Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

A course on lalkitab

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Dear Kulbir bhai,

 

Your humility makes me speechless.

 

I have a few reservations about such a Lal Kitab course.

 

Firstly I believe that a skill like astrology can not be learnt

through distance learning/teaching. Astrology is some thing like

classical singing which has to be learnt in the company of [ or at

the feet of] a competent Guru. It needs complete devotion of the

pupil and unflinching love, care and affection of the Guru towards

his pupil. Can we expect either in the present materialistic world? I

do not think so.

 

Secondly I doubt if the experienced astrologers will be willing to

share their secret knowledge with these students. We have found

through our own experience that not many people come forward to share

what they know. You can see this group itself. Except a few of us how

many people have come forward to share their knowledge. They will

come forward to test your knowledge, but never to share. This is the

situation when we in the group are extremely courteous to every one.

Have you ever noticed us to jeer at some one, or make some one feel

small or say any thing humiliating? And yet they are not prepared to

share.

 

Thirdly astrology is also like carpentry where a lot of manual

drilling has to be gone through under the supervision of a learned

supervisor. Who has got so much time for all this?

 

All such courses which are being advertised and floated are to make

money and have nothing to do with imparting genuine knowledge. And

there will be no use adding yet another course into that list.

 

Now what is the best alternative ?

 

Any one who is genuinely interested in learning Lal Kitab has to

download all the 180 or so articles in our file section. There is an

article in the file section on how to study the Lal Kitab. You can go

through that article and suggest a few modifications if you like.

That article is a very good guideline for beginners.

 

He should start reading the book, try to understand it. May be he

will need a few readings of the book before he gets a hang of it. We

might have read the book a few dozen times and can not claim as

having understood more than 40% of the book.

 

If he has any difficulties, he can always come to the group and seek

clarifications.

 

I assure you that we will share every thing we know. We have no

professional interest in hiding any knowledge. We will try to bring

every one to our level of competence at least. Then each on his own.

 

The motto of our group is " qot rami tot arbores " as many branches so

many trees; every branch to become a tree in itself.

 

Regards,

 

Varun Trivedi

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

, kulbir bance

<kulbirbance wrote:

>

> Varun ji,

>

> consider it as literally begging. With u i enjoy a brotherly

> relation but i am in awe of shukla ji and bhooshanpriya ji. Both of

> them have a spirit of teacher. Why don't u devise a chapter wise

> syllabus for LK learners. Umesh ji i hope is teaching seperately. To

> bring in prabhakar ji is my responsibility, i have special immunity

> from him. We have mahajan ji and so many more like him in this group

> who want to repay the debt of lalkitab. But educationist is the one

> who can give compass to the knowledge. Many like me have some little

> knowledge but the compass is missing. Can u help, i am really pained

> when i see advertisments for courses for lalkitab. We have scholars

> here with 3 decades of learning who still consider themselves

> students. And now i see teachers produced by 2 years course. Plz

> listen to the voice of ur aatma.

>

> Regards.

>

> Kulbir.

>

>

>

>

>

On 2/18/09, varun_trvd <varun_trvd wrote:

> > Dear Kulbir Bhai,

> >

> > [ 1 ] Palmistry is a knowledge known only to a few people. At

least I

> > have not come across any palmistry expert who had a tradition of

> > palmists in the family. On the contrary, I have come across many

> > astrologers where astrology goes back to generations in the

family.

> > In the Lal Kitab a horoscope drawn on the basis of the palm is

> > advised under two circumstances:

> >

> > [ a ] when the birth details are either not known or may not be

very

> > accurate; it is a desperate measure. A horoscope based on the

palm

> > is not used as a substitute under normal circumstances. I have

been

> > told that Pt. Roopchand ji was very particular that the horoscope

> > should be drawn by an able pundit and based on accurate birth

details.

> >

> > [ b ] To confirm certain events or matters indicated in the

horoscope

> > cast according to the birth details. This is included in the book

as

> > Kyafa.

> >

> > Therefore the major role of palmistry in the Lal Kitab is ,

> > primarily, confirmatory.

> >

> > [ 2 ] The signs given in the Lal Kitab are the same which you will

> > find in any book on palmistry. The names of these signs are so

> > archaic that it is difficult to identify them unless you are

formally

> > trained by a knowledgeable palmist. It is like a vaidya teaching

you

> > to identify herbs in a jungle.

> >

> > Since I had never come across a really learned palmist, I never

tried

> > to devote time on palmistry.

