Guest guest Posted January 22, 2009 Report Share Posted January 22, 2009 Kulbhir Bhai, Your are right, i wrote that previous post from my memory. I again read the note , L R Chawdhri has mention Lal-kitab ,Girdhari lal and also other writers like Gaffer in the note. He has taken the main help from a sanyasi as i told your earlier. Thanks, Vijay Goel Jaipur kulbir bance wrote: > Goel ji, plz read the foreword by the author. Lalkitab is directly > mentioned therein.-kulbir > > On 1/22/09, Vijay Goel <goyalvj wrote: > >> Kulbir Bhai, >> >> You are right that Dr. L.R. Chawdhari in his book astropalmistry has >> not mention about the Lal-kitab directly, but while searching the link >> between palmistry and astrology, he met some saint who gave him old torn >> manuscript. Though it appears some similarities with lalkitab. >> >> I think lal kitab concept was also present at that time secretly to few >> saints before Pt. Roop Chandji wrote about it. It could be the technique >> which a particular group\community of people devised it and used it from >> generation to generation. >> >> Best Wishes, >> Vijay Goel >> >> >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2009 Report Share Posted January 22, 2009 Respected Vijay ji, You are absolutely correct when you say: " I think lal kitab concept was also present at that time secretly to few saints before Pt. Roop Chandji wrote about it. It could be the technique which a particular group\community of people devised and used from generation to generation. " We had always maintained that the Lal Kitab paddhati had been in use, may be by a few people, for centuries before it was made public by Pt. Roopchand ji in early 40s Regards, Varun Trivedi , Vijay Goel <goyalvj wrote: > > Kulbhir Bhai, > Your are right, i wrote that previous post from my memory. > I again read the note , L R Chawdhri has mention Lal- kitab ,Girdhari > lal and also other writers like Gaffer in the note. > He has taken the main help from a sanyasi as i told your earlier. > > Thanks, > Vijay Goel > Jaipur > kulbir bance wrote: > > Goel ji, plz read the foreword by the author. Lalkitab is directly > > mentioned therein.-kulbir > > > > On 1/22/09, Vijay Goel <goyalvj wrote: > > > >> Kulbir Bhai, > >> > >> You are right that Dr. L.R. Chawdhari in his book astropalmistry has > >> not mention about the Lal-kitab directly, but while searching the link > >> between palmistry and astrology, he met some saint who gave him old torn > >> manuscript. Though it appears some similarities with lalkitab. > >> > >> I think lal kitab concept was also present at that time secretly to few > >> saints before Pt. Roop Chandji wrote about it. It could be the technique > >> which a particular group\community of people devised it and used it from > >> generation to generation. > >> > >> Best Wishes, > >> Vijay Goel > >> > >> > >> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2009 Report Share Posted January 22, 2009 Varun ji; in the introductory part of Cheiro's book of astrology there is mention of such like practice/system in jammu region. He also mentions a (joshi) tribe in northwest. Also the diagram of timing of events from palm is same as printed in the lalkitab. Regards kulbir On 1/23/09, varun_trvd <varun_trvd wrote: > Respected Vijay ji, > > You are absolutely correct when you say: > > " I think lal kitab concept was also present at that time secretly to > few saints before Pt. Roop Chandji wrote about it. It could be the > technique which a particular group\community of people devised and > used from generation to generation. " > > We had always maintained that the Lal Kitab paddhati had been in use, > may be by a few people, for centuries before it was made public by > Pt. Roopchand ji in early 40s > > Regards, > > Varun Trivedi > , Vijay Goel <goyalvj > wrote: >> >> Kulbhir Bhai, >> Your are right, i wrote that previous post from my memory. >> I again read the note , L R Chawdhri has mention Lal- > kitab ,Girdhari >> lal and also other writers like Gaffer in the note. >> He has taken the main help from a sanyasi as i told your earlier. >> >> Thanks, >> Vijay Goel >> Jaipur >> kulbir bance wrote: >> > Goel ji, plz read the foreword by the author. Lalkitab is directly >> > mentioned therein.-kulbir >> > >> > On 1/22/09, Vijay Goel <goyalvj wrote: >> > >> >> Kulbir Bhai, >> >> >> >> You are right that Dr. L.R. Chawdhari in his book > astropalmistry has >> >> not mention about the Lal-kitab directly, but while searching > the link >> >> between palmistry and astrology, he met some saint who gave him > old torn >> >> manuscript. Though it appears some similarities with lalkitab. >> >> >> >> I think lal kitab concept was also present at that time secretly > to few >> >> saints before Pt. Roop Chandji wrote about it. It could be the > technique >> >> which a particular group\community of people devised it and used > it from >> >> generation to generation. >> >> >> >> Best Wishes, >> >> Vijay Goel >> >> >> >> >> >> >> > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2009 Report Share Posted January 22, 2009 Dear Kulbir bhai, Thank you so much for this information. This further confirms our belief that the Lal Kitab paddhati had been there for much before than it is made out to be. Have a nice day Varun Trivedi , kulbir bance <kulbirbance wrote: > > Varun ji; > > in the introductory part of Cheiro's book of astrology there > is mention of such like practice/system in jammu region. He also > mentions a (joshi) tribe in northwest. Also the diagram of timing of > events from palm is same as printed in the lalkitab. > > Regards > > kulbir > On 1/23/09, varun_trvd <varun_trvd wrote: > > Respected Vijay ji, > > > > You are absolutely correct when you say: > > > > " I think lal kitab concept was also present at that time secretly to > > few saints before Pt. Roop Chandji wrote about it. It could be the > > technique which a particular group\community of people devised and > > used from generation to generation. " > > > > We had always maintained that the Lal Kitab paddhati had been in use, > > may be by a few people, for centuries before it was made public by > > Pt. Roopchand ji in early 40s > > > > Regards, > > > > Varun Trivedi > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , Vijay Goel <goyalvj@> > > wrote: > >> > >> Kulbhir Bhai, > >> Your are right, i wrote that previous post from my memory. > >> I again read the note , L R Chawdhri has mention Lal- > > kitab ,Girdhari > >> lal and also other writers like Gaffer in the note. > >> He has taken the main help from a sanyasi as i told your earlier. > >> > >> Thanks, > >> Vijay Goel > >> Jaipur > >> kulbir bance wrote: > >> > Goel ji, plz read the foreword by the author. Lalkitab is directly > >> > mentioned therein.-kulbir > >> > > >> > On 1/22/09, Vijay Goel <goyalvj@> wrote: > >> > > >> >> Kulbir Bhai, > >> >> > >> >> You are right that Dr. L.R. Chawdhari in his book > > astropalmistry has > >> >> not mention about the Lal-kitab directly, but while searching > > the link > >> >> between palmistry and astrology, he met some saint who gave him > > old torn > >> >> manuscript. Though it appears some similarities with lalkitab. > >> >> > >> >> I think lal kitab concept was also present at that time secretly > > to few > >> >> saints before Pt. Roop Chandji wrote about it. It could be the > > technique > >> >> which a particular group\community of people devised it and used > > it from > >> >> generation to generation. > >> >> > >> >> Best Wishes, > >> >> Vijay Goel > >> >> > >> >> > >> >> > >> > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.