QUESTIONS about Ashok Thapar ji' and Dheendayalan Jee's horoscopes...

[Guest guest]

Respected BhooshanPriya Jee,

 

I take a strong exception to the Bhav-Spashta techniques applied by you to Ms. Ankur's horoscope as well as the one submitted by Dheendayalan Jee. I am somewhat familiar with Vedic astrology and do understand many of these techniques, though not in fine details.

 

Birth details provided by Ashok Jee are as follows:

 

> Her Birth Details are Ms. Ankur > DOB: Aug 27,1981> TOB: 7:17AM IST> POB: Patiala Longitude: 76E24 Latitude: 30N19

This gives me the following horoscope:

+--------------+| \ Ve Sa / \ Ma Ra / || \ Ju / \ Mo / || \ / \ / ||

\ / Su \ / || \ / \ / || x As x || / \ / \ ||

/ \ Me / \ || / \ / \ || / \ 5 / \ || / \ / \ ||

GL x || \ / \ / || \ / \ / || \ / \ / || \

/ \ / || \ / \ / || x x || / \ / \ || /

\ / \ || / \ / \ || / Ke \ / \ || / \ / \ |+--------------+

Please keep in mind the following facts:

1. The ascendant does not change for another 17 minutes and 02 seconds.

2.Mercury does not change signs for approximately three days.

3. Sun will stay in Leo for almost 20 more days at this particular point in time.

4. Moon came into Cancer 14 hours 47 minutes earlier and will stay there for another 1 day and 14 hours (approximately).

5. Mars came into Cancer 4 days earlier and will stay there for another 44 days.

6. Rahu will stay in Cancer for another 119 days and has been there for the last 447 days.

These numbers, for a LalKitab based kunDali, present absolutely no need to warrant a move to the next sign/house. Had the Lagna been such that it were going to change in five to six minutes, then one would have been justified to attempt moving the planets over (but would verify the effects before doing so and only upon confirmation would solidify such a move) or, if a planet were to transit the same hour (as of birth) , the shift could be justified. I have seen it done and have done it many times but NOT before LalKitab based verification. My utmost respect to the MahaRishees who formulated classical Indian astrology but we are dealing with LalKitab here in the cotext of this forum - we are using LalKitab for interperetation and nivaran and it is WRONG, DANGEROUS AND MISLEADING TO MIX AND MATCH THE TWO SYSTEMS. I've made similar

mistakes in the past and have caused harm for which I regret to this day.

I humbly request you to please not adulterate LalKitab kundali unnecessarily. Let us minimize the possibilities of causing harm though your intentions are extremely honest - (no two ways about your intentions - you are working very hard, very honestly and are extremely knowledgeable.

Respectfully,

Rajinder Bhatia.

 

bhooshanpriya <bhooshanpriya wrote:

Dear Ashok ji,The lagna of your daughter is at 26d :17m in simha , With this lagna after Bhav-spashth the Sun from the 1st has moved to the 12th , the three planets moon , mars and rahu have moved to the 11th and ketu from the 6th has moved to the 5th.I have worked out the 25th year varsh phal based on the planets after the bhav-spashtha.Here are the upaya for the 25th year starting August 27 , 2005. These upaya should be done after August 27th only.Upaya :[ 1 ] Offer at any temple a little chanaa daal at any temple for six days regularly.[ 2 ] Keep at home a little rain water with four small square pieces of silver immersed in it. As and when the water dries up , replenish it with rain water again.[ 3 ] Keep with her a small solid silver toy elephant.[ 4 ] Bury deep under water a little

mustard oil kept in an earthen pot. Cement the earthen lid so that the oil doesn't spill out into the water. The pot should be buried at a place where it always stays under water.Dos :[ a ] Give a pair of clothes to a pujari of any temple[ b ] Take a little honey early in the morning.[ c ] Should sleep with a little saunf under her pillow. The saunf should be kept in a dull red square thaili of cloth.[ d ] Make sure that none of her leather items are either lost or stolen.Don'ts :[ a ] Should not keep old brass utensils either empty or turned upside down.[ b ] Should not have any blunt knife etc at home.[ c ] Should not eat eggs.[ d ] Should not buy any thing of leather for the whole year.[ e ] Should not make any smoke around where she lives.[ f ] should not keep locks , that which she is not using , locked.Sincerely,Priya--- In

lalkitab , "ashok_thapar" <ashok_thapar> wrote:> Dear Ms. Bhooshanpriya,> > Please refer to the message no. 1675 dated Apr 28, 2004 vide which > Er. Upadhyay had recommended remedies for my daughter in view of her > Varshphal for the year 23rd (2003-04).> > 1. Since now she is running her 24th year and she has asked me the > following:> What should she do with the haldi ganth and small solid silver toy > elephant? > > 2. Can you suggest her some upaya for her current running year > 24th year? She is having Sun in 6th and Rahu in Lagna in her current > Varshphal.> > In her 25th year starting from 27 Aug 2005 she will be having > Ju,Ven. and Sat. in 6th Rahu in 9th and Ketu in 8th. > > Her Birth Details are Ms. Ankur > DOB: Aug 27,1981> TOB: 7:17AM IST>

POB: Patiala Longitude: 76E24 Latitude: 30N19> > Thanks> > Ashok Thapar

!