Guest guest Posted March 3, 2008 Report Share Posted March 3, 2008 Shri Rao Sahib, Under the same very impression I too wasted my time to answer your mail. Initially I thought that your are some scholar and keen to know the truth. But your wicked slang and gauche way of challenging everybody revealed everything. You always accused us of using " you pat my back and I pat yours " method. Rao Sahib you are absolutely wrong. Admiring someone is certainly not " you pat my back and I pat yours " . I admire Late Krishnamurty ji - does that means he too was a roadside fortune teller? Or by admiring him I became a one? You admire Krishnamurty ji too - are you a roadside fortune teller or he was? I feel really sorry for a person like you who claims to have 57 years experience of astrology. See another example of your 57 years experience, Instead of trying to know the truth, you daringly pointed your finger towards Dr. Amar Aggarwal jee. Why dont you call that guy whose contact number has been provided by Dr. Sahib? What are you afraid of? what is stopping you? Dont you have the guts to face the reality or what? Call that guy, know the reality and inform this august forum whether it is true or not. For your kind information the admiration from such a legend like Dr. Aggarwal is just a " Well done " for the correct and bold statements. Otherwise, he " dusted " me like hell on many occasions whenever I was wrong. Everybody knows who is throwing Mud. Dont expect that you will continue spitting venom against the holy scripture and we will be the silent spectators. You called Lal Kitab a Hoax, you called one of us a Quack, you termed us like Roadside fortune tellers, you accused us of our ignorance regarding Raja Harishchandra & Shakuntala legend and what not. It clearly shows that you are suffering from a very dangerous disease called Khush-Fehmee, unfortunately it is incurable, Rao Sahib there is a popular saying in Hindi: " Kutta Paalo, Biili Paalo, Gadha-Ghoda kuch bhi Paalo - Magar Ghalti se bhi kabhi apne deemagh mein Khush-fehmee mat paalo, kyon ki saanp ka kaata to shayad bach bhi jaye, magar khush-fehmee ke maarye admi ko koyee nahi bacha sakta. " Now you are complining that you asked for a good book on Lal Kitab, but no one came forward. Didnt I gave you the full information regarding various editions? Didnt I offered these editions to you in this very forum? Can you deny that? Rao Sahib, We are bounded by one strict instruction of the originator and author of the holy Lal kitab Pt. Rup Chand joshi ji. He advised not to criticize any other stream of knowledge or its scholars to prove the point (which you seems to be very fond of), Otherwise I could have produced proofs where even the analyzes made by your " God of KP " failed miserably and was unable to score even the single digit percentage. But when the case was referred to some Lal Kitab astrologer, the score was more than 90 out of 100. Should I provide you the detail and contact number of those persons to verify the truth? Bhagwan mere sath sath thodi see SadBudhee apko bhi deh. Please take care of your health. Yograj Prabhakar lalkitab , " L.Y.Rao. " <lyrastro1 wrote: > > Mr.Prabhakar, > I took you to be a scholarly person,but it seems that you > and your admirer,Aggarwal,are stooping to levels no better than the > many of the roadside " fortune-tellers " ,atleast that is the impression > you both give from the language and tone of your letters... > While " throwing mud " at everybody who asks you for the > RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...you are actually admitting that either you and > Aggarwal et al,are yourselves just ignorant of it,and instead of making > efforts to FIND OUT THE RATIONALE FOR YOURSELVES..you are both > defending yourselves by indulging in mud-slinging...betraying only your > bankruptcy in good manners as well as any 'knowledge' of Lal Kitab,let > alone any " expert knowledge " but proclaim yourselves to be " experts " > in Lal Kitab...in a " you pat my back and I'll pat yours " manner...! > You both do not seem to have read or even heard about the > Raja Harishchandra & Shakuntala legend and similar stories that abound > in our Puranas...all illustrating the futility of trying to > influence/change Karmic destiny. > NOTHING/NOBODY CAN CHANGE ONE'S KARMIC DESTINY...! ! > That is precisely why I asked you all to recommend a good > book on Lal Kitab...perhaps the book also says that,but not according > to you,I suppose... > I pray to GOD that better sense prevails... > L.Y.Rao. