[Jagannath] Prasna (Horary): My practice of my fath er's approach

[Guest guest]

Dear Learned Listmembers

 

It seems to me that perhaps KP's method of checking whether there is Any

correlation that exists between Prasna & ones Birth Chart before venturing

interpretation is More correct as then the 2 charts should give similar

readings. I believe this practice was also done by practitioners of William

Lilly teachings.

 

Please note I am Not an expert on KP But his methods certainly hold alot of

truth from what I have seen - it certainly has lent itself for Birth

rectification's etc.

 

Jai Sita Ram

 

Ram

 

>

> Narasimha Rao [sMTP:pvr]

> 15 February 2000 05:32

> varahamihira

> Cc: vedic astrology

> [vedic astrology] Re: Prasna (Horary): My practice of my

> father's approach

>

> Om Sanjayaaya Namaha

> Dear Sanjay,

>

> > Jaya Jagannath

> > Dear Narasimha & Vijay,

> > The process of the formation of the question is like

> > pregnancy.

> > Initially it is unclear and blurred andlater it crystallises.

> > This could

> > take months to form like questions pertaining to spirituality.

> > Thus, if we

> > were to try to attempt the time when the prasna was first

> > conceived, then we

> > are attempting the impossible.

>

> I don't agree with your analogy of conception.

>

> The time when the question strikes in the most basic form is

> analogous to conception. The time when the query is formed in

> clear terms for being posed to an astrologer is analogous to

> delivery.

>

> > If we take the time when the prasna was finally conceived,

> > then also we

> > are attempting the impossible, because the querist will never

> > know this and

> > will attempt a guess.

> > Communicating the Prasna: This can be communicated to ten

> > different

> > astrologers at ten different times. For example a businessman

> > suffering

> > losses goes to one astrologer with the same prasna on one day

> > and to another

> > on another day. Thus, each Jyotish will have a different

> > Prasna Jataka.

> > Thus each Jyotish will get the Prasna in his ears (Hearing

> > or receipt of

> > communication is Akash Tatwa and is ruled by Vishnu/Jupiter)

> > at different

> > times. Thus depending on the blessings of Jupiter/Vishnu the

> > blessed one

> > gets the right time.

>

> I have two problems with this:

>

> (1) The time when astrologer finally analyzes the prasna is

> dependent on the actions of the astrologer. How can lagna of that

> chart represent the queror then?

>

> (2) Saying that different astrologers get different charts and

> the blessed one gets the right one sounds too arbitrary to me.

> One could extend this to natal charts, after all, and say that

> the exact birthtime is not needed and astrologer can cast the

> chart for the moment he analyzes a native's fortune and the

> blessed astrologer gets the right chart.

>

> This may sound like an exaggeration to you, but there isn't much

> difference.

>

> With the approach I outlined, query formation time is fixed and

> all astrologers have the same chart. It is no longer arbitrary.

>

> > As regards examples, I have about a dozen charts everyday.

> > This proves

> > nothing.

>

> I am surprised by this assertion Sanjay. I never said it " proves "

> anything! The four examples were just for illustrating how the

> basic nature of query is visible in the query formation chart.

> They do not prove anything.

>

> By detailing my approach to prasna, I did not want to prove

> anything. My only wish is that learned astrologers (including

> you) should consider my approach with an open mind. I wrote it

> because I am convinced that it is worth your (and others')

> consideration.

>

> > Om Tat Sat

> > Best Wishes

> > Sanjay Rath

>

> May He show us the Right Path,

> Your grateful sishya,

> Narasimha

>

>

>

> ------

>

>

>

> ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us .......

>

>

> ------

> eLerts!

> Save cash today!

> http://click./1/1413/0/_/311/_/950592784/

>

> -- Talk to your group with your own voice!

> -- /VoiceChatPage?listName=vedic astrology & m=1

>