Punarphoo-cases also need holistic approach

[Guest guest]

since spelling mistake is there in the subject i am repeating the message

Dear K.JagdishI agree with your analysis - you have brought out many many punarapoo charts who are amidst us -

My idea is to highlight that no single planet works in isolation - anytime native gets a package deal of all planets - may be a few planets take a lead by virtue of dasa periods / transit -

Punarapoo is connection of two planets Saturn and moon - they work amidst of all other planets -

Whole chart is to be studied - every bhava has connection to lagna and eleventh - besides the connecting bhavas - say for 4th bhava education we have to see 6th bhava for competitive exams etc.,

Like this we need a holistic approach - to examine negative/positive qualities and the connections acting against negative and positive qualities - before finalizing reading of any bhava - any planet(s)

About level of knowledge - I am always a student of this science - and so no hurting for me

rao chitturuJagadish K <kjagadish48 wrote:

 

Dear Rao Chitturu,

 

I fully agree with you. Further if mere conjunction or aspect is going to be called as a Dosha, then every month there will be 4 unfortunate days Viz.,

 

1. Moon will be conjunct Transi Saturn for approx one day.

 

2. Saturns 3 aspects on other 3 days of the month.

 

Further, whenever Saturn remains in Moon's star approx once in 10 years, around 13 months when he will be Moon's star, children born then will be under severe PUNARPHOO DOSHA?

Generalising the natural Astronomical Periodical events and interpolating the results uniformly across all those born during that period, lacks Astrological prudence. Each hunan being is uniquely created by God, as we know.

Please enlighten me more. While I make this request, please do not assume my level of Astrological knowledge (or foolishness, if any) nor I am interested to know your level either. My request is only on the point under discussion. I certainly do not mean hurting you or any one, for that matter.

Highest Regards,

K Jagadish

rao chitturu <csr162002 wrote:

 

dear friends

because of moon's speed around every 27th day or even within sat-moon connection occures - so natives born on all such days cannot be condemmed with negative effects- the bad events in such charts must contain other malefic or weak points - So every individual chart to be judged in a wholistic approach - even a weight is given to connection -in any system.

rao chitturuanant raichur <anant_1608 wrote:

 

Dear Rangarajan: Some more cases:

 

Male: DOB JUL 4 1972: TOB 10-17 HRS: POB 18N58 72E49

SA in VE:MO:VE

effect Problem during negotiatins. Later Divorced

 

Male :DOB NOV 15 1975 : TOB 15,18 HRS: POB 19N14 73E10

MOON :JU;ME;VE::SAT MO;SA; VE

effect Delayed maariage due to parental objections;

 

FEMALE DOB NOV 3 1977: TOB 20-15 HRS: POB 19N14 73E10

MOON in MO SA MO: SA in SU KE RA Ra in MO star

effect Delayed marriage due to parental objections

 

FEMALE: DOB OCT 22 1977: TOB 11-30 HRS; POB 19N59;73E48

MOON in SA;RA;JU

effects trouble in Negotiations. Solved and married.

 

Hope this helps;

 

good luck

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

--------- A.R.Raichur bombayanant_1608

raichuranant

USE ONE OF THESE ADDRESS ES ONLYtel: 022-2506 2609 ---------

 

 

Start your day with - make it your home page

 

 

India Matrimony: Find your partner online.Go to http://.shaadi.com

Start your day with - make it your home page

[Guest guest]

Dear Mr.Rao Chitturu,

 

Thanks for your response. In a package deal as you have mentioned, is it possible for some kind of quanitificaion of the role of different planets is the key issue.

 

Study of Cuspal Interlinks may mean something and that is entirely in isolation of current transit chart for the native under study.

 

What I mean is SUPER IMPOSITION OF THE TRANSIT CHART ON THE NATAL CHART IN TOTALITY (all the planets). Whole thing may look silly initially and can be termed as thinking experiment. However, if some one comes with some idea, it can improve the quality of prediction many fold.

 

Can all the Learned members (I mean every member) think over and come to some elementary basis of such a quantification. Even if it is wrong initially, a hint here and there may lead to something good in due course. I realise that it is just not easy but let us try.

