Horary and Sincerity

[Guest guest]

Dear Members,

I have a delicate question.

 

All of us know that when we use horary technique, the chart cast using

the number given must reflect the mind (through Moon). In other words,

we expect the person who gave us the number to have a " genuine urge "

to know the answer to his question. Consider the following two scenarios.

 

Scenario-1: I am the astrologer. A person who is a disbeliever in

astrology CHALLENGES me openly, asking me to predict whether he will

have a child (assume he has been recently married). I have to offer a

prediction. (Assume this is happening in a live TV show.)

 

Scenario-2: I am teaching astrology in an institute. A student in the

class respectfully observes that he is not convinced that Horary can

work and wants me to prove him WRONG by predicting whether he will

have a child (assume he has been recently married).

 

There could be other scenarios such as the above, but the point is

that the " client " is unlikely to have a " genuine " desire to know (at

least in these examples) whether he will have a child.

 

Will horary work in these cases? If it does not work (esp. in Scenario

- 1), my reputation will be at stake. Of course I could withdraw from

the challenge but it does not bring credibility to the system I practise.

 

If astrology is believed (at least by its practitioners) to be a

science, how do you explain such cases?

 

Regards,

Rangarajan