Guest guest Posted August 7, 2008 Report Share Posted August 7, 2008 Dear Shri Krishnadayaji, Jai Shri Krishna! < I hope that learned Brahmanas like yourselves will endeavor to promote Vedic faith > That is exactly what I am doing when I am divesting the real Vedic lore from the atrocities of “Vedic astrologers”! < since the anti-Vedic hawks all around are eagerly awaiting to exploit divisions within the Vedic family .> Here also you are right! And the anti-Vedic hawks have got a handle by labelling the entire Hindu community as nothing but superstitious cowards by being fatalists! In order to extricate ourselves from the clutches of such anti-Vedic hawks, the first thing we have to do is to shun predictive gimmicks like plague, since that is what our Vedic Rishis have advised us! < The heartbreaking sufferings of Kashmiri Brahmins is not the fault of Vedic religion > Here also you are right! < None other than, an irreligious Kashmiri " Pandit " himself has constituted it> Yes, here also you are right, but the blame for making Kashmir Pandits irreligious squarely lies with “Vedic astrologers” since they made us, like they made the entire Hindu community including a Krishna Bhakta like you, celebrate all our festivals and muhurtas on wrong days just to prove their astrological prowess on the shoulders of some non-existent Lahiri or Ramana or Fagan Rashichakra! <As a humble Vaishnava , it is heartbreaking to see the blind rejection of Rishi-created doctrines like *Parasara hora* , *Varahamihira hora* , etc as non-vedic .> It is a very bad habit of “Vedic astrologers” -- and you are no exception! They just remain and also want to remain ignorant about the reality! The Brihat Parashari you are talking about is one of the worst concoctions of the nineteenth century---all the editions of them—whether the Nirnaya Sagara press edition or Master Khelari Lal and Sons edition---which has been translated into English by R. Santhanam later! They are not works by Parashara Rishi at all but have been published by some people just for the greed of money in the name of Parashara! You know, jyotishis are a greedy lot! They want money even for “predicting” as to how miserable he/she is going to be and then to help him/her some amelioration from those miseries they want more money! The same is the case with Parashara Hora and Brighu Samhita and Ravana Samhita and Aruna Samhita etc. etc. All are concoctions for the sake of money! < Bhagavan repeats often " Ancient Rishis mentioned so … In the opinion of Rishis " …. , etc) . > You are right! We find in the Vedas also “iti shushruma dheeranam ye nas tad vichachakshire” But those Rishis did not tell lies whereas today’s fake Rishis are liars of the worst order when they say that the phalit they are “revealing” is as per Parashara Rishi or Brighu Rishi etc. < Astrological Business for monetary gains is not * Vedic Astrology * but " Mlecha Astrology " > You are right, again! And these days ninety-nine per cent astr9ologers are practicing mleccha astrology, as such! Regarding Ashtamangala Prashna, it may be just a way of prognosis like Tarot cards or I Ching or Feng Shi etc. I wonder whether you are aware that Prashna Shastra (Horary astrology) is admittedly an import from Chaldea/Greece since it follows the principles of Ithsshala, Mushraja etc. as given in Tazika Neelakanthi! In other words, what you are trying to prove is that Asthamagnala Prashna being followed in some temples is also a remnant of Babylonian astrology! The rest of the points that you have discussed are really irrelevant to proving “Vedic astrology” either as Vedic or scientific! They maybe a good “pravachan” in some temple for some simpletons! They do not answer any of the questions raised by me! Let me repeat just one of my questions: If till the advent of twentieth century, all the panchangas in India were prepared from monstrously wrong astronomical works like the Surya Sidhanta or Aryabhati etc., how on earth could the predictions based on them be correct? You will appreciate that by brushing such questions under the carpet we are making ourselves more vulnerable to criticism of anti-Vedic hawks! With regards, Avtar Krishen Kaul Krishna daya [krishnadaya] Wednesday, August 06, 2008 9:02 PM jyotirved RE: About Vedic Astrology .. Hare Krishna ! Dear Shri. Kaul ji , I hope that learned Brahmanas like yourselves will endeavor to promote Vedic faith , since the anti-Vedic hawks all around are eagerly awaiting to exploit divisions within the Vedic family . The heartbreaking sufferings of Kashmiri Brahmins is not the fault of Vedic religion . None other than, an irreligious Kashmiri " Pandit " himself has constituted it . (Jawaharlal Nehru who never missed an opportunity to ridicule the Vedic faith , by advocating western " mlecha " philosophies and it's tirades like " aryan invasion " blasphemy) . As a humble Vaishnava , it is heartbreaking to see the blind rejection of Rishi-created doctrines like *Parasara hora* , *Varahamihira hora* , etc as non-vedic . Bhagavan Krishna has never rejected the teachings of Rishis , the *Acharyas* of Vedic sanatana dharma . In Gita , Bhagavan repeats often " Ancient Rishis mentioned so … In the opinion of Rishis " …. , etc) . There are several occasions where Bhagavan made adjustments to uphold the words of Rishis . For example : Rishis promised Nabhi-raja that their Yajna will get him a son equivalent to Lord Vishnu . Bhagavan appeared at the culmination of the Yajna and said " There can not be an equivalent to Me . However , the words of Rishis can not be wrong . Therefore, I Myself will be born as Nabhi-raja's son " . ( Rishabha-deva was manifested accordingly) . In this era , Poonthanam Namboodiri , was doing Bhagavata-parayanam at Guruvayoor temple . He mis-spelled " Amaraprabhu " as " Maraprabhu " . When the scholars among the audience ridiculed Poonthanam , Bhagavan's celestial voice stated " Poonthanam has not said anything wrong . I am " Maraprabhu " as well " .. What matters to Bhagavan is *Bhakti* and not mundane *Yukti* (human