> >

> > [ 3 ] Yes. The 1939 book does have its emphasis on palmistry more

> > than the later editions. In the later editions palmistry is

confined

> > to Kyafa, an exercise into confirmation of general condition of

the

> > native. For finer details of the life of the native, it is the

> > horoscope which is the main stay of the study. Like the event you

> > yourself mentioned a couple of days ago about Saturn in the 8th

house

> > with two planets, and the native being born only after two family

> > members had left this world. Now such a finer detail would be

> > possible only through the horoscope. I doubt if it were possible

to

> > predict this through a palm.

> >

> > [ 4 ] Yes, you are right. This section on a correlation between

the

> > height and the life expectancy might have been true a few

centuries

> > ago. But in the modern times with access to medicines and a better

> > general awareness about health, the correlation between height and

> > life expectancy may not hold good.

> >

> > [ 5 ] Yes, you are right. It is only a few roaming pundits, whom

we

> > call bhaddari, who still earn their living through palm readings.

But

> > they are mostly confined to either villages or near courts and

> > stations. Very few of them have any formal learning into

palmistry.

> >

> > [ 6 ] Yes you are right. The results based on a horoscope either

for

> > Janma Kundali or for varsh phal Kundali would definitely come to

be

> > more accurate then the readings through a palm.

> >

> > A horoscope is a very scientific tool, very accurate and very

> > objective. Every astrologer would end up with the same horoscope

for

> > the same birth details. There is nothing subjective about it. Yes,

> > the interpretation of a horoscope can be subjective, that too to a

> > very limited extent. Most of the interpretation will be objective

> > shared by every other astrologer who happens to read the same

> > horoscope.

> >

> > A horoscope cast on the basis of a house or the `makan kundali'

as it

> > is known is not a substitute for a Janma kundali. The primary

purpose

> > of the `makan kundali' as you had mentioned earlier, is to align

the

> > objects kept in the house with that of the janma kundali planets.

> > Therefore the makan kundali can also be used to correct some

> > planetary placements in the janma kundali. A makan kundali as such

> > can not be an authentic tool to base your predictions on.

> >

> > Have a nice day,

> >

> > Varun Trivedi

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > , kulbir bance

> > <kulbirbance@> wrote:

> >>

> >> Varun ji,

> >>

> >>

> >> 1.lalkitab specifically mentions that palm kundali may not

coincide

> > with

> >> birth horoscope as palm kundali may sometimes include influence

of

> > native's

> >> forefathers actions.

> >> 2. many signs have been given in lalkitab to be found on palm

but i

> > have

> >> come across not more than jaali, mach rekha, trishul triangle and

> > square.

> >> 3. 1939 edition relied heavily on palmistry but i don't think

later

> > editions

> >> put that much emphasis on palmistry, the emphasis was passed on

to

> >> astrology.

> >> 4. what seems to be an ambuguity is the chapter/portion that says

> > person

> >> with such snd such height will have certain age span but i have

> > seen in

> >> total contrast to it that persons with long height have died

> > earlier some

> >> even in prime of their youth whereas persons short in height have

> > lived

> >> long. the average age remains more or less the same irrespective

of

> > height.

> >> 5. apart from some nomads i have not seen any astrologer

especially

> > a

> >> lalkitab follower deciphering from palm.

> >> if we prepare a horoscope by astrology, then varshphal, the

results

> > are more

> >> authentic, house horoscope comes in the curative or remedial

> > portion.

> >> it's true that samudrik shashtra is useful but it only comes with

> > profound

> >> observation.

> >> kindly share your views reagrding this portion.

> >>

> >> regards

> >>

> >> kulbir

> >>

> >

> >

> >

>

> --

> Sent from my mobile device

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Varun Jee,

Jab aapne yeh likha ki 'They will come forward to test your knowledge, but never to share. Iss baat par mein 100% sehmat hoon.

Kisi ko bhee iss baat ki fikar nahi ki knowldge kaise badai ya share karein sab apni janampatri ke anusar hee swal puchhte hain,jankari badane ke liye nahi.

