Positioning of planets in a house (Bhav)

[Guest guest]

Dear Learned Members,

 

I will request you to throw a light on positioning of planets in a very

typical situation such as following.

 

Ascendent: Cancer 7 degree 6 minute (house Lord Moon, Starlord Saturn Sublord

Mercury)

 

Jupiter in Cancer (5 degree 58 minutes) (Starlord Saturn Sublord Mercury)

Moon in Cancer (5 degrees 43 minutes) (starlord Saturn Sublord Mercury)

 

KP Niryana Bhavchalit Kundali suggersts that Moon and Jupiter be posted in

12th Bhav. Kshetra Kundali KP suggests that these two planets must be posited in

1st house.

 

My opinion is that because all the three (ascendents, Moon and Jupiter) have

same starlord (Saturn) and same sublord (Mercury), these two panets should be

posited in 1st house in Cancer and NOT in 12th house. Please advise your

opinions.

 

Regards,

 

Yatendra Sharma

 

 

 

 

 

 

On 7

360°: Your own space to share what you want with who you want!

 

 

[Guest guest]

Dear Mr Sharma

In the case cited, Moon and Jupiter are within 3.33 deg of the Ascendent Cusp.

In such cases the planets will give results as though they are in the 1st

house.

So they should be placed in 1st house for getting signification of houses

good luck

 

 

Yatendra Sharma <sharmay1953 wrote:

Dear Learned Members,

 

I will request you to throw a light on positioning of planets in a very

typical situation such as following.

 

Ascendent: Cancer 7 degree 6 minute (house Lord Moon, Starlord Saturn Sublord

Mercury)

 

Jupiter in Cancer (5 degree 58 minutes) (Starlord Saturn Sublord Mercury)

Moon in Cancer (5 degrees 43 minutes) (starlord Saturn Sublord Mercury)

 

KP Niryana Bhavchalit Kundali suggersts that Moon and Jupiter be posted in

12th Bhav. Kshetra Kundali KP suggests that these two planets must be posited in

1st house.

 

My opinion is that because all the three (ascendents, Moon and Jupiter) have

same starlord (Saturn) and same sublord (Mercury), these two panets should be

posited in 1st house in Cancer and NOT in 12th house. Please advise your

opinions.

 

Regards,

 

Yatendra Sharma

 

 

 

 

 

 

On 7

360°: Your own space to share what you want with who you want!

 

 

[Guest guest]

Thanks Anantji. I greatly appreciate that. I think this will be a lesson to all

and we can take it as a thumb rule. God bless you.

 

All the best and with warmest regards,

 

Yatendra Sharma

 

 

anant raichur <raichurar wrote:

Dear Mr Sharma

In the case cited, Moon and Jupiter are within 3.33 deg of the Ascendent Cusp.

In such cases the planets will give results as though they are in the 1st

house.

So they should be placed in 1st house for getting signification of houses

good luck

 

 

Yatendra Sharma <sharmay1953 wrote:

Dear Learned Members,

 

I will request you to throw a light on positioning of planets in a very

typical situation such as following.

 

Ascendent: Cancer 7 degree 6 minute (house Lord Moon, Starlord Saturn Sublord

Mercury)

 

Jupiter in Cancer (5 degree 58 minutes) (Starlord Saturn Sublord Mercury)

Moon in Cancer (5 degrees 43 minutes) (starlord Saturn Sublord Mercury)

 

KP Niryana Bhavchalit Kundali suggersts that Moon and Jupiter be posted in

12th Bhav. Kshetra Kundali KP suggests that these two planets must be posited in

1st house.

 

My opinion is that because all the three (ascendents, Moon and Jupiter) have

same starlord (Saturn) and same sublord (Mercury), these two panets should be

posited in 1st house in Cancer and NOT in 12th house. Please advise your

opinions.

 

Regards,

 

Yatendra Sharma

 

 

 

 

 

 

On 7

360°: Your own space to share what you want with who you want!

 

 

[Guest guest]

Dear Shri Anant ji,

Do we always take this 3.33 degree reference for calculating

planets.If the planet comes in 7th house and taking 3.33 factor it

comes in 8th house then we should think it as placed in 8th only??

All the significators will change related to this planet..

