Further questions on aspects and issue of Benefic/Malefic

[Guest guest]

Group,

 

I write further to my post today on the above subject. I am going to

use my own natal chart for this:

 

 

1. Aspect Issue

===============

 

Hs #6 - Mar, Rahu

 

Hs #12 - Moon , Mer, Sat, Ket

 

 

6 aspects 12. When with Mar, as I quoted from Goswami & Vashistha

earlier, Rahu becomes dormant(if there are caveats I am not aware of

them). Therefore both Mar and Rahu or just Mar since Rahu is supposed

to be dormant, are aspecting planets in Hs #12 ?

 

 

2. House issue

==============

 

Since both Mar & Rahu are enemies of Mer and Hs #6 is Mer's house,

shouldnt both these planets be exmained starting with a presumption of

Malefic and then further examination be done to see if they are having

any malefic impact or not?

 

Look forward to the views of the learned members. Thanks in advance,

 

Rgards

 

 

 

R S

[Guest guest]

Respected Rakesh Ji,

You say

When a determination is being made about the benefic/malefic nature

of the planets in a tewa?

Ans:-

Pandit Ji Says in his book ( 1952 Edition) in Farmaan no.11

1. 2. 3.

Grah Malefic(maanda)when in Benefic when in

Jupiter H. No. 6, 7,10,11 H.No. 1 to 5th, 8,9,12

Sun H.No. 6, 7, 10 H.No. 1 to 5, 7,9,11,12.

Moon H.No. 6,8,10 to 12 H.No. 1 to 5, 7,9,11,12

Venus H.no. 1,6,9 H.no. 2 to 5, 7,8, 10 to 12

Mars H.no. 4, 8 H.no. 1 to 3, 5 to 7, 9 to 12

Merc. H.no.3, 8 to 12 H.no. 1,2,4,5,6,7

In no.9 not always malefic.

Saturn H.no. 1, 4 to 6 H.no. 3, 7 to 12

Rahu H.no.1,5, 7 to 12 H.no. 3,4,6

Ketu H.no. 3 to 6, 8 H.no. 1,2,7,9 to 12

 

No.1 = Grah-- It Means grah ghar main akela betha ho aur koi bhi

chor grah Kisi tarah ki drishti aadi se na dekh sakta ho.

Maaf kariyega meri choti si budhi main jo samajh me aya bata raha

hoon Koi truti ho to kshama karein. And I have a little knowledge of

English so forgive my bad English writing.

II

Firstly we check the position of planets

Hs #6 - Mar, Rahu

Are you only son or youngest in brothers?

Or If you have strained relation with brothers?

Are you have a mole or til on your Pvt.part?

Have you a bottle of champange in your house

( Kya aapke ghar mai Hare Rang ki bottle mai videshi sharab ya

perfume to nahi rakha)?

 

mudit982001.

Milten hain ek break ke bad

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

lalkitab , " rakeshsahgal " <rakeshsahgal>

wrote:

> Group,

>

> I write further to my post today on the above subject. I am going to

> use my own natal chart for this:

>

>

> 1. Aspect Issue

> ===============

>

> Hs #6 - Mar, Rahu

>

> Hs #12 - Moon , Mer, Sat, Ket

>

>

> 6 aspects 12. When with Mar, as I quoted from Goswami & Vashistha

> earlier, Rahu becomes dormant(if there are caveats I am not aware of

> them). Therefore both Mar and Rahu or just Mar since Rahu is

supposed

> to be dormant, are aspecting planets in Hs #12 ?

>

>

> 2. House issue

> ==============

>

> Since both Mar & Rahu are enemies of Mer and Hs #6 is Mer's house,

> shouldnt both these planets be exmained starting with a presumption

of

> Malefic and then further examination be done to see if they are

having

> any malefic impact or not?

>

> Look forward to the views of the learned members. Thanks in advance,

>

> Rgards

>

>

>

> R S

[Guest guest]

Mudit Sahib,

 

Ingrezi ko ingrezo ko mor(return) dete hai. hun kam di gal.

 

AGAR main aap ki patience test karun kyunki mujhe samajhne mein der

lagti hai to maaf karna, naya naya tajurbaa kar raha hoon.