logic) . Astrological Business is not " Vedic Astrology " . Astrological Business for monetary gains is not * Vedic Astrology * but " Mlecha Astrology " . Such fake " astrologers " are not vedic followers and they freely use " Mlecha " techniques ( western and Islamic astrology) . A genuine Jyothishi must be a *Sattvic Upasak* who learns and practices the *vedic astrology ritual * as a " seva " to Bhagavan and His Bhaktas as * swadhrma* . It is up to the Bhakta to give " Acharya-dakshina " to the Jothishi who never asks for it . Adi Shankaracharya and Ashtamangalya Devaprasna During His divine mission , Adi Shankara has established rules and regulations for Vedic temples . Some of these are common whereas some are specific for each Temple . For instance , he spent forty five days at Guruvayoor temple to develop and put in place the doctrines . He documented it in palm-leafs and taught to chosen * Namboodiris* ( Brahmana Poojaris) and they have been traditionally passing it to the next generation. As I mentioned earlier , same " Ashtamangalya Devaprasna " (ADP) system is being applied to all the Vedic temples in Kerala . ADP is a team work involving Tantriks, Jyothishis , Administrators and Devotees . Prior to starting it , all necessary Vedic rituals are completed by Tantrik and then he invokes . Deva-chaitanya " ( divine power of *Navagrahas* and the Presiding Deity) to reveal Deity's will through astrological findings based on calculations and *nimithams " ( divine symptoms) . Recent Evidences for the effectiveness of ADP · In my family temples , the ADPs revealed unknown incidents such as liquor addiction of Poojari , theft inside temple , defect of Murthy , corruption by administrators, etc . Even the hitherto unknown whereabouts of our ancestral family source was found out through analysis. During the ADP , *Nymithams* appeared to reveal the above And all of these were proved 100% accurate . · In a Lord Ayyappa temple near my place , the ADP revealed that the Murthy has been disfigured .. Upon questioning , the Poojari confessed that he was hiding the truth . · The previous ADP at Guruvayoor revealed that , the proposed alteration of main entrance is unacceptable to Bhagavan , since it is against the " Vastu-sastra " . This was reconfirmed by the Vastu-experts later. · In the historical Guruvayoor ADP in November 2007 , several *shocking * truths were revealed which were unknown till then. ( I described it in the ADP report) . There are numerous evidences such as the above which are personally known to me . Late Kanchi Shankaracharya , Swamy Chandrasekharendra Sarasvathi , on Vedic Astrology . I hope you know about the renowned Swamy Chandrasekaharendra Sarasvathi , the previous head of Kanchi Shakaracharya Mutt . ( Please browse this link for more details, http://www.kamakoti.org/newlayout/template/souvenir.html ) : Jyothisha is not Blind faith " Hindu sastras are all nonsensical, " exclaim critics of our religion. " They say that north of the earth is the Meru mountain, that our one year is one day for the celestials residing there, and that the sun revolves round it. They believe that, besides the ocean of salt, there are oceans of sugarcane juice and milk, in fact several kinds of oceans. They describe the earth with its five continents as consisting of seven islands. It is all prattle. " Why should the ocean be salty? Who put the salt in it? Why should not there have been an ocean tasting sweet or of milk? Is the talk about the seven islands and the seven oceans absurd? What to the sastras say about the position of the earth, the same sastras that speak about the seven ocean, and so on? " Meru is situated on the northern tip of the earth, " they state. " Directly opposite to it is the Pole star(Dhruva). " The northern tip of the earth is the North pole. Is the Pole star directly opposite to it? No. " Eons ago, " scientists explain, " it was so. But later big changes took place and the earth tilted a bit. " The sastras refer to a time when the Pole star was directly opposite the North Pole and at that time the seven islands and the seven oceans must have existed. When the rotating earth tilted a bit the oceans must have got mixed and become salty and in the process the seven islands must have become the five continents. If there is a place above the North Pole it must be Meru where we have our svarga or paradise. Let us imagine that this earth is a lemon. A spot on its top is the Meru peak. In relation to that spot any other part of the fruit is south. Where can you go from there, east or west? You can go only south. You will learn this if you mark a point on the top of the lemon. For all countries of the earth, for all " varsas " , north is Meru. " Sarvesamapi varsanam Meruruttaratahsthitah. " On the North pole it is six months day and six months night. We must have been taught this in our primary classes. It means our one year is one day on the North pole. This is what is meant by saying that our one year is one day for the celestials. When the earth rotates, the northernmost and southernmost points are not affected. In some places there will be sun for 18 hours and in other places only for six hours. There are many differences in the durations of day and night with regard to different places on earth. Only on some days does the sun rise directly in the east and is overhead without departing even by one degree. On other days it rises from other angles(from north-east to south-east). Such is not the case on the North pole. There the sun shines six months and the other six months it is darkness. And, again, during the sunny months it would seem as if the sun were revolving round this place(the North pole). The six-month period when there is sun in the North Pole is called uttarayana and the similar sunny period on the South Pole is daksinayana. The North Pole is called " Sumeru " and the South Pole " Kumeru " . ( " Sumeria " is from Sumeru. In that land, it is said, the Vedic gods were worshipped. ) Just as the North pole is the abode of the gods, the