Guest guest Posted September 24, 2004 Report Share Posted September 24, 2004 Respected Bhatia Ji, Thank you for posting your article on DST and foreign births. While informative, I don't think it yet clears up some of the confusion that many of us foreign-borns have. For instance, you have placed Venus+Rahu in the lagna using the example cited (September 27, 1976 21:45 TORONTO, CAN), but using several software programs including Parashara's and online calculators, the planet formation comes out as follows: Jupiter - 1 Saturn - 3 Me/Ma/Su- 5 Ve/Ra - 6 Mo - 7 Ke - 12 This is because it is Taurus ascendant. Even if we take the 1 hour off of the 21:45pm time, then we are left with Taurus ascendant also, which would in both cases place Jupiter in lagna. This issue is very important to understand, so much so that I visited Pandit Som Dutt Ji in Toronto to get a kundli made, and while he first made it according to the planet formation listed, during the process he changed it to Gemini rising with Me/Ma/Sun in lagna. The planets that were in formation in India's skies were not the ones a native is born under in his foreign abode. The calculations of the Lal Kitab are all based on the planets exactly at the time of birth. If we say that only IST is relevant, then the items mentioned in the Lal Kitab(houses, kinds of trees, effects on neighbors, power outages during birth) should only be in effect in India (i.e: The native's ancestor's/parents home). Do you see the paradox we are facing? One the one hand, we say that Lal Kitab is universal in its application, but then we say that everything has to be engineered back to IST. I have checked the planet placements several times, and each time, the planets in the sky in India are NOT the same ones present over North America at the exact time of birth. This is not a negative post in any way, for I am indebted to you for the time and effort you have placed in bringing this issue to light with your article. What I am saying is that the impacts of Lal Kitab should be applied universally based on the planets at place of birth. I have taken your example and the native at hand does not exhibit any of the qualities mentioned with the planetary formation. Rather, he still exhibits the qualities of the planets I have mentioned above. Your seniority in this issue is much appreciated - do you have any further thoughts based on my post? Respectfully, Iqbal Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.