Antares/Sagittarius

[Guest guest]

At 12:07 AM 7/12/04 -0700, dezember wrote:

> " How can Pluto be in Sagittarius when it's so close to Antares? "

 

It means if you look at the sky in the Tropical zodiac, Pluto is within the

boundaries of the sign of Sagittarius. But Pluto was close in the sky to

Antares, the bright red star in the Scorpion. In the sidereal zodiac Pluto

has been in the sign of Scorpio for many years.

 

Therese

[Guest guest]

So why not sidereal is right but tropical?

are people who do tropical wrong?

 

Therese Hamilton <eastwest wrote:

At 12:07 AM 7/12/04 -0700, dezember wrote:

> " How can Pluto be in Sagittarius when it's so close to Antares? "

 

It means if you look at the sky in the Tropical zodiac, Pluto is within the

boundaries of the sign of Sagittarius. But Pluto was close in the sky to

Antares, the bright red star in the Scorpion. In the sidereal zodiac Pluto

has been in the sign of Scorpio for many years.

 

Therese

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Guest guest]

Vci, here is one astrologers response,

I was a tropical astrologer for over 20 years when I saw the results of a

sidereal model.

 

Tropical is a wonderful personality model, but sidereal offers something

deeper and a more accurate picture.

 

Remember, about 1800 years ago the sign ARies and the constellation were the

same. THere was something called the dark and middle ages where

calculations were lost, but astrology lingered. Tropical astrology has

really become strong in the last 100 years, primarily due to Carl Jung and

many psychologists who foung gret meaning in the signs and began to

identifyl qualities of such in a psychological manner.

 

Typically, the tropical astrologer looks out inot the heaves for more and

more aspects and asteroids, in my experiece, the sidereal astrologer looks

down deeper.

Vci . [dezember1480]

Monday, July 12, 2004 1:56 PM

Re: Re: Antares/Sagittarius

 

 

So why not sidereal is right but tropical?

are people who do tropical wrong?

 

Therese Hamilton <eastwest wrote:

At 12:07 AM 7/12/04 -0700, dezember wrote:

> " How can Pluto be in Sagittarius when it's so close to Antares? "

 

It means if you look at the sky in the Tropical zodiac, Pluto is within

the

boundaries of the sign of Sagittarius. But Pluto was close in the sky to

Antares, the bright red star in the Scorpion. In the sidereal zodiac Pluto

has been in the sign of Scorpio for many years.

 

Therese

 

 

 

[Guest guest]

At 11:56 AM 7/12/04 -0700, Vci wrote:

>So why not sidereal is right but tropical?

>are people who do tropical wrong?

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 

Dedicated siderealists believe so, yes. This claim is supported by solar

and luanr returns, which occur at different times than Tropical returns,

and show events more clearly. Some siderealists will claim that there is no

Tropical zodiac. The so-called traits of the Tropoical signs are a bleed

through from the sidereal. I tend to hold this view.

 

Therese