LK discussion group 1941 Gutka [ hindi ] / Pt. Yograj Prabhakar ji

[Guest guest]

Gurudev the 1942 edition in hindi with me says budh ke sher/teer ko mangal badh KA MUNH LAGA HAI JO mammu.....; please check in the original 1942 udu; we might get a missing and correct words.

thanks for ur effort; it would have been better if yograj ji took ur services as a proof reader (joking).

sincerely

kulbirbance

On 3/30/08, varun_trvd <varun_trvd wrote:

 

 

 

 

 

Respected Yograj ji,Page 288 line #1/2 reads:'bhudh ke teer ko mangal bud ka munh mamu khandan aur aage aulad inki bhi tabah kare'In the original urdu text there is a long stretched dash [------]

between the word 'budh ka kamunh' and ' mamu khandan'.By reading the line it is felt that some word is missing between 'budh ka munh' and 'mamu khandan'. To me it appears that the qatib did not understand the word written there and that is why he

marked a long stretched dash signaling that there should be a word in between. The dash marked in the original is not a normal dash [-] it is a stretched long dash.In case you do not want to add a word like 'gina hai' or 'kaha hai'

on your own then you should also leave that gap so that the reader can add a word himself.Another minor correction : page 280 line #3 the word 'se'. the matra is missing.With great regards,

Varun Trivedi