Opinion: Asc-Moon Method of Rectification

[Guest guest]

Hello Friends,

 

A lot of discussion is going on now-a-days on the Asc-Moon connection

method of birth time rectification. Though I have never used it but

always suspected its authenticity due to being unaware of the

rationale behind the method. The method is quite old now and there

will definitely be many regular users of this method. I believe that

this group, probably being the biggest on KP, is the best place to

have such kind of polls. I request everybody to share his invaluable

experience. Here is the link to the poll -

 

/surveys?id=11996085

 

Thanks & Regards,

 

Punit Pandey

[Guest guest]

Dear Punit,

 

1. I agree with you. Perhaps rules were set by our sages with their

intuitive power and scientific knowledge (e.g. a particular order of

planet periods and allottment of each planet a particular numbers of

years in Vimsottari dasa) and by great astrologers of our time on the

basis of their experience or research with hundreds of consultants or

charts. Rules may not agree to each and every native and there may be

rare exceptional natives, execptional charts. For those exceptional

ones significant life events may not agree with rules like in

mathematical formulars. The following quotations are worthy to note:

 

(1) KSK, " Many general rules which should not be strictly applied.

Many modifications are to be included.--- Analytical study, correct

intuition and good judgment are needed -– " KP Reader III.

 

(2) B. V. Raman, " Astrology is a subject where not only an insight

into its techniques is needed but also certain amount of

intuition. Experience can gradually make appreciate the nuances of

the predictive art. " (A Note On Problems In Prediction, by Pemmaraju

V.R.Rayudu)

 

2. However rules may not be reversed by the correctness of one or

two exceptional cases since rules are usually set on the basis of

hundreds of charts and it is not mathematics. In mathematics, one

case is enough to prove, e.g. in 1960's one young chinese

mathematician was honoured with a higher acknowledgement than a PhD

and someone got PhD in Mathematics with a thesis of 3 pages by

reversing wellknown mathematical concepts and Einstein became famous

for reversing Newton's theory but he got Nobel Price for another

contribution not for that reversal.

 

3. As far as my reading goes, even Dr. K.R. Kar and Prof. K.

Balachandran do not outrightly reverse KP rules of Retrogression and

Punarphoo in their presentation of SUB SUB theory. In his examples

Prof. K. Balachandran usually explains why Retro planet is taken into

consideration and how Punarphoo is cancelled according to the

Retrogression Theory and Punarphoo Cancellation Theory propounded by

Dr. K. Kar, i.e. keeping the ball in control started to roll by Dr.

Kar, not just rolling the ball. It has been pinned down for Dr.

Kar's original Retrogression Theory of KK (Kar Padhdhati) to be in

KP Annual 2001, a missing copy of which has been requested again

from my book supplier at any cost.

 

4. Even though Dr. Kar's articles are reserved for copy right,

hopefully someone may explain generally his rules of exemption from

KP Retrogression rule.

 

Thanks and best regards,

 

tw

 

 

 

 

, Punit Pandey <punitp@g...> wrote:

> Hello Friends,

>

> A lot of discussion is going on now-a-days on the Asc-Moon

connection

> method of birth time rectification. Though I have never used it but

> always suspected its authenticity due to being unaware of the

> rationale behind the method. The method is quite old now and there

> will definitely be many regular users of this method. I believe that

> this group, probably being the biggest on KP, is the best place to

> have such kind of polls. I request everybody to share his invaluable

> experience. Here is the link to the poll -

>

> /surveys?id=11996085

>

> Thanks & Regards,

>

> Punit Pandey