RETROSPECTION

[Guest guest]

Respected members of the forum,

Namaskar,

First of all welcome to all new members who joined our forum during

the month.

 

During the month we have very good interaction. Thanks for your

active participation in discussion relating to predictive astrology,

raising various points, reading, observing etc. in your own ways.

During this period you may have observed that most of the members are

silently reading the msg. I will like to request you to please offer

your comments either in favour or in opposition of any point. This is

your forum and only forum discussing the science of astrology that

too without any prior approval of moderator on any msg. Because

discussion is the best way of learning and improving our knowledge.

 

There are many astrologers in the forum, who are active in other

forums but silent in this forum. Either they may have no courage to

discuss or they may have decided for not discussing and may have

classified this forum as anti astrology. But, where I have degraded

astrology. And if I am wrong then every member has full right to

correct me. But only blind faith will not do in coming years. So how

long will you continue to earn your livelihood by cheating or

befooling. Though many astrologer may not have even imagined that

they are wrong. Hence it is very essential that they must know ground

realities.

 

Perhaps this may be the only forum where opposite views are welcome,

otherwise almost all forums do not want to allow any opposite msg.

 

Within a very short time we have +100 members. We have discussed many

points. Latest position of various points has been incorporated in

various SOA________ files and these files will be updated in due

course according to discussion on some point (I have shortage of time

but new files will definitely be added). Hence you may offer your

comments on any point in SOA files or in " Astrology a science or

myth " file or may raise new point. Some astrologers have also left

the forum because they were not able to scientifically defend their

stand in support of astrology and they have only faith on astrology

without any substance. Thus members can realize as to how predictive

astrology was fabricated around false footings and astrologers do not

have any solid argument in support of their stand. Unfortunately

astrologers are more interested in their business instead of sparing

some time to know the bare truth behind astrology. Thus actually they

them-selves are unaware and convincing others to follow their path.

 

Almost all members may also be associated with many other forums;

hence I will like to request you to please invite your friends (they

may either be in favour or against astrology, but may be interested

in analysis of predictive astrology as science) to this forum, so

that we may have different and diversified views for learning and

thinking. I am continuously inviting astrologers to come forward with

their stand, but as-usual they are more interested in exploiting

general innocent public in comparison to discussion. If some members

have little argument in support of any point then please do not

hesitate to share your views. As we are discussing various points

academically, scientifically with open mind and without any biased

attitude and there is nothing personal.

 

I hope you will continue to provide your full cooperation with active

discussion and not with silence and invite other astrologers to

support your stand. If all members may raise or defend their stand

then we may have very vibrant and useful reading material. If members

are satisfied with the outcome of discussion on some points as listed

in SOA_______ and not able to start a new point then I will like to

invite the views of all the members on following preliminary points

appeared during discussion.

 

Astrology is science or myth, if it is science then :-

 

what is the basis of forming of sign and who decided the name of

signs?

How sign lord was decided?

What is the basis of aspect and how they were decided?

friendship between planets

exalted

vinshotary dasha

How concept of Rahu and Ketu were devised?

What is Rahu or Ketu?

What is Ayanansh and their affect.

……………………. And so on ……….you may add many more points.

 

Some members are observing long silence when I asked some

explanation. Some examples are

Clarification on a principle of diabetes.

Description after entering a house of Nadi shastra.

Description of a principle of Khullar astrology for decoding death.

Position of Ketu in horoscope at the time of total solar eclipse.

And so on. I hope members may please continue to support their stand

or admit that they have corrected their stand. Only then there may be

some use of discussion. Because silence is not going to serve anyone.

 

Members may take help of friends of other forums too and may raise

these points in their forum for deciding the appropriate answer.

After discussing above points we will take some other points in due

course.

 

If you have some email addresses of the individuals (astrologer or

general), whom you would like to invite in this forum, then either

you can invite them or intimate their email to me and I will

personally invite them.

 

If you have some suggestion or want to inform something personally

then you can also write to sanatkumar_jain. If any

member passes through Gwalior then he can meet me and can contact on

0751-2626868.

 

Thanks once again to you,

 

Yours

 

Scienceofastrology

 

Think differently, Think logically and Think scientifically