For Shri Pardeepji and Shri Chandrasekharji.

[Guest guest]

There has lot of discussion and time been spent on the subject of

whether aspects

should be seen in the divisional charts or not. Many references

-authenticated were

been given from the side of the people proposing the same. But the

authors about

whom such references were given were themselves rejected, as to be

prone of

committing mistakes and these references were thrown away to dust.The

people

opposing could not provide the same number of references.

 

I have a suggestion to make this discussion more interesting and

knowledgeable and

palatable for all-

 

1) Let the proposers take any chart of a famous personality, and prove

the events

in the Life in the native through the aspects in D Charts.

2) let the opposers do the same with another chart ,and prove the events

without the use of any of the D Charts or aspects therein.

3) Next, allow the participants to argue, counter argue on whatever

they have supported their stand with.

 

But before doing this, let there be consensus in the Birth time of the

Native,

you pick, for examination of the chart.

 

That would be real discussion, and tarka, kutarka.

and enjoyable too. And we too would see the Sanskrit

knowledge put in practice, when the great Titans meet

on a real take-off in predictive astrology, and not on

countless unproved theories .

 

regards,

Bhaskar.