South pole is the abode of the fathers (pitrs) and hell. To see the gods and the pitrs who are in the form of spirits and the denizens of hell one must obtain divine sight through yoga. Merely because we do not possess such sight we cannot deny their existence. There was Blavatsky who was born in Russia, lived in America and later came to India. She speaks about the worlds of the gods and of the spirits. A great scientist of our times, Sir Oliver Lodge, affirmed the existence of spirits and deities and stated that mankind could benefit from them. If you ask why Jyotisa, after dealing with the science of astronomy, should turn to spiritualism, the answer is that there is no contradiction between the two as supported by the example of a scientist like Sir Oliver who too turned to spiritualism. Our sastras came into existence at a time when mortals mixed with the gods. We would be able to appreciate this fact if we tried to understand the samkalpa we make at the time of performing any religious function. The samkalpa traces the present from the time of creation itself. From Jyotisa we learn the position of the grahas at the commencement of the yuga: then they were all in a line. Some calculations with regard to heavenly bodies today are different from those of the past. And, if the findings at present are not the same as seen in the sastras, it does not mean that the latter are all false. The sastras have existed from the time the grahas were in a line and the North pole was directly opposite the Pole star. Since then vast changes have taken place in nature. Valleys have become mountains, mountains have become oceans, oceans have become deserts and so on. Geologists speak about such cataclysmic changes, and astronomers tell us about the change in the courses of the heavenly bodies. So what we see today of the earth and the heavenly bodies is different from what is mentioned in the sastras. The date of creation according to Jyotisa agrees more or less with the view of modern science. Kali yuga--the age of Kali--has a span of 432, 000 years. Dvapara yuga is twice as long, 864, 000 years, Treta yuga is 1, 296, 000 years and Krta yuga 1, 728, 000 years. The four yugas together, called maha yuga, are 4, 320, 000 years long. A thousand mahayugas add up to the period of 14 Manus. The regnal period of a Manu is a manvantara. There are royal and republican rulers on earth, but God has appointed Manu as ruler of all the worlds. There are fourteen Manus ruling the world successively from the creation of man. The word " manusya " and " manuja " are derived from Manu. So too the English word " man " . In the samkalpa for any ritual we perform we mention the year of the seventh Manu, Vaivasvata. If we go back to the first Manu, Svayambhuva, we arrive at a date for the origin of the human species which agrees with the view of modern science. The Sanskrit word, " man " , means to think. Manu was the first of the human race with its power of thinking. There is a saying in English : " Man is a thinking animal. " " Since man's distinctive characteristic is his capacity to think the descendants of Manu came to be called " manusyas. " The life-span of the fourteen Manus put together make one day(daytime) of Brahma, that is 4, 320, 000, 000 years. His night has the same length. While one day of Brahma is thus 8, 640, 000, 000 years his one year is 365 such days and his life-span is 100 such years. The life of his cosmos is the same. When Brahma's life comes to an end the Brahman alone will remain and there will be no cosmos. Then another Brahma will start creation all over again. It is believed that Hanuman will be the next Brahma. Bhuloka, Bhuvarloka, Suvarloka, Maharloka, Janaloka, Tapoloka and Satyaloka comprise the seven worlds. The gods, mortals and so on live in these worlds. Bhuloka, Bhuvarloka and Suvarloka form one group. " Bhurbhuvassuvaha, " we pronounce this so often while performing rituals. The remaining four belong to higher planes. When Brahma goes to sleep at night the first three worlds will be dissolved in the pralaya (deluge). This is called " avantara-pralaya " ( " intermediate deluge " ). All other worlds will perish when his life-span ends. Scientists say that the heat of the sun is decreasing imperceptibly. Without the warmth of the sun there will be no life on earth. Scientists have calculated the time when the sun's heat will be reduced so much that life on earth cannot be sustained. Then this world itself will perish. The date on which this will occur agrees with that given by our sastras for the next " avantara-pralaya " . Half of Brahma's allotted life-span is over. This life-span is divided into seven " kalpas " . Now we have come more than half way of the fourth kalpa, " Svetavaraha " . We mention in samkalpa how old Brahma is at the time we perform a rite, which year we are in of the saka era, also the year according to the 60-year cycle beginning with Prabhava--all details of the almanac including the day, the asterism and the lagna. The date of Brahma's appearance, according to this calculation is said to agree with the view of modern science of when this cosmos came into being. Brahma is called " Parardha-dvaya-jivin " . It means he lives for two " parardhas " . A " paradha " is half the number meant by " para " . When Brahma is called " Paradha-dvaya-jivin " it means he lives as many years as is meant by 2*1/2 paras. Two half paras are the same as one para. Then why say " parardha-dvaya " instead of just one " para " . The reason for this is that Brahma has already completed half of one para and is going on 51. So it is meaningful to use the term " half of para " [two half-paras]. Fourteen Manus reign successively during one daytime of Brahma which lasts a thousand caturyugas. So one manvantara is 71 caturyugas. Now running is the 28th caturyuga, the Vaivasvata manvantara. And of it, it is Kali yuga now. In our samkalpa we mention all this and, in addition, the day according to the moon, the Lagna, etc. We also mention how we are situated in the space, from