Guest guest Posted March 9, 2009 Report Share Posted March 9, 2009 Varun ji, i know it is not right to pick topics from other groups but going by past experience and gravity of the issue i couldn't stop myself. Is there any SIYAH KITAB written by pt. Ji. U must be having some knowledge. They say this book is based on illham. If this book is written on the basis of illham then on what basis were the earlier 5 written. Regards. Kulbir. -- Sent from my mobile device Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2009 Report Share Posted March 9, 2009 Dear Kulbir bhai, Yes, I have seen the Black book [ syah kitab] with a book seller in Nai Sarak Delhi. I have not read it. When I asked the book seller about this Book he said it is based on Islamic tantra / ilma known as 'Naqsh-e-Sulaimani'. I do not know how authentic his information is, because I neither have the book nor I have read it. This book has nothing to do with ilhaam. Quite possible some one might have mis-interpreted the word ilma as ilhaam. In the Islamic tradition tantra is known as ilma. The only book ever received as ilhaam is the Quran. Pt. Roopchand ji has nothing to do with this book. To the best of my knowledge Pt. Roopchand ji never wrote such a book. Quite possible that some one is trying to get respectability for syaah kitab by trying to associate Pt. Roopchand ji's name with it. Have a nice day, Varun Trivedi , kulbir bance <kulbirbance wrote: > > Varun ji, > > i know it is not right to pick topics from other groups but > going by past experience and gravity of the issue i couldn't stop > myself. Is there any SIYAH KITAB written by pt. Ji. U must be having > some knowledge. They say this book is based on illham. If this book is > written on the basis of illham then on what basis were the earlier 5 > written. > > Regards. > > > Kulbir. > > > > > > -- > Sent from my mobile device > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 10, 2009 Report Share Posted March 10, 2009 varun ji, this use of siyah in place of kaali and ilham instead of ilam gave in the trick. I must say u very intelligently picked the difference in ilam and ilham. I repeat ur words " we have only 5 books and we have to work on that " . I am clear about that. The post was to alert fellow members against such malicious vested interests. Associating pt ji with siah kitab is atrocious. Wonder where the khairkhwah and self appointed guardians of lalkitab and pt ji have migrated. Regards. Kulbir. On 3/10/09, varun_trvd <varun_trvd wrote: > Dear Kulbir bhai, > > Yes, I have seen the Black book [ syah kitab] with a book seller in Nai > Sarak Delhi. I have not read it. > > When I asked the book seller about this Book he said it is based on Islamic > tantra / ilma known as 'Naqsh-e-Sulaimani'. I do not know how authentic his > information is, because I neither have the book nor I have read it. > > This book has nothing to do with ilhaam. Quite possible some one might have > mis-interpreted the word ilma as ilhaam. In the Islamic tradition tantra is > known as ilma. The only book ever received as ilhaam is the Quran. > > Pt. Roopchand ji has nothing to do with this book. To the best of my > knowledge Pt. Roopchand ji never wrote such a book. Quite possible that some > one is trying to get respectability for syaah kitab by trying to associate > Pt. Roopchand ji's name with it. > > Have a nice day, > > Varun Trivedi > > > > > > , kulbir bance <kulbirbance > wrote: >> >> Varun ji, >> >> i know it is not right to pick topics from other groups but >> going by past experience and gravity of the issue i couldn't stop >> myself. Is there any SIYAH KITAB written by pt. Ji. U must be having >> some knowledge. They say this book is based on illham. If this book is >> written on the basis of illham then on what basis were the earlier 5 >> written. >> >> Regards. >> >> >> Kulbir. >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> -- >> Sent from my mobile device >> > > > -- Sent from my mobile device Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.