Comments on Frans's answers- Lesson 12 - Yogada

[Guest guest]

OHM SHRI RAGAVENDRAYA NAMAH

JAYA JAGANNATHA

 

Namaste Frans,

 

Welcome to the Gurukulam.

 

Yes. Except Gurus, all are beginners like you. So, feel free to contribute.

 

Other comments are below.

 

Thanks

Solai Kannan

 

Before I attempt the question on calculating Yogada planets, I was wonderingwhy we do not use Rasi and Graha Dristi simultaneously - as was suggested inanother context by Sanjay Rath (Message 50 - Sep.8, 1999):"Both Rasi and Graha dristi are to be applied simultaneously. Rasi dristi is apermanent aspect while Graha dristi only moulds the desire of the object."I imagine that there are informed reasons why this may not apply in this case. I would appreciate learning about them.

 

Comment:- Gurudeva Sanjay explains in this mail about considering the drishti for chart analysis. But, what we are seeing in the lesson, is the rules for the Yogada. The given rules are as it is and we follow. Bavalagna, also an important lagna. So, we cannot question, why BL is not considered for Yogada. Because, the given rules are rules. But, you can later think on these matters and research, why the sages have considered the Lagna, GL,HL and rasi drishti only. Otherthan this, Narasimha has already explained the importance of Rasi drishti in one of the today's mail. Whatever, I mentioned recently about Rasi drishti is my own opinion. So, until, it is approved by any of the Gurus, do not give importance to that.

Sincerely,Frans I - Calculation of Yogada own chartBirthdata:7 May 19559:45 A.M.5E20; 50N56Asc. 3Canc36Sun 22Ar47Moon 27Lib35Mars 24Ta27Merc 8Ta17Jup 0 Canc 31Venus 22Pisc03Sat ® 24Libr46Rahu 5Sag29GL in AriesHL in Virgo

+----------------------+| | GL | Mer | || | | | || Ven | Glk | Mnd | Ket || | | | || | Sun | Mar | ||-------------|---------------------------|-------------|| | | Jup || | | || | | BL || | | || | | Asc ||-------------| R A S I |-------------|| | | || | | || | | || | | || | | ||-------------|---------------------------|-------------|| | | | || | | SatR | || Rah | | | HL || | | Moo | || | | | |+----------------------+

 

1) Subhapati is Venus.2) Karta: a) Venus, Rahu, Ketu asp. HL b) Merc., Mars aspect L c) Mars own GL d) Moon owns L e) Merc owns HL f) Sun in GL g) Jup in L3) Kevala: Subhapati Venus aspects HL, is therefore Kevala.4) Yogada planets:-Mars aspects L and owns GL. -Mercury aspects L and owns HL.Mars as owner of 5 & 10 is the more important Giver of Yoga.5) Kevala Yogada: none. 6) Maha Yogada: none.7) Kevala Mahayogada: none

Comment:- Perfect.

II - Rajiv Gandhi Chart.1) Subhapati is Sun 2) Karta: Sun, Venus, Jupiter, Mercury, Moon, Ketu3) Kevala: Sun4) Yogada planets: Sun, Venus, Jupiter, Mercury, Moon, Ketu5) Kevala Yogada: Sun6) Maha Yogada: Sun (*), VENUS, JUPITER, MERCURY, MOON7) Kevala Maha Yogada: Sun[(*)I learned from reading someone else's response to the question, that Moon,Merc, Jupiter and Venus should be included as Maha Yogada's as they allconjoin and aspect L, HL & GL - I had previously wrongly assumed that planetsexcluded in earlier qualifications could not be included in later ones]

 

Comment:- Perfect.

 

III - King Abdulla Chart.1) Subhapati is Venus2) Karta: Moon, Mars, Saturn, Venus, Sun, Jupiter, Ketu, Mercury, Rahu3) Kevala: Venus4) Yogada planets: Mars (owns L, asp L), Venus (owns HL, asp L)5) Kevala Yogada: Venus

Comment:- Perfect.

IV - Priyanka's Son's Chart.1) Subhapati is Sun 2) Karta: Ketu, Rahu, Venus, Mercury, Jupiter3) Kevala: No4) Yogada: Venus, Ketu, Rahu (**) (***)5) Kevala Yogada: No[(**)Again, I learned from reading other responses, that Rahu, Venus and Ketuare MAHA YOGADA's - planets excluded in earlier qualifications can still beincluded in later ones](***) I wondered if Mercury has to be included (owns HL & GL) - the rule, asstated, only makes mention of combinations of L & HL, and L & GL.Comment:- Karta, yogada and Mahayogada are the steps. Like School final, graduate and post graduate. So, we are looking at them step by step. If a planet is not a Yogada, then definitely he cannot be a Mahayogada. But, by looking at a chart, if you notice, that a planet is having association with Lagna, HL, and GL, then you can conclude that it is a Mahayogada planet. You need not call them Yogada. Here, we are doing a lesson. So, we follow the steps.

Otherwise, your understanding is perfect. OM TAT SATArchive: varahamihiraInfo: varahamihira/info.html