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 2, 2008 Report Share Posted April 2, 2008 Dear L.Y.Rao Ji, Kindly do not waste your time in mud slinging on othjers. If you are desirous of getting new light on Lal Kitab, please read "Lal Kitab, a System of Progression and Curative Measure", by R.S.Chillar. This is a Sagar Publication. If you still have some questions on Lal Kitab, you are most welcome. With best wishes and kind regards. rajchillar"L.Y.Rao." <lyrastro1 wrote: Mr.Prabhakar,I took you to be a scholarly person,but it seems that you and your admirer,Aggarwal,are stooping to levels no better than the many of the roadside "fortune-tellers",atleast that is the impression you both give from the language and tone of your letters...While "throwing mud" at everybody who asks you for the RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...you are actually admitting that either you and Aggarwal et al,are yourselves just ignorant of it,and instead of making efforts to FIND OUT THE RATIONALE FOR YOURSELVES..you are both defending yourselves by indulging in mud-slinging...betraying only your bankruptcy in good manners as well as any 'knowledge' of Lal Kitab,let alone any "expert knowledge" but proclaim yourselves to be "experts" in Lal Kitab...in a "you pat my back and I'll pat yours" manner...!You both do not seem to have read or even heard about the Raja Harishchandra & Shakuntala legend and similar stories that abound in our Puranas...all illustrating the futility of trying to influence/change Karmic destiny.NOTHING/NOBODY CAN CHANGE ONE'S KARMIC DESTINY...! ! That is precisely why I asked you all to recommend a good book on Lal Kitab...perhaps the book also says that,but not according to you,I suppose...I pray to GOD that better sense prevails...L.Y.Rao. Sent from Mail. A Smarter Inbox. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 2, 2008 Report Share Posted April 2, 2008 Dear Chillarji, Neither you,nor Rajni Khan,nor Prabhakar...nor ANY OF YOU...have mustered the courage to reply to my query AT ALL... For your information,I am repeating the question again...WHAT IS THE RATIONALE FOR LAL KITAB,PREDICTIONS/REMEDIES ? IF YOU CAN,PLEASE DO SO...ALL YOUR STALWARTS HAVE FAILED MISERABLY...and are in hiding,perhaps... How can I sling mud... they've all RUN AWAY...INTO HIDING ? OR IS IT HIBERNATION...? Come on,Raj Chillar I take you on...I PRAY YOU WILL NOT RUN AWAY..IF YOU DO...YOU WILL ONLY PROVE THAT LAL KITAB TRULY,IS A HOAX... Umesh et al,asked me for the rationale of Vimshottari Dasa,in retaliation,which I have duly provided...in exchange,he had PROMISED TO GIVE ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...pl.check all the correspondence on this site... ALL your stalwarts seem to have " laid huge eggs " ... Come on Raj can YOU help them...and provide me the rationale of Lal Kitab...? YOU CANNOT ACCUSE ME OF MUD-SLINGING... In your book,HAVE YOU PROVIDED THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...TELL ME THE TRUTH... EVEN AFTER SEVERAL REQUESTS/DEMANDS NONE OF YOU LAL KITAB " EXPERTS " HAVE PROVIDED ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...! ! ! I HAVE BEGUN TO BELIEVE THAT LAL KITAB IS TRULY A BIG JOKE AND A BIGGER HOAX,TO BOOT... L.Y.Rao. > > Dear L.Y.Rao Ji, > Kindly do not waste your time in mud slinging on othjers. If you are desirous of getting new light on Lal Kitab, please read " Lal Kitab, a System of Progression and Curative Measure " , by R.S.Chillar. This is a Sagar Publication. If you still have some questions on Lal Kitab, you are most welcome. > With best wishes and kind regards. > rajchillar > > " L.Y.Rao. " <lyrastro1 wrote: > Mr.Prabhakar, > I took you to be a scholarly person,but it seems that you > and your admirer,Aggarwal,are stooping to levels no better than the > many of the roadside " fortune-tellers " ,atleast that is the impression > you both give from the language and tone of your letters... > While " throwing mud " at everybody who asks you for the > RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...you are actually admitting that either you and > Aggarwal et al,are yourselves just ignorant of it,and instead of making > efforts to FIND OUT THE RATIONALE FOR YOURSELVES..you are both > defending yourselves by indulging in mud-slinging...betraying only your > bankruptcy in good manners as well as any 'knowledge' of Lal Kitab,let > alone any " expert knowledge " but proclaim yourselves to be " experts " > in Lal Kitab...in a " you pat my back and I'll pat yours " manner...! > You both do not seem to have read or even heard about the > Raja Harishchandra & Shakuntala legend and similar stories that abound > in our Puranas...all illustrating the futility of trying to > influence/change Karmic destiny. > NOTHING/NOBODY CAN CHANGE ONE'S KARMIC DESTINY...! ! > That is precisely why I asked you all to recommend a good > book on Lal Kitab...perhaps the book also says that,but not according > to you,I suppose... > I pray to GOD that better sense prevails... > L.Y.Rao. > > Sent from Mail. > A Smarter Inbox. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2008 Report Share Posted April 3, 2008 Dear Rao, Kindly do not lose haert. When Mahatma Budha could not get the desired reply for 12 years even in penance, why should you expect it so soon. Rational of Philosophy behind any astrological science branch is only one i.e. Karma and resultant Sanskaras.Man has acurious mentality that he wants to unviel the secrets and truth behind phenoma, and tries to find some solution to straighten his path of life. If, in his opinion, he finds some food of thought, he tries to put down in black and white for the benefit of others at present and in future also. SAimilarly Lal Kitab advocates that a frame of destiny has been cast on the basis of our Karmas in the past. These Karmas can be diluted, if they are not compatible, or accentuated if they are suited to life and conscience of the individual.Some Karmas may be accepted silently and finished. You may be right to some extent that lal Kitab is a puzzle in the beginning, but it begins to clear after a number of readings from beginning to end. Lal Kitab's rational that is more puzzling tnah any thing is the search of rationale behind curative meassures of Kama Sanskars. One may do it as follows:- One may silently face the results and complete the Sanskaras of past deeds One may be a staunch follower of virtues and show courage to face the Karma Sanskars boldly without let lose the ethical values. One may try to dilute his past Karmas through proxy Karmas, a mystiq approach in the form of curative measures. The above submission may not satisfy you, but it is what I understand. Kindly, excuse me if you felt teased at my words in the past or presnt. If you are not satisfied, kindly do not lose heart. Keep on your search but in a peaceful manner because no one is under any compulsion to show you the real path. The tradition holds that go to the Jungles and search the truth i.e. try to read more, search and seek the company of some real master. Such persons may not be found through internet. The sages would only reveal the secrets to you ,if they feel you deserve it. wish you peace and success. Kshma Prarthi rajchillar "L.Y.Rao." <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Chillarji,Neither you,nor Rajni Khan,nor Prabhakar...nor ANY OF YOU...have mustered the courage to reply to my query AT ALL...For your information,I am repeating the question again...WHAT IS THE RATIONALE FOR LAL KITAB,PREDICTIONS/REMEDIES ?IF YOU CAN,PLEASE DO SO...ALL YOUR STALWARTS HAVE FAILED MISERABLY...and are in hiding,perhaps...How can I sling mud... they've all RUN AWAY...INTO HIDING ?OR IS IT HIBERNATION...?Come on,Raj Chillar I take you on...I PRAY YOU WILL NOT RUN AWAY..IF YOU DO...YOU WILL ONLY PROVE THAT LAL KITAB TRULY,IS A HOAX...Umesh et al,asked me for the rationale of Vimshottari Dasa,in retaliation,which I have duly provided...in exchange,he had PROMISED TO GIVE ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...pl.check all the correspondence on this site...ALL your stalwarts seem to have "laid huge eggs"...Come on Raj can YOU help them...and provide me the rationale of Lal Kitab...?YOU CANNOT ACCUSE ME OF MUD-SLINGING...In your book,HAVE YOU PROVIDED THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...TELL ME THE TRUTH...EVEN AFTER SEVERAL REQUESTS/DEMANDS NONE OF YOU LAL KITAB "EXPERTS" HAVE PROVIDED ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...! ! !I HAVE BEGUN TO BELIEVE THAT LAL KITAB IS TRULY A BIG JOKE AND A BIGGER HOAX,TO BOOT...L.Y.Rao.