Lalkitab Course - Positive inputs needed

[Guest guest]

Dear Members and Gurujans,

 

We all would have a copy of lalkitab with us by now, if not please

run and get it.

 

And those who have it must be breaking our heads on it.

 

Any way, this is a controversial topic and i want to tread on this

very slowly.

 

I would like to ask Punit to create a Vote on whether the members

here want to have course or not.

 

Will it be a classroom course or a corresponse course.

 

Then how would the examination will be conducted.

 

I believe the examination need to be in one place(closes to the place

where all the learned members can come) atleast for the first batch

and the exam needs not only to check not just the knowledge but also

the haav bhaav of the student( could create a controversy/ but please

avoid it now).

 

What kind of Certificates be given to the students. Exact matter to

be written on the certificate. This can be decided during the

discussion in the group itself.

 

What kind of fee structure be of the course. Will it be free or no

profit no loss. How will the fees be decided, somebody who has some

accouting knowledge can come up with some idea.

 

Who all will be in the involved in the creation of the course

structure and content.

 

Will there be any classroom session if yes then who will take up the

classess.

 

The teachers who would like to come forward should they be paid for

their service, if not how will the food and travel and accomodation

expenses be taken care of.

 

I personally believe we need to have a teacher for any knowledge gain.

 

Thanks & Regards

Vivek

[Guest guest]

Since the group moderator has made it clear beyond doubt that the

primary objective of the group is discusion and upayas etc. is

incidental. sopunitmay i have the permission to start with the

houses. then planets nad so on. if someone is intersted he can joinor

contribute if someone is not intersted he can have parrallel

discussions but lets start only if we get a goahead from

punit.regarding certificate nobody asks for certificates or medals in

astrology the people are intersted in solving there problems if you

have the capacity this is the only certificate otherwise certificates

are of no use at all. i know a gentleman who gives a doctorate degree

from a srilanka university in jyotish by taking money the persons who

have got even a doctorate degree are still at crossroads. so lets

concntrate on learning alone.

kulbir

 

lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " <jyotish_mail>

wrote:

>

> Dear Members and Gurujans,

>

> We all would have a copy of lalkitab with us by now, if not please

> run and get it.

>

> And those who have it must be breaking our heads on it.

>

> Any way, this is a controversial topic and i want to tread on this

> very slowly.

>

> I would like to ask Punit to create a Vote on whether the members

> here want to have course or not.

>

> Will it be a classroom course or a corresponse course.

>

> Then how would the examination will be conducted.

>

> I believe the examination need to be in one place(closes to the

place

> where all the learned members can come) atleast for the first batch

> and the exam needs not only to check not just the knowledge but

also

> the haav bhaav of the student( could create a controversy/ but

please

> avoid it now).

>

> What kind of Certificates be given to the students. Exact matter to

> be written on the certificate. This can be decided during the

> discussion in the group itself.

>

> What kind of fee structure be of the course. Will it be free or no

> profit no loss. How will the fees be decided, somebody who has some

> accouting knowledge can come up with some idea.

>

> Who all will be in the involved in the creation of the course

> structure and content.

>

> Will there be any classroom session if yes then who will take up

the

> classess.

>

> The teachers who would like to come forward should they be paid for

> their service, if not how will the food and travel and accomodation

> expenses be taken care of.

>

> I personally believe we need to have a teacher for any knowledge

gain.

>

> Thanks & Regards

> Vivek

[Guest guest]

Kulbir ji,

 

You have taken words out of my mouth (hope it is a correct idiom).

After forming group constitution, the next immediate target is to

start discussion on lal kitab grammar. I tried in the past, but I

think, I am not the right person for it, especially due to the ongoing

time problem.

 

We are still not through with the formation of core group. But may I

request you and Hameed ji to take responsibility for discussion of lal

kitab grammar. I have seen you and Hameed ji doing it in desecrate

manner. We need some person to lead on the process. The process is

needed to be streamlined.

 

If you are okay with the idea, let us start the discussion on lal

kitab grammar. Also let me know what sort of help is required form my

side, if any. We can start discussion either couplet-by-couplet or

topic-by-topic. Please decide on which method can be the best and

vitalize the process.

