that a prasna posed to a gathering of learned

astrologers is not genuine.

 

> For your example, if some one asks a question in SJVC class,

> and the

> teacher feels it was genuine (I mean to say, it can

> be genuine) teacher may take up the prasna himself, or may

> direct one of

> disciples there to work on it.

 

That is ONE possibility. What if student x takes it up after

going home, student y after his dinner and Sanjay after the pooja

next morning? Which becomes the correct prasna lagna?

 

May Jupiter's light shine on us,

Narasimha