the Brahmanda down to the locality where we are performing the function (for which the samkalpa is made). It is all similar to writing the date and address on a letter. Astrology and Astronomy Astronomy examines the position of the planets and other heavenly bodies. It does not concern itself with how they affect the life of the world or the individual. It is not its function to find out how far the celestial bodies are beneficial to us or how they may be made favourable to us. Such functions belong to astrology. Jyotisa includes both astronomy and astrology. Telling us about the results of performing a ritual at a given time, keeping in mind the position of the planets, the sun and the moon and the naksatras ( asterisms ), comes under the purview of astrology. The hours favourable to the performance of Vedic rites are determined according to calculations based on the movement of planets. All this entails mathematical work. The measurements of the place where a sacrifice is to be conducted (yajnabhumi) are based on certain stipulations. These must be strictly adhered to if the sacrifices is to yield the desired benefits. Mathematics developed in this way as a handmaid to the Vedic dharma. Jyothisha, the Eye of Vedapurusha Of the fourteen branches of learning basic to our Vedic religion, siksa, Vyakarana, Chandas and Nirukta form part of Sadanga (the six limbs of the Vedas). I will now speak about Jyotisa, it being the first of the remaining two of the Sadanga. Jyotisa, which is the science of the celestial bodies and the eye of the Vedapurusa, consists of three " skandhas " or sections. So it is called " Skandha-trayatmakam " . Sages like Garga, Narada and Parasura have written samhitas (treatises) on this subject. The sun god, in disguise, taught the science to Maya, the carpenter of the Asuras. The work incorporating his teachings is called the Suryasiddhanta. There are treatises on astronomy written by celestials and sages and ordinary mortals. Of them some are by Varahamihira, Aryabhata and Bhaskaracarya. In recent times we had Sundaresvara Srautin who wrote a work called Siddhanta-Kausthubham. Why is Jyotisa regarded as the eye of the Vedapurusa? What purpose is served by the eye? Near objects may be perceived by the sense of touch. With our eyes we learn about distant objects. Just as our eyes help us to know objects that are distant in space (that is just as we see distant object with our eyes), Jyotisa sastra help us to find out the position of the heavenly bodies that are distant in time (their configuration many years ago in the past or many years hence in future). We can find out directly the positions of the sun and the moon and other heavenly bodies. Just as we can know near objects, even if we are blind, by feeling them with our hands, we can learn about the positions of the heavenly bodies near in time even without the help of astronomy. What is 50 feet away is to be perceived by the eye. Similarly, if you want to know the position of planets 50 years ago or 50 years hence, you have to have recourse to Jyotisa. We cannot, however, form a full picture of near objects only by feeling them. For instance, we cannot know whether they are green or red. For this, we must see them with our eyes. Again, even if we are able to see the planet with our naked eye, we will need the help of astrology to find out its effects on our life, how its positions in the heavens will influence our destiny. This is the reason why Jyotisa is called the eye of the Vedapurusa. Vedic rituals are performed according to the position of the various planets [and the sun and the moon]. There are rules to determine this. The right day and hour [muhurta] for a function is fixed according to the position of the celestial bodies. Here again, Jyotisa performs the function of the eye. This Anga of the Vedas is indeed called " nayana " which word means " to lead " . A blind man needs to be led by another. So it is the eye that leads. Astronomy / Astrology is the eye that enables us to fix the hours for Vedic rituals. Empirical Proof A ray of light pouring through an opening in the roof of a building falls on a particular spot. Normally, we shall not be able to tell where the same ray of light will fall next year. But a prediction can be made with the help of Jyotisa. This is how it was done in the olden days. A pearl attached to a thread was hung from the roof. If a man was able to indicate correctly in advance where its shadow would fall on a particular day, he received a reward from the king. One's competence in other sastras is established through argument, but in Jyotisa it has to be proved by actual demonstration. You cannot deceive anyone by employing the methods taught by this science. The sun and the moon are witness to what you do. " Pratyaksam Jyotisam sastram. " Ancient Mathematical Treaties Jyotisa, as we have seen, consists of three sections. There was a scholarly man in the Matha who was particularly learned in this science. We wished to honour him with a title and decided upon " Triskandha-Bhaskara " . " Skandha " literally means a big branch springing from the trunk of a tree. The three skandhas of Jyotisas are : siddhanta, hora and samhita. The siddhanta-skandha deals with arithmetic, trigonometry, geometry and algebra. The higher mathematics developed by the west in later centuries is found in our ancient Jyotisa. Arithmetic, called " vyakta-ganita " in sanskrit, includes addition, subtraction, multiplication and division. " Avyakta-ganita " is algebra. " Jya " means the earth and " miti " is method of measurement. " Jyamiti " evolved with the need to measure the sacrificial place : " geometry " is derived from this word. The " geo " in geography is from " jya " . There is a mathematical exercise called " samikarana " which is the same as " equation " . The sixth Anga of the Vedas, Kalpa ( I will speak about it later ), has a great deal to do with the fifth, that is Jyotisa. Kalpa has a section on " sulba-sutras " . These sutras mention the precise measurements of the " yajnavedi " (sacrificial altar). The character of the yajnabhumi is called " cayana " . The sulba- sutras deal with a number of cayanas like, for instance, the one shaped like Garuda. They tell us how to construct a brick-kiln ---the number of bricks required for the cayana of such and such shapes. The siddhanta-skandha is used in all this. There is an equation in the Apastamba sulba sutras which could not be proved until recently. Westerners had thought it to be faulty merely as they could not solve it. Now they accepted it as right. That Indians had taken such great strides in mathematics, thousand of years ago has caused amazement in the West. There are a number of old equations still to be solved. Our sastras mention branches of mathematics like " rekhaganita, " kuttaka " , " angapaka " , etc. " Avyakta-ganita " is also called " bijaganita " . Eight hundred years ago there lived a great mathematician called Bhaskaracarya. An incident in his life illustrates how relentless destiny is. Bhaskaracarya had a daughter called Lilavati. The great astrologer that he was, he found that she had " mangalya-dosa " in her horoscope, but he felt confident that he could change his daughter's destiny, as foreshadowed by the stars, with his ingenuity and resourcefulness, as an astrologer. He decided to celebrate Lilavati's marriage during a lagna in which all the planets would be in positions favourable to the bride. This should, he thought, ensure that Lilavati would remain a " dirgha-sumangali " . In those days there were no clocks as we have today. A water-pot was used to measure time. It consisted of an upper as well as a lower part. The water in the upper receptacle would trickle down through a hole into the lower container. The lower part was graduated according to the unit of time then followed ---nazhikai (nadika), one sixtieth of a day or 24 minutes. So the time of day was calculated by observing the level of the water in the lower container. ( " Water-clock " and " hour-glass " are English names for such an apparatus. Since water evaporates quickly sand was used instead. ) According to the custom then prevailing, Lilavati's marriage was to be celebrated when she was still a child. On the appointed day, she sat beside the water--clock and bent over it fascinated by the apparatus. As she fumbled around a pearl from her nose--stud got loosened and fell into the apparatus lodging itself in its hole. The flow of water into the lower receptacle was reduced. So what the clock indicated as the hour fixed for the marriage was not the right one---the auspicious hour had passed. Nobody including Lilavati, had noticed the pearl dropping into the water-clock. When they came to know about it, it was too late. They realised that destiny could not be overcome. Later Bhaskaracarya wrote a mathematical treatise and named it " Lilavati " after his daughter. The father taught his widowed daughter mathematics and she became highly proficient in the subject. Lilavati deals with arithmetic, algebra, etc. It is a delightful book in which the problems are stated in verse as stories. Bhaskaracarya also wrote the Siddhanta-Siromani which deals with how the positions and movement of the heavenly bodies are determined. We learn the text of an edict in the Pracinalekhamala that a Gurjara (Gujarat) king had made an endowment to popularise the works of Bhaskaracarya. Parts 7, 8, 9 and 10 of Euclid's Geometry are believed to be lost. All the 12 books on mathematics in Sanskrit are still available. " Making additions several times is multiplication; carrying out subtraction several times is division. " We remain ignorant of such easy methods of calculations dealt with in our mathematical texts. Varahamihira lived several years before Bhaskaracarya, that is about 1, 500 years ago. He wrote a number of treatises including the Brhat-Samhita and the Brhajjatika. The first is a digest of many sciences, its contents being a wonderful testimony to the variety of subjects in which our forefathers has taken strides. Brhajjatika is all about astrology. Aryabhata, famous for his Aryabhatiya-Siddhanta, also lived 1, 500 years ago. The vakya--ganita now in use is said to be based on his Siddhanta. Varahamihira and Aryabhata are much acclaimed by mathematicians today. All these books on mathematics also deal with the movements of the celestial bodies. There are seven " grahas " according to the ancient reckoning--the five planets and the sun and the moon. Rahu and Ketu are called " chaya -grahas " (shadow planets) and their orbits are opposite of the sun's and the moon's. Grihas and Human Life The conditions of man corresponds to the changes in the position of the nine grahas. A human being does not enjoy happiness all the time nor does he always suffer hardships-- that is he experiences a mixture of happiness and sorrow. While he may be pushed up to a high position today, he may be thrust down to the depths tomorrow. It is not man alone that is subject to changes of fortune. Establishments too have their ups and downs, so also nations. The sages saw a relationship between the position and movements of the planets and the destiny of man, the sorrow and happiness experienced by him. There is a branch of astrology called " hora--skandha " . If we knew the planetary position at the time of commencing a job or enterprise, with its help we should be able to find out how it would take shape, how we would fare in it. If our horoscope is cast on the basis of the configuration of the planets at the time of our birth, our fortunes over the entire period of our life can be predicted. Different reasons are given for the ups and downs in a man's life for his joys and sorrows. It is similar to finding out the different causes of the ailment he suffers from. The physician will explain that the disease is due to an imbalance in the " dhatus " . The mantravadin will say that it is due to the gods being displeased with the patient, while the astrologer will observe that it is all in his (the patient's) stars. The pandit versed in