 

Thanks

Amit

 

 

 

, anant raichur <raichurar wrote:

>

> Dear Mr Sharma

> In the case cited, Moon and Jupiter are within 3.33 deg of the

Ascendent Cusp.

> In such cases the planets will give results as though they are in

the 1st house.

> So they should be placed in 1st house for getting signification of

houses

> good luck

>

>

> Yatendra Sharma <sharmay1953 wrote:

> Dear Learned Members,

>

> I will request you to throw a light on positioning of planets in a

very typical situation such as following.

>

> Ascendent: Cancer 7 degree 6 minute (house Lord Moon, Starlord

Saturn Sublord Mercury)

>

> Jupiter in Cancer (5 degree 58 minutes) (Starlord Saturn Sublord

Mercury)

> Moon in Cancer (5 degrees 43 minutes) (starlord Saturn Sublord

Mercury)

>

> KP Niryana Bhavchalit Kundali suggersts that Moon and Jupiter be

posted in 12th Bhav. Kshetra Kundali KP suggests that these two

planets must be posited in 1st house.

>

> My opinion is that because all the three (ascendents, Moon and

Jupiter) have same starlord (Saturn) and same sublord (Mercury), these

two panets should be posited in 1st house in Cancer and NOT in 12th

house. Please advise your opinions.

>

> Regards,

>

> Yatendra Sharma

>

>

>

>

>

>

> On 7

> 360°: Your own space to share what you want with who you want!

>

>

[Guest guest]

dear sirs

i think slow moving planets should be exempted from this 3.33 degree

theory.it is effective if we apply this to fast moving planets.

for slow moving planets we can take it in the same bhava if they are

posited in the same sub.

counter ideas entertained

b.indira , " ak_131 "

<agrawal.amitk wrote:

>

> Dear Shri Anant ji,

> Do we always take this 3.33 degree reference for calculating

> planets.If the planet comes in 7th house and taking 3.33 factor it

> comes in 8th house then we should think it as placed in 8th only??

> All the significators will change related to this planet..

>

> Thanks

> Amit

>

>

>

> , anant raichur <raichurar@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear Mr Sharma

> > In the case cited, Moon and Jupiter are within 3.33 deg of the

> Ascendent Cusp.

> > In such cases the planets will give results as though they are

in

> the 1st house.

> > So they should be placed in 1st house for getting signification

of

> houses

> > good luck

> >

> >

> > Yatendra Sharma <sharmay1953@> wrote:

> > Dear Learned Members,

> >

> > I will request you to throw a light on positioning of planets

in a

> very typical situation such as following.

> >

> > Ascendent: Cancer 7 degree 6 minute (house Lord Moon, Starlord

> Saturn Sublord Mercury)

> >

> > Jupiter in Cancer (5 degree 58 minutes) (Starlord Saturn Sublord

> Mercury)

> > Moon in Cancer (5 degrees 43 minutes) (starlord Saturn Sublord

> Mercury)

> >

> > KP Niryana Bhavchalit Kundali suggersts that Moon and Jupiter be

> posted in 12th Bhav. Kshetra Kundali KP suggests that these two

> planets must be posited in 1st house.

> >

> > My opinion is that because all the three (ascendents, Moon and

> Jupiter) have same starlord (Saturn) and same sublord (Mercury),

these

> two panets should be posited in 1st house in Cancer and NOT in 12th

> house. Please advise your opinions.

> >

> > Regards,

> >

> > Yatendra Sharma

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > On 7

> > 360°: Your own space to share what you want with who you want!

> >

> >

[Guest guest]

dear amit

That is what I do, and indicate in my SW. You test a few cases for your self.

Some take effects of 7th and also 8th.

good luck

 

 

 

 

How low will we go? Check out Messenger’s low PC-to-Phone call rates.

 

 

[Guest guest]

REMARKS OF SHRI RAICHUR in Msg# 2700, 2665, 1590 of this group

 

KP READER IV page 108 " What does Rahu denoye ? Rahu is posited in

Thula very near the 11 th cusp;--- " page 107 Rahu 13-09 & XI cusp 15-

38-42 both in Thula

 

AN EXAMPLE in " K.P. in Every Corner " by T. Rajendra Kumar, KP &

Astrology Yearbook 2003, page 46: Jupiter (Cp 10-22) is actually in

5H (since 6th cusp is Cp 11-32), but it signifies 6H as per " ORB

Theory " (which was proved with cases presented in magazines like KP

& Astrology and The Times of Astrology) saying a planet within 1 or

2 deg behind the cusp of a house and no other planet in the

following house, gains the significance of the following house, ie.

