Guest guest Posted April 28, 2005 Report Share Posted April 28, 2005 I agree with the aspects based on authentic LK only.One should not mix two system while diagnosing the chart. Use one tool(KP, LK, Vedic) at a time, why Vedic aspect in LK?? when LK has its own grammer, own way of prescribing remedies, own karka of planets etc etc. Initially when I started LK I also followed some authors who consider vedic special aspect of Sat, Mars and Jup but later I realised sticking to original and authentic version of LK would be better. So when I analyse chart through LK I apply only LK and when through other method(Vedic or KP) I apply the principal of those systems only. This is my personnal view only. Shunny Nigam Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 29, 2005 Report Share Posted April 29, 2005 Friends, LalKitab doesn't recognize the special aspects of Jupiter, Saturn, Mars etc. However, you can't blame the LK practitioners. Almost all the authors of the published material on LalKitab (except the authentic LalKitab, attempted transliterations and translations) mix traditional astrology and LK principles, causing a disastrous disservice to their readers. For example, the explanation of the upaya for Saturn in the fifth house by Prof. Krishan Ashant, who postulates that Saturn aspects the tenth house (thus Saturn from the fifth house aspecting the second house, which is the dharma sthaan, so we place almonds in a temple as recommended in the '52 edition) is based on half-baked logic. The fact is that this upaya has absolutely nothing to do with the aspects recognized in Vedic astrology; it is just by chance that the dharma sthaan was picked for this upaya but not because of Saturn's tenth aspect. If this aspect theory were true then one could have created (and unfortunately people are creating) upayas for Saturn in each house - there would be no need to consult and concentrate on LalKitab anymore. Respectfully, Rajinder Bhatiavinod kumar <chamakkam2003 wrote: I agree with the aspects based on authentic LK only.One should not mix two system while diagnosing the chart. Use one tool(KP, LK, Vedic) at a time, why Vedic aspect in LK?? when LK has its own grammer, own way of prescribing remedies, own karka of planets etc etc. Initially when I started LK I also followed some authors who consider vedic special aspect of Sat, Mars and Jup but later I realised sticking to original and authentic version of LK would be better. So when I analyse chart through LK I apply only LK and when through other method(Vedic or KP) I apply the principal of those systems only. This is my personnal view only. Shunny Nigam Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 14, 2005 Report Share Posted May 14, 2005 --- Punit Pandey <punitp wrote: > > > > Hello Fellow Lalkitabists, > > It is great that Lal Kitab study has started again > in the forum. So > IMO it is the best time to keep getting answers of > small-small queries. > My last query, Suicidal Tendencies, was very well > replied by Priya ji. > I hope we will see more and more qualitative replies > in future. > > I have another small question. Do you take the > special planetary > aspects (Saturn 3,10), Jupiter (5,9) and Mars (4,8) > in account in Lal > Kitab based analysis? > > I hope that all expert members will give at least a > quick reply. > > Regards, > > Punit Pandey > > yes, it is necessary to take special aspects of Saturn. Jupiter and Mars regards pani Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 14, 2005 Report Share Posted May 14, 2005 Dear Punit ji, Except of the mahadasa part of Lal Kitab , these aspects are not taken into account. But this does not mean lal Kitab has ignored them completely infact they are used in a far practical and efficient way. 5 - 9 aspect is taken as friendly aspect and planets become foundation of each other even they are enemies. 4 - 10 aspect is taken as deceiving aspect. This means that these planets can do good or bad depending on few factors. 6 - 8 aspect is enemy aspect and planets harm the prospects of each other even if friends. Awaiting more enlightenment on the subject, Best regards Jai On 5/14/05, athmananda athmananda <mahashodashi wrote: --- Punit Pandey <punitp wrote:>>>> Hello Fellow Lalkitabists,>> It is great that Lal Kitab study has started again> in the forum. So > IMO it is the best time to keep getting answers of> small-small queries.> My last query, Suicidal Tendencies, was very well> replied by Priya ji.> I hope we will see more and more qualitative replies > in future.>> I have another small question. Do you take the> special planetary> aspects (Saturn 3,10), Jupiter (5,9) and Mars (4,8)> in account in Lal> Kitab based analysis? >> I hope that all expert members will give at least a> quick reply.>> Regards,>> Punit Pandey>> yes, it is necessary to take special aspects ofSaturn. Jupiter and Mars regardspani>>>>>>> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.