Guest guest Posted June 2, 2005 Report Share Posted June 2, 2005 Dear Members, This is my first message and i have read almost all the messages but on some issues i disagree which i always discuss with Nirmal ji But, i have one question that i wanted to put in front of all the estemeed members.... and that is regarding the retrograde planets... and their effects on the prediction.... I have seen that Lal Kitab does not take the retrograde motion of the planets into consideration but in actual i have seen that the results predicted for a planet does not fully materialize if the planet is retrograde and infact sometimes the results are exactly opposite...... Please tell me about your opinion regarding this matter.... With Regards, Sumit Bansal Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2005 Report Share Posted June 2, 2005 Dear Sumit ji, One thing that all the classics and researches indicate to is that Retro planets are very strong and their beneficiance or maleficince will depend upon their nature, lordship and influences. You can consult BPHS, Phaldeepika, Sarvarth Chintamani, Brihat Jatak, Jaimini Sutra,etc for reference. I have noticed that their(planets) natural significations are always boosted due to retro motion. Awaiting response of all the learned members. Best regards Jaisumitbansal_81 <sumitbansal_81 wrote: Dear Members, This is my first message and i have read almost all the messages but on some issues i disagree which i always discuss with Nirmal ji But, i have one question that i wanted to put in front of all the estemeed members.... and that is regarding the retrograde planets... and their effects on the prediction.... I have seen that Lal Kitab does not take the retrograde motion of the planets into consideration but in actual i have seen that the results predicted for a planet does not fully materialize if the planet is retrograde and infact sometimes the results are exactly opposite...... Please tell me about your opinion regarding this matter.... With Regards, Sumit Bansal Discover Get on-the-go sports scores, stock quotes, news more. Check it out! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 6, 2005 Report Share Posted June 6, 2005 Dear Jai Nahata Ji, I am happy to have this one more occasion to meet you through this discussion. You are always correct in your explanations. We know that your knowledge is unfathomable and the aim of your reply in such a simple way is to give an opportunity to us to get into the discussion with out any hesitation. Thank you Ji for the same. As you have well said with quotes, the planets will definitely gain strength during retrograde motion but when? I mean at the beginning or middle or at the end of retrograde motion! Simple nature's logic is, pull back mean for a leap. So at the end of the retrograde motion it will have maximum strength, at the middle half strength and at the beginning not much because it may be started collecting and storing all its energy for the leap action. I am putting this view for your and other learned scholars correction please. With respects. Yours Sincerely, S.Dheenadayalan , Jai Nahata <nahata_jay> wrote: > Dear Sumit ji, > > One thing that all the classics and researches indicate to is that Retro planets are very strong and their beneficiance or maleficince will depend upon their nature, lordship and influences. > You can consult BPHS, Phaldeepika, Sarvarth Chintamani, Brihat Jatak, Jaimini Sutra,etc for reference. > I have noticed that their(planets) natural significations are always boosted due to retro motion. > Awaiting response of all the learned members. > > Best regards > > Jai > > sumitbansal_81 <sumitbansal_81> wrote: > Dear Members, > This is my first message and i have read almost all the messages > but on some issues i disagree which i always discuss with Nirmal ji > But, i have one question that i wanted to put in front of all the > estemeed members.... and that is regarding the retrograde planets... > and their effects on the prediction.... > I have seen that Lal Kitab does not take the retrograde motion of > the planets into consideration but in actual i have seen that the > results predicted for a planet does not fully materialize if the > planet is retrograde and infact sometimes the results are exactly > opposite...... > > Please tell me about your opinion regarding this matter.... > With Regards, > Sumit Bansal > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 6, 2005 Report Share Posted June 6, 2005 Dear Dheendayalan Ji, I dont feel there is any instance of seperate effect of retrograde planet, described in Lalkitab. You may find tonnes of articles on this subject in Vedic astrology section. This forum is discussing only lalkitab therfore, I appeal all members to please raise querries on LalKitab Only Best regards Nirmal Kumar Bhardwaj ***** I am busy these days because of official occupancy, so excuse me for less appearance.