On Lal Kitab Forum

[Guest guest]

Dear Group Members

I am new to this group and I had to study the archive mails to get a

deep insight to the subject of Lal kitab. I noticed that all the

members have done helping and doing good deeds for the people but we

still need to have knowledge and education through the help service.

I hope tht following facts will be of help to all members and

moderators.

1. The forum needs to get problems from people so that there will

be discussions and education. But I think that we need feedback from

the persons to whom the upaye was given. What is the response to

upaye? what happened to the problem? When ? etc. which is like a

follow up in medical fields and then only the forum members can gain

knowledge. How will we make a kind of Format in accepting questions

to get feedback?

2. I have studied three English translated Lal Kitab books. As usual

in the field of Astrology they have many confusional, repetitive and

non releavant points. I hope that this forum can only give practical

teaching based on case studies. So I think we need to have a

structured format of analysis to be compiled and used in answers. I

fully understand that the subject of Lal Kitab is a spiritual one. It

is of no doubt tht the analysis depends much only on the background

knowledge and hand on experience but also personal factors of the

analyst like Sadana experiences and intuitions which I accepts to

play a big role. However we need to frmulate a stuctured format of

analysis. In traditional Astrology The tablets of KN Rao like DARES,

CBI were very useful. We also have Prof. VK Chowdry's SA system where

the format of " how to analyse a horoscope in three minutes " and

likes made it easy to understand by the learners.

3. The part of mathmetical based ones like Lal kitab Worksheet, hand

books were presented to the forum and we have to congratulate the

authors. I think it is now the time to go to Standard Formatted

Analysis. If to give an example

a. Particulars of the chart and planetary positions

b. planetary aspects

c. planetary characters

d. Analysis on problems based on that.

This can be used both on Natal and Vashapal. The only other aspect

left is the verification of Birth or Chart which may be an

individualised one but even in that case we can have knowledge about

it if the discussing person can work out a system like what KN Rao

has done in birth rectification in his book Vimshottari Dasa. Once we

have the basic anlysis format we can expand and use it and the

propagation of the Science of Lal kitab will be more effective. Then

also we can have collected cases with orientation to further

research. This work can be done by joint effort of all the Lal Kitab

Specialists and will someone started organising about it if majority

of the members think it to be beneficial.

Sincerely Yours

Dr Aung Chein

Yangon, Myanmar