[Jagannath] Prashna

[Guest guest]

My dear brother,

 

Narasimha Rao wrote:

 

> Are you saying that a prasna posed to several astrologers is not

> genuine? If someone with great faith in you and your students walks in

> to an SJVC class at the end of the class and poses a prasna to the

> class collectively (addressing the whole class), is not a genuine

> prasna??

>

> I am not challenging what elders teach. I am only asking a question

> that troubles me, so that the knowledge can be consolidated.

 

Does the person who is asking expect all who are present in the class to

attempt it? Does all of them attempt to answere?

If so, will they do it then, or postpone it? If it is done there and

then itself, your example do not serve the purpose. If they choose

to pospone to attempt to answere, whoom will the native approach

afterwards? One or all of them?

 

What I am trying to say is, though a question is directed to a

collection of astrologers, the native might have to resort to a single

astrologer. Your example do not serve the purpose of contradicting this

statement.

 

For your example, if some one asks a question in SJVC class, and the

teacher feels it was genuine (I mean to say, it can

be genuine) teacher may take up the prasna himself, or may direct one of

disciples there to work on it.

 

Regards,

Vijay.