Guest guest Posted September 3, 2005 Report Share Posted September 3, 2005 Daer Jagdish ji,my comment in bold******* Thanks for subsribing to my views on books. Let us go through every point without any bias or any kind of HERO WORSHIP. I have always considered you as a JEWEL of the Forum, although this is the first time I am writing a mail. Earlier I sincerely wished a reward in some context or the other in future, if you have not already received one. thnks but other member are also very important. I believe in giving respect first and making ourself eligible for return of respect. Since I do not Hindi, I always address people as Mr. and invariably put Regards, while signing off. Whereas Hindi speaking members might as well use 'Ji' , as they have been rightly doing. Some members are deliberately following the courtesy. I propose to take it up with the Moderator. Further, I do not want to assume the knowledge of other members nor I want them to assess my level either. It is also wrong to classify as learner, beginner, expert etc. Members will automatically come to know other members once they start posting messages.First of all who are we to assess others? No one has appointed us Chief Examiner or Head Master. why we go in any disupitable metter? the goal of Punit ji is only to findout best book in KP nothing else so frist we complit this and then if any member have doubt about any book we can try to find out what is right. like Asc. sub-Moonstar conection. but after finishe this work. No one need to appoint himself as a big man. We need to win other's heart by love and affection and not by arrogance. We can always help each other. There may be several points we know and may be one idea can come from somewhere. Is that not the purpose of the Forum. Yes and most of member always help each other but Jagdish ji our five finger is not same BUT WE HAVE TO REMEMBER THAT FINGER IS OUR, WE CANT CUT AND THROW.difference of opinion is very healthy for our group but dont take it as personal atttake.and if we fill that this is a personal attke dont reply or send your objection to moderatore. If it is a question of research, if we go on accepting the rule book as 100% right, then computers could have given the prediction. Allthough I do not mean that we should go on contradicting points unnecessarily, Astrology as you know is such a subject for 100 rules there may be 1000 exceptions. There will be always scope for mutual consultation. Books should not be treated as Gospel Truth, let it be written by anyone, however high and mighty he may be. Yes i am 100% agree with you i never ready book bcoz writen by so and so. and never accept from book blindly and this is the resone that in past we done research on Asc sub- Moon Star conection. our duty complite, now what other member think is his view not our. Sorry for taking your time. I will need your help for sure. you are always welcome regards kanak Get MSN Messenger with Video Conversation - FREE. The next best thing to being there. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 3, 2005 Report Share Posted September 3, 2005 Dear Lajmi ji, Dear Kanak, Thank you for your keen observations... I agree with you...but, is the analysis of a single cusp alone,like say the Xth cusp alone enough, to arrive at a native's profession ? I have therefore suggested that "many other factors need to be factored in", like the running Dasa-Bhukti, status of the horoscope A,or B or C grade etc.,by examining the s/l of the Ascendant,his family back-ground,cultural background etc...all these are mentioned as preliminaries to be undertaken before a K.P. astrologer even as he begins analysing a chart...for assessing it... Books mention only to check 10th cusp and given example are on the 10th cusp only the dont give any details about what you write.What i write is only my experince and may be i am wrong. The book on Profession gives the various possibilities...it is then left to the astrologer's experience, knowledge and intelligence,and most importantly his intuitive ability...to arrive at the correct prediction...it is not to be taken literally..it is only a pointer... without experience , knowladge and intelligence no one pridict any thing so this is the comman in all branch of astrology not only in KP. As some "instant-astrology" enthusiasts seem to suggest that "some simple formula" ...perhaps a "one-line-formula" needs to be arrived at...for many things...in order to make things easy and simple... ? ! It is strongly felt by me,that,the still easily available and extremely "popular 'examination-guide' culture" is making it manifest itself again in K.P. also...should we not rise above it ? " Algebra made easy"..."calculus made easy"...et al...are easily available,are we now looking to publish a new "K.P.made easy" by XYZ...on these lines ? ? So,it seems to me increasingly... Nothing wrong if any one write this type of books but ofcourse reliable.... it will great healp for KP Learner.Shri KSK done this in past and now we are free from1000 and 1000 Yagas. I wish to reiterate that,as for me I belong to a culture which holds all those from whom I learnt K.P. astrology,(starting with our Guruji,The Great KSK,and all his learned,experienced and the numerous early disciples,like