Dharmasastra will explain that the illness is the fruit of the man's past actions, his karma. And the psychologist will express the view that the bodily affliction is related to an emotional disturbance. What is the true cause? All these different causes may be valid. All of them together go to create an experience. When it rains it becomes wet and the place is swarmed with winged white ants. Frogs croak. All these are indicators of the rain. Many outward signs manifest themselves as the fruits of our past karma. They are all related to one another. The course of the planets governing our life is in accordance with our karma. We come to know the consequences of our past actions in previous births in various ways. Astrological calculations help us to find out such consequences as indicated by the heavenly bodies. Omens and Signs Where can you discover water? Where does ground water occur? Or where do streams flow inside the earth? By what signs on the surface do you make out the presence of water underground? How are perfumes manufactured? What are the right measurements for a house? These questions are discussed in the samhita-skandha of Jyotisa. Also omens and signs. " Sakuna " is one thing, " nimitta " quite another. " Sakuna " literally means a bird: only signs connected with birds come under the category of " Sakuna " . All things in this world are interrelated: all happenings are linked to one another. If we know the precise scale and manner in which events are woven together, we would be able to know everything. Everything in this world occurs according to the will of the One Being and according to a precise system. So with reference to one we can know all others. Palmistry, " arudam " (a method of divination), astrology, all are interrelated. What does a bird flying from right to left indicate? What is foretold by the chirping of such and such a bird? Question like these belong to the sakuna-sastra. " Nimitta " means omen. " Nimittani ca pasyami viparitani Kesava " says Arjuna to Krsna before the start of the battle of Kuruksetra. He uses the right word " nimitta " while we use the word " sakuna " carelessly. When a cat crosses our path it is an omen; when an eagle flies above us it is a sakuna. To go back to Arjuna. The Lord tells Arjuna: " Nimittamatram bhava Savyasacin " . This is in answer to Arjuna telling Krsna, lamenting, that it is sinful to kill one's enemies [or one's kin]. Says krsna: " I have already resolved to slay them in this battle. So they are already as good as dead. It is I who will kill them. You are a mere tool " (Nimittamatram bhava). A nimitta does not produce any result on its own. It points to the result that has already been ordained by some other factor--or, in other words, it merely indicates the fruits of our past karma. Om Namo Narayanaya !!! Krishnadaya ------ Shri Krishna Daya ji, Jai Shri Krishna! < I am attaching the report copy of the recent " Ashtamangala Prasna " held at Guruvayoor temple in November 2007. Please read it carefully , without any prejudice . > Many thanks for your sending me again details regarding " Ashtamangala Prashna " which I am reproducing below after the contents of your letter. I still fail to understand as to how this " Ashtamangala Prshna " can be clubbed with " Vedic astrology " even if it is being " practiced " at some ancient temple in India! You have talked of Bhagwan Shankaracharya in your mail, but have not quoted even a single line from any of his works where he has asked us to go by " Asthamangala Prashna " or any other predictive gimmick, for that matter! To the best of my knowledge, it his only his " modern shishyas " who want us to believe blindly in such hocus pocus! Besides, you have not answered any of the questions raised by me about the authenticity of the so called " Vedic astrology " . You can take it that these very questions are being repeated since I am sending my earlier mail again herewith. The most important question that you are avoiding to answer is: Till about a hundred years back, i.e., the advent of modern astronomy into India, all the Hindu Panchangas, on which all the Hindu festivals and muhurtas and horoscopy and patri melapak (horoscope matching) etc. etc. were based, whether in South or North or East or West, were prepared from one or the other sidhanta like the Surya Sidhanta or Arya Sidhanta or Sidhanta Shiromani etc. or one or the other karma-grantha like Grahalaghava or Makaranda etc. etc. And we know now without any doubt that all those sidhantas and karn-granthas are fundamentally and monstrously wrong about the planetary data! So how on earth could the panchangas prepared from such erroneous sidhantas and karma-granthas be correct and how under the sun could the predictions and muhurtas and patri-melapak etc. based on those panchangas be correct? That means all the Indian/Hindu astrology, which you would like to call " Vedic astrology " was actually astrology by charlatans of charlatans and for charlatans since it is only charlatans who can claim correct predictions from incorrect data! If you have any doubts, you can see the " Notable Horoscopes " by the " greatest Vedic astrologer of the twentieth century " ---since he also has/had made " correct predictions " from all those hundred and odd horoscopes of that book which are fundamentally incorrect in every way! Does it mean by implication that any gimmicks by charlatans can be called Vedic astrology and the more correct predictions one makes from incorrect data, the " more efficient " --- " greater " astrologer he/she is? You must also be aware that the so called nirayana rashichakra, whether Lahiri or Raman or Fagan etc. etc. is an astronomical joke! And so is a so called Sayana Rashichakra! And that is why we do not find any mention of any Mesha etc. Rashis in any of the Vedas since our real Rishis never made such clumsy jokes! And still you would like to go on calling predictive gimmicks as " Vedic astrology " and continue to celebrate the " janmatithi " of your beloved Bhagwan Krishna on wrong