>> Dear L.Y.Rao Ji,> Kindly do not waste your time in mud slinging on othjers. If you are desirous of getting new light on Lal Kitab, please read "Lal Kitab, a System of Progression and Curative Measure", by R.S.Chillar. This is a Sagar Publication. If you still have some questions on Lal Kitab, you are most welcome.> With best wishes and kind regards.> rajchillar> > "L.Y.Rao." <lyrastro1 wrote:> Mr.Prabhakar,> I took you to be a scholarly person,but it seems that you > and your admirer,Aggarwal,are stooping to levels no better than the > many of the roadside "fortune-tellers",atleast that is the impression > you both give from the language and tone of your letters...> While "throwing mud" at everybody who asks you for the > RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...you are actually admitting that either you and > Aggarwal et al,are yourselves just ignorant of it,and instead of making > efforts to FIND OUT THE RATIONALE FOR YOURSELVES..you are both > defending yourselves by indulging in mud-slinging...betraying only your > bankruptcy in good manners as well as any 'knowledge' of Lal Kitab,let > alone any "expert knowledge" but proclaim yourselves to be "experts" > in Lal Kitab...in a "you pat my back and I'll pat yours" manner...!> You both do not seem to have read or even heard about the > Raja Harishchandra & Shakuntala legend and similar stories that abound > in our Puranas...all illustrating the futility of trying to > influence/change Karmic destiny.> NOTHING/NOBODY CAN CHANGE ONE'S KARMIC DESTINY...! ! > That is precisely why I asked you all to recommend a good > book on Lal Kitab...perhaps the book also says that,but not according > to you,I suppose...> I pray to GOD that better sense prevails...> L.Y.Rao.> > > > > > > > > Sent from Mail.> A Smarter Inbox.> for Good helps you make a difference Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2008 Report Share Posted April 3, 2008 Mr.Rao, I wrote in my mails that I am a novice to Lal-Kitab astrology but at the same time I am trying to explore the rationale and truth about this book through this group. Since you are engaged in this subject since 1960 and must be having a vast knowledge of vedic astrology. keeping this thing in mind I just asked you one question and that is "Role of Tithi in Predictive Astrology" but to save your skin you have not cared to answer the question or you do not have the guts. Now here comes an other question, but you are bound to answer, under certain conditions Rahu behaves like a yogakarka planet and in such a case it takes the native to dizzy heights. Can you explain the rules? Conjunction of the Moon and Jupiter is worst and it spoils the house in which this conjunction is. Now I can proove these by glaring examples. more so if you are keen to confirm I will provide the names and telephone/mobile numbers of the said persons. Since you as well as me are not conversant with Lal-kitab, under the circustances we shall discuss traditional astrology. Keep one thing in mind if you have the rights to raise objections on a specific subject which the people over here are enjoying, I have also right to ask you that you are bound to answer my querries. In case you can not you admit it opnely. "vaise to punjabi mein ek kahawat hai kee bhains ke aage rona aur apne deede khona" agar yeh bhee samajh mein nahin aaya to aapka sirf rab hee raakha hai, insan kee kaya bisat. Dr.Aggarwal"L.Y.Rao." <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Chillarji,Neither you,nor Rajni Khan,nor Prabhakar...nor ANY OF YOU...have mustered the courage to reply to my query AT ALL...For your information,I am repeating the question again...WHAT IS THE RATIONALE FOR LAL KITAB,PREDICTIONS/REMEDIES ?IF YOU CAN,PLEASE DO SO...ALL YOUR STALWARTS HAVE FAILED MISERABLY...and are in hiding,perhaps...How