Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Question on Prashna Shastra

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Gurus and Learned Members,

 

Looks like, my question / doubt did not got your attention.

 

Can't we answer to these kind of question using the known methods ?

 

If that is case, I will reply to the person, who asked me these

questions as " there are no known methods in Vedic Astrology to get a

precise Numerical answers to your questions " .

 

Alternatively, if you have any pointers or clues, please write in the

list or to me privately. If not then I may have to continue my own

discovery to find answers, which may take longer time.

 

Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

 

sohamsa , Raghunatha RaoNemani <raon1008

wrote:

>

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Gurus and Learned Members,

 

I am struglling to understand and get some guidelines on answering

the following two questions:-

 

1) When a native comes and say: I was told I am getting a Promotion

in my current job. How much raise in my Salary, can I expect ?

 

2) When a native comes and say: I was told I am getting some

performance based bonus/reward. How much money can I expect ?

 

May I reqeust you to please teach me or provide me or point me to

some references where I can find some numerical calculations to

derive the answers such as follows to the above questions:-

 

Answer to Q.1) You will get 6 % pay raise

Answer to Q.2) You will get US$ 2500 as a bonus / reward for your

hard work.

 

As you know I go very focused to find answers, so please guide me to

get the answers to the above using " Prashna based Methods " ONLY.

 

You may write in the list or if you choose to write to me privately,

that is fine too. Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Visti Ji,

 

Thanks for the note. I have read both of them and could not figure

out the numerical method yet. May be you can help me with an

example. Let us take a practical case. I was one of those high

performers in my organization for the year 2005. As a result of that

I was told this week, I will be given an Award/Bonus in March 1st/2nd

week.

 

May I request you to cast a Prashna and tell me what would be the

percentage of bonus I get in March 1st/2nd week. Based on my role as

a Manager, I could be given a award anywhere between 1% and 15 %.

 

When you give your reply, please eloborate the process so that I can

learn from your anlaysis. If you prefer to write to me privately,

please do so, as my intension was to learn this method. I would like

to use the Prashna Method only for this exercise.

 

Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

sohamsa , " Visti Larsen " <visti wrote:

" Visti Larsen " <visti

Wed Feb 15, 2006 10:07 am

RE: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

||Hare Rama Krsna||

 

Dear Raghunatha, Namaskar

 

You pose very big questions and sometimes we just don't have the

answers.

But i can help with a bit.

 

First of all i assume that you have identified that the person is

going to

get a raise or not? After having done so, read Krishneeyam and Jataka

Tattva (chapter on second house) to figure out how much.

 

Best wishes,

***

Visti Larsen

 

For services and articles visit:

http://srigaruda.com or http://astrovisti.com

***

 

 

sohamsa [sohamsa ] On

Behalf Of

Raghunatha RaoNemani

15 February 2006 16:57

sohamsa

Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Gurus and Learned Members,

 

Looks like, my question / doubt did not got your attention.

 

Can't we answer to these kind of question using the known methods ?

 

If that is case, I will reply to the person, who asked me these

questions as " there are no known methods in Vedic Astrology to get a

precise Numerical answers to your questions " .

 

Alternatively, if you have any pointers or clues, please write in the

list or to me privately. If not then I may have to continue my own

discovery to find answers, which may take longer time.

 

Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

 

sohamsa , Raghunatha RaoNemani <raon1008

wrote:

>

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Gurus and Learned Members,

 

I am struglling to understand and get some guidelines on answering

the following two questions:-

 

1) When a native comes and say: I was told I am getting a Promotion

in my current job. How much raise in my Salary, can I expect ?

 

2) When a native comes and say: I was told I am getting some

performance based bonus/reward. How much money can I expect ?

 

May I reqeust you to please teach me or provide me or point me to

some references where I can find some numerical calculations to

derive the answers such as follows to the above questions:-

 

Answer to Q.1) You will get 6 % pay raise

Answer to Q.2) You will get US$ 2500 as a bonus / reward for your

hard work.

 

As you know I go very focused to find answers, so please guide me to

get the answers to the above using " Prashna based Methods " ONLY.

 

You may write in the list or if you choose to write to me privately,

that is fine too. Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Bharat Ji,

 

Thanks for the note. I have looked at the Prashna Chart casted by you

and I liked the analysis and your approach. But honestly, my

original questions was : how to determine the Numerical Value. In

other words, from your analysis, how did you arrived at 10% ( the

number 10 ). That is what I am trying to understand and learn.