Jupiter gains significance of 6H and loses signification of 5H where

Jupiter actually located since there is no planet in 6H.

 

 

 

, anant raichur <raichurar

wrote:

>

> dear amit

> That is what I do, and indicate in my SW. You test a few cases

for your self.

> Some take effects of 7th and also 8th.

> good luck

>

>

>

>

> How low will we go? Check out Messenger's low PC-to-Phone

call rates.

>

>

[Guest guest]

Dear Bindira

The rule is not a theorey, but is evolved after experience on a number of

charts.

 

Try out, and if you find that Slow moving planets do not obey this rule, the

rule can be modified.

 

good luck

 

bindira2003 <bindira2003 wrote: dear sirs

i think slow moving planets should be exempted from this 3.33 degree

theory.it is effective if we apply this to fast moving planets.

for slow moving planets we can take it in the same bhava if they are

posited in the same sub.

counter ideas entertained

b.indira , " ak_131 "

<agrawal.amitk wrote:

>

> Dear Shri Anant ji,

> Do we always take this 3.33 degree reference for calculating

> planets.If the planet comes in 7th house and taking 3.33 factor it

> comes in 8th house then we should think it as placed in 8th only??

> All the significators will change related to this planet..

>

> Thanks

> Amit

>

>

>

> , anant raichur <raichurar@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear Mr Sharma

> > In the case cited, Moon and Jupiter are within 3.33 deg of the

> Ascendent Cusp.

> > In such cases the planets will give results as though they are

in

> the 1st house.

> > So they should be placed in 1st house for getting signification

of

> houses

> > good luck

> >

> >

> > Yatendra Sharma <sharmay1953@> wrote:

> > Dear Learned Members,

> >

> > I will request you to throw a light on positioning of planets

in a

> very typical situation such as following.

> >

> > Ascendent: Cancer 7 degree 6 minute (house Lord Moon, Starlord

> Saturn Sublord Mercury)

> >

> > Jupiter in Cancer (5 degree 58 minutes) (Starlord Saturn Sublord

> Mercury)

> > Moon in Cancer (5 degrees 43 minutes) (starlord Saturn Sublord

> Mercury)

> >

> > KP Niryana Bhavchalit Kundali suggersts that Moon and Jupiter be

> posted in 12th Bhav. Kshetra Kundali KP suggests that these two

> planets must be posited in 1st house.

> >

> > My opinion is that because all the three (ascendents, Moon and

> Jupiter) have same starlord (Saturn) and same sublord (Mercury),

these

> two panets should be posited in 1st house in Cancer and NOT in 12th

> house. Please advise your opinions.

> >

> > Regards,

> >

> > Yatendra Sharma

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > On 7

> > 360�: Your own space to share what you want with who you want!

> >

> >

[Guest guest]

Dear Binidraji,

 

my experience has shown that if the starlord and sublord of the planet/

planets in question are the same as cusp starlord and sublord, those should be

posted on the same cusp irrespective of slow or fastr moving planets.

 

For example:

 

Ascendent: Cancer 7 degree 6 minute (house Lord Moon, Starlord Saturn

Sublord Mercury)

 

Jupiter in Cancer (5 degree 58 minutes) (Starlord Saturn Sublord Mercury)

Moon in Cancer (5 degrees 43 minutes) (starlord Saturn Sublord Mercury)

 

 

In the above case, Cancer ascendent has the same starlord and sublord as

Jupiter and Moon. So in my opinion and as per my past experiences, Jupiter and

Moon should be positioned in Cancer ascendent rather than in 12th house.

 

However, even if planets are close to the degrees of a cusp, but having

different starlord / sub lord than the cusp of the house, then positioning may

require careful consideration.

 

Please comment.

 

Regards,

 

Yatendra Sharma

 

 

 

 

 

Personals: It's free to check out our great singles!