MAHAJAN

 

 

 

 

, "varun_trvd" <varun_trvd wrote:>> Dear Kulbir bhai,> > Your humility makes me speechless.> > I have a few reservations about such a Lal Kitab course.> > Firstly I believe that a skill like astrology can not be learnt > through distance learning/teaching. Astrology is some thing like > classical singing which has to be learnt in the company of [ or at > the feet of] a competent Guru. It needs complete devotion of the > pupil and unflinching love, care and affection of the Guru towards > his pupil. Can we expect either in the present materialistic world? I > do not think so. > > Secondly I doubt if the experienced astrologers will be willing to > share their secret knowledge with these students. We have found > through our own experience that not many people come forward to share > what they know. You can see this group itself. Except a few of us how > many people have come forward to share their knowledge. They will > come forward to test your knowledge, but never to share. This is the > situation when we in the group are extremely courteous to every one. > Have you ever noticed us to jeer at some one, or make some one feel > small or say any thing humiliating? And yet they are not prepared to > share.> > Thirdly astrology is also like carpentry where a lot of manual > drilling has to be gone through under the supervision of a learned > supervisor. Who has got so much time for all this?> > All such courses which are being advertised and floated are to make > money and have nothing to do with imparting genuine knowledge. And > there will be no use adding yet another course into that list.> > Now what is the best alternative ?> > Any one who is genuinely interested in learning Lal Kitab has to > download all the 180 or so articles in our file section. There is an > article in the file section on how to study the Lal Kitab. You can go > through that article and suggest a few modifications if you like. > That article is a very good guideline for beginners.> > He should start reading the book, try to understand it. May be he > will need a few readings of the book before he gets a hang of it. We > might have read the book a few dozen times and can not claim as > having understood more than 40% of the book.> > If he has any difficulties, he can always come to the group and seek > clarifications. > > I assure you that we will share every thing we know. We have no > professional interest in hiding any knowledge. We will try to bring > every one to our level of competence at least. Then each on his own. > > The motto of our group is " qot rami tot arbores" as many branches so > many trees; every branch to become a tree in itself.> > Regards,> > Varun Trivedi> > > > > > > > > , kulbir bance > kulbirbance@ wrote:> >> > Varun ji, > > > > consider it as literally begging. With u i enjoy a brotherly> > relation but i am in awe of shukla ji and bhooshanpriya ji. Both of> > them have a spirit of teacher. Why don't u devise a chapter wise> > syllabus for LK learners. Umesh ji i hope is teaching seperately. To> > bring in prabhakar ji is my responsibility, i have special immunity> > from him. We have mahajan ji and so many more like him in this group> > who want to repay the debt of lalkitab. But educationist is the one> > who can give compass to the knowledge. Many like me have some little> > knowledge but the compass is missing. Can u help, i am really pained> > when i see advertisments for courses for lalkitab. We have scholars> > here with 3 decades of learning who still consider themselves> > students. And now i see teachers produced by 2 years course. Plz> > listen to the voice of ur aatma.> > > > Regards.> > > > Kulbir.> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > On 2/18/09, varun_trvd varun_trvd@ wrote:> > > Dear Kulbir Bhai,> > >> > > [ 1 ] Palmistry is a knowledge known only to a few people. At > least I> > > have not come across any palmistry expert who had a tradition of> > > palmists in the family. On the contrary, I have come across many> > > astrologers where astrology goes back to generations in the > family.> > > In the Lal Kitab a horoscope drawn on the basis of the palm is> > > advised under two circumstances:> > >> > > [ a ] when the birth details are either not known or may not be > very> > > accurate; it is a desperate measure. A horoscope based on the > palm> > > is not used as a substitute under normal circumstances. I have > been> > > told that Pt. Roopchand ji was very particular that the horoscope> > > should be drawn by an able pundit and based on accurate birth > details.> > >> > > [ b ] To confirm certain events or matters indicated in the > horoscope> > > cast according to the birth details. This is included in the book > as> > > Kyafa.> > >> > > Therefore the major role of palmistry in the Lal Kitab is ,> > > primarily, confirmatory.> > >> > > [ 2 ] The signs given in the Lal Kitab are the same which you will> > > find in any book on palmistry. The names of these signs are so> > > archaic that it is difficult to identify them unless you are > formally> > > trained by a knowledgeable palmist. It is like a vaidya teaching > you> > > to identify herbs in a jungle.> > >> > > Since I had never come across a really learned palmist, I never > tried> > > to devote time on palmistry.> > >> > > [ 3 ] Yes. The 1939 book does have its emphasis on palmistry more> > > than the later editions. In the later editions palmistry is > confined> > > to Kyafa, an exercise into confirmation of general condition of > the> > > native. For finer details of the life of the native, it is the> > > horoscope which is the main stay of the study. Like the event you> > > yourself mentioned a couple of days ago about Saturn in the 8th > house> > > with two planets, and the native being born only after two family> > > members had left this world. Now such a finer detail would be> > > possible only through the horoscope. I doubt if it were possible > to> > > predict this through a palm.> > >> > > [ 4 ] Yes, you are right. This section on a correlation between > the> > > height and the life expectancy might have been true a few > centuries> > > ago. But in the modern times with access to medicines and a better> > > general awareness about health, the correlation between height and> > > life expectancy may not hold good.> > >> > > [ 5 ] Yes, you are right. It is only a few roaming pundits, whom > we> > > call bhaddari, who still earn their living through palm readings. > But> > > they are mostly confined to either villages or near courts and> > > stations. Very few of them have any formal learning into > palmistry.> > >> > > [ 6 ] Yes you are right. The results based on a horoscope either > for> > > Janma Kundali or for varsh phal Kundali would definitely come to > be> > > more accurate then the readings through a palm.> > >> > > A horoscope is a very scientific tool, very accurate and very> > > objective. Every astrologer would end up with the same horoscope > for> > > the same birth details. There is nothing subjective about it. Yes,> > > the interpretation of a horoscope can be subjective, that too to a> > > very limited extent. Most of the interpretation will be objective> > > shared by every other astrologer who happens to read the same> > > horoscope.> > >> > > A horoscope cast on the basis of a house or the `makan kundali' > as it> > > is known is not a substitute for a Janma kundali. The primary > purpose> > > of the `makan kundali' as you had mentioned earlier, is to align > the> > > objects kept in the house with that of the janma kundali planets.> > > Therefore the makan kundali can also be used to correct some> > > planetary placements in the janma kundali. A makan kundali as such> > > can not be an authentic tool to base your predictions on.> > >> > > Have a nice day,> > >> > > Varun Trivedi> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > > , kulbir bance> > > <kulbirbance@> wrote:> > >>> > >> Varun ji,> > >>> > >>> > >> 1.lalkitab specifically mentions that palm kundali may not > coincide> > > with> > >> birth horoscope as palm kundali may sometimes include influence > of> > > native's> > >> forefathers actions.> > >> 2. many signs have been given in lalkitab to be found on palm > but i> > > have> > >> come across not more than jaali, mach rekha, trishul triangle and> > > square.> > >> 3. 1939 edition relied heavily on palmistry but i don't think > later> > > editions> > >> put that much emphasis on palmistry, the emphasis was passed on > to> > >> astrology.> > >> 4. what seems to be an ambuguity is the chapter/portion that says> > > person> > >> with such snd such height will have certain age span but i have> > > seen in> > >> total contrast to it that persons with long height have died> > > earlier some> > >> even in prime of their youth whereas persons short in height have> > > lived> > >> long. the average age remains more or less the same irrespective > of> > > height.> > >> 5. apart from some nomads i have not seen any astrologer > especially> > > a> > >> lalkitab follower deciphering from palm.> > >> if we prepare a horoscope by astrology, then varshphal, the > results> > > are more> > >> authentic, house horoscope comes in the curative or remedial> > > portion.> > >> it's true that samudrik shashtra is useful but it only comes with> > > profound> > >> observation.> > >> kindly share your views reagrding this portion.> > >>> > >> regards> > >>> > >> kulbir> > >>> > >> > >> > >> > > > -- > > Sent from my mobile device> >>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Respected Mahajan ji,