days---on August 24 instead of July 25! But then that certainly is your sweet will and prerogative! After all, we are living in a democracy! The tail piece is that ironically, none of your " Ashtamangala Pashnas " ---which are being performed almost every year over the last several years---either has not told you till date that you are celebrating all your festivals and muhurtas on wrong days, thanks to your " Vedic astrology " ! With regards, A K Kaul Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 9, 2008 Report Share Posted August 9, 2008 Dear Shri Krishna Dayaji, Jai Shri Krishna! < After reading your " Speech " ( Vedic astrology is fraud) , I was shocked . I thought you are an anti-vedic missionary (Missionaries often use fake Hindu names) . So I refrained myself from writing much . ( Since Gita advises us not to waste time with non-devotees) . > After I read the Satyartha Prakasha of Swami Dayanada Saraswati, I was also shocked since he had said several unpalatable truths! But then I had to reconcile with the facts! (Pl. do not take it to mean that I am an Aryasamaji! I am a Sanatani to the core!) I was also shocked to learn from S. B. Dikshit and Dr. M. N. Saha and several other scholars that the Mesha, Vrisha etc. rashis wre imported into India from Grecho-Chaldean systems. But on doing a lot of research, I had to agree with them! < However , through the later mails , I understood that you are a devoted Hindu . Therefore I replied in detail . Thanks to Bhagavan's grace , we agreed on quite a few aspects . > Glad that you agree with me on several points! <. I agree with you that majority of the " Astrologers " these days are " Frauds " > In your earlier post you had said that any astrologer charging money for predictions is a mlechha! It naturally means that ninety-nine percent “Vedic astrologers” are mlechhas and quite a few of them are also frauds! <However , we must not discredit * Vedic Sanatana Dharma * by publicly criticizing it's sacred traditions such as genuine * Jyothisha * >. That is the error we have been committing over the last about two thousand years---ever since the advent of Greek invaders. We confuse predictive gimmicks as a branch of the Vedas! No. They ae not. As such, when we expose the jyotishis who claim to be practising “Vedic astrology” we are actually doing a great service to the Vedas, as otherwise even charvakas claim that they are following the real Vedic principle---“yavaj-jeevet, sukham jeevet, rinam kritva api ghritam pivet”. < I am not an Astrologer . As a Krishna-bhakta settled in a Muslim country , I am trying to promote Krishna-bhakti among the potential devotees . Also , I am participating in the functioning of five temples in Kerala . Bhagavan has given me opportunities to serve Him . I have been closely involved with " sattvic " Daivajnas who are pure practitioners of Vedic faith > Very glad to learn that. You are just like Vibheeshna in Lanka! You have so much of dharmic strength and fearlessness only because you are not an astrologer and have hence no dichotomies that you would annoy your clients by telling them some unpleasant truths! < Purity of Vedic faith in Kerala Please don't misunderstand me as a fanatic " Mallu " , for stating the following which is my firm conviction : Kerala is known as " God's own country " or " Parashurama-kshetram " because it's Vedic frame work was established by Bhagavan Parashuraman . Later Adi Shankaracharya developed and commissioned a self-sustaining Vedic system . Unlike north-India , this Vedic System in Kerala has not been corrupted by Islamic or Christian invaders . Namboodiris are maintaining the pure tradition of Vedic rituals . There are Adi-shankara created systems to ensure this . Because of this purity , the divinity of the Deities can be experienced by a faithful devotee . Where necessary , the Deities have pro-actively conveyed * Divine Will " through chosen mediums such as " Daivajnas " and Brahmana Tantriks . ( I can confirm this from my personal experiences related to Temple affairs) .> I am from another extreme i.e. Kashmir, which was known as the land of Sarasvati and Saraswat Brahmins. We lost much of our glory because we celebrated all the festivals and muhurtas on topsy tuvy days---thanks to V”edic astrology”! Another reason of KPs’ downfall was their blind faith in “Vedic astrology” than their faith in reasoning and logic and planning! However, I have equal respect for all the regions. In fact, I am a cent per cent devotee of Bhagwan Shanakara. The way he has explained subtle and highest truths in his prasthana-trayee could have been done only by a yogi and brahmajnyani! My pranams to him. By “daivajnyas” and Brahmana Tantriks etc. I am sure you do not mean the ones who claim to practice these rituals after having read the Brihat Samhita of Varahamihria the worst charlatan or Brihat Parashari of the fake Parashara etc.! They must be doing some spiritual sadhna for that purpose. There cannot be any dispute about their sadhana since the Gita also has said “ye yatha mam prapapadyante tanstathaiva bajamyaham”. < Key Role of a genuine " Jyothishi " As a committed volunteer of vedic faith , I have noticed with appreciation the contributions of genuine " Jyothishis " . When a customer consults, the Jyothishi explains the status of " Daiva-krupa " and measures to improve the " sadhana* . Atonements for bad karma , may be Poojas and Vedic charity activities . ( And not wearing of precious stones or Yantras)> . As clarified above, jyotish in the sense of Brhat Samhita and Brihat Parashari and Brihat Jatakam etc. is meaningless but if a volunteer who has done sadhana etc. is able to help someone through his sadhna, and if people call him jyotishi instead of a sadhaka etc., how can anybody have any quarrel with that! Pl. try to understand that when I say “Vedic astrology” is a fraud on the Vedas, I mean that by claiming that he/she has read all the books on predictive astrology right from Yavana Jataka to K N Rao’s latest books, he/she can claim to be a “Vedic astrologer” you