Lal Kitab Discussion Group Feb & March sarini examined : found grossly inaccurat

[Guest guest]

Dear Varun Ji,You excercise is good and elaborative. But, Let us stick to the task given to individual by Mr. Kalsi. Yours is . For Varun Trivedi JiPerson Name - B, DOB 15.02.1976, place Toronto,Canada, Time 15.43

Kalsi Ji has give on date for all for differnt places. We will submitt the details for that onlyRegardsNirmal Kumar BhardwajOn 10/29/07, varun_trvd

<varun_trvd wrote:

Respected Kalsi ji, ooops made a few typos. Corrections:

[ a ] Example 1 The difference between the lagna derived through software and manually is 1d3'; had typed less than a degree. [ b ] Example 3 The difference is some 11 degrees or some 44 minutes; had typed 55 minutes. Regards, Varun Trivedi

, Varun Trivedi <varun_trvd wrote: > > > { Let anyone cross check } > > > Respected kalsi ji, > > I have randomly selected different dates, different ascendants and different years to verify the sarini February and March pages. > > I have tried to verify it through the soft ware and through manual procedure with the help of Table of Ascendants by Lahiri. > > While using the table of Ascendants of Lahiri to calculate the ST of Epoch I have left out minor corrections of table iv [ of a few seconds only ]. The entire exercise is to find an approximate lagna through the help of the ephemeris. > > Example -1 > February 4, 1952 > At 1:19 pm > Madras [ 80E15;13N4 ]

> > In the Sarini Taurus is shown to end at 1:18 pm. Therefore at 1:19 pm the Lagna should show Gemini rising. > > Here are the results of verification : > > Using a software :

> > The Lagna works out to 14 Ta 47 > From Table of ascendants : > > ST at noon on Feb 4, 1952 at madras > [ 20-55-51 + 0-1-36 + 0-0-1 ] > > = 20-57-28

> Therefore the ST of Epoch = [ 20 �57-28 + 1-10-0] > > = 22-7-28 > Lagna at ST 22-8 in Madras is shown as = 1-16-2 > > [ 1- 16 �2 ] � [0-0-12 ayanansh] > > = 1 �15 � 50 > > The Lagna derived through the Lahiri Table of Ascendant is > > 15 Ta 50 > > The difference of the lagna derived with the soft ware and manually derived from the Table of Ascendant is less than one degree. > > Therefore The Sarini is off by almost 15 degrees or about ONE HOUR. The Sarini is grossly inaccurate. >

> > > > Example � 2 > Date : February 21, 1962 > Time ; 7:9 pm > Place : Madras > > The Sarini says that Leo will set at 7:9 pm and the Virgo will rise. > > The Lagna acquired with a software is : > > 22 Le 50 > > The Lagna acquired manually with the help of Table of ascendants > > ST at noon on Feb 21, 1962 at Madras is : 22-2-50 [ corrections done] > > ST of the epoch is = [ 22-2-50 ] + [ 7-0-0 LMT] > > = 5 � 2 � 50 > > The lagna acquired through the Table of ascendants > > = [ 4 � 22-55] � [ 0-0-20 ayanansh corr] > > = Lagna 22 Le 35 > > The difference between the soft ware and the manually calculated Lagna is 15� which is within limits. > > The Lagna sarini is off by more than 7 degrees or some 28 minutes. Once again grossly inaccurate. > > > Example 3 > > > Date : March 5 , 1972 > Time : 3:59 pm > Place Madras > > The Sarini shows that Cancer will set at 3:59 pm and Leo will rise. > > The Lagna works out : 18 Ca 55 through a software > Lagna acquired manually with the help of Table of ascendants of Lahiri : > > ST at noon on March 5,1972 at Madras :

> > [ 22-50-12 ] - [ 0-1-4] + [ 0-0-1] > > = 22 � 49 � 9 > > ST at the epoch : > > [ 22-49-9] + [ 3-50] > > = 2-39-9

> > The Lagna at ST 2-40 shown in the sarini for Madras is 3-18-41 > [3-18-41] � [ 0-0-28 ayanansh corr] > > = Lagna 18 Ca 13 > > The difference between the lagna acquired manually and through the software is just 42� > > Here again the Sarini is off by some 11 degrees or some 55 minutes. > > > Example 4 ; > > Date : March 18, 1982

> Time : 12:49 pm > Place : Madras > > The Sarini shows that at 12:49 pm Gemini ends and the Cancer rises. > > The soft ware derived Lagna is = 16 Ge 41 > Lagna derived manually through Table of ascendants by lahiri : > > ST at noon on March 18, 1982 at Madras is > > [ 23-41-27] + [ 0-0-33 ] + [ 0-0-1] > > = 23-42-1

> > The ST of the epoch is : > > [ 23-42-1] + [ 0-40-0] > > = 0 � 22 �1 > > The Lagna shown in the Table at ST 0-22-1 is : 2-17-18 > > [ 2-17-18 ] � [ 0-0- 37 ayanansh corr] > > = Lagna 16 Ge 41 > > The Lagna acquired through the software and manually are the same. > > The sarini is off by some 13 degrees or some 52 minutes. Grossly inaccurate. > > I think we have done enough exercises to verify the Sarini and every time it has been found that the Sarini is grossly inaccurate. > > I think I need not waste any more of my time on the sarini which has been found to be inaccurate many times over. > > Regards, > > Varun Trivedi > > > > >

> Unlimited freedom, unlimited storage. Get it now >