 

Some very senior Lal Kitab scholars too had posted queries in the

group to test our knowledge. When it came to sharing their knowledge

with the rest of us, they never came forward.

 

This is the tragedy of the Lal Kitab.

 

With regards and respect,

 

Varun Trivedi

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

, " heartzthief54 "

<heartzthief54 wrote:

>

>

> Varun Jee,

>

> Jab aapne yeh likha ki 'They will come forward to test your

knowledge,

> but never to share. Iss baat par mein 100% sehmat hoon.

>

> Kisi ko bhee iss baat ki fikar nahi ki knowldge kaise badai ya share

> karein sab apni janampatri ke anusar hee swal puchhte hain,jankari

> badane ke liye nahi.

>

> MAHAJAN

>

>

>

>

, " varun_trvd "

> <varun_trvd@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear Kulbir bhai,

> >

> > Your humility makes me speechless.

> >

> > I have a few reservations about such a Lal Kitab course.

> >

> > Firstly I believe that a skill like astrology can not be learnt

> > through distance learning/teaching. Astrology is some thing like

> > classical singing which has to be learnt in the company of [ or at

> > the feet of] a competent Guru. It needs complete devotion of the

> > pupil and unflinching love, care and affection of the Guru towards

> > his pupil. Can we expect either in the present materialistic

world? I

> > do not think so.

