Pucca Ghar Lord has the precedence over Rasi Lord.

[Guest guest]

Respected Varun Ji,

 

Sar in 5th:-- Bad impact on children since sar is in his enemy

house(Sun).

Sun in 11:-- Dharmi Swabhav sun will occupy jur qualities since 11th is

pucca ghar of jur.

 

If a planet is placed in a house which is the pucca ghar of another

planet then the posited planet will occupy the color of Lord of

pucca ghar rahter then the lord of the house(sign), as is clear

in above 2 intrepretations.

 

Hence can we say that pucca ghar influence will have precedence over

rasi lord influence, when a planet is placed in a house.

 

If my understanding is right then my query is that 5 H is also the

pucca ghar of Jur then why the sar w'nt have the jur qualities.

 

With Regards,

Pradeep

[Guest guest]

Respected Pradeep ji,

 

I believe that the planets in a house are affected more by their

friendship / enmity relationship rather than who whose pucca ghar

it is. If the house is owned by a friend, the planet placed there

would feel comfortable, if not then it might be hostile.

 

Taking your own example the fifth house is a karak of progeny and

owned by the Sun [ in the cardinal kundali, kalpurush kundali ] .

When Saturn gets posited there, it is likely to harm the progeny

because it is in an enemy house. The same is true about the Sun

posited in the 11th , the house owned by Saturn. Sun stops giving

good effects on the karaks of Saturn, so says the Lal Kitab.

 

The Sun behaves like a dharmi, in spite of being in the house owned

by its enemy Saturn , only so long as it doesn't antagonize the

owner of the house by eating meat and drinking liquor etc. The

moment the jatak starts eating meat etc, even Jupiter, who also

shares the 11th as its pucca house with Saturn, can not save the

Sun. Therefore the Sun will be dharmi so long as " nek chalata

poora " .

 

Finally, I to the Vedic dictum that the Rasi lord has a

greater influence on the planet posited there than the karak of the

house [ Vedic concept ] or what the Lal Kitab calls the pucca ghar

owner.

 

With regards,

 

Varun Trivedi

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

, " pm_pmishra "

<pm_pmishra wrote:

>

> Respected Varun Ji,

>

> Sar in 5th:-- Bad impact on children since sar is in his enemy

> house(Sun).

> Sun in 11:-- Dharmi Swabhav sun will occupy jur qualities since

11th is

> pucca ghar of jur.

>

> If a planet is placed in a house which is the pucca ghar of another

> planet then the posited planet will occupy the color of Lord of

> pucca ghar rahter then the lord of the house(sign), as is clear

> in above 2 intrepretations.

>

> Hence can we say that pucca ghar influence will have precedence

over

> rasi lord influence, when a planet is placed in a house.

>

> If my understanding is right then my query is that 5 H is also the

> pucca ghar of Jur then why the sar w'nt have the jur qualities.

>

> With Regards,

> Pradeep

>