is navmansh (fruit) of the natal(tree) chart

[Guest guest]

Resected guruji

 

In some sites i have read that the navmansh chart is the fruit of the natal

chart

as the tree.

Even if the natal chart (tree ) is good if the navmansh chart is not that good

one will not have good results in life(fruits)

 

How far would you agree with this.

 

You wrote that the " HERE THE FUNCTIONAL NATURE OF NAVAMSA

PLANETS COUNTS "

Does your statement mean that even the navmansh chart's 6th,8th,12th house

need to be looked if they are having a MT sign and then take out the

malefic planets.

 

Does that mean that a functinal benefic may turn func malefic in the chart.

or vice versa.

 

Thanks a lot for your time and efforts

 

This

V K CHOUDHRY <siha wrote:

Hello Naman,

I add my replies to your questions in the appended message.

 

, Naman Goyal <naman2121 wrote:

>

> Respected guruji

>

> I want to ask you that when we analyze the navmansh chart

>

> Should the planets in that chart be seen as the benefics and the

malefics of the natal chart or according to the ascendant of the

navmansh chart.

IN NAVAMSA WE SEE. 1. STRENGTH OF PLANETS. 2. INFLUENCES ON ASDT OF

NAVAMSA IF IT IS AN MT SIGN - HERE THE FUNCTIONAL NATURE OF NAVAMSA

PLANETS COUNTS 3. POSN OF SIGNIFICATORS OF MARRIAGE IN NATAL CHART IN

THE NAVAMSA CHART.

> Also the degrees the planets have in the natal chart should the

same degrees be taken for the navmansh chart.

NO.

> Is it true that the navmansh chart is the chart as the person

actually become.

>

NO.

> your reply should surely be enlightening

>

> Kind regards

> Naman goyal

>

>

>

> Never miss a thing. Make your homepage.

>

>

[Guest guest]

Hello Naman,

 

I add my replies/comments to your questions in your message appended below.

 

Best wishes.

 

 

 

 

-

" Naman Goyal " <naman2121

 

Wednesday, December 26, 2007 5:07 PM

Re: Re: is navmansh (fruit) of the natal(tree) chart

 

 

Resected guruji

 

In some sites i have read that the navmansh chart is the fruit of the natal

chart

as the tree.

Even if the natal chart (tree ) is good if the navmansh chart is not that

good

one will not have good results in life(fruits)

 

How far would you agree with this.

I DO NOT AGREE WITH THIS.

 

You wrote that the " HERE THE FUNCTIONAL NATURE OF NAVAMSA

PLANETS COUNTS "

Does your statement mean that even the navmansh chart's 6th,8th,12th house

need to be looked if they are having a MT sign and then take out the

malefic planets.

 

FOR THE PURPOSES OF STUDYING INFLUENCES ON NAVAMSA MT SIGN ASDT, YES.

Does that mean that a functinal benefic may turn func malefic in the chart.

or vice versa.

FOR THE PURPOSES OF NAVAMSA, ONLY.

Thanks a lot for your time and efforts

 

V K CHOUDHRY <siha wrote:

Hello Naman,

I add my replies to your questions in the appended message.

 

, Naman Goyal <naman2121 wrote:

>

> Respected guruji

>

> I want to ask you that when we analyze the navmansh chart

>

> Should the planets in that chart be seen as the benefics and the

malefics of the natal chart or according to the ascendant of the

navmansh chart.

IN NAVAMSA WE SEE. 1. STRENGTH OF PLANETS. 2. INFLUENCES ON ASDT OF

NAVAMSA IF IT IS AN MT SIGN - HERE THE FUNCTIONAL NATURE OF NAVAMSA

PLANETS COUNTS 3. POSN OF SIGNIFICATORS OF MARRIAGE IN NATAL CHART IN

THE NAVAMSA CHART.

> Also the degrees the planets have in the natal chart should the

same degrees be taken for the navmansh chart.

NO.

> Is it true that the navmansh chart is the chart as the person

actually become.

>

NO.

> your reply should surely be enlightening

>

> Kind regards

> Naman goyal

>

>

>

> Never miss a thing. Make your homepage.

>

>