Books Karaka Quiz Answer 2

November 12, 2008

Om Datta Guru

Pranam

Ofcourse i was to post the much bigger post but in installments as i had

mentioned in my reply to ur private mail that i would not get involved

in discussions as it consumes time now esp when work - jyotish cum

office is upto the neck due to deadlines.

Now the Reason for Posting the query in the first place.

How does one see a kundali and predict that books would become the

reason for a persons marital harmony and also to the extent of husband

wife seperating.

Its evening time and you receive frantic call from friend begging you to

take his books, and its the same books he would not part earlier to u,

he wants you to come and take minimum 400 books from his house, u ignore

it and then he calls everyday finally on the 5th day he spills the beans

that i should come now only otherwise his wife has decided to throw him

out of the house. In short i took some books, others i drove to Nashik

with him and donated some books to a jyotish organisation there. His

collection was envious, while coming back he is so adamant that he says

that he still wants to retain some 200 books which are remaining at home

(out of 2000) and if his wife and daughter do not allow then he is going

to throw them out of the house, wants me to come and intervene. So far i

have not had the opportunity to intervene.

Prediction By Gujurat Astrologer: Books will decide his marital harmony,

i remembered this prediction given to me.

The above is Chart 2 & the prediction to be given on this chart is not

how many books or writer but what role this books will play in his

family life, daughter does not speak to him, wife etc

Chart 1: Predicting person will have books is half story, the real story

is 'You would have lot of books akin to a library and one day your wife

would give ultimatum and when you shift to smaller house you will let go

of it'. This how to see in chart i dont know hence i asked query.

Prediction By Near Delhi Astrologer: This astrologer is now dead and he

was approached by Chart 1 on when his bhagya will rise, he said 'Jaa

tere kitab mein demakh hain usko pehla teekh kar phir sab theek hojaye

ga'. In english it means 'Go, there is white ants in your books first

rectify that problem then your luck will rise'. This is a stunning

prediction & then it was told to him 'These books will go away, others

will use it and make illegal money out of it'. The gentleman of Chart 1

had to let go of his books due to wife & house restrictions etc and now

the books he donated, a famous company in Delhi sells it Photocopied

copies of it for Rs 1000 to Rs 5000 ($100) - just photocopies

Chart 3: Prediction by Gujurat Astrologer, Kala Aksar Bhais Barabar -

now use this in our context, i am sorry i tried translating that in

english but somehow not getting right meaning, basically it means man

does not read (in our context) so what books are u talking Sunil is my

Gujurat Astrologer told me.

When i embarked on this quest I obviously did not post on the net first

i called my Varanasi contacts and other giants in India but could not

get satisfactory answer, so i thought maybe one way to start searching

is to find out what classics hint on karaka and house of books and hence

posted on the list. I just wanted help on classical quote which would be

just one line and nothing else but it seems this thread went on its own

to prove that we all (including me) can theorise a lot but when it comes

to predictions on such charts i atleast cannot make the prediction that

is required to be made which is ' Books will become the reason for your

marital discord' or as in the case of another chart 'Either you come

home or bring your books' - what a father said to his son.

best wishes

Sunil John

November 12, 2008

Dear Sunil,

The story is good and I admire the reading of the astrologer,

But your placing the chart in the way you enquired and posted was wrong.

It is easy to see if you look at 7th lord afflicted heavily by Mars who is

disposing Mercury.

Mars is afflicting to 7th to asc and 7th to Mars.

Another is look at fight in Jupiter and Venus in the house of Mercury in

which Venus is winner having higher latitude.

Disposing Mercury in the fourth showing a library of books.

This combination make me to write that he is an Astrologer and his 3rd

cusp strength relation with Mercury made me to write that he is a good

writer.

Double check with this man, he may had not written a single book , but he

is a good orator and writer both.

He is basically Venus type , because Moon the ascendant occupant and sub

lord had Venus relation, but every thing is transferred to Mars and that is

causing great affliction to this chart and 7th in particular.

Now trace the books in it.

These are in Mercury.

Again in the 2nd case, the logic you can apply even to the 1st chart and the

list members can trace that which house is the maximum afflicted.

12th lord Venus in the 9th , 6th lord aspect to 9th and 8th lord

depositor Venus in 9th further sandwiching Mercury retrograde dispositor

of Ketu (significator of ants ) in 9th.

So why at all you need the explanation , I could not understand.

The significator surfaced again is Mercury.

By his sub lord Saturn I judged this being a Technocrat and as the ongoing

talk was Books , it can be a Press person , But Saturn in air sign and

connected with fiary Rahu , had given him connection with Air and Fire.

In the 3rd case , I look only a person of lower category who will show up

to the persons hollows in themselves, and just to show off can have gadgets

, books every thing having no knowledge at all , so my refusal to comment

on this chart. But as you had written now I was correct in my assumptions .

With the revelation of your story , I am most satisfied with my writings .

With Best Wishes,

Inder Jit Sahni

On

Behalf Of suniljohn_2002

Wednesday, November 12, 2008 11:49 AM