> >

> > Secondly I doubt if the experienced astrologers will be willing to

> > share their secret knowledge with these students. We have found

> > through our own experience that not many people come forward to

share

> > what they know. You can see this group itself. Except a few of us

how

> > many people have come forward to share their knowledge. They will

> > come forward to test your knowledge, but never to share. This is

the

> > situation when we in the group are extremely courteous to every

one.

> > Have you ever noticed us to jeer at some one, or make some one

feel

> > small or say any thing humiliating? And yet they are not prepared

to

> > share.

> >

> > Thirdly astrology is also like carpentry where a lot of manual

> > drilling has to be gone through under the supervision of a learned

> > supervisor. Who has got so much time for all this?

> >

> > All such courses which are being advertised and floated are to

make

> > money and have nothing to do with imparting genuine knowledge. And

> > there will be no use adding yet another course into that list.

> >

> > Now what is the best alternative ?

> >

> > Any one who is genuinely interested in learning Lal Kitab has to

> > download all the 180 or so articles in our file section. There is

an

> > article in the file section on how to study the Lal Kitab. You

can go

> > through that article and suggest a few modifications if you like.

> > That article is a very good guideline for beginners.

> >

> > He should start reading the book, try to understand it. May be he

> > will need a few readings of the book before he gets a hang of it.

We

> > might have read the book a few dozen times and can not claim as

> > having understood more than 40% of the book.

> >

> > If he has any difficulties, he can always come to the group and

seek

> > clarifications.

> >

> > I assure you that we will share every thing we know. We have no

> > professional interest in hiding any knowledge. We will try to

bring

> > every one to our level of competence at least. Then each on his

own.

> >

> > The motto of our group is " qot rami tot arbores " as many

branches so

> > many trees; every branch to become a tree in itself.

> >

> > Regards,

> >

> > Varun Trivedi

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > , kulbir bance

> > kulbirbance@ wrote:

> > >

> > > Varun ji,

> > >

> > > consider it as literally begging. With u i enjoy a brotherly

> > > relation but i am in awe of shukla ji and bhooshanpriya ji.

Both of

> > > them have a spirit of teacher. Why don't u devise a chapter wise

> > > syllabus for LK learners. Umesh ji i hope is teaching

seperately. To

> > > bring in prabhakar ji is my responsibility, i have special

immunity

> > > from him. We have mahajan ji and so many more like him in this

group

> > > who want to repay the debt of lalkitab. But educationist is the

one

> > > who can give compass to the knowledge. Many like me have some

little

> > > knowledge but the compass is missing. Can u help, i am really

pained

> > > when i see advertisments for courses for lalkitab. We have

scholars

> > > here with 3 decades of learning who still consider themselves

> > > students. And now i see teachers produced by 2 years course. Plz

> > > listen to the voice of ur aatma.

> > >

> > > Regards.

> > >

> > > Kulbir.

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > > On 2/18/09, varun_trvd varun_trvd@ wrote:

> > > > Dear Kulbir Bhai,

> > > >

> > > > [ 1 ] Palmistry is a knowledge known only to a few people. At

> > least I

> > > > have not come across any palmistry expert who had a tradition

of

> > > > palmists in the family. On the contrary, I have come across

many

> > > > astrologers where astrology goes back to generations in the

> > family.

> > > > In the Lal Kitab a horoscope drawn on the basis of the palm is

> > > > advised under two circumstances:

> > > >

> > > > [ a ] when the birth details are either not known or may not

be

> > very

> > > > accurate; it is a desperate measure. A horoscope based on the

> > palm

> > > > is not used as a substitute under normal circumstances. I have

> > been

> > > > told that Pt. Roopchand ji was very particular that the

horoscope

> > > > should be drawn by an able pundit and based on accurate birth

> > details.

> > > >

> > > > [ b ] To confirm certain events or matters indicated in the

> > horoscope

> > > > cast according to the birth details. This is included in the

book

> > as

> > > > Kyafa.

> > > >

> > > > Therefore the major role of palmistry in the Lal Kitab is ,

> > > > primarily, confirmatory.

> > > >

> > > > [ 2 ] The signs given in the Lal Kitab are the same which you

will

> > > > find in any book on palmistry. The names of these signs are so

> > > > archaic that it is difficult to identify them unless you are

> > formally

> > > > trained by a knowledgeable palmist. It is like a vaidya

teaching

> > you

> > > > to identify herbs in a jungle.

