Guest guest Posted April 25, 2008 Report Share Posted April 25, 2008 Dear econ, Thanks for your participation, To sum up your point is " SMALLER quantity of something is more potent, as demonstrated in homeopathy. So, perhaps the planets do affect us,… " . I will further add that little poisonous substance may end whole story. The point is that whether planet affects. We may have two answers yes or no. If we want to say yes then in support we can say that without Sun our existence it self is in question. Hence planet affects. (but scientifically only Sun is star hence it affects, but leave it, you can presume that planet afffects). Now next question is as to whether we can workout the affect. Yes, scientifically we know that planets have gravity, magnetic affect and star have cosmic energy…… which can be calculated. Now from above statement it can easily be concluded that planet affects hence astrology is correct. But wait, before that we have to find out as to whether their affect of gravity, magnetism, cosmic affect etc. have ever been considered in predictive astrology, while formulating various basic principles like sign lord, friendship, exalted, aspect etc……. Though answer is No, still we can defend that it makes no difference so long planet affects. OK Now finally we have to find out that whether any socalled affect of planet can affect my future. If an individual have no child, education, job, bankbalance, wife, position and so on ………….. then how socalled affect either scientifically known or unknown, can provide these shortcomings in the life. Which is the field of predictive astrology, which is being examined in the forum. Is their any astrological principle or system (Indian, western, Greek, Chinese, palmistry, Nadishastra (Balaji are you hearing), numerology, Vaastu and so on ……..) by which we can find out these events. Certainely No. Thus I am of the opinion that astrology (predictive) is myth, which is the title of my book (refer signature picture) and Ms Dipika ji is some what right when she says that it is fiction. In view of predictive part, my answer to the point that whether planet affects. I will say NO or in dilute sense I may say that prediction can not be concluded at least from the present set of astrological principles (you can also read " astrology a science or myth " file in file section). So there is no question whether Neptune, Pluto or Sun, Moon have affect or not. Main point is this that predictive astrology is bogus, which is based on planetary movement etc. because neither any planetary affect can change event of my life nor it is possible to disclose future with present set of principles. Heading of the msg has been changed for proper linking for SOA________. Please maintain it. Thanks Yours Sanat PS : I find that members are not providing a little brief about them. I will like to request the members specially who are writing msg. that please provide a little brief about age, qualification, profession, city etc. (as they may pl) so that responding member may form an image before answering and also take care for proper attention / answer. It will certainly associate interacting members. , econdude <econ_dude wrote: > > I was thinking that skeptics try to debunk astrology by saying that, say, Neptune, has a magnetic or energetic field that affects people on earth to such a small degree that Neptune could not have an effect on a person's actions on earth or in their natal chart. In nature, sometimes a SMALLER quantity of something is more potent, as demonstrated in homeopathy. So, perhaps the planets do affect us, and our physical and energetic systems do detect the energies from the planets and the signs that they're in, even though science cannot explain how or why at the current moment. The astrology that I've taught myself has emphasized how powerful Pluto is - but it's the smallest planet and the farthest away from earth! So smaller doesn't mean less powerful, and less in homeopathy, at least from my understanding, doesn't mean less potent. > > I know this is going to start a familiar debate, but I have often thought that science in its arrogance dismisses what it cannot yet explain, yet refuses to acknowledge that it's not sophisticated enough to explain what is happening to a person's system via the planets, for example. Rupert Sheldrake and other alternative authors are must reads. Best wishes, econ > > > > Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Mobile. Try it now. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 25, 2008 Report Share Posted April 25, 2008 so sun does affect our lives in earth.thank god for small mercies khe khe sb , " sanat2221 " <sanatkumar_jain wrote: > > Dear econ, > Thanks for your participation, > To sum up your point is " SMALLER quantity of something is more > potent, as demonstrated in homeopathy. So, perhaps the planets do > affect us,… " . I will further add that little poisonous substance may > end whole story. > > The point is that whether planet affects. We may have two answers yes > or no. > If we want to say yes then in support we can say that without Sun our > existence it self is in question. Hence planet affects. (but > scientifically only Sun is star hence it affects, but leave it, you > can presume that planet afffects). > > Now next question is as to whether we can workout the affect. Yes, > scientifically we know that planets have gravity, magnetic affect and > star have cosmic energy…… which can be calculated. > Now from above statement it can easily be concluded that planet > affects hence astrology is correct. > > But wait, before that we have to find out as to whether their affect > of gravity, magnetism, cosmic affect etc. have ever been considered > in predictive astrology, while formulating various basic principles > like sign lord, friendship, exalted, aspect etc……. Though answer is > No, still we can defend that it makes no difference so long planet > affects. OK > > Now finally we have to find out that whether any socalled affect of > planet can affect my future. If an individual have no child, > education, job, bankbalance, wife, position and so on ………….. then how > socalled affect either scientifically known or unknown, can provide > these shortcomings in the life. Which is the field of predictive > astrology, which is being examined in the forum. > > Is their any astrological principle or system (Indian, western, > Greek, Chinese, palmistry, Nadishastra (Balaji are you hearing), > numerology, Vaastu and so on ……..) by which we can find out these > events. Certainely No. Thus I am of the opinion that astrology > (predictive) is myth, which is the title of my book (refer signature > picture) and Ms Dipika ji is some what right when she says that it is > fiction. > > In view of predictive part, my answer to the point that whether > planet affects. I will say NO or in dilute sense I may say that > prediction can not be concluded at least from the present set of > astrological principles (you can also read " astrology a science or > myth " file in file section). So there is no question whether Neptune, > Pluto or Sun, Moon have affect or not. Main point is this that > predictive astrology is bogus, which is based on planetary movement > etc. because neither any planetary affect can change event of my life > nor it is possible to disclose future with present set of principles. > > Heading of the msg has been changed for proper linking for > SOA________. Please maintain it. > > Thanks > > Yours > Sanat > > PS : I find that members are not providing a little brief about them. > I will like to request the members specially who are writing msg. > that please provide a little brief about age, qualification, > profession, city etc. (as they may pl) so that responding member may > form an image before answering and also take care for proper > attention / answer. It will certainly associate interacting members. , econdude econ_dude@ > wrote: > > > > I was thinking that skeptics try to debunk astrology by saying > that, say, Neptune, has a magnetic or energetic field that affects > people on earth to such a small degree that Neptune could not have an > effect on a person's actions on earth or in their natal chart. In > nature, sometimes a SMALLER quantity of something is more potent, as > demonstrated in homeopathy. So, perhaps the planets do affect us, and > our physical and energetic systems do detect the energies from the > planets and the signs that they're in, even though science cannot > explain how or why at the current moment. The astrology that I've > taught myself has emphasized how powerful Pluto is - but it's the > smallest planet and the farthest away from earth! So smaller doesn't > mean less powerful, and less in homeopathy, at least from my > understanding, doesn't mean less potent. > > > > I know this is going to start a familiar debate, but I have often > thought that science in its arrogance dismisses what it cannot yet > explain, yet refuses to acknowledge that it's not sophisticated > enough to explain what is happening to a person's system via the > planets, for example. Rupert Sheldrake and other alternative authors > are must reads. Best wishes, econ > > > > > > > > Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Mobile. > Try it now. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.