 

Request you or others in the list to guide me in this process.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

----

Bharat Hindu Astrology <hinduastrology

Wed Feb 15, 2006 1:58 pm

Re: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

Namaskaar Sri Raghunatha

 

I am attempting this question:

It looks like to be more than expected. I would say this figure would

be 10% or above.

I have taken the particulars of Feb 15, 2006 23:17 hrs at New Delhi

 

Reasoning:

The Yogi for the chart is Rahu and the Yogi point is in Swati and it

is likely to prosper. The lagna rises in Swati.Venus is avayogi but

it is also the duplicate yogi and will offer results of prosperity

too.

 

The dasha on March 1 will be Sun-Rahu-Venus-Venus-Jupiter. You see

Rahu and Venus are deeply involved and Jupiter is in the lagna too.

Rahu gives more than expected as it is in the nakshatra of a

yogakaraka graha.

 

Even if the above turns out to be true, it might just be a fluke

case. We will need to apply principles on charts again and again and

check what would work and what would not.

 

Do let me know how it comes about.

 

Thanks and Regards

Bharat

 

--------------

 

On 2/15/06, Raghunatha RaoNemani <raon1008 wrote:

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Visti Ji,

 

Thanks for the note. I have read both of them and could not figure

out the numerical method yet. May be you can help me with an

example. Let us take a practical case. I was one of those high

performers in my organization for the year 2005. As a result of that

I was told this week, I will be given an Award/Bonus in March 1st/2nd

week.

 

May I request you to cast a Prashna and tell me what would be the

percentage of bonus I get in March 1st/2nd week. Based on my role as

a Manager, I could be given a award anywhere between 1% and 15 %.

 

When you give your reply, please eloborate the process so that I can

learn from your anlaysis. If you prefer to write to me privately,

please do so, as my intension was to learn this method. I would like

to use the Prashna Method only for this exercise.

 

Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

sohamsa , " Visti Larsen " <visti wrote:

" Visti Larsen " <visti

Wed Feb 15, 2006 10:07 am

RE: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

 

||Hare Rama Krsna||

 

Dear Raghunatha, Namaskar

 

You pose very big questions and sometimes we just don't have the

answers.

But i can help with a bit.

 

First of all i assume that you have identified that the person is

going to

get a raise or not? After having done so, read Krishneeyam and Jataka

Tattva (chapter on second house) to figure out how much.

 

Best wishes,

***

Visti Larsen

 

For services and articles visit:

http://srigaruda.com or http://astrovisti.com

***

 

 

sohamsa [ sohamsa ] On

Behalf Of

Raghunatha RaoNemani

15 February 2006 16:57

sohamsa

Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Gurus and Learned Members,

 

Looks like, my question / doubt did not got your attention.

 

Can't we answer to these kind of question using the known methods ?

 

If that is case, I will reply to the person, who asked me these

questions as " there are no known methods in Vedic Astrology to get a

precise Numerical answers to your questions " .

 

Alternatively, if you have any pointers or clues, please write in the

list or to me privately. If not then I may have to continue my own

discovery to find answers, which may take longer time.

 

Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

 

sohamsa , Raghunatha RaoNemani <raon1008

wrote:

>

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Gurus and Learned Members,

 

I am struglling to understand and get some guidelines on answering

the following two questions:-

 

1) When a native comes and say: I was told I am getting a Promotion

in my current job. How much raise in my Salary, can I expect ?

 

2) When a native comes and say: I was told I am getting some

performance based bonus/reward. How much money can I expect ?

 

May I reqeust you to please teach me or provide me or point me to

some references where I can find some numerical calculations to

derive the answers such as follows to the above questions:-

 

Answer to Q.1) You will get 6 % pay raise

Answer to Q.2) You will get US$ 2500 as a bonus / reward for your

hard work.

 

As you know I go very focused to find answers, so please guide me to

get the answers to the above using " Prashna based Methods " ONLY.

 

You may write in the list or if you choose to write to me privately,

that is fine too. Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Swee Ji,

 

Thanks for the note and I am already familiar with all those

principles which you have provided.

 

Honestly, I am looking for a method to Quantify the percentage of

rise ( between 1 and 15 ) in this case.

 

So, please do not mis-understand me by writing this, but my quest is

to find a method to quantify the things. In this example, what

percent of Bonus.

