2-Rohini_ & All: .....re: Digest Number 4040, #7 Why does Astrology work?

[Guest guest]

8b.

 

Re: 2-Roini_ranjan re: Digest Number 4040, #7 " Why

does Astrology work

 

 

 

 

Posted by: " Rohiniranjan "

rohini_ranjan rohinicrystal

Thu

Nov 13, 2008 3:31 pm (PST)

Dear Marc, Thank you for taking so much time to write your

long response. It was a pity that for some reason the formatting

came through in such a way that it was difficult to follow

easily

Dear Rohini:

So sorry to hear that. I'm sending a response here, via the group

instead. Hopefully that'll be better.

However

the bulk of your writing seemed to be addressing the question,

" Does jyotish work? " . That was never the question or

issue. We all know that already and even after a few years of

sincere study that becomes very apparent. That is why people stay

with jyotish as long as 22 years in your case and even longer in

many other cases :-) That said, there was a somewhat confusing

piece which I quote below:

 

 

" Now, 38 years of meditation and 22 years of practicing Jyotish

have > improved my Moon so much I can't even recognize myself. > > I'm > not that shy, overly sensitive,

vulnerable person emotionally! > > Our charts do fit

us. " I am sure you would notice the controversy in

your presentation! On the one hand you are saying that people do

fit their classical chart description but at the same time you are

saying that people can change with remedies, yoga, meditation

etc.

 

 

What I was trying to give expression to here was the fact that #1

Our charts really do fit us. So, my chart when I was

young really did fit the classic descriptions of the malefic ness of

my Moon. On the other hand, astrology is also about

self-development and self-improvement. Therefore,

practicing Yogic and meditation remedies and then 22 years of Jyotish,

literally changed by chart! And this is my point. Not only our charts about our beginnings but about how and where

we're supposed to improve ourselves, If we don't do

Jyotish remedies then we will very likely repeat the gloom and doom of our

original birth charts. But, predictions for me, based on

my original birth chart do not affect me nearly as negatively as in the

past.

By that what I

am understanding is that people can change, despite

what

their classical chart descriptions indicate! A shy person's

birthchart will not change but he or she can outgrow the shyness that would be the classical description for the chart! Yes. sort

of. We can change any of the malefic situations in our charts.

A so-called shy person's birth chart will not change, on paper,

but their chart inside; or their nervous system, their personality,

mind set, even emotional nature can improve! I

think that is the general assumption and hope of such groups like Jyotish

Remedies here.

But

thanks for trying to address the issue that is certainly not

easy...! Best wishes, RR You're very

welcome. It's not only difficult to describe because the whole, most

recent history of Jyotish like other vedic sciences is riddled with too

much fatalism. My Guru, in fact, used to say:

" If Jyotish was only about predicting the dangers on the horizon,

then it might be better to not know what was coming. " Therefore, astrology is all about helping us change our trends of time

and becoming the un-developed person that's there inside of our charts.

 

Sincerely, Mark Kincaid Nature's Astrology www..com

(Temporarily under re-construction)

/