**************** , " dheena0104 " <dheena0104> wrote: > Dear Jai Nahata Ji, > > I am happy to have this one more occasion to meet you through this > discussion. You are always correct in your explanations. We know > that your knowledge is unfathomable and the aim of your reply in > such a simple way is to give an opportunity to us to get into the > discussion with out any hesitation. > > Thank you Ji for the same. > > As you have well said with quotes, the planets will definitely gain > strength during retrograde motion but when? I mean at the beginning > or middle or at the end of retrograde motion! > > Simple nature's logic is, pull back mean for a leap. So at the end > of the retrograde motion it will have maximum strength, at the > middle half strength and at the beginning not much because it may be > started collecting and storing all its energy for the leap action. > > I am putting this view for your and other learned scholars > correction please. > > With respects. > > Yours Sincerely, > S.Dheenadayalan > > > > > > > > > > , Jai Nahata <nahata_jay> > wrote: > > Dear Sumit ji, > > > > One thing that all the classics and researches indicate to is that > Retro planets are very strong and their beneficiance or maleficince > will depend upon their nature, lordship and influences. > > You can consult BPHS, Phaldeepika, Sarvarth Chintamani, Brihat > Jatak, Jaimini Sutra,etc for reference. > > I have noticed that their(planets) natural significations are > always boosted due to retro motion. > > Awaiting response of all the learned members. > > > > Best regards > > > > Jai > > > > sumitbansal_81 <sumitbansal_81> wrote: > > Dear Members, > > This is my first message and i have read almost all the > messages > > but on some issues i disagree which i always discuss with Nirmal ji > > But, i have one question that i wanted to put in front of all > the > > estemeed members.... and that is regarding the retrograde > planets... > > and their effects on the prediction.... > > I have seen that Lal Kitab does not take the retrograde motion > of > > the planets into consideration but in actual i have seen that the > > results predicted for a planet does not fully materialize if the > > planet is retrograde and infact sometimes the results are exactly > > opposite...... > > > > Please tell me about your opinion regarding this matter.... > > With Regards, > > Sumit Bansal > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 6, 2005 Report Share Posted June 6, 2005 My understanding is that Retrograde motion is not in reality the planet doing a reverse jig... rather, it appears to be doing a reverse jig. Hence, question of leap or coiling for a leap may not arise. bye Sheikh Pervez Hameed On Behalf Of dheena0104 06 June 2005 17:05 Re: Retrograde planets and their effects Dear Jai Nahata Ji, I am happy to have this one more occasion to meet you through this discussion. You are always correct in your explanations. We know that your knowledge is unfathomable and the aim of your reply in such a simple way is to give an opportunity to us to get into the discussion with out any hesitation. Thank you Ji for the same. As you have well said with quotes, the planets will definitely gain strength during retrograde motion but when? I mean at the beginning or middle or at the end of retrograde motion! Simple nature's logic is, pull back mean for a leap. So at the end of the retrograde motion it will have maximum strength, at the middle half strength and at the beginning not much because it may be started collecting and storing all its energy for the leap action. I am putting this view for your and other learned scholars correction please. With respects. Yours Sincerely, S.Dheenadayalan , Jai Nahata <nahata_jay> wrote: > Dear Sumit ji, > > One thing that all the classics and researches indicate to is that Retro planets are very strong and their beneficiance or maleficince will depend upon their nature, lordship and influences. > You can consult BPHS, Phaldeepika, Sarvarth Chintamani, Brihat Jatak, Jaimini Sutra,etc for reference. > I have noticed that their(planets) natural significations are always boosted due to retro motion. > Awaiting response of all the learned members. > > Best regards > > Jai > > sumitbansal_81 <sumitbansal_81> wrote: > Dear Members, > This is my first message and i have read almost all the messages > but on some issues i disagree which i always discuss with Nirmal ji > But, i have one question that i wanted to put in front of all the > estemeed members.... and that is regarding the retrograde planets... > and their effects on the prediction.... > I have seen that Lal Kitab does not take the retrograde motion of > the planets into consideration but in actual i have seen that the > results predicted for a planet does not fully materialize if the > planet is retrograde and infact sometimes the results are exactly > opposite...... > > Please tell me about your opinion regarding this matter.... > With Regards, > Sumit Bansal > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.