 

See if you can give me some ideas and pointers, then I will look into

those taking Bharat Ji's Prashna Chart as an example.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

 

sohamsa , " Swee Chan " <swee wrote:

 

" Swee Chan " <swee

Wed Feb 15, 2006 8:07 am

RE: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra swee10101

Offline

Send Email

Invite to 360º

 

Jaya Jagannatha

 

Dear Raghunatha,

Namaste

 

Jaimini 1.3.12 etairyaH evaM lAbaH

The sources of expenses will indicate the sources of gains if the

concerned

planets are in the eleventh house.

Sanjay ji's notes:

The sources of gains and expenses will be indicated by the planets in

the

11th and 12th from AL. If Mars is in the 11th, gains could be accrued

from

younger borther.

 

etc.

 

Please read page 81

If prsna lord aspects the HL or SL without Saturn's aspect, you may

expect

a better rise. The yogada aspecting HL or SL with LL is also another

clue to

expect a phenomenal increase.

Astakavarga of the 11th from LL can also give another clue.

 

Hope this is of some help.

 

Love,

Swee

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Swee Ji,

 

Thanks for the noteand it was an excelletn analysis. I like that kind

of approach to quantify things. I will surely let you know what is

the actual % when I know.

 

Now, you have mentioned that " Taking the averages of the points

between the 11th from AL and AL itself, it equates to almost 8%

increase. "

 

I am still unable to understand how did you arrived at 8% form the

above. Can you please eloborate the actual math for me.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

sohamsa , " Swee Chan " <swee wrote:

" Swee Chan " <swee

Wed Feb 15, 2006 8:37 am

RE: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

Jaya Jagannatha

 

Dear Bharat,

 

Namaste

 

Ah, I missed this part of the question. Anyway, you have not

considered the dagdha rasis, which are the 4th and the 11th houses.

Venus is both an avayogi and a yogi planet. Jupiter is in Bhojana

avastha and Venus is in Jalapana avastha. He might need to negotiate

for better as he will not be happy with what is being offered. Note

that Venus is also in 11th from AL in rasi drishti with GL and HL, in

bhagya sthana. But the AV of Venus in the 11th from AL is slightly

better off than AL. the 12th from AL indicates that he will not lose

out anyway, with the 2nd from AL with higher points than the AL.

 

Taking the averages of the points between the 11th from AL and AL

itself, it equates to almost 8% increase.

 

Raghunatha, please let us know the outcome.

 

Love

 

Swee

----

 

sohamsa [sohamsa ] On

Behalf Of Bharat Hindu Astrology

Thursday, February 16, 2006 3:58 AM

sohamsa

Re: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

 

 

Namaskaar Sri Raghunatha

 

I am attempting this question:

It looks like to be more than expected. I would say this figure would

be 10% or above.

I have taken the particulars of Feb 15, 2006 23:17 hrs at New Delhi

 

Reasoning:

The Yogi for the chart is Rahu and the Yogi point is in Swati and it

is likely to prosper. The lagna rises in Swati.Venus is avayogi but

it is also the duplicate yogi and will offer results of prosperity

too.

 

The dasha on March 1 will be Sun-Rahu-Venus-Venus-Jupiter. You see

Rahu and Venus are deeply involved and Jupiter is in the lagna too.

Rahu gives more than expected as it is in the nakshatra of a

yogakaraka graha.

 

Even if the above turns out to be true, it might just be a fluke

case. We will need to apply principles on charts again and again and

check what would work and what would not.

 

Do let me know how it comes about.

 

Thanks and Regards

Bharat

------

 

On 2/15/06, Raghunatha RaoNemani <raon1008 wrote:

 

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Visti Ji,

 

Thanks for the note. I have read both of them and could not figure

out the numerical method yet. May be you can help me with an

example. Let us take a practical case. I was one of those high

performers in my organization for the year 2005. As a result of that

I was told this week, I will be given an Award/Bonus in March 1st/2nd

week.

 

May I request you to cast a Prashna and tell me what would be the

percentage of bonus I get in March 1st/2nd week. Based on my role as

a Manager, I could be given a award anywhere between 1% and 15 %.

 

When you give your reply, please eloborate the process so that I can

learn from your anlaysis. If you prefer to write to me privately,

please do so, as my intension was to learn this method. I would like

to use the Prashna Method only for this exercise.

 

Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

sohamsa , " Visti Larsen " <visti wrote:

" Visti Larsen " <visti

Wed Feb 15, 2006 10:07 am

RE: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

 

 

||Hare Rama Krsna||

 

Dear Raghunatha, Namaskar

 

You pose very big questions and sometimes we just don't have the

answers.

But i can help with a bit.

 

First of all i assume that you have identified that the person is

going to

get a raise or not? After having done so, read Krishneeyam and Jataka

Tattva (chapter on second house) to figure out how much.

