read this-sideral astrology isnt scientific nor logic

[Guest guest]

Tropical astrology (or false astrology) was created by muslim in 830.

 

The first tropical chart is dated after 830 AC.

 

Before 830, all charts, all astrologers used sidereal zodiac!:

 

- Anonymous (Fagan-Bradley ayanamsa) 397 AC

- Stephanos of Alexandria (ayanamsa for 130 AC) 625 AC [his islam

chart showed that Saturn in 24° Cancer [if tropical, 2° Leo]

- Naubhakt (Sassanide ayanamsa) 762 AC [chart of Bagdhad)

 

It's strange???

 

Muslim = Tropical astrology because Mecca was situed exactly in the

Tropical latitude (23° N). It's an astronomy reason, no astrology

object! The reason was the Hegira calculates (islamic calendar).

 

Tropical longitudes aren't Astrology longitudes.

 

The relics of Ptolemy are the latins traductions of the arabic

traduction!

 

In this direction, all people who used tropical zodiac are muslims...

no astrologers!!!

[Guest guest]

Hi Patrice,

 

I wasn't aware of the Muslim origin of the tropical zodiac. What evidence

is there to support your contention that the Greeks used the sidereal

zodiac? I think the fact that the zodiacs were very close together in those

days has made this question difficult to answer definitively.

 

Chris

 

 

On 12/14/06, Patrice <aartbouriche wrote:

>

> Tropical astrology (or false astrology) was created by muslim in 830.

>

> The first tropical chart is dated after 830 AC.

>

> Before 830, all charts, all astrologers used sidereal zodiac!:

>

> - Anonymous (Fagan-Bradley ayanamsa) 397 AC

> - Stephanos of Alexandria (ayanamsa for 130 AC) 625 AC [his islam

> chart showed that Saturn in 24° Cancer [if tropical, 2° Leo]

> - Naubhakt (Sassanide ayanamsa) 762 AC [chart of Bagdhad)

>

> It's strange???

>

> Muslim = Tropical astrology because Mecca was situed exactly in the

> Tropical latitude (23° N). It's an astronomy reason, no astrology

> object! The reason was the Hegira calculates (islamic calendar).

>

> Tropical longitudes aren't Astrology longitudes.

>

> The relics of Ptolemy are the latins traductions of the arabic

> traduction!

>

> In this direction, all people who used tropical zodiac are muslims...

> no astrologers!!!

>

>

>

 

 

 

--

http://modernVedic Astrology.com

 

 

 

[Guest guest]

Hi Chris!

 

Exatly! All byzantines astrologers used sidereal zodiac. They are

greeks astrologers of Alexandria school of Ptolemy.

 

You can read the works of historians David Pingree or Paul Magdalino

in English. All charts were sidereal until 830 AC. It's not my

invention...

 

Kind regards.

 

 

Patrice.