Fine tuning dual marriage research: Reply to a new logic

[Guest guest]

Dear Mr. Rao, I am very sorry to say that this logic doesnt make any sense at all. When a woman is married to a man, we are judging the man's chart for the woman's life. Then what shall we do when this woman will divorce this man?? What we would do if she remarries a different man?? Shall we now judge this new man's chart or shall we tell her to get her ex-husband's birth details?? Further complication will arise if this woman marries for the third time (which is quite common is US). Which husband's chart shall we ask her to get in order to judge her life events?? What do we do for those woman who remain spinsters throughout their life?? For the benefit of our group members, may I request you to kindly tell the name of the classical text and the concerned chapter where such a rule is expounded. I would request group members to

throw informed opinions on this for our common learning. Regards, AndrewYogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Andrew, In addition to Mr.Raichur's explanation,may I also add,that in Vedic Astrology,after a female is married,only her husband's chart is generally examined,except perhaps in Horary Astrology,where a female married or not,or widowed/divorced can proffer a query along with a number (1-249)..in my humble opinion... With best wishes, L.Y.Rao. GOOD LUCK ! andrew dutta <andrewinfinitum >KP System Friday, 6 October, 2006 8:47:04 AM Fine tuning dual marriage research Dear Raichur ji, Tin Win ji and all esteemed members, The research on 100 birth charts about dual marraige is highly impressive. The finding of a new rule is equally important for the progress of practice theory in astrology.

However, over the last few days a couple of thoughts came in to my mind which I would like to share with all of you in order to get deeper insights. 1) Can birth charts be divided in to groups of males and females to see how far the rules apply to each gender? This may enable us to find whether rules vary for the two genders for dual marriage. If so, to what extent and what could be the possible social explanations. 2) Can charts also be divided into groups of people (males and fermales) who married second time due to demise of the partner and those who married due to divorce or separation. I am sure research through such divisions would yield superb insights. 3) We would require more birth charts to make such groupings and make statisitcally valid tests. For this I would request our list members to send birth details of dual

marriages for males and females due to demise and divorce from their own collections. Soemhow I have a feeling that if research is done on these lines, greater insight would make our astrological dictums more robust and scientific. I wish I had some software and programing knowledge to run these tests. Nevertheless, heartfelt thanks to Raichur ji et al. Regards, Andrew Prof. Andrew Dutta Faculty, ICFAI Institute For Management Teachers 6-3-352/2 & 3, 3rd Floor, Astral Heights, Road No. 1, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad 500034, India. Tel: 91-4023430254/ 55 Extn: 324 Fax: 91-4023430468 Cell: 0-0-98666 20483 Get your email and more, right on the new .com Find out what India is talking about on - Answers India Send FREE SMS to your friend's mobile from Messenger Version 8. Get it NOW

Everyone is raving about the all-new Mail.

[Guest guest]

Dear Mr.Andrew Dutta,

Firstly,I have said "generally examined"... only drawing your attention to the prevalent custom,and certainly not making it an absolute rule,it was only a mention of what Vedic Astrology used to observe...however it certainly does not debar a married woman's or any kind of woman's,horoscope from being judged...

Secondly,it seems to be thought that such cases may be a common occurence abroad,but, in ancient India officially, a rich person a noble or a commoner, was 'sanctioned' and allowed to keep a concubine,by the then society, there was no stigma attached to it...Even today among Adivasi Societies and sociieties in the Terai Region of Northern India,Eastern India etc.,and in Kerala,among the Nairs/Menons (Ezhavas),a matriarchial Society prevails...

and a woman can keep as many men as she pleases...!

Indian Society became prudish during ther British Raj,and adopted Victorian values in Society...and astrologers were aware of these customs,then prevailing...

Vedic astrology still preferred to treat a married woman's husband's horoscope more important and relevant...perhaps after Yagnavalkya and his totally "managed" defeat of Gargi,in a debate lasting 3 log days,wher ALL the voters were MEN...! After which women were given an inferior status as compared to her husband...! !

However, let that be...

You have a point,and I contibute to your view that everybody's horoscope should be examined whenever possible...for a detailed study and individual effects etc...

Space constraints force all of us to be brief...and hence sometimes everything that one wants to say cannot be said...and brief notes could cause such misunderstandings...

With best wishes,

L.Y.Rao.

 

andrew dutta <andrewinfinitum Sent: Saturday, 7 October, 2006 8:59:27 AMRe: Fine tuning dual marriage research: Reply to a new logic

 

 

Dear Mr. Rao,

I am very sorry to say that this logic doesnt make any sense at all.

 

When a woman is married to a man, we are judging the man's chart for the woman's life. Then what shall we do when this woman will divorce this man?? What we would do if she remarries a different man?? Shall we now judge this new man's chart or shall we tell her to get her ex-husband's birth details?? Further complication will arise if this woman marries for the third time (which is quite common is US). Which husband's chart shall we ask her to get in order to judge her life events??

 

What do we do for those woman who remain spinsters throughout their life??

 

For the benefit of our group members, may I request you to kindly tell the name of the classical text and the concerned chapter where such a rule is expounded.

 

I would request group members to throw informed opinions on this for our common learning.

 

Regards,

 

AndrewYogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 (AT) (DOT) co.in> wrote:

 

 

 

 

Dear Andrew,

In addition to Mr.Raichur's explanation, may I also add,that in Vedic Astrology,after a female is married,only her husband's chart is generally examined,except perhaps in Horary Astrology,where a female married or not,or widowed/divorced can proffer a query along with a number (1-249)..in my humble opinion...

With best wishes,

L.Y.Rao.

GOOD LUCK !

andrew dutta <andrewinfinitum@ >KP System <@gro ups.com>Friday, 6 October, 2006 8:47:04 AM Fine tuning dual marriage research

 

 

Dear Raichur ji, Tin Win ji and all esteemed members,

 

The research on 100 birth charts about dual marraige is highly impressive. The finding of a new rule is equally important for the progress of practice theory in astrology.

 

However, over the last few days a couple of thoughts came in to my mind which I would like to share with all of you in order to get deeper insights.

 

1) Can birth charts be divided in to groups of males and females to see how far the rules apply to each gender? This may enable us to find whether rules vary for the two genders for dual marriage. If so, to what extent and what could be the possible social explanations.

 

2) Can charts also be divided into groups of people (males and fermales) who married second time due to demise of the partner and those who married due to divorce or separation. I am sure research through such divisions would yield superb insights.

 

3) We would require more birth charts to make such groupings and make statisitcally valid tests. For this I would request our list members to send birth details of dual marriages for males and females due to demise and divorce from their own collections.

 

Soemhow I have a feeling that if research is done on these lines, greater insight would make our astrological dictums more robust and scientific. I wish I had some software and programing knowledge to run these tests.

 

Nevertheless, heartfelt thanks to Raichur ji et al.

 

Regards,

 

Andrew

 

Prof. Andrew Dutta

Faculty,

ICFAI Institute For Management Teachers

6-3-352/2 & 3, 3rd Floor, Astral Heights,

Road No. 1, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad 500034, India.

Tel: 91-4023430254/ 55 Extn: 324

Fax: 91-4023430468

Cell: 0-0-98666 20483

 

 

Get your email and more, right on the new .com

 

 

Find out what India is talking about on - Answers India Send FREE SMS to your friend's mobile from Messenger Version 8. Get it NOW

 

 

Everyone is raving about the all-new Mail.

 

 

Find out what India is talking about on - Answers India Send FREE SMS to your friend's mobile from Messenger Version 8. Get it NOW