 

Regards,

 

K Jagadishrao chitturu <csr162002 wrote:

 

 

since spelling mistake is there in the subject i am repeating the message

Dear K.JagdishI agree with your analysis - you have brought out many many punarapoo charts who are amidst us -

My idea is to highlight that no single planet works in isolation - anytime native gets a package deal of all planets - may be a few planets take a lead by virtue of dasa periods / transit -

Punarapoo is connection of two planets Saturn and moon - they work amidst of all other planets -

Whole chart is to be studied - every bhava has connection to lagna and eleventh - besides the connecting bhavas - say for 4th bhava education we have to see 6th bhava for competitive exams etc.,

Like this we need a holistic approach - to examine negative/positive qualities and the connections acting against negative and positive qualities - before finalizing reading of any bhava - any planet(s)

About level of knowledge - I am always a student of this science - and so no hurting for me

rao chitturuJagadish K <kjagadish48 wrote:

Dear Rao Chitturu,

 

I fully agree with you. Further if mere conjunction or aspect is going to be called as a Dosha, then every month there will be 4 unfortunate days Viz.,

 

1. Moon will be conjunct Transi Saturn for approx one day.

 

2. Saturns 3 aspects on other 3 days of the month.

 

Further, whenever Saturn remains in Moon's star approx once in 10 years, around 13 months when he will be Moon's star, children born then will be under severe PUNARPHOO DOSHA?

Generalising the natural Astronomical Periodical events and interpolating the results uniformly across all those born during that period, lacks Astrological prudence. Each hunan being is uniquely created by God, as we know.

Please enlighten me more. While I make this request, please do not assume my level of Astrological knowledge (or foolishness, if any) nor I am interested to know your level either. My request is only on the point under discussion. I certainly do not mean hurting you or any one, for that matter.

Highest Regards,

K Jagadish

rao chitturu <csr162002 wrote:

 

dear friends

because of moon's speed around every 27th day or even within sat-moon connection occures - so natives born on all such days cannot be condemmed with negative effects- the bad events in such charts must contain other malefic or weak points - So every individual chart to be judged in a wholistic approach - even a weight is given to connection -in any system.

rao chitturuanant raichur <anant_1608 wrote:

 

Dear Rangarajan: Some more cases:

 

Male: DOB JUL 4 1972: TOB 10-17 HRS: POB 18N58 72E49

SA in VE:MO:VE

effect Problem during negotiatins. Later Divorced

 

Male :DOB NOV 15 1975 : TOB 15,18 HRS: POB 19N14 73E10

MOON :JU;ME;VE::SAT MO;SA; VE

effect Delayed maariage due to parental objections;

 

FEMALE DOB NOV 3 1977: TOB 20-15 HRS: POB 19N14 73E10

MOON in MO SA MO: SA in SU KE RA Ra in MO star

effect Delayed marriage due to parental objections

 

FEMALE: DOB OCT 22 1977: TOB 11-30 HRS; POB 19N59;73E48

MOON in SA;RA;JU

effects trouble in Negotiations. Solved and married.

 

Hope this helps;

 

good luck

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

--------- A.R.Raichur bombayanant_1608

raichuranant

USE ONE OF THESE ADDRESS ES ONLYtel: 022-2506 2609 ---------

 

 

Start your day with - make it your home page

 

 

India Matrimony: Find your partner online.Go to http://.shaadi.com

 

 

Start your day with - make it your home page

India Matrimony: Find your partner online.Go to http://.shaadi.com

[Guest guest]

Dear Mr.Rao Chituru,

 

Just one more point subsequent to my last msg.

 

It has always been found by many members that the Horary chart results have faired much better than the Natal chart analysis. Perhaps the only reason is that the current transit is totally accounted for. However, the position of Moon and interpretational skills of the astrologer, which are fundamentally divine in nature plays a significant role.

 

Therefore, for a given natal chart, which is fundamentally a reference point and superimposing the current transit chart and interpolating the results, probably even through software and drawing a consolidated inference may make some meaning.

 

May the Software freternity help us.

 

Regards,

 

K Jagadish

Jagadish K <kjagadish48 wrote:

 

Dear Mr.Rao Chitturu,

 

Thanks for your response. In a package deal as you have mentioned, is it possible for some kind of quanitificaion of the role of different planets is the key issue.

 

Study of Cuspal Interlinks may mean something and that is entirely in isolation of current transit chart for the native under study.

