[Jagannath] CASE STUDY NOW

[Guest guest]

Pranaam Sanjay,

 

> > No chart works in isolation. All the charts together make a person

> > what (s)he is.

>

> RATH: ALL THE CHARTS WILL WORK PERFECTLY. IN FACT ALL OF THEM WILL

GIVE

> EXCELLENT ANSWERS TO THE QUESTIONS, BUT YOU CANNOT IGNORE ONE CHART

AND THAT

> TOO A PRIMARY CHART AND SAY THAT THIS WILL SHOW UP ELSEWHERE. D-24 IS

FOR

> SIDDI AND THAT MEANS THE EFFORTS FOR ADDITIONAL KNOWLEDGE AND

LEARNING THAT

> IS TAUGHT WILL SHOW UP OUT HERE. IT DOES NOT GO INTO THE INHERENT

ABILITIES

> TO LEARN SOMETHING OR ONES INNER NATURE. BOTH PARASARA AND JAIMINI

HAVE

> GIVEN UMPTEEN DICTUMS FOR THESE INNATE ABILITIES FROM THE NAVAMSA.

WHY DID

> JAIMINI OR PARASARA SAY THAT SATURN IN TRINES WILL GIVE ONE SKILLED IN

> TRADITIONAL LORE OR JUPITER IN TRINES WOULD GIVE WIDE BASED KNOWLEDGE

IF

> NAVAMSA HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH IT. WHAT YOU ARE SUGGESTING IS AGAINST

WHAT

> IS TAUGHT BY THESE MAHARISHI'S.

 

If one's skills are seen only from navamsa, why did

Parasara say that Bhamsa is the chart of strengths

and weaknesses? If one's wide-based learning can be

confidently concluded from navamsa, why did Parasara

prescribe Siddhamsa for learning and knowledge?

 

My basic point is that Jupiter in 8th in navamsa can

give different results based on his position in D-1,

D-24, D-27 etc.

 

> > With Taurus lagna, Sun is in a trine.

>

> RATH: YOUR MOON IN THE THIRD IS MORE CORRECT FOR YOUR POETRY AND

SONGS.

 

With Ta lagna, Moon will be the ruler of 3rd and he

joins Venus. I can still be into poetry.

 

Irrespective of lagna in navamsa, actually there is

a rule in Saravali that says that Moon in Mercury's

navamsa and conjoined/aspected by Venus makes one a

poet and musician.

 

In my case, Moon is in Gemini with Venus. So both

Ar and Ta lagnas are fine for explaining poetry and

music.

 

> RATH: OK LET US AGREE TO KEEP THIS CHART ASIDE FOR A WHILE. THIS WILL

TAKE

> SOME MORE DELIBERATION AND ALL JYOTISHA CAN EASILY SEE HOW DIFFICULT

IT IS

> TO CORRECT A CHART AS THERE ARE TOO MANY METHODS AND FACTS AND

OPTIONS. WE

> SHALL COME BACK TO THIS LATER.

 

Let it be as you wish. I will be interested in

listening to how you explain my D-24 based events

and D-20 based ones.

 

> I AM MAILING A CASE STUDY OF THE CHART OF A PROSTITUTE, A LADY WHOSE

LIFE IS

> THE DARKEST THAT CAN EVER BE. I HOPE ALL JYOTISHA SHALL COMMENT ON

THE RASI

> AND NAVAMSA.

 

I will answer later.

 

Your sishya,

Narasimha