Gutka; strange messages-2 for Bhatia ji

[Guest guest]

Respected bhatia ji; u have written about 10 pages exclusively to

prove that pt. Rup Chand Joshi didn't take any fee for analyzing a

tewa. but i have proof that u returned the request of a gentleman

Mr.Chakravarty phone + 19565841918; who also resides in USA because

he couldn,t pay ur fee of 3oo dollars. either practice what u say or

don't preach.

 

kulbir bains

 

lalkitab , " kulbirbains " <kulbirbains

wrote:

>

> Respected Bhatia ji, a person of ur calibre is supposed to write

in a

> responsible manner.I have just read ur forwarding message and also

> message at the end gutka of prabhakar ji. u r terming Arun as

Sarthi

> of Ravana. god bless u if u don't have that much knowledge of

> mythology. And the fairy tales u have written in theend are more

> suitable for grannies to tell their children. there are some other

> people who belong to that area and they have something totally

> different to tell some of them are of ur age group and were

> closely related to pandit ji. they met him daily. while u had a

few

> occassions.don't believe me ask prabhakr ji.

> And Nirmal ji what do u mean that u have a booklet explaining

phrases,

> idioms etc which u will give on request. either give it straight

away

> or conceal it. why this viel of secrecy and funda of personal

> contacts. at this point i think umesh was true. either u r into

the

> bussiness of selling sequels or creating ur personal fiefdom.

> where has ur ideals gone.

>

> kulbir bains

>

[Guest guest]

Dear Kulbir ji,

 

What it has to do with the topic? This is a Lal Kitab learning and

discussion forum and we should not discuss whether somebody accepted

or refused some money. It is none of the forum's business.

 

Thanks & Regards,

 

Punit Pandey

 

lalkitab , " kulbirbains " <kulbirbains

wrote:

>

> Respected bhatia ji; u have written about 10 pages exclusively to

> prove that pt. Rup Chand Joshi didn't take any fee for analyzing a

> tewa. but i have proof that u returned the request of a gentleman

> Mr.Chakravarty phone + 19565841918; who also resides in USA because

> he couldn,t pay ur fee of 3oo dollars. either practice what u say

or

> don't preach.

>

> kulbir bains

>

> lalkitab , " kulbirbains " <kulbirbains@>

> wrote:

> >

> > Respected Bhatia ji, a person of ur calibre is supposed to write

> in a

> > responsible manner.I have just read ur forwarding message and

also

> > message at the end gutka of prabhakar ji. u r terming Arun as

> Sarthi

> > of Ravana. god bless u if u don't have that much knowledge of

> > mythology. And the fairy tales u have written in theend are more

> > suitable for grannies to tell their children. there are some

other

> > people who belong to that area and they have something totally

> > different to tell some of them are of ur age group and were

> > closely related to pandit ji. they met him daily. while u had a

> few

> > occassions.don't believe me ask prabhakr ji.

> > And Nirmal ji what do u mean that u have a booklet explaining

> phrases,

> > idioms etc which u will give on request. either give it straight

> away

> > or conceal it. why this viel of secrecy and funda of personal

> > contacts. at this point i think umesh was true. either u r into

> the

> > bussiness of selling sequels or creating ur personal fiefdom.

> > where has ur ideals gone.

> >

> > kulbir bains

> >

>

[Guest guest]

Dear Kulbir Jee,

I thought that as a legal person, you perhaps would have known that you can't

be all-in-one, the prosecutor, the judge, the jury and give a one-sided verdict

(unless, of course, you are from mahakmaa-e- police.)

 

I don't owe it to you or to anyone else, as to how much I charge, why I charge

and what I do with that money. If a private Email comes to me, it is my personal

affair. I have openly announced in this forum (and repeatedly) that if a

personal Email comes to me from people who are not known to me, I may charge

money for it or handle the Email whichever way suits my fancy. And what I do

with that money, if ever collected, is between me and my maker who watches every

move of mine (I am verrry aware of that, thanks for reminding me though.)

 

Incidentally, the person about whom you have gone to bat didn't even have the

basic decency of calling me. If he were needy enough, he would have made

repeated attempts to call me or leave messages, he had my phone number (I had

mis-typed my phone number to him earlier but then I corrected my mistake) - he

jumped the gun and so did you.

 

For the gutkaa, I wrote whatever I thought would be relevant and interesting.

It was up to the editors of the gutka edition to reject or edit my writing.

Please talk to them about your resentments and frustrations. Mahapurushon kee

jeewanee daadi naani kee kahaanee kee tarah hee kahee jaatee hai. This is how

the legends are remembered.

 

And, WHERE did I EVER claim that I met Pt Jee everyday or every week or every

month or even EVERY year? I was living " saat samunder paar " from that mahapurush

and visited him only when I visited India. For sure though, I do keep in touch

with Pt Som Dutt jee. He has provided me better information about Pt jee than

those who claim to have been with him on " daily basis. "

 

Actually, here is my suggestion to you and all your friends who met Pt jee on

" daily basis. " YOU have the golden opportunity to relate the experiences of

those who met Pt jee on " daily basis " May I submit a humble request to you to

present, in detail, those experiences to all the forum members? Will you please

take the initiative for the sake of all of us LalKitab lovers?