 

What I mean is SUPER IMPOSITION OF THE TRANSIT CHART ON THE NATAL CHART IN TOTALITY (all the planets). Whole thing may look silly initially and can be termed as thinking experiment. However, if some one comes with some idea, it can improve the quality of prediction many fold.

 

Can all the Learned members (I mean every member) think over and come to some elementary basis of such a quantification. Even if it is wrong initially, a hint here and there may lead to something good in due course. I realise that it is just not easy but let us try.

 

Regards,

 

K Jagadishrao chitturu <csr162002 wrote:

 

 

since spelling mistake is there in the subject i am repeating the message

Dear K.JagdishI agree with your analysis - you have brought out many many punarapoo charts who are amidst us -

My idea is to highlight that no single planet works in isolation - anytime native gets a package deal of all planets - may be a few planets take a lead by virtue of dasa periods / transit -

Punarapoo is connection of two planets Saturn and moon - they work amidst of all other planets -

Whole chart is to be studied - every bhava has connection to lagna and eleventh - besides the connecting bhavas - say for 4th bhava education we have to see 6th bhava for competitive exams etc.,

Like this we need a holistic approach - to examine negative/positive qualities and the connections acting against negative and positive qualities - before finalizing reading of any bhava - any planet(s)

About level of knowledge - I am always a student of this science - and so no hurting for me

rao chitturuJagadish K <kjagadish48 wrote:

Dear Rao Chitturu,

 

I fully agree with you. Further if mere conjunction or aspect is going to be called as a Dosha, then every month there will be 4 unfortunate days Viz.,

 

1. Moon will be conjunct Transi Saturn for approx one day.

 

2. Saturns 3 aspects on other 3 days of the month.

 

Further, whenever Saturn remains in Moon's star approx once in 10 years, around 13 months when he will be Moon's star, children born then will be under severe PUNARPHOO DOSHA?

Generalising the natural Astronomical Periodical events and interpolating the results uniformly across all those born during that period, lacks Astrological prudence. Each hunan being is uniquely created by God, as we know.

Please enlighten me more. While I make this request, please do not assume my level of Astrological knowledge (or foolishness, if any) nor I am interested to know your level either. My request is only on the point under discussion. I certainly do not mean hurting you or any one, for that matter.

Highest Regards,

K Jagadish

rao chitturu <csr162002 wrote:

 

dear friends

because of moon's speed around every 27th day or even within sat-moon connection occures - so natives born on all such days cannot be condemmed with negative effects- the bad events in such charts must contain other malefic or weak points - So every individual chart to be judged in a wholistic approach - even a weight is given to connection -in any system.

rao chitturuanant raichur <anant_1608 wrote:

 

Dear Rangarajan: Some more cases:

 

Male: DOB JUL 4 1972: TOB 10-17 HRS: POB 18N58 72E49

SA in VE:MO:VE

effect Problem during negotiatins. Later Divorced

 

Male :DOB NOV 15 1975 : TOB 15,18 HRS: POB 19N14 73E10

MOON :JU;ME;VE::SAT MO;SA; VE

effect Delayed maariage due to parental objections;

 

FEMALE DOB NOV 3 1977: TOB 20-15 HRS: POB 19N14 73E10

MOON in MO SA MO: SA in SU KE RA Ra in MO star

effect Delayed marriage due to parental objections

 

FEMALE: DOB OCT 22 1977: TOB 11-30 HRS; POB 19N59;73E48

MOON in SA;RA;JU

effects trouble in Negotiations. Solved and married.

 

Hope this helps;

 

good luck

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

--------- A.R.Raichur bombayanant_1608

raichuranant

USE ONE OF THESE ADDRESS ES ONLYtel: 022-2506 2609 ---------

 

 

Start your day with - make it your home page

 

 

India Matrimony: Find your partner online.Go to http://.shaadi.com

 

 

Start your day with - make it your home page

 

 

India Matrimony: Find your partner online.Go to http://.shaadi.com

India Matrimony: Find your partner online.Go to http://.shaadi.com

[Guest guest]

Dear Jagadish,

How about considering the (annual) progressed chart. ?

It is very easy to give such suggestions galore...but what is important is, to experiment first,and then, present one's findings and cogently argued/deduced conclusions...

With best wishes,

Yours sincerely,

L.Y.Rao.

GOOD LUCK !