 

Lets stick to the principles. Jawab khud dhoond loongaa - nahi to aap

ho hi, aapse phir sawaal kar loonga.

 

1. Aspects - Aap aspects ko consider karte hai apne analysis mein yaa

nahi? Do the others follow them too? The reason I ask is the few

analyses I have seen(not from you only but others too as well) seem to

focus on placement and not on aspects. Please do correct me if I am

wrong.

 

2. Planets when dormant with a particular planet e.g Rahu when with

Mars , such planets dont have any impact on the planets they aspect or

are conjoined with?

 

 

Philhaal bhai sahib itnaa hi. Aage agar zaroorat mahsoos hui to, aapko

takleef dene ki izzazat chahunga. As to your questions. I only cited

the example because it was the principle I was concerned with and it

was the obvious example.

 

Jawaab dene ke liye time nikaalne kaa bahut shukriyaa.

 

Warm Regards

 

 

R S

 

lalkitab , " mudit982001 " <mudit982001>

wrote:

> Respected Rakesh Ji,

> You say

> When a determination is being made about the benefic/malefic nature

> of the planets in a tewa?

> Ans:-

> Pandit Ji Says in his book ( 1952 Edition) in Farmaan no.11

> 1. 2. 3.

> Grah Malefic(maanda)when in Benefic when in

> Jupiter H. No. 6, 7,10,11 H.No. 1 to 5th, 8,9,12

> Sun H.No. 6, 7, 10 H.No. 1 to 5, 7,9,11,12.

> Moon H.No. 6,8,10 to 12 H.No. 1 to 5, 7,9,11,12

> Venus H.no. 1,6,9 H.no. 2 to 5, 7,8, 10 to 12

> Mars H.no. 4, 8 H.no. 1 to 3, 5 to 7, 9 to 12

> Merc. H.no.3, 8 to 12 H.no. 1,2,4,5,6,7

> In no.9 not always malefic.

> Saturn H.no. 1, 4 to 6 H.no. 3, 7 to 12

> Rahu H.no.1,5, 7 to 12 H.no. 3,4,6

> Ketu H.no. 3 to 6, 8 H.no. 1,2,7,9 to 12

>

> No.1 = Grah-- It Means grah ghar main akela betha ho aur koi bhi

> chor grah Kisi tarah ki drishti aadi se na dekh sakta ho.

> Maaf kariyega meri choti si budhi main jo samajh me aya bata raha

> hoon Koi truti ho to kshama karein. And I have a little knowledge

of

> English so forgive my bad English writing.

> II

> Firstly we check the position of planets

> Hs #6 - Mar, Rahu

> Are you only son or youngest in brothers?

> Or If you have strained relation with brothers?

> Are you have a mole or til on your Pvt.part?

> Have you a bottle of champange in your house

> ( Kya aapke ghar mai Hare Rang ki bottle mai videshi sharab ya

> perfume to nahi rakha)?

>

 

> mudit982001.

> Milten hain ek break ke bad

>

lalkitab , " rakeshsahgal " <rakeshsahgal>

> wrote:

> > Group,

> >

> > I write further to my post today on the above subject. I am going

to

> > use my own natal chart for this:

> >

> >

> > 1. Aspect Issue

> > ===============

> >

> > Hs #6 - Mar, Rahu

> >

> > Hs #12 - Moon , Mer, Sat, Ket

> >

> >

> > 6 aspects 12. When with Mar, as I quoted from Goswami & Vashistha

> > earlier, Rahu becomes dormant(if there are caveats I am not aware

of

> > them). Therefore both Mar and Rahu or just Mar since Rahu is

> supposed

> > to be dormant, are aspecting planets in Hs #12 ?

> >

> >

> > 2. House issue

> > ==============

> >

> > Since both Mar & Rahu are enemies of Mer and Hs #6 is Mer's house,

> > shouldnt both these planets be exmained starting with a

presumption

> of

> > Malefic and then further examination be done to see if they are

> having

> > any malefic impact or not?

> >

> > Look forward to the views of the learned members. Thanks in

advance,

> >

> > Rgards

> >

> >

> >

> > R S