 

I hope that soon you will start a series of articles about Pt Rup Chand jee.

We are all waiting quite eagerly. Kindly don't disappoint us.

 

With warm regards and best wishes.

 

Sincerely,

Rajinder Bhatia

 

 

kulbirbains kulbirbains

 

Respected bhatia ji; u have written about 10 pages exclusively to

prove that pt. Rup Chand Joshi didn't take any fee for analyzing a

tewa. but i have proof that u returned the request of a gentleman

Mr.Chakravarty phone + 19565841918; who also resides in USA because

he couldn,t pay ur fee of 3oo dollars. either practice what u say or

don't preach.

 

kulbir bains

 

 

 

 

 

Be a better Heartthrob. Get better relationship answers from someone who knows.

Answers - Check it out.

 

 

[Guest guest]

Respected bhatia ji; the authority u hold on lalkitab is evident

from the fact that u wrote something wrong in ur article and

group dared not touch it or review it and published it

as it is. so much so that prabahakr ji repeated the same mistake in

his message.

there are so many books on lalkitab with the contents that i don't

approve but they don't hurt me. but ur message did when u wrote

SAARTHI OF RAVANA and by any stretch of imagination it was not a

typing or clerical mistake.

of course i sent my resentment and frustration to but

they didn't bother to approve my message what to ask of reply.

i know there are no free lunches available anywhere and whatever u

charge or donate is ur personal matter but when u prophise on a

subject then ur individival acts comes under survelience of public

domain. it would have been better had u elaborated on this issue in

ur message itself and written on the set of ethics for lk

practitioners

..

there are many myths associated with great people like akbar-birbal,

maharana pratap. rani of jhansi etc etc but all of them are not

true. the concept of atishioti dilutes the facts and thus pollutes.

the question here is as to how are these folk stories which have no

proof are associated with lk principles. i am searching for it and

shall share whatever i feel is in accordance or furthers lk idealogy.

i respect u a lot what i am is questioning is not applicable

personal to u as an individual but to the ideology u represent.i

konw ur finacial status and also of ur forefathers and the work ur

family does for charity so much so that ur family is responsible for

revival of the books but what about bthose who don't know about

these facts and know u only as a lalkitab practitioner and scholar.

kulbir bains

 

lalkitab , Rajinder Bhatia

<rajinderbhatia2002 wrote:

>

>

>

> Dear Kulbir Jee,

> I thought that as a legal person, you perhaps would have known

that you can't be all-in-one, the prosecutor, the judge, the jury

and give a one-sided verdict (unless, of course, you are from

mahakmaa-e- police.)

>

> I don't owe it to you or to anyone else, as to how much I

charge, why I charge and what I do with that money. If a private

Email comes to me, it is my personal affair. I have openly announced

in this forum (and repeatedly) that if a personal Email comes to me

from people who are not known to me, I may charge money for it or

handle the Email whichever way suits my fancy. And what I do with

that money, if ever collected, is between me and my maker who

watches every move of mine (I am verrry aware of that, thanks for

reminding me though.)

>

> Incidentally, the person about whom you have gone to bat didn't

even have the basic decency of calling me. If he were needy enough,

he would have made repeated attempts to call me or leave messages,

he had my phone number (I had mis-typed my phone number to him

earlier but then I corrected my mistake) - he jumped the gun and so

did you.

>

> For the gutkaa, I wrote whatever I thought would be relevant and

interesting. It was up to the editors of the gutka edition to reject

or edit my writing. Please talk to them about your resentments and

frustrations. Mahapurushon kee jeewanee daadi naani kee kahaanee kee

tarah hee kahee jaatee hai. This is how the legends are remembered.

>

> And, WHERE did I EVER claim that I met Pt Jee everyday or every

week or every month or even EVERY year? I was living " saat samunder

paar " from that mahapurush and visited him only when I visited

India. For sure though, I do keep in touch with Pt Som Dutt jee. He

has provided me better information about Pt jee than those who claim

to have been with him on " daily basis. "

>

> Actually, here is my suggestion to you and all your friends who

met Pt jee on " daily basis. " YOU have the golden opportunity to

relate the experiences of those who met Pt jee on " daily basis " May

I submit a humble request to you to present, in detail, those

experiences to all the forum members? Will you please take the

initiative for the sake of all of us LalKitab lovers?

>

> I hope that soon you will start a series of articles about Pt

Rup Chand jee.

> We are all waiting quite eagerly. Kindly don't disappoint us.

>

> With warm regards and best wishes.

>

> Sincerely,

> Rajinder Bhatia

>

>

> kulbirbains kulbirbains

>

> Respected bhatia ji; u have written about 10 pages exclusively

to

> prove that pt. Rup Chand Joshi didn't take any fee for analyzing a

> tewa. but i have proof that u returned the request of a gentleman

> Mr.Chakravarty phone + 19565841918; who also resides in USA

because

> he couldn,t pay ur fee of 3oo dollars. either practice what u say

or

> don't preach.

>

> kulbir bains

>

>

>

>

>

> Be a better Heartthrob. Get better relationship answers from

someone who knows.

> Answers - Check it out.

>

>