My experiences ............

[Guest guest]

Dear Naveen, If you have a good experience of Naadi , why dont you share with group members, which would be benefial to all. Nobody said they are not ready to listen. Others have mixed experience hence they are sharing. Regards Naveen Vidyarthi <naveenvidyarthi wrote: Thanks Mr. Madhusudan for your reply. I am relatively new to Naadi and also to this group. My expereince with Naadi has been good so far and as far as I am concerned, from

your reply, it has been made clear to me that this is not the group that I am looking for. Regards.madhusudan sadagopan <madhusudan01 > wrote: Thank you mr Rohit, mr Sunny and "aries".That is exactly the purpose of this forum - to share experiences and your two paisa contribution can save thousands of rupees and avoid causing mental agony to a seeker.I agree questions like ‘does rishi mentioned amount of money’ looks silly, however .. The question is very apt. The rates changes so fast as

experienced by mr Sunny. We really need to know the truth behind this. May be tax doesn’t apply to them as they serving the public and passing the information from the Great Maharishis to the general public.True service is selfless service ... nadi readers are getting in return name, fame and money. Not that iam against the naadi reader to be economically well established, i just dont like cheats and liars. Just wonder, through all these visits, have you people ever thought of asking the Naadi readers, about the authenticity of leaf, as you were finding it everywhere.I went to two places and found that the content itself was enough to judge the authenticity of the leaf. I was doing a mantra and

the sage correctly indentified it. I was fortunate to know the genuine ones but there are many others who have not. They need to be vigilant and well informed. They also told me that the original is not with them but they have the ones which were copied in Tamil a century ago. And they currently have only one hundred bundles left with them. I am giving below my thoughts about various issues/ questions being raised in this forum which lose their relevance due to repititions. To start with: "Do rishis prescribe only remedies or amount of money also? Do Naadi readers pay taxes?", etc. Without any prejudice to anyone, let each of us ask

ourselves: What is this forum about?Allow members to share experiences and discuss issues related to naadi astrology. a) To my mind it is to add value to the thought process of each member. To raise our thinking to a higher level than the existing level and perhaps do some philosophical thinking as to how the ancient rishis could enable themselves to do such kind of accurate/ not so accurate (debatable) predictions. Was there any technology or science behind it or were they endowed with Divine powers?Nobody is competent to question the abilities of our sages. We are not even discussing about it, so why bring it up?b) Take benefit of the "so much research" that Wg Cdr Oak and Inderjeet Sahni ji or other members of the group have done so that not all

of us have to undergo this kind of rigour again. To a considerable extent this is being achieved. And all these benefits which we are reaping with the efforts of Wg Cdr Oak and other experienced members of the group, are with zero/ minimum investments of the young / new members.Do not judge people's experience on the basis of the number of the post they make or their age etc. Every member has contributed when he/she signs into this forum, they have invested their time in sharing, learning and passing the info posted here.Should we really be bothered about whether rishis prescribed the money or not? I do not think that Naadi reading is hobby of any Naadi reader as much as medicine or surgery is the hobby of a doctor. Exceptions and extreme cases are there. We do not wish to generalise by taking extreme cases. A millionaire who is not in need of money may make medicine/ surgery/

Naadi reading his or her passion. Those cases are one in lacs/ millions. If a Naadi reader charges Rs.1000/- for general kandam, he is dedicating his time and resources for that. For which he must have spent years gaining that kind of experience. Moreover a Naadi centre is not being run by one person or on Govt. grants. Many people (at least 3-4) support one Naadi centre. I would say Rs.1000 is still cheap. At least there is a higher probability of finding the truth about oneself rather than go to quack astrolgers and end up with no results. If Naadi reading is offered for free, perhaps many of us will start doubting the efficacy of the Naadi centre and start doubting as to how are these people running the centre. Is there some political angle behind it? There must be some ulterior motive and may be these guys will ask us to shell out more money during pujas, etc. Or perhaps we would have stood in queue to get our turn after 3-4 years (being free) and perhaps

govt. would have made amendments in issuing visas to Chinese or American or Europeans to restrict the no. of people entering India.For u 1000 rs may mean nothing that does not apply to the general public. You may not be bothered why the sages have/have not mentioned but iam definitely concerned about it. If you can provide proof that the sages have mentioned the amount then present it here please. Let us not beat around the bush. We need facts.We say that our rishis said this and that - which means we have full faith in our rishis and we go by their dictum - but when it comes to money we feel our rishis were not capable enough to predict the inflation rates in India or recession in the US. When we hear our names being taken out of Naadi leaves, we feel - Oh a miracle! But why is he charging me for a miracle which some rishi had predicted. This is wrong and unjustified because that time value of money was 1/hundred thousand of the value of money now. I can't pay this much for this miracle because the Naadi leaf is not the original one.But here we are not talking about the reading when it comes true. The difficulty is when it does not. People have paid more than asked because many things came right.What about the people who have

been cheated? Try to visualize the agony of a person seeking answers for his problem and is cheated by a naadi reader. The idea is to flush out the fake ones and identify the genuine ones. Lets show empathy here for those people and help with info which can prevent fraud.This is what we must seek from this group and not frivolous facts like X charged this much, he is a fraud and Y charged this much, he is good. (Sure we must be cautious and such information sharing can alert group members). I pay taxes but Naadi centres do not pay taxes. Should we be concerned about these issues? I do not think we should be because Naadi readers do not make predictions about us whether we should be paying taxes or not and they do not put to misuse any information in the predictions that they read for us. They are rendering services to general public and these services are not regulated, for which they charge

varying amounts. Since these services are not regulated, we also have the right to negotiate the price with them. Not paying tax is a crime , u know it i know it and our esteemed members know about it.Paying taxes makes you accountable before the law. If the seeker has registered an office(naadi) , he has to maintain records and provide provide bills.If the reading is incorrect or way off the seeker can approach the court and prosecute the reader for fraud on the basis of the bill.Now they dont give bill because they dont pay taxes. Tax department at one particular of time will focus its attention on the naadi readers, like it or not.I feel we should focus on larger issues where we can advance the knowledge of this group. You are right ! Start a topic and

contribute.Regards,ms Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Mobile. Try it now. Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Mobile. Try it now.

Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Mobile. Try it now.