Guest guest Posted January 18, 2006 Report Share Posted January 18, 2006 Respected Nirmalji, You clarification is very true. So using LK principals, every person will be having 2 horoscopes (charts) : One prepared from Samudrik Shastra (i.e. from hast rekha) and one prepared from basic horoscope altering house nos. starting from lagn as Khana #1. May be some of the planet positions will differ in both. I think you rightly pointed out and suggested that samudrik shastra will be accurate and prevail over all other. I am highly oblige for enlighten me. Thanks. M.R. GUPTA --- nirbhar <nirbhar wrote: > Respected Gupta Ji, > You are right that Budh and Sooraj always stay > besides each other. But > in LalKitab the Rahu and Ketu can be in one House > what to say about > Suraj and Budh. The LalKitab is a MahaGranth of > Astrology. In my > opinion, It consists of Samudrik Shastra, Jyostisha, > Shgun Shastra and > Vaastu, compiled and discussed in One book. In > Samudrik Shastra, These > Planets can be in one House or may fell appart up to > 12th House. The > Results from the Kundli made with Samudrik shastra > is stated to be > much correct and to the point. > That is why it is said earlier to keep aside > Parashari while learning > LalKitab. > Regards > Nirmal Kumar Bhardwaj > , " m.r. gupta " > <mrgupta_in> > wrote: > > > > Respected Gurujans, > > > > I have a doubt about expected position of sun in > khana > > no.1 or 2, when Budh is in Khana No.6. I > understand > > that as Budh and Sun are close by and either they > stay > > together or in neighbouring house only and > therefore, > > when Budh is in Khana No.6, then Sun can never be > in > > Khana No.1 or 2, in BASIC HOROSCOPE, as is > discussed > > here for detecting mistake. For LK horoscope > study, > > only rashi nos. are re-written starting from > 'Lagn' > > (House No.1) as Khana No.1. However, when Sun & > Budh > > are in neighboring houses, then in Varshphal only > such > > possibility takes place when Budh is in Khana > No.6, > > then Sun could be in Khana No.1 or2. Kindly clear > my > > doubt. Thanks. > > > > M.R. GUPTA > > > > --- Varun Trivedi <varun_trvd> wrote: > > > > > Mistake > in > > > Budh Khana # 6 > > > > > > > > > > > > 1952 Urdu ed : Page 558 > > > budh in khana # 6 > > > note # 12 , nek halat > > > > > > " raj yog , zar daulat aur dharma maryada ka > malik > > > aur jageerdar hoga - # 1 mein brahaspati, suraj > ya > > > shanishchar ho " > > > > > > > > > Arun Sanhita : Page 191 > > > Budh in khana # 6 > > > Nek halat , note # 12 > > > > > > " raj yog , dhan aur maryada ka swami > jageerdar > > > hoga > > > - jab > khana # > > > 1 mein surya ya brahaspati ya shani ho " > > > > > > > > > Lal Kitab : Prashthabhoomi aur vyakhya > > > > > > Pt. Krishna Ashant > > > Page #266 > > > Budh chhate ghar mein > > > > > > " budh no 6 ke samay khana # 1 mein surya , > > > brahaspati ya shani ho to ye vyakti ke liye raj > yog > > > hoga jis se uski daulat , jageer-jaydad barhe > gi " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Lal Kitab { pratham khand } By Keshava Nand > Bharti > > > > > > Budh khana # 6 > > > > > > Page 438 > > > Note # 11 > > > > > > " Raj yog , zar , daulat aur dharm maryada ka > > > malik aur zageerdar hoga - # 1 mein brahaspati , > > > suraj ya shanishchchar " > > > > > > > > > > > > 1952 Lal Kitab : Translated by G & V > > > Page 528 > > > > > > Note # 3 > > > Sun , Jupiter or Saturn in khana # 1 > > > > > > > royal combination, one will be wealthy, have > > > power, authority > > > and immovable property > > > > > > > > > Lal Kitab by R S Chiller > > > Page # 260 > > > > > > Mercury in the 6th house > > > > > > " If the mercury were in the 6th house and the > Sun > > > , Jupiter or Saturn occupies the 1st house; this > > > shall be raj yog. The native's wealth and > property > > > shall grow " > > > > > > > > > Lal Kitab by UC Mahajan > > > > > > Mercury in the 6th house > > > > > > Page # 206 > > > > > > Sun or Jupiter or Saturn in 1st : Raj Yog ; > rich > > > ; religious minded ; traditionalist ; landlord. > > > > > > > > > > > > The original 1952 urdu edition of the Lal > Kitab > > > and all other subsequent books consistently > maintain > > > that when the Mercury is in the 6th house and if > sun > > > or Jupiter or Saturn happen to be in the 1st > house , > > > it forms a Raj yog etc. > > > > > > Now compare the above statements with the last > > > line of the couplet for budh khana # 6 > > > > > > " sooraj shani guru dooje baithe , jageer > raja > > > dhan bharhta ho " [ 52ed page 557, Arun sanhita > 190} > > > > > > The introductory poem says if the sun , > Jupiter or > > > the Saturn are in the 2nd house , then `jageer > raja > > > dhan barhta ho'. > > > > > > The simple question is which of the two > statements > > > is correct. The initial statement where Pt. > > > Roopchand Joshi clearly states that if either of > > > these three planets is in the 2nd house then > > > `jageer, raja, dhan barhta ho' or the notes { or > > > tippani } where the same result are said to > occur if > > > either of these planets is in the 1st house. > > > > > > I find the poetic line " sooraj shani guru > dooje > > > baithe " to be correct and a misprint in the > notes > > > where it should be house # 2 instead of house # > 1. > > > > > > My reasons for accepting the poetic line , and > > > hence khana # 2 , to be correct are : > > > > > > { 1 }because the book further says, > > > - " khana # 2 ya shukra ki halat par budh ka > aam > > > asar hoga " > > > > > > - " teve mein jab bhi koi grah uttam ho > khaskar # > > > 2 ke ; budh fauran usi ki nakal karega " > > > > > > { 2 } Pt Roop Chand Joshi has been consistent > > > about khana # 2 . > > > > > > In 1939 Lal Kitab he says " jaise grah khana # > 2 > > > ke honge , budh ab vaisa hi phal dega " { Arun > > > Sanhita version page 199 } > > > > > > In the 1941 gutaka " jaise grah khana # 2 ke > honge > > > budh ab vaisa hi phal dega { sirf nek arthon ke > > > liye} " [ Arun sanhita version page 72 ] > > > > > > [ 3 ] Now let us further verify the position > of > > > the sun or the jupiter or Saturn in the 2nd > house in > > > the light of yet another line from the initial > > > poetry. The line says, > > > > > > " bhala guru shani sooraj baitha , yog raja > zar > > > mandir ho " > > > > > > Again the word `mandir' could refer to the 2nd > > > house. { it could also mean a temple , but the > word > > > mandir has been very often used for khana # 2} > > > > > > [ 4 ] Are these planets ` bhale' in the 2nd > house? > > > > > > Yes. It is the pakka ghar of Jupiter. Sun here > > > would be in the pakka ghar of his friend and > Saturn > > > here is called as " guru sharan … hasbe > haisiat > > > jeevan gujare, jeevit jab tak rahata ho " > > > > > > Therefore it is conclusively proved that > either of > > > these planets in the 2nd house will give the > results > > > which erroneously have been attributed to the > 1st > > > house in the notes . > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Send instant messages to your online friends > > > http://in.messenger. > > > > > > > > > > Tired of spam? Mail has the best spam > protection around > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.