can I sling mud... they've all RUN AWAY...INTO HIDING ?OR IS IT HIBERNATION...?Come on,Raj Chillar I take you on...I PRAY YOU WILL NOT RUN AWAY..IF YOU DO...YOU WILL ONLY PROVE THAT LAL KITAB TRULY,IS A HOAX...Umesh et al,asked me for the rationale of Vimshottari Dasa,in retaliation,which I have duly provided...in exchange,he had PROMISED TO GIVE ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...pl.check all the correspondence on this site...ALL your stalwarts seem to have "laid huge eggs"...Come on Raj can YOU help them...and provide me the rationale of Lal Kitab...?YOU CANNOT ACCUSE ME OF MUD-SLINGING...In your book,HAVE YOU PROVIDED THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...TELL ME THE TRUTH...EVEN AFTER SEVERAL REQUESTS/DEMANDS NONE OF YOU LAL KITAB "EXPERTS" HAVE PROVIDED ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...! ! !I HAVE BEGUN TO BELIEVE THAT LAL KITAB IS TRULY A BIG JOKE AND A BIGGER HOAX,TO BOOT...L.Y.Rao.>> Dear L.Y.Rao Ji,> Kindly do not waste your time in mud slinging on othjers. If you are desirous of getting new light on Lal Kitab, please read "Lal Kitab, a System of Progression and Curative Measure", by R.S.Chillar. This is a Sagar Publication. If you still have some questions on Lal Kitab, you are most welcome.> With best wishes and kind regards.> rajchillar> > "L.Y.Rao." <lyrastro1 wrote:> Mr.Prabhakar,> I took you to be a scholarly person,but it seems that you > and your admirer,Aggarwal,are stooping to levels no better than the > many of the roadside "fortune-tellers",atleast that is the impression > you both give from the language and tone of your letters...> While "throwing mud" at everybody who asks you for the > RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...you are actually admitting that either you and > Aggarwal et al,are yourselves just ignorant of it,and instead of making > efforts to FIND OUT THE RATIONALE FOR YOURSELVES..you are both > defending yourselves by indulging in mud-slinging...betraying only your > bankruptcy in good manners as well as any 'knowledge' of Lal Kitab,let > alone any "expert knowledge" but proclaim yourselves to be "experts" > in Lal Kitab...in a "you pat my back and I'll pat yours" manner...!> You both do not seem to have read or even heard about the > Raja Harishchandra & Shakuntala legend and similar stories that abound > in our Puranas...all illustrating the futility of trying to > influence/change Karmic destiny.> NOTHING/NOBODY CAN CHANGE ONE'S KARMIC DESTINY...! ! > That is precisely why I asked you all to recommend a good > book on Lal Kitab...perhaps the book also says that,but not according > to you,I suppose...> I pray to GOD that better sense prevails...> L.Y.Rao.> > > > > > > > > Sent from Mail.> A Smarter Inbox.> You rock. That's why Blockbuster's offering you one month of Blockbuster Total Access, No Cost. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2008 Report Share Posted April 4, 2008 Mr. rao; lalkitab is book or comilation of some systems that are combined for remedial or predictive purposes. what u mean by rationale of lalkitab is not being understood by me. yes u r true when u say that fruits of karma have to be borne; lalkitab perfectly denotes in the topic pakka ghar ka grah. the past actions , the fruit of which cannot be altered is denoted by this planatary concept. u r again trye that rationale about the specific ingredients of this book like varshphal, rashi number ke bolne wale grah , makan kundali have not been decoded yet; but that could be because we are weak at the basics and not understood the system fully. but the results show that this system works and that is the motivating factor to pursue the logics. but i am afraid to say ur approach is negative; that way a volley of questions be thrown at any branch related with spiritual or astrology stream; one should pick a branch that suits him or in which he sees light ahead. it good to be master of some streams in a particular branch than jumping between different branches. the way u question is like whether hindi is good or english is good, there can be no end to such debate. kulbirbance lalkitab , " L.Y.Rao. " <lyrastro1 wrote: > > Dear Chillarji, > Neither you,nor Rajni Khan,nor > Prabhakar...nor