Guest guest Posted April 29, 2005 Report Share Posted April 29, 2005 Dear friends, Please consider this book "Asli Prachin Vrihad Lal Kitab" Manoj publication by group of 3 authors. First Edition 2004 I am finding it better than some known versions. Best regards JaiPunit Pandey <punitp wrote: Priya ji & Friends, In my opinion, different books are useful for different readers. Pt. Ashant's book is good for the beginner but not much usable after a period of time. The biggest problem with this book is its incompleteness. The grammar has been discussed in very brief and not sufficient to understand Lal Kitab. But as we all know that there are not many options available in English. So in English, the only possible option is to use Goswami & Vashishta ji's book in conjunction with Ashant ji's book. Ashant ji's book is easy to understand and one can find detailed grammar in G & V book. I have personally stopped using Ashant ji's book, as I am more interested in grammar now a days. As I don't understand Urdu, I cannot read the original Lal Kitab. Now a days I have to rely on 1952 & 1942 transliteration of Lal Kitab (Arun Samhita) by Hare Krishan Trust. Regards, Punit Pandey On 4/28/05, bhooshanpriya <bhooshanpriya wrote: Dear Friends,I am again posting a list of books for those interested in Lal KitabThere can be no substitute of the original Lal Kitab However there are four books available in English that one couldbuy.[ a ] An english translation of the Lal Kitab by Goswami & Vashishtha . {A very poor translation and at places atrocious.}[ b ] A book written by Pt. Krishna Ashant. It is a translation of his hindi book called `Prashthbhoomi evam Vyakhya of LK { by far thebest }[ c ] A book by RS Chillar . { just an ordinary book }All these three books are published by :Sagar Publications72, Janpath , Ved Mansion New Delhi - 110001phone : [ 011 ] 23320648 ; 23328245e – mail : sagrpubThe fourth book is Lal Kitab by Prof UC Mahajan : { a well written book , with his own interpretations }Published by :Pustak Mahal6686, khari baoli , Delhi – 110006ph : 23944314 ; 23911979e – mail : rapidexdelhi Books in Hindi :Books by Pt. Krishna Ashant { very good books }Published by :Shilalekha,4/32, Subhas gali , Vishwas NagarShahdara , Delhi : 110032Phone : 22303184Arun Sanhita { transliteration of Lal Kitab , full of typographical mistakes }Published by :Hare Krishna TrustPO box – 123Chandigarh – 160017In Delhi most of these books will be available with :K K Goyal & Co214 , Dariba KalanDelhi – 6Phone : 23253604Sincerely,Priya------------------------ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 19, 2008 Report Share Posted May 19, 2008 Dear Varun Jee, I tried Nai Sarak for these two books to no avail. Please suggest where can I get these two books in Delhi. Thanks and regards, Dhiraj Misravarun_trvd <varun_trvd wrote: Respected Yogesh ji,You would lover eading that book. Not only that, once you have read it a couple of times your interest in the Lal Kitab would grow. If you start with any editions of the Lal Kitab to begin with, there is always a possibility that you might develop an aversion to the book. This book acts as a very good introduction to the Lal Kitab. I would advise you to buy his 'Trik bhavanon ki gatha' also. Another a must book.Regards,Varun Trivedi , "yogesh jaitely" <yogesh.jaitely wrote:>> Respected Varun Ji,> > I have purchased the suggested book. It is a handy book and looks to be> simple.> > Thanks for guidance> > Yogesh> > On 5/16/08, varun_trvd <varun_trvd wrote:> >> > Respected Yogesh ji,> >> > You can get all information about these terms from Pt. Krishna> > Ashant ji's book " Lal Kitab Prashthabhoomi aur Vyakhya". This book> > is recommended in the reading list for those who are interested in> > learning the Lal Kitab system.> >> > We as a group avoid being a long distance teaching group.> >> > Regards,> >> > Varun Trivedi> >> > <%40>,> > "yogesh jaitely"> > <yogesh.jaitely@> wrote:> > >> > > Respected Sirs,> > > I just started reading Lal kitab. The following terms become> > difficult for> > > me.> > > 1. What is grah fal and what is rashi fal. How these can be used> > in remedial> > > measures.> > > 2. What is Bilmuqabil planet. How it can be find from Kundli.> > > Thanks> > > Yogesh> > >> >> > > >> Unlimited freedom, unlimited storage. Get it now Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.