Jagadish K <kjagadish48 wrote:

 

Dear Mr.Rao Chitturu,

 

Thanks for your response. In a package deal as you have mentioned, is it possible for some kind of quanitificaion of the role of different planets is the key issue.

 

Study of Cuspal Interlinks may mean something and that is entirely in isolation of current transit chart for the native under study.

 

What I mean is SUPER IMPOSITION OF THE TRANSIT CHART ON THE NATAL CHART IN TOTALITY (all the planets). Whole thing may look silly initially and can be termed as thinking experiment. However, if some one comes with some idea, it can improve the quality of prediction many fold.

 

Can all the Learned members (I mean every member) think over and come to some elementary basis of such a quantification. Even if it is wrong initially, a hint here and there may lead to something good in due course. I realise that it is just not easy but let us try.

 

Regards,

 

K Jagadishrao chitturu <csr162002 wrote:

 

 

since spelling mistake is there in the subject i am repeating the message

Dear K.JagdishI agree with your analysis - you have brought out many many punarapoo charts who are amidst us -

My idea is to highlight that no single planet works in isolation - anytime native gets a package deal of all planets - may be a few planets take a lead by virtue of dasa periods / transit -

Punarapoo is connection of two planets Saturn and moon - they work amidst of all other planets -

Whole chart is to be studied - every bhava has connection to lagna and eleventh - besides the connecting bhavas - say for 4th bhava education we have to see 6th bhava for competitive exams etc.,

Like this we need a holistic approach - to examine negative/positive qualities and the connections acting against negative and positive qualities - before finalizing reading of any bhava - any planet(s)

About level of knowledge - I am always a student of this science - and so no hurting for me

rao chitturuJagadish K <kjagadish48 wrote:

Dear Rao Chitturu,

 

I fully agree with you. Further if mere conjunction or aspect is going to be called as a Dosha, then every month there will be 4 unfortunate days Viz.,

 

1. Moon will be conjunct Transi Saturn for approx one day.

 

2. Saturns 3 aspects on other 3 days of the month.

 

Further, whenever Saturn remains in Moon's star approx once in 10 years, around 13 months when he will be Moon's star, children born then will be under severe PUNARPHOO DOSHA?

Generalising the natural Astronomical Periodical events and interpolating the results uniformly across all those born during that period, lacks Astrological prudence. Each hunan being is uniquely created by God, as we know.

Please enlighten me more. While I make this request, please do not assume my level of Astrological knowledge (or foolishness, if any) nor I am interested to know your level either. My request is only on the point under discussion. I certainly do not mean hurting you or any one, for that matter.

Highest Regards,

K Jagadish

rao chitturu <csr162002 wrote:

 

dear friends

because of moon's speed around every 27th day or even within sat-moon connection occures - so natives born on all such days cannot be condemmed with negative effects- the bad events in such charts must contain other malefic or weak points - So every individual chart to be judged in a wholistic approach - even a weight is given to connection -in any system.

rao chitturuanant raichur <anant_1608 wrote:

 

Dear Rangarajan: Some more cases:

 

Male: DOB JUL 4 1972: TOB 10-17 HRS: POB 18N58 72E49

SA in VE:MO:VE

effect Problem during negotiatins. Later Divorced

 

Male :DOB NOV 15 1975 : TOB 15,18 HRS: POB 19N14 73E10

MOON :JU;ME;VE::SAT MO;SA; VE

effect Delayed maariage due to parental objections;

 

FEMALE DOB NOV 3 1977: TOB 20-15 HRS: POB 19N14 73E10

MOON in MO SA MO: SA in SU KE RA Ra in MO star

effect Delayed marriage due to parental objections

 

FEMALE: DOB OCT 22 1977: TOB 11-30 HRS; POB 19N59;73E48

MOON in SA;RA;JU

effects trouble in Negotiations. Solved and married.

 

Hope this helps;

 

good luck

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

--------- A.R.Raichur bombayanant_1608

raichuranant

USE ONE OF THESE ADDRESS ES ONLYtel: 022-2506 2609 ---------

 

 

Start your day with - make it your home page

 

 

India Matrimony: Find your partner online.Go to http://.shaadi.com

 

 

Start your day with - make it your home page

 

 

India Matrimony: Find your partner online.Go to http://.shaadi.com

India Matrimony: Find your partner online.Go to http://.shaadi.com