ANY OF YOU...have mustered the courage to reply to my > query AT ALL... > For your information,I am repeating the question > again...WHAT IS THE RATIONALE FOR LAL KITAB,PREDICTIONS/REMEDIES ? > IF YOU CAN,PLEASE DO SO...ALL YOUR STALWARTS HAVE FAILED > MISERABLY...and are in hiding,perhaps... > How can I sling mud... they've all RUN AWAY...INTO HIDING ? > OR IS IT HIBERNATION...? > Come on,Raj Chillar I take you on...I PRAY YOU WILL NOT > RUN AWAY..IF YOU DO...YOU WILL ONLY PROVE THAT LAL KITAB TRULY,IS A > HOAX... > Umesh et al,asked me for the rationale of Vimshottari > Dasa,in retaliation,which I have duly provided...in exchange,he had > PROMISED TO GIVE ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...pl.check all the > correspondence on this site... > ALL your stalwarts seem to have " laid huge eggs " ... > Come on Raj can YOU help them...and provide me the > rationale of Lal Kitab...? > YOU CANNOT ACCUSE ME OF MUD-SLINGING... > In your book,HAVE YOU PROVIDED THE RATIONALE OF LAL > KITAB...TELL ME THE TRUTH... > EVEN AFTER SEVERAL REQUESTS/DEMANDS NONE OF YOU LAL > KITAB " EXPERTS " HAVE PROVIDED ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...! ! ! > I HAVE BEGUN TO BELIEVE THAT LAL KITAB IS TRULY A BIG JOKE > AND A BIGGER HOAX,TO BOOT... > L.Y.Rao. > > > > > > Dear L.Y.Rao Ji, > > Kindly do not waste your time in mud > slinging on othjers. If you are desirous of getting new light on Lal > Kitab, please read " Lal Kitab, a System of Progression and Curative > Measure " , by R.S.Chillar. This is a Sagar Publication. If you still > have some questions on Lal Kitab, you are most welcome. > > With best wishes and kind regards. > > rajchillar > > > > " L.Y.Rao. " <lyrastro1@> wrote: > > Mr.Prabhakar, > > I took you to be a scholarly person,but it seems that you > > and your admirer,Aggarwal,are stooping to levels no better than the > > many of the roadside " fortune-tellers " ,atleast that is the > impression > > you both give from the language and tone of your letters... > > While " throwing mud " at everybody who asks you for the > > RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...you are actually admitting that either you > and > > Aggarwal et al,are yourselves just ignorant of it,and instead of > making > > efforts to FIND OUT THE RATIONALE FOR YOURSELVES..you are both > > defending yourselves by indulging in mud-slinging...betraying only > your > > bankruptcy in good manners as well as any 'knowledge' of Lal > Kitab,let > > alone any " expert knowledge " but proclaim yourselves to > be " experts " > > in Lal Kitab...in a " you pat my back and I'll pat yours " manner...! > > You both do not seem to have read or even heard about the > > Raja Harishchandra & Shakuntala legend and similar stories that > abound > > in our Puranas...all illustrating the futility of trying to > > influence/change Karmic destiny. > > NOTHING/NOBODY CAN CHANGE ONE'S KARMIC DESTINY...! ! > > That is precisely why I asked you all to recommend a good > > book on Lal Kitab...perhaps the book also says that,but not > according > > to you,I suppose... > > I pray to GOD that better sense prevails... > > L.Y.Rao. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Sent from Mail. > > A Smarter Inbox. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2008 Report Share Posted April 4, 2008 Respected chillar ji; that was a rare and brilliant piece of writing. you have summed up the entire philosphy in one para; especially the sentence . One may try to dilute his past Karmas through proxy Karmas, a mystiq approach in the form of curative measures. is a gem.thanks kulbirbancelalkitab , Raj Chillar <rajchillar wrote:>> Dear Rao,> Kindly do not lose haert. When Mahatma Budha could not get the desired reply for 12 years even in penance, why should you expect it so soon. Rational of Philosophy behind any astrological science branch is only one i.e. Karma and resultant Sanskaras.Man has acurious mentality that he wants to unviel the secrets and truth behind phenoma, and tries to find some solution to straighten his path of life. If, in his opinion, he finds some food of thought, he tries to put down in black and white for the benefit of others at present and in future also.