M/s. K.Subramaniam,K.Hariharan,Vaikari Ramamurthi, K.Balachandran,the late Pt.K.R.Kar,K.Kuppu Ganapati,K.Baskaran, and a host of other K.P. stalwarts) with the greatest reverence and respect for their deep knowledge and most valuable contributions towards the popularisation of K.P. I also salute them. and i am also from same culture but nothing wrong if we not accept what is prove wrong. always what thay write is right is a knowladge suicide tendency in my opinion. I belong to a culture where such thinking is inculcated in us,very early in life...It is only since recently,it appears,that the American and Foreign culture is seen to be influencing us,where such reverence is often interpreted as servility... ! I have a bed experince of American and Foreign culture in other group and i imidiatly left that group. thay are do anything in the name of culture i know but what we doing in Asc sub - Moon star connection is not American and Foreign culture . and our intention is not bed by heart.please belive me. It must be remembered that these books have been written by people who've worked very hard,(there were no computers in vogue, like now,in those days,all work was done either manually or mentally...) Further,reading a book intelligently, is an art,and it seems to have vanished in this age of computers and "ready-made-masalas"...! so we have to accept all blindly??? No at all. we must check and if we found correct then and then only we have to eccept. and nothing wrong if we check rules given in book. please do not take my word as old v/s young or american type of reaserch. regards kanak Find just what you're after with the new, more precise MSN Search - try it now! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 3, 2005 Report Share Posted September 3, 2005 Dear Mr.Kanak, Thank you for your organised reply. I took the opportunity to congratulate you, but at the same time I agree that others also have made significant contribution. I see your humility in the approach. I have noted every point in detail. I am in total agreement with your views. Your intervention in the discussion is absolutely essential and I am sure that you will oblige. Regards, K JagadishKanak Bosmia <kanbosastro wrote: Daer Jagdish ji,my comment in bold******* Thanks for subsribing to my views on books. Let us go through every point without any bias or any kind of HERO WORSHIP. I have always considered you as a JEWEL of the Forum, although this is the first time I am writing a mail. Earlier I sincerely wished a reward in some context or the other in future, if you have not already received one. thnks but other member are also very important. I believe in giving respect first and making ourself eligible for return of respect. Since I do not Hindi, I always address people as Mr. and invariably put Regards, while signing off. Whereas Hindi speaking members might as well use 'Ji' , as they have been rightly doing. Some members are deliberately following the courtesy. I propose to take it up with the Moderator. Further, I do not want to assume the knowledge of other members nor I want them to assess my level either. It is also wrong to classify as learner, beginner, expert etc. Members will automatically come to know other members once they start posting messages.First of all who are we to assess others? No one has appointed us Chief Examiner or Head Master. why we go in any disupitable metter? the goal of Punit ji is only to findout best book in KP nothing else so frist we complit this and then if any member have doubt about any book we can try to find out what is right. like Asc. sub-Moonstar conection. but after finishe this work. No one need to appoint himself as a big man. We need to win other's heart by love and affection and not by arrogance. We can always help each other. There may be several points we know and may be one idea can come from somewhere. Is that not the purpose of the Forum. Yes and most of member always help each other but Jagdish ji our five finger is not same BUT WE HAVE TO REMEMBER THAT FINGER IS OUR, WE CANT CUT AND THROW.difference of opinion is very healthy for our group but dont take it as personal atttake.and if we fill that this is a personal attke dont reply or send your objection to moderatore. If it is a question of research, if we go on accepting the rule book as 100% right, then computers could have given the prediction. Allthough I do not mean that we should go on contradicting points unnecessarily, Astrology as you know is such a subject for 100 rules there may be 1000 exceptions. There will be always scope for mutual consultation. Books should not be treated as Gospel Truth, let it be written by anyone, however high and mighty he may be. Yes i am 100% agree with you i never ready book bcoz writen by so and so. and never accept from book blindly and this is the resone that in past we done research on Asc sub- Moon Star conection. our duty complite, now what other member think is his view not our. Sorry for taking your time. I will need your help for sure. you are always welcome regards kanak Get MSN Messenger with Video Conversation - FREE. The next best thing to being there. India Matrimony: Find your partner online.Go to http://.shaadi.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.