> > > >

> > > > Since I had never come across a really learned palmist, I

never

> > tried

> > > > to devote time on palmistry.

> > > >

> > > > [ 3 ] Yes. The 1939 book does have its emphasis on palmistry

more

> > > > than the later editions. In the later editions palmistry is

> > confined

> > > > to Kyafa, an exercise into confirmation of general condition

of

> > the

> > > > native. For finer details of the life of the native, it is the

> > > > horoscope which is the main stay of the study. Like the event

you

> > > > yourself mentioned a couple of days ago about Saturn in the

8th

> > house

> > > > with two planets, and the native being born only after two

family

> > > > members had left this world. Now such a finer detail would be

> > > > possible only through the horoscope. I doubt if it were

possible

> > to

> > > > predict this through a palm.

> > > >

> > > > [ 4 ] Yes, you are right. This section on a correlation

between

> > the

> > > > height and the life expectancy might have been true a few

> > centuries

> > > > ago. But in the modern times with access to medicines and a

better

> > > > general awareness about health, the correlation between

height and

> > > > life expectancy may not hold good.

> > > >

> > > > [ 5 ] Yes, you are right. It is only a few roaming pundits,

whom

> > we

> > > > call bhaddari, who still earn their living through palm

readings.

> > But

> > > > they are mostly confined to either villages or near courts and

> > > > stations. Very few of them have any formal learning into

> > palmistry.

> > > >

> > > > [ 6 ] Yes you are right. The results based on a horoscope

either

> > for

> > > > Janma Kundali or for varsh phal Kundali would definitely come

to

> > be

> > > > more accurate then the readings through a palm.

> > > >

> > > > A horoscope is a very scientific tool, very accurate and very

> > > > objective. Every astrologer would end up with the same

horoscope

> > for

> > > > the same birth details. There is nothing subjective about it.

Yes,

> > > > the interpretation of a horoscope can be subjective, that too

to a

> > > > very limited extent. Most of the interpretation will be

objective

> > > > shared by every other astrologer who happens to read the same

> > > > horoscope.

> > > >

> > > > A horoscope cast on the basis of a house or the `makan

kundali'

> > as it

> > > > is known is not a substitute for a Janma kundali. The primary

> > purpose

> > > > of the `makan kundali' as you had mentioned earlier, is to

align

> > the

> > > > objects kept in the house with that of the janma kundali

planets.

> > > > Therefore the makan kundali can also be used to correct some

> > > > planetary placements in the janma kundali. A makan kundali as

such

> > > > can not be an authentic tool to base your predictions on.

> > > >

> > > > Have a nice day,

> > > >

> > > > Varun Trivedi

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > > , kulbir bance

> > > > <kulbirbance@> wrote:

> > > >>

> > > >> Varun ji,

> > > >>

> > > >>

> > > >> 1.lalkitab specifically mentions that palm kundali may not

> > coincide

> > > > with

> > > >> birth horoscope as palm kundali may sometimes include

influence

> > of

> > > > native's

> > > >> forefathers actions.

> > > >> 2. many signs have been given in lalkitab to be found on palm

> > but i

> > > > have

> > > >> come across not more than jaali, mach rekha, trishul

triangle and

> > > > square.

> > > >> 3. 1939 edition relied heavily on palmistry but i don't think

> > later

> > > > editions

> > > >> put that much emphasis on palmistry, the emphasis was passed

on

> > to

> > > >> astrology.

> > > >> 4. what seems to be an ambuguity is the chapter/portion that

says

> > > > person

> > > >> with such snd such height will have certain age span but i

have

> > > > seen in

> > > >> total contrast to it that persons with long height have died

> > > > earlier some

> > > >> even in prime of their youth whereas persons short in height

have

> > > > lived

> > > >> long. the average age remains more or less the same

irrespective

> > of

> > > > height.

> > > >> 5. apart from some nomads i have not seen any astrologer

> > especially

> > > > a

> > > >> lalkitab follower deciphering from palm.

> > > >> if we prepare a horoscope by astrology, then varshphal, the

> > results

> > > > are more

> > > >> authentic, house horoscope comes in the curative or remedial

> > > > portion.

> > > >> it's true that samudrik shashtra is useful but it only comes

with

> > > > profound

> > > >> observation.

> > > >> kindly share your views reagrding this portion.

> > > >>

> > > >> regards

> > > >>

> > > >> kulbir

> > > >>

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > >

> > > --

> > > Sent from my mobile device

> > >

> >

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...