 

Best wishes,

***

Visti Larsen

 

For services and articles visit:

http://srigaruda.com or http://astrovisti.com

***

 

 

sohamsa [ sohamsa ] On

Behalf Of

Raghunatha RaoNemani

15 February 2006 16:57

sohamsa

Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Gurus and Learned Members,

 

Looks like, my question / doubt did not got your attention.

 

Can't we answer to these kind of question using the known methods ?

 

If that is case, I will reply to the person, who asked me these

questions as " there are no known methods in Vedic Astrology to get a

precise Numerical answers to your questions " .

 

Alternatively, if you have any pointers or clues, please write in the

list or to me privately. If not then I may have to continue my own

discovery to find answers, which may take longer time.

 

Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

 

sohamsa , Raghunatha RaoNemani <raon1008

wrote:

>

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Gurus and Learned Members,

 

I am struglling to understand and get some guidelines on answering

the following two questions:-

 

1) When a native comes and say: I was told I am getting a Promotion

in my current job. How much raise in my Salary, can I expect ?

 

2) When a native comes and say: I was told I am getting some

performance based bonus/reward. How much money can I expect ?

 

May I reqeust you to please teach me or provide me or point me to

some references where I can find some numerical calculations to

derive the answers such as follows to the above questions:-

 

Answer to Q.1) You will get 6 % pay raise

Answer to Q.2) You will get US$ 2500 as a bonus / reward for your

hard work.

 

As you know I go very focused to find answers, so please guide me to

get the answers to the above using " Prashna based Methods " ONLY.

 

You may write in the list or if you choose to write to me privately,

that is fine too. Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Swee Ji,

 

Looks like, you did not get a chance to see my last message on this

thread.

What was the math you have applied to arrive at the numerical value

of 8%. Please eloborate as I am interested in such calculations

always and you may recollect, that was my question to begin with for

this thread.

 

You may refer the following messages on this regard.

 

sohamsa/message/3836

sohamsa/message/3831

 

If any one has understood how did Swee Ji had arrived at 8% based on

her above message, then please eloborate for me. As I wanted to close

this question from my pending list (once I get this calculation) and

move forward, otherwise I am stuck here.

 

Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

sohamsa , " Swee Chan " <swee wrote:

" Swee Chan " <swee

Wed Feb 15, 2006 8:37 am

RE: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

Jaya Jagannatha

 

Dear Bharat,

 

Namaste

 

 

 

Ah, I missed this part of the question. Anyway, you have not

considered the dagdha rasis, which are the 4th and the 11th houses.

Venus is both an avayogi and a yogi planet. Jupiter is in Bhojana

avastha and Venus is in Jalapana avastha. He might need to negotiate

for better as he will not be happy with what is being offered. Note

that Venus is also in 11th from AL in rasi drishti with GL and HL, in

bhagya sthana. But the AV of Venus in the 11th from AL is slightly

better off than AL. the 12th from AL indicates that he will not lose

out anyway, with the 2nd from AL with higher points than the AL.

 

Taking the averages of the points between the 11th from AL and AL

itself, it equates to almost 8% increase.

 

 

 

Raghunatha, please let us know the outcome.

 

 

 

Love,

 

Swee

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...
Guest guest

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Swee Ji and Bharat Ji,

 

Swee Ji you have predicted 8%and Bharat Ji you have predicted 10%. I

have predicted 13.5 %. We are all wrong as the actual number is 12%

which I got Y'day ( March 7th 2006) at about 12:45 PM.

 

Now may I request both of you to look at your prashna chart and the

principles you have applied and do the postmortem and see if you can

fine tune the principles and write to us

 

So that I will take this as an exercise and try applying these

principles for future prashnas accordingly.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

sohamsa , Bharat Hindu Astrology

<hinduastrology wrote:

 

Namaskaar Sri Swee

 

Very nice analysis.

 

My hope is still rested on 10% or above as the Ascendant rises in

Yogi Point. A very powerful combination. I must say Sri Raghunatha

has engaged us in an absorbing exercise.

 

Thanks and Regards

Bharat

 

 

On 2/15/06, Swee Chan <swee wrote:

Jaya Jagannatha

 

Dear Bharat,

 

Namaste

 

Ah, I missed this part of the question. Anyway, you have not

considered the dagdha rasis, which are the 4th and the 11th houses.