> SAimilarly Lal Kitab advocates that a frame of destiny has been cast on the basis of our Karmas in the past. These Karmas can be diluted, if they are not compatible, or accentuated if they are suited to life and conscience of the individual.Some Karmas may be accepted silently and finished.> You may be right to some extent that lal Kitab is a puzzle in the beginning, but it begins to clear after a number of readings from beginning to end. > Lal Kitab's rational that is more puzzling tnah any thing is the search of rationale behind curative meassures of Kama Sanskars. One may do it as follows:-> One may silently face the results and complete the Sanskaras of past deeds> One may be a staunch follower of virtues and show courage to face the Karma Sanskars boldly without let lose the ethical values.> One may try to dilute his past Karmas through proxy Karmas, a mystiq approach in the form of curative measures.> The above submission may not satisfy you, but it is what I understand. Kindly, excuse me if you felt teased at my words in the past or presnt. If you are not satisfied, kindly do not lose heart. Keep on your search but in a peaceful manner because no one is under any compulsion to show you the real path. The tradition holds that go to the Jungles and search the truth i.e. try to read more, search and seek the company of some real master. Such persons may not be found through internet. The sages would only reveal the secrets to you ,if they feel you deserve it. > wish you peace and success.> Kshma Prarthi> rajchillar > > > "L.Y.Rao." lyrastro1 wrote:> Dear Chillarji,> Neither you,nor Rajni Khan,nor > Prabhakar...nor ANY OF YOU...have mustered the courage to reply to my > query AT ALL...> For your information,I am repeating the question > again...WHAT IS THE RATIONALE FOR LAL KITAB,PREDICTIONS/REMEDIES ?> IF YOU CAN,PLEASE DO SO...ALL YOUR STALWARTS HAVE FAILED > MISERABLY...and are in hiding,perhaps...> How can I sling mud... they've all RUN AWAY...INTO HIDING ?> OR IS IT HIBERNATION...?> Come on,Raj Chillar I take you on...I PRAY YOU WILL NOT > RUN AWAY..IF YOU DO...YOU WILL ONLY PROVE THAT LAL KITAB TRULY,IS A > HOAX...> Umesh et al,asked me for the rationale of Vimshottari > Dasa,in retaliation,which I have duly provided...in exchange,he had > PROMISED TO GIVE ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...pl.check all the > correspondence on this site...> ALL your stalwarts seem to have "laid huge eggs"...> Come on Raj can YOU help them...and provide me the > rationale of Lal Kitab...?> YOU CANNOT ACCUSE ME OF MUD-SLINGING...> In your book,HAVE YOU PROVIDED THE RATIONALE OF LAL > KITAB...TELL ME THE TRUTH...> EVEN AFTER SEVERAL REQUESTS/DEMANDS NONE OF YOU LAL > KITAB "EXPERTS" HAVE PROVIDED ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...! ! !> I HAVE BEGUN TO BELIEVE THAT LAL KITAB IS TRULY A BIG JOKE > AND A BIGGER HOAX,TO BOOT...> L.Y.Rao.> > > >> > Dear L.Y.Rao Ji,> > Kindly do not waste your time in mud > slinging on othjers. If you are desirous of getting new light on Lal > Kitab, please read "Lal Kitab, a System of Progression and Curative > Measure", by R.S.Chillar. This is a Sagar Publication. If you still > have some questions on Lal Kitab, you are most welcome.> > With best wishes and kind regards.> > rajchillar> > > > "L.Y.Rao." lyrastro1@ wrote:> > Mr.Prabhakar,> > I took you to be a scholarly person,but it seems that you > > and your admirer,Aggarwal,are stooping to levels no better than the > > many of the roadside "fortune-tellers",atleast that is the > impression > > you both give from the language and tone of your letters...> > While "throwing mud" at everybody who asks you for the > > RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...you are actually admitting that either you > and > > Aggarwal et al,are yourselves just ignorant of it,and instead of > making > > efforts to FIND OUT THE RATIONALE FOR YOURSELVES..you are both > > defending yourselves by indulging in mud-slinging...betraying only > your > > bankruptcy in good manners as well as any 'knowledge' of Lal > Kitab,let > > alone any "expert knowledge" but proclaim yourselves to > be "experts" > > in Lal Kitab...in a "you pat my back and I'll pat yours" manner...!