are really committing a fraud on the Vedas since none of these books has referred to any Vedic mantra which has advised us to consult some soothsayer! The Vedas do not have planets like Mangal, Shani etc. either, nor do they talk of Mesha, Vrisha etc. rashis. So their claims of being “Vedic astrologers” are a sham! <Accuracy of Vedic Astrology and Panchangas We have conducted numerous rituals according to *Panchagas* and have never faced problems . Bhagavan has mercifully forgiven the " human errors " in the *Panchangas*. ( Since Bhakti matters to Him more than Logic ) . In this " Kali-yugam " , we can not expect 100% accuracy and need to manage with what we have .. For examples the present day Acharyas are not extraordinary like our Ancient Rishis. > It is not only that conducting rituals according to the dates fixed in the panchangas in vogue is wrong and incorrect but even the fasts, fairs and festivals that you are observing these days are wrong, thanks to all these panchangas! You are celebrating Pitra-Amavasya on the day of Dipavali and marriages during Shradapaksha these days because of these very faulty panchagnas! Similarly, there is no question of any predictions having been correct in the past since they were based on faulty panchangas. In several of your “ashtmangala prashnas” you have felt that the “deity” was angry because of one reason or the other! Have you ever thought on the reasons of the “deity’s” anger being the use of wrong panchangas? It could be that the deity has hinted at it several times but in your “habits die hard” syndrome you have just not understood them. Now that this problem has been pointed out to you, I suggest you have a rethink on the same! For calculating a correct panchanga, these days you donot have to be a rishi! All you have to do is to gear to a different type of astronomical parameters! I am enclosing a list of correct dates of festivals during the current year. You can start celebrating the same from today onwards, even without calculating a fresh panchanga! Rest assured that they are as per the Vedic lore and not as per the “commandments” of “Vedic astrologers” who do not actually know even ABC of the Vedas! Rest in my next post. With regards, Avtar Krishen Kaul P.S I suggest that you join the forum HinduCalendar for knowing complete details about the gamut of festivals etc. I am sending you an invitation separately for the same. AKK Krishna daya [krishnadaya] Friday, August 08, 2008 1:39 PM jyotirved Re: About Vedic Astrology .. Hare Krishna ! Dear Shri Kaul ji , Thanks for your mail . And I hope that I am not wasting your time . Let me frankly reveal my views : After reading your " Speech " ( Vedic astrology is fraud) , I was shocked . I thought you are an ant-vedic missionary (Missionaries often use fake Hindu names) . So I refrained myself from writing much . ( Since Gita advises us not to waste time with non-devotees) . However , through the later mails , I understood that you are a devoted Hindu . Therefore I replied in detail . Thanks to Bhagavan's grace , we agreed on quite a few aspects . I agree with you that majority of the " Astrologers " these days are " Frauds " . However , we must not discredit * Vedic Sanatana Dharma * by publicly criticizing it's sacred traditions such as genuine * Jyothisha * . About my background I am not an Astrologer . As a Krishna-bhakta settled in a Muslim country , I am trying to promote Krishna-bhakti among the potential devotees . Also , I am participating in the functioning of five temples in Kerala . Bhagavan has given me opportunities to serve Him . I have been closely involved with " sattvic " Daivajnas who are pure practitioners of Vedic faith . Purity of Vedic faith in Kerala Please don't misunderstand me as a fanatic " Mallu " , for stating the following which is my firm conviction : Kerala is known as " God's own country " or " Parashurama-kshetram " because it's Vedic frame work was established by Bhagavan Parashuraman . Later Adi Shankaracharya developed and commissioned a self-sustaining Vedic system . Unlike north-India , this Vedic System in Kerala has not been corrupted by Islamic or Christian invaders . Namboodiris are maintaining the pure tradition of Vedic rituals . There are Adi-shankara created systems to ensure this . Because of this purity , the divinity of the Deities can be experienced by a faithful devotee . Where necessary , the Deities have pro-actively conveyed * Divine Will " through chosen mediums such as " Daivajnas " and Brahmana Tantriks . ( I can confirm this from my personal experiences related to Temple affairs) . Key Role of a genuine " Jyothishi " As a committed volunteer of vedic faith , I have noticed with appreciation the contributions of genuine " Jyothishis " . When a customer consults, the Jyothishi explains the status of " Daiva-krupa " and measures to improve the " sadhana* . Atonements for bad karma , may be Poojas and Vedic charity activities . ( And not wearing of precious stones or Yantras) . Recently , I was standing in the queue at a Jyothishis residence . An NRI in trouble was consulting in side . After verification, the Jyothishi stated " You haven't worshipped Bhagavan properly in your life . Your faith is very weak . Better you perform " Hare Krishna nama-japa " daily for at least one month . Situation will improve for you " . That NRI agreed his lack of faith and promised to do as advised . And I came to know later that the advice worked well for him . I am sure that he will remain a faithful Hindu till the end of his life . Accuracy of Vedic Astrology and Panchangas We have conducted numerous rituals according to *Panchagas* and have never faced problems . Bhagavan has mercifully forgiven the " human errors " in the *Panchangas*. ( Since Bhakti matters to Him more than Logic ) . In this " Kali-yugam " , we can not expect 100% accuracy and need to manage with what we have .. For examples the present day Acharyas are not extraordinary like our Ancient Rishis. …….. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.