Venus is both an avayogi and a yogi planet. Jupiter is in Bhojana

avastha and Venus is in Jalapana avastha. He might need to negotiate

for better as he will not be happy with what is being offered. Note

that Venus is also in 11th from AL in rasi drishti with GL and HL, in

bhagya sthana. But the AV of Venus in the 11th from AL is slightly

better off than AL. the 12th from AL indicates that he will not lose

out anyway, with the 2nd from AL with higher points than the AL.

 

Taking the averages of the points between the 11th from AL and AL

itself, it equates to almost 8% increase.

 

Raghunatha, please let us know the outcome.

 

Love,

 

Swee

 

----

 

sohamsa [ sohamsa ] On

Behalf Of Bharat Hindu Astrology

Thursday, February 16, 2006 3:58 AM

sohamsa

Re: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

Namaskaar Sri Raghunatha

 

I am attempting this question:

It looks like to be more than expected. I would say this figure would

be 10% or above.

I have taken the particulars of Feb 15, 2006 23:17 hrs at New Delhi

 

Reasoning:

The Yogi for the chart is Rahu and the Yogi point is in Swati and it

is likely to prosper. The lagna rises in Swati.Venus is avayogi but

it is also the duplicate yogi and will offer results of prosperity

too.

 

The dasha on March 1 will be Sun-Rahu-Venus-Venus-Jupiter. You see

Rahu and Venus are deeply involved and Jupiter is in the lagna too.

Rahu gives more than expected as it is in the nakshatra of a

yogakaraka graha.

 

Even if the above turns out to be true, it might just be a fluke

case. We will need to apply principles on charts again and again and

check what would work and what would not.

 

Do let me know how it comes about.

 

Thanks and Regards

Bharat

 

----- original message ----

 

On 2/15/06, Raghunatha RaoNemani <raon1008 wrote:

 

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Visti Ji,

 

Thanks for the note. I have read both of them and could not figure

out the numerical method yet. May be you can help me with an

example. Let us take a practical case. I was one of those high

performers in my organization for the year 2005. As a result of that

I was told this week, I will be given an Award/Bonus in March 1st/2nd

week.

 

May I request you to cast a Prashna and tell me what would be the

percentage of bonus I get in March 1st/2nd week. Based on my role as

a Manager, I could be given a award anywhere between 1% and 15 %.

 

When you give your reply, please eloborate the process so that I can

learn from your anlaysis. If you prefer to write to me privately,

please do so, as my intension was to learn this method. I would like

to use the Prashna Method only for this exercise.

 

Thanks for your help in advance.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Om Krishna Guru

 

Namaste Bharat Ji and Swee Ji,

 

Thanks for the note. Lately I am struggling to get the precision

rather than I am close or closer to the actual events,which I use to

be happier some time ago. So if you are happy about being close to

the actual % that is perfectly fine. In my opinion, I need to learn

or find the finer method to get the accurate method.

 

Bharat Ji, I have also used the Prashna with the AshtakaVarga

calculations to find the value, but failed too. I have not found any

precise principles using Ashtakavarga, but appllied some random

thoughts, hence I do not have any method either.

 

So I/we need guidnace in getting there.

 

Regards

Raghunatha Rao

 

 

sohamsa , " Swee Chan " <swee wrote:

" Swee Chan " <swee

Tue Mar 7, 2006 7:01 am

RE: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

Congratulations Bharat, you came closest! I think what we've both

done is to over look the pairs of yoga makers which are the trinal

lords to YP Venus' nakshatra.

 

Love,

 

Swee

---------

 

sohamsa [sohamsa ] On

Behalf Of Bharat Hindu Astrology

Tuesday, March 07, 2006 2:45 PM

sohamsa

Re: Re: Question on Prashna Shastra

 

Namaskaar Sri Raghunatha

 

Thank you for telling us the result.

 

I had actually predicted this :

" It looks like to be more than expected. I would say this figure

would be 10% or above. " and I had given the estimation as under:

 

" Unfortunately there is no mathematical calculation to arrive at a

particular value, atleast in my mind. What I understood was that the

result would be on the higher side. You have given the limit of 1% to

15%, so I choose 67% (10/15). The reason why I did not choose 14 or

15% is that Venus is also an Avayogi and is capable of lowering the

value. This is what we need to check, if our estimation is correct or

not - assuming the logic used is correct. "

 

So kindly give me credit for saying something right! Atleast it is

over 10%. Now we need to fill the gap of 2%, which I feel can only

come by applying the same again and again over a few hundred charts.

 

How did you arrive at 13.5% and by what mathematical and astrological

principles?

 

Thanks and Regards

Bharat

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...