Mars Dosha in KP

September 13, 2008

Dear Friends,

For those members who are interested in Mars Dosha in KP like K.S.V.

Ramani, an opinion and a collection of different views are given below

(as in the case of counting 2nd, 3rd wives etc.)

Regards,

tw

Msg#15445/14045/14033/14028/14021/11144/11138/11132/10694/10689/10688/10686/1068\

3/10680/10678/10677/8398/8386/5237/1317/1317/1311/1303

" Analysis of Mars Dosha as per KP Principles.doc

Mars Dosha and Marriage in KP " (in File section)

Message #15375

Dear All,

Mars Dosha is not valid in KP on the basis of the following reasons:

1) KP Reader IV page 69: " To cause difference of opinion,

disagreement, dispute, divorce etc. among the couple it is not left

to Mars alone, any planet can cause such undesirable effect provided

they happen to be deposited in such a position, that the sublord of

the planet is the significator of 6 or 10 or 12 or the sublord is

deposited in a constellation, the lord of which is the significator

of 6 or 10 or 12 " .

2) N. Sarangan quoted the above statement in his article " Mars Dosha-

A Myth " (KP & Astrology Year Book 2002, page 48) to conclude that

the traditional ideas about Mars Dosha are meaningless without

taking into consideration of the beneficial aspects received by Mars

from other planets, its stellar position etc, and Mars Dosha does

not suit our modern age.

3) KP Reader VI page 319: " Prof. Krishnamurti says that when a house

is in fire, we throw water and send. " does not agree with suggestion

for a native with Mars Dosha to marry with another one with Mars

Dosha like adding more fire to a house which is already in fire.

4) Astrosecrets & KP, Part 1 (Sri Shanmugam}: Regarding Mars Dosha,

naturally, each one will have their own say according to their whims

and fancies, and due to this it is the general public pushed to run

from pillar to post.....In several ways a prediction is given which

has neither clarity nor a systematic approach etc. Finally it is the

public who suffers.

5) Shri Raichur has found in a study on the TOB AA- rated 100

foreign born charts of multi-marriages Kanak had used for the Multi-

marriage study that no Marsl Dosha in 52 charts, mitigated Dosha in

38 charts and unmitigated Dosha in 10 charts, ie.10% only.

6) In the study on " Analysis of Mars Dosa as per KP Principles " by

Kanak and Rangarajan in the `file section' of this Group, the 11

rules of Mars Dosha have been tested for the TOB AA-rated 103 single

marriage charts and 69 multi-marriage charts. Only the 2nd rule

of " Any planet deposited in the star or sub of Mars, and occupying

1, 2, 4, 7, 8 or 12 " is significant for 47 (46%) single-marriage

charts and for 34 (49%) multi-marriage charts, indicating Mars Dosha

has nothing to do with single or multi marriage.

7) No other attention has been given in the KP literature.

Any `particular' experience of learned members will be helpful for

KP lovers.

Regards,

tw

September 14, 2008

Dear Mr.Tin Winji,

Many thanks for your promp reply on the subject. It seems that in Vedic Astro., undue importance is given to Doshas

threatening clients with the result that parents may loose

good alliances.

With regards, Astrologically yours,

K.S.V.Ramani

-

tw853

Saturday, September 13, 2008 9:39 AM

Mars Dosha in KP

Dear Friends,For those members who are interested in Mars Dosha in KP like K.S.V.Ramani, an opinion and a collection of different views are given below(as in the case of counting 2nd, 3rd wives etc.)Regards,tw Msg#15445/14045/14033/14028/14021/11144/11138/11132/10694/10689/10688/10686/10683/10680/10678/10677/8398/8386/5237/1317/1317/1311/1303"Analysis of Mars Dosha as per KP Principles.doc Mars Dosha and Marriage in KP" (in File section)Message #15375 Dear All,Mars Dosha is not valid in KP on the basis of the following reasons:1) KP Reader IV page 69: "To cause difference of opinion,disagreement, dispute, divorce etc. among the couple it is not leftto Mars alone, any planet can cause such undesirable effect providedthey happen to be deposited in such a position, that the sublord ofthe planet is the significator of 6 or 10 or 12 or the sublord isdeposited in a constellation, the lord of which is the significatorof 6 or 10 or 12".2) N. Sarangan quoted the above statement in his article "Mars Dosha-A Myth" (KP & Astrology Year Book 2002, page 48) to conclude thatthe traditional ideas about Mars Dosha are meaningless withouttaking into consideration of the beneficial aspects received by Marsfrom other planets, its stellar position etc, and Mars Dosha doesnot suit our modern age.3) KP Reader VI page 319: "Prof. Krishnamurti says that when a houseis in fire, we throw water and send." does not agree with suggestionfor a native with Mars Dosha to marry with another one with MarsDosha like adding more fire to a house which is already in fire.4) Astrosecrets & KP, Part 1 (Sri Shanmugam}: Regarding Mars Dosha,naturally, each one will have their own say according to their whimsand fancies, and due to this it is the general public pushed to runfrom pillar to post.....In several ways a prediction is given whichhas neither clarity nor a systematic approach etc. Finally it is thepublic who suffers.5) Shri Raichur has found in a study on the TOB AA- rated 100foreign born charts of multi-marriages Kanak had used for the Multi-marriage study that no Marsl Dosha in 52 charts, mitigated Dosha in38 charts and unmitigated Dosha in 10 charts, ie.10% only.6) In the study on "Analysis of Mars Dosa as per KP Principles" byKanak and Rangarajan in the `file section' of this Group, the 11rules of Mars Dosha have been tested for the TOB AA-rated 103 singlemarriage charts and 69 multi-marriage charts. Only the 2nd ruleof "Any planet deposited in the star or sub of Mars, and occupying1, 2, 4, 7, 8 or 12" is significant for 47 (46%) single-marriagecharts and for 34 (49%) multi-marriage charts, indicating Mars Doshahas nothing to do with single or multi marriage.7) No other attention has been given in the KP literature.Any `particular' experience of learned members will be helpful forKP lovers.Regards,tw