Guest guest Posted December 22, 2007 Report Share Posted December 22, 2007 About ayanamsa to be used....i request members to kindly clarify this doubt in my mind.... why this confusion in jyotish still....because using different ayanamsas sometimes changes the houses and navamsas and this should clearly decide which one is correct. It would be interesting to know the experiences of members in this regard. Also with all the modern technology available ..... why this problem of fixing the date when the two zodiacs coincided!! and thereby the ayanamsa value. Also how were horoscopes cast in the ancient times till the recent past. They would not have known about latitudes and longitudes or about the accurate value of ayanamsas for that matter. I would greatly appreciate the thoughts of members of this group on this subject. Thank you Prad Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2007 Report Share Posted December 22, 2007 Dear Which ever calander u follow,events of particular date remain the same.OR which ever religion u follow to understand the GOD. GOD remains the same and one. Only u follow different approachs to understand the almighty All Ayanamsh given by N.C.LAHIRI, B.V. RAMAN AND Krishnammurthy are correct but there are two conditions 1)follow only one at particular time for giving predictions 2)Don't apply rules of one into another. We follow lagan chart for prediction but our Bhaskarji follow Chalit chart. I have given my opinion but still i want to hear from others. Thanks Dhananjay , " Prad " <psd1955 wrote: > > About ayanamsa to be used....i request members to kindly clarify this > doubt in my mind.... > why this confusion in jyotish still....because using different > ayanamsas sometimes changes the houses and navamsas and this should > clearly decide which one is correct. > It would be interesting to know the experiences of members in this > regard. > Also with all the modern technology available ..... why this problem > of fixing the date when the two zodiacs coincided!! and thereby the > ayanamsa value. > > Also how were horoscopes cast in the ancient times till the recent > past. They would not have known about latitudes and longitudes or > about the accurate value of ayanamsas for that matter. > I would greatly appreciate the thoughts of members of this group on > this subject. > Thank you > Prad > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2007 Report Share Posted December 22, 2007 Dear Dhananjay ji, It would be difficult to better your reply. best regards, Bhaskar. , " gupta089 " <gupta089 wrote: > > Dear > Which ever calander u follow,events of particular date remain > the same.OR > which ever religion u follow to understand the GOD. GOD > remains the same and one. Only u follow different approachs > to understand the almighty > > All Ayanamsh given by N.C.LAHIRI, B.V. RAMAN AND Krishnammurthy > are correct but there are two conditions > 1)follow only one at particular time for giving predictions > 2)Don't apply rules of one into another. > > We follow lagan chart for prediction but our Bhaskarji follow > Chalit chart. > I have given my opinion but still i want to hear from others. > > Thanks > Dhananjay > > , " Prad " <psd1955@> wrote: > > > > About ayanamsa to be used....i request members to kindly clarify > this > > doubt in my mind.... > > why this confusion in jyotish still....because using different > > ayanamsas sometimes changes the houses and navamsas and this should > > clearly decide which one is correct. > > It would be interesting to know the experiences of members in this > > regard. > > Also with all the modern technology available ..... why this problem > > of fixing the date when the two zodiacs coincided!! and thereby the > > ayanamsa value. > > > > Also how were horoscopes cast in the ancient times till the recent > > past. They would not have known about latitudes and longitudes or > > about the accurate value of ayanamsas for that matter. > > I would greatly appreciate the thoughts of members of this group on > > this subject. > > Thank you > > Prad > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2007 Report Share Posted December 22, 2007 Dear Prad, Ayanamsha part has been answered by Shri Dhananjayji. The other part. Our ancients had already calculated the distance of the Sun from the earth, as well as the Diameters of the Circumference of the Planets, so what great feat was it for them to calculate the longitudes and the latitudes for the places in a small country comparatively, India. Aynamsha difference is not fixing the dates of Zodiac more than the belief in same, which causes the difference. If it was so easy through Science, then all ayanasmha versions would have vanished, and only one remained. The when of the Aries