 

Waiting for feedbacks and suggestions from all members.

 

Regards,

 

Punit Pandey

 

On Fri, 22 Oct 2004 07:12:35 -0000, Kulbir Singh Bains

<ceetabains wrote:

>

>

> Since the group moderator has made it clear beyond doubt that the

> primary objective of the group is discusion and upayas etc. is

> incidental. sopunitmay i have the permission to start with the

> houses. then planets nad so on. if someone is intersted he can joinor

> contribute if someone is not intersted he can have parrallel

> discussions but lets start only if we get a goahead from

> punit.regarding certificate nobody asks for certificates or medals in

> astrology the people are intersted in solving there problems if you

> have the capacity this is the only certificate otherwise certificates

> are of no use at all. i know a gentleman who gives a doctorate degree

> from a srilanka university in jyotish by taking money the persons who

> have got even a doctorate degree are still at crossroads. so lets

> concntrate on learning alone.

> kulbir

>

> lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " <jyotish_mail>

> wrote:

>

>

> >

> > Dear Members and Gurujans,

> >

> > We all would have a copy of lalkitab with us by now, if not please

> > run and get it.

> >

> > And those who have it must be breaking our heads on it.

> >

> > Any way, this is a controversial topic and i want to tread on this

> > very slowly.

> >

> > I would like to ask Punit to create a Vote on whether the members

> > here want to have course or not.

> >

> > Will it be a classroom course or a corresponse course.

> >

> > Then how would the examination will be conducted.

> >

> > I believe the examination need to be in one place(closes to the

> place

> > where all the learned members can come) atleast for the first batch

> > and the exam needs not only to check not just the knowledge but

> also

> > the haav bhaav of the student( could create a controversy/ but

> please

> > avoid it now).

> >

> > What kind of Certificates be given to the students. Exact matter to

> > be written on the certificate. This can be decided during the

> > discussion in the group itself.

> >

> > What kind of fee structure be of the course. Will it be free or no

> > profit no loss. How will the fees be decided, somebody who has some

> > accouting knowledge can come up with some idea.

> >

> > Who all will be in the involved in the creation of the course

> > structure and content.

> >

> > Will there be any classroom session if yes then who will take up

> the

> > classess.

> >

> > The teachers who would like to come forward should they be paid for

> > their service, if not how will the food and travel and accomodation

> > expenses be taken care of.

> >

> > I personally believe we need to have a teacher for any knowledge

> gain.

> >

> > Thanks & Regards

> > Vivek

>

>

>

[Guest guest]

Dear Sir,

 

A good idea for learning about Lalkitab. Pl. let us

know when it is going to be started and what will be

the carriculum.

Who will be our teachers and other things????

 

Manoj../

 

--- jyotish_mail <jyotish_mail wrote:

 

>

> Dear Members and Gurujans,

>

> We all would have a copy of lalkitab with us by now,

> if not please

> run and get it.

>

> And those who have it must be breaking our heads on

> it.

>

> Any way, this is a controversial topic and i want to

> tread on this

> very slowly.

>

> I would like to ask Punit to create a Vote on

> whether the members

> here want to have course or not.

>

> Will it be a classroom course or a corresponse

> course.

>

> Then how would the examination will be conducted.

>

> I believe the examination need to be in one

> place(closes to the place

> where all the learned members can come) atleast for

> the first batch

> and the exam needs not only to check not just the

> knowledge but also

> the haav bhaav of the student( could create a

> controversy/ but please

> avoid it now).

>

> What kind of Certificates be given to the students.

> Exact matter to

> be written on the certificate. This can be decided

> during the

> discussion in the group itself.

>

> What kind of fee structure be of the course. Will it

> be free or no

> profit no loss. How will the fees be decided,

> somebody who has some

> accouting knowledge can come up with some idea.

>

> Who all will be in the involved in the creation of

> the course

> structure and content.

>

> Will there be any classroom session if yes then who

> will take up the

> classess.

>

> The teachers who would like to come forward should

> they be paid for

> their service, if not how will the food and travel

> and accomodation

> expenses be taken care of.

>

> I personally believe we need to have a teacher for

> any knowledge gain.

>

> Thanks & Regards

> Vivek

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>