> > You both do not seem to have read or even heard about the > > Raja Harishchandra & Shakuntala legend and similar stories that > abound > > in our Puranas...all illustrating the futility of trying to > > influence/change Karmic destiny.> > NOTHING/NOBODY CAN CHANGE ONE'S KARMIC DESTINY...! ! > > That is precisely why I asked you all to recommend a good > > book on Lal Kitab...perhaps the book also says that,but not > according > > to you,I suppose...> > I pray to GOD that better sense prevails...> > L.Y.Rao.> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Sent from Mail.> > A Smarter Inbox.> >> > > > > > > > for Good helps you make a difference> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 5, 2008 Report Share Posted April 5, 2008 Dear Rao, There is no end to such discussions. Better be a researcher and dig out the mud, if you feel that Lal Kitab is a big hoax. leave it to its fate and try your luich in pursuit of some other field. with best wishes and kind regards without any prejudice. r.s.chillar"L.Y.Rao." <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Chillarji,Neither you,nor Rajni Khan,nor Prabhakar...nor ANY OF YOU...have mustered the courage to reply to my query AT ALL...For your information,I am repeating the question again...WHAT IS THE RATIONALE FOR LAL KITAB,PREDICTIONS/REMEDIES ?IF YOU CAN,PLEASE DO SO...ALL YOUR STALWARTS HAVE FAILED MISERABLY...and are in hiding,perhaps...How can I sling mud... they've all RUN AWAY...INTO HIDING ?OR IS IT HIBERNATION...?Come on,Raj Chillar I take you on...I PRAY YOU WILL NOT RUN AWAY..IF YOU DO...YOU WILL ONLY PROVE THAT LAL KITAB TRULY,IS A HOAX...Umesh et al,asked me for the rationale of Vimshottari Dasa,in retaliation,which I have duly provided...in exchange,he had PROMISED TO GIVE ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...pl.check all the correspondence on this site...ALL your stalwarts seem to have "laid huge eggs"...Come on Raj can YOU help them...and provide me the rationale of Lal Kitab...?YOU CANNOT ACCUSE ME OF MUD-SLINGING...In your book,HAVE YOU PROVIDED THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...TELL ME THE TRUTH...EVEN AFTER SEVERAL REQUESTS/DEMANDS NONE OF YOU LAL KITAB "EXPERTS" HAVE PROVIDED ME THE RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...! ! !I HAVE BEGUN TO BELIEVE THAT LAL KITAB IS TRULY A BIG JOKE AND A BIGGER HOAX,TO BOOT...L.Y.Rao.>> Dear L.Y.Rao Ji,> Kindly do not waste your time in mud slinging on othjers. If you are desirous of getting new light on Lal Kitab, please read "Lal Kitab, a System of Progression and Curative Measure", by R.S.Chillar. This is a Sagar Publication. If you still have some questions on Lal Kitab, you are most welcome.> With best wishes and kind regards.> rajchillar> > "L.Y.Rao." <lyrastro1 wrote:> Mr.Prabhakar,> I took you to be a scholarly person,but it seems that you > and your admirer,Aggarwal,are stooping to levels no better than the > many of the roadside "fortune-tellers",atleast that is the impression > you both give from the language and tone of your letters...> While "throwing mud" at everybody who asks you for the > RATIONALE OF LAL KITAB...you are actually admitting that either you and > Aggarwal et al,are yourselves just ignorant of it,and instead of making > efforts to FIND OUT THE RATIONALE FOR YOURSELVES..you are both > defending yourselves by indulging in mud-slinging...betraying only your > bankruptcy in good manners as well as any 'knowledge' of Lal Kitab,let > alone any "expert knowledge" but proclaim yourselves to be "experts" > in Lal Kitab...in a "you pat my back and I'll pat yours" manner...!> You both do not seem to have read or even heard about the > Raja Harishchandra & Shakuntala legend and similar stories that abound > in our Puranas...all illustrating the futility of trying to > influence/change Karmic destiny.> NOTHING/NOBODY CAN CHANGE ONE'S KARMIC DESTINY...! ! > That is precisely why I asked you all to recommend a good > book on Lal Kitab...perhaps the book also says that,but not according > to you,I suppose...> I pray to GOD that better sense prevails...> L.Y.Rao.> > > > > > > > > Sent from Mail.> A Smarter Inbox.> for Good helps you make a difference Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.