point shifting, is the point of contention where Science has not been able to help uptil now. How could ancients live for 1000 years in treat Yugas or for 200 -300 years in subseqnet yugas, or why in future man would mature by age of 10 and be dead by 20, is all matter of many speculations, and does not help us, in the present. Same way we can write 100 pages on the Why and How of ancient ways of making charts and calculating the astronomical positions of the planets, but this is good time utilisation for one who has spare time at hand. best wishes, Bhaskar. , " Prad " <psd1955 wrote: > > About ayanamsa to be used....i request members to kindly clarify this > doubt in my mind.... > why this confusion in jyotish still....because using different > ayanamsas sometimes changes the houses and navamsas and this should > clearly decide which one is correct. > It would be interesting to know the experiences of members in this > regard. > Also with all the modern technology available ..... why this problem > of fixing the date when the two zodiacs coincided!! and thereby the > ayanamsa value. > > Also how were horoscopes cast in the ancient times till the recent > past. They would not have known about latitudes and longitudes or > about the accurate value of ayanamsas for that matter. > I would greatly appreciate the thoughts of members of this group on > this subject. > Thank you > Prad > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2007 Report Share Posted December 23, 2007 Bhaskar ji Thankyou very much. I have just written what came in my mind. Any good or bad qualities of a person present in him, is due to his planatery combinations. And u know, how lord Krishna was able to beautifully explain different aspects of various yogas in Gita to Arjun when he was in state of confusion.This was also due to certain planetary combination present in Krishna's Horoscope. His 2nd house lord ie. house of speech was present in 5th house ie. house of intelligence.And this lord is no other planet then mercury - planet of intellect, exalted in fifth house .His lagna was Vrishabha I also have similar combination but my lagna is leo with mercury placed in fifth and exalted in navamsa. And u know i am also running Rahu mahadasa. Thanks and Regards Dhananjay , " Bhaskar " <bhaskar_jyotish wrote: > > Dear Prad, > > Ayanamsha part has been answered by Shri Dhananjayji. > The other part. > Our ancients had already calculated the distance of > the Sun from the earth, as well as the Diameters of the > Circumference of the Planets, so what great feat was it > for them to calculate the longitudes and the latitudes > for the places in a small country comparatively, India. > > Aynamsha difference is not fixing the dates of Zodiac > more than the belief in same, which causes the difference. > If it was so easy through Science, then all ayanasmha > versions would have vanished, and only one remained. > The when of the Aries point shifting, is the point of > contention where Science has not been able to help > uptil now. > > How could ancients live for 1000 years in treat Yugas > or for 200 -300 years in subseqnet yugas, or why in > future man would mature by age of 10 and be dead by > 20, is all matter of many speculations, and does not help > us, in the present. Same way we can write 100 pages > on the Why and How of ancient ways of making charts and > calculating the astronomical positions of the planets, > but this is good time utilisation for one who has spare > time at hand. > > best wishes, > Bhaskar. > > > > , " Prad " <psd1955@> wrote: > > > > About ayanamsa to be used....i request members to kindly clarify > this > > doubt in my mind.... > > why this confusion in jyotish still....because using different > > ayanamsas sometimes changes the houses and navamsas and this should > > clearly decide which one is correct. > > It would be interesting to know the experiences of members in this > > regard. > > Also with all the modern technology available ..... why this > problem > > of fixing the date when the two zodiacs coincided!! and thereby the > > ayanamsa value. > > > > Also how were horoscopes cast in the ancient times till the recent > > past. They would not have known about latitudes and longitudes or > > about the accurate value of ayanamsas for that matter. > > I would greatly appreciate the thoughts of members of this group on > > this subject. > > Thank you > > Prad > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2007 Report Share Posted December 23, 2007 Dear Bhaskarji and Dhananjayji, Thank you so much for your kindness in throwing more light on these concepts....and taking the trouble to explain them with such patience. Thank you once again. Prad Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.