Lagna Lord Moon in the 8th House-Issue of Malefic/Benefic

[Guest guest]

All the members

Sabse pahle main aap sabse mafi chahta hun kyonki maine bina arth ki

ek nyi bahas shuru kar di.

Members respected sh.Bhatia ji absolutely right.I bow my head in

front of him. Muje aur methods ko mix nahin karna chaiye tha.

sincerely

mudit982001

lalkitab , " rakeshsahgal " <rakeshsahgal>

wrote:

> Sir,

>

> When I joined the group and started going through the archives I

came

> across a mezssage from you which stated the benefic/malefic

positions

> of different planets in different houses which you reproduced for

the

> benefit of the group fromn the text(LK).

>

> However I have observed from your subsequent posts(please correct me

> if I am erring in understanding you) that you will not straight off

> make a call in categorising a particular planet either benefic or

> malefic without examining (a) the various caveats incorporated in

the

> text, and (b) the impact the planetary disposition is having on the

> individual.

>

> Insofar as the caveats in the text are concerned they can be checked

> for, by working out a check list so I wont ask you about that.

However

> I will be highly obliged if you will please comment upon your

> methodology for determining benefic/malefic disposition of a planet

by

> correlating it with prior events.

>

> If however I am failing to comprehend the right way to look at this

> entire issue I will be most grateful if you can show me the right

> path.

>

>

> Warm Regards

>

>

>

> Rakesh Sahgal

>

> lalkitab , Rajinder Bhatia

> <rajinderbhatia2002> wrote:

> > Sir,

> > In the context of LalKitab, the lord of the lagna (or any other

> house for that matter) carries absolutely no weight. Moon in the

> eighth is generally considered doubtful but one shouldn't make a

> judgement on its evil or benefic effects till other planetary

> positions have been considered. It can be a fantastic benefic if

> certain conditions are met in the horoscope.

> > Respectfully,

> > Rajinder Bhatia

> >

> > jyotish_mail <jyotish_mail> wrote:

> > Hi Mudit and other learned members of the group,

> >

> > If moon is alone in the eight house and also happens to be the

lord

> > of the lagna what are the remedies and ways of strengthning it.

> >

> > Regards

> > Siddharth

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > Mail is new and improved - Check it out!

[Guest guest]

Respected Mudit jee,

 

there is nothing to apologise for. jyotish ke sabhi methods ek doosre

ke poorak hai. methods mein koi virodhabhas nahi hai. I believe that

a person has to know vedic astrology well in order to appreciate Lal

Kitab paddhati. Lal Kitab ka adhyan aur bhi sarthak aur rochak ho

jayaga yadi aap vedic astrology ki drishti se bhi dekhen. Respected

Upadhyay jee to aksar dono vidhaon ko mila kar hi dekhte hain.

 

vaise aap ki apni ruchi par bhi nirbhar hai.

 

with respect to all the gurujan

 

bhuwan

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

lalkitab , " mudit982001 " <mudit982001>

wrote:

> All the members

> Sabse pahle main aap sabse mafi chahta hun kyonki maine bina arth

ki

> ek nyi bahas shuru kar di.

> Members respected sh.Bhatia ji absolutely right.I bow my head in

> front of him. Muje aur methods ko mix nahin karna chaiye tha.

> sincerely

> mudit982001

> lalkitab , " rakeshsahgal " <rakeshsahgal>

> wrote:

> > Sir,

> >

> > When I joined the group and started going through the archives I

> came

> > across a mezssage from you which stated the benefic/malefic

> positions

> > of different planets in different houses which you reproduced for

> the

> > benefit of the group fromn the text(LK).

> >

> > However I have observed from your subsequent posts(please correct

me

> > if I am erring in understanding you) that you will not straight

off

> > make a call in categorising a particular planet either benefic or

> > malefic without examining (a) the various caveats incorporated in

> the

> > text, and (b) the impact the planetary disposition is having on

the

> > individual.

> >

> > Insofar as the caveats in the text are concerned they can be

checked

> > for, by working out a check list so I wont ask you about that.

> However

> > I will be highly obliged if you will please comment upon your

> > methodology for determining benefic/malefic disposition of a

planet

> by

> > correlating it with prior events.

> >

> > If however I am failing to comprehend the right way to look at

this

> > entire issue I will be most grateful if you can show me the right

> > path.

> >

> >

> > Warm Regards

> >

> >

> >

> > Rakesh Sahgal

> >

> > lalkitab , Rajinder Bhatia

> > <rajinderbhatia2002> wrote:

> > > Sir,

> > > In the context of LalKitab, the lord of the lagna (or any other

> > house for that matter) carries absolutely no weight. Moon in the

> > eighth is generally considered doubtful but one shouldn't make a

> > judgement on its evil or benefic effects till other planetary

> > positions have been considered. It can be a fantastic benefic if

> > certain conditions are met in the horoscope.

> > > Respectfully,

> > > Rajinder Bhatia

> > >

> > > jyotish_mail <jyotish_mail> wrote:

> > > Hi Mudit and other learned members of the group,

> > >

> > > If moon is alone in the eight house and also happens to be the

> lord

> > > of the lagna what are the remedies and ways of strengthning it.

> > >

> > > Regards

> > > Siddharth

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > > Mail is new and improved - Check it out!

[Guest guest]

Respected bhuwan ji

Thanks,Meri hoslaa afzai ke liye shukriya.

mudit982001

lalkitab , " bhuwanvashishtha "

<bhuwanvashishtha> wrote:

> Respected Mudit jee,

>

> there is nothing to apologise for. jyotish ke sabhi methods ek

doosre

> ke poorak hai. methods mein koi virodhabhas nahi hai. I believe

that

> a person has to know vedic astrology well in order to appreciate

Lal

> Kitab paddhati. Lal Kitab ka adhyan aur bhi sarthak aur rochak ho

> jayaga yadi aap vedic astrology ki drishti se bhi dekhen. Respected

> Upadhyay jee to aksar dono vidhaon ko mila kar hi dekhte hain.

>

> vaise aap ki apni ruchi par bhi nirbhar hai.

>

> with respect to all the gurujan

>

> bhuwan

>

>

>

>

lalkitab , " mudit982001 " <mudit982001>

> wrote:

> > All the members

> > Sabse pahle main aap sabse mafi chahta hun kyonki maine bina arth

> ki

> > ek nyi bahas shuru kar di.

> > Members respected sh.Bhatia ji absolutely right.I bow my head in

> > front of him. Muje aur methods ko mix nahin karna chaiye tha.

> > sincerely

> > mudit982001

> > lalkitab , " rakeshsahgal "

<rakeshsahgal>

> > wrote:

> > > Sir,

> > >

> > > When I joined the group and started going through the archives

I

> > came

> > > across a mezssage from you which stated the benefic/malefic

> > positions

> > > of different planets in different houses which you reproduced

for

> > the

> > > benefit of the group fromn the text(LK).

> > >

> > > However I have observed from your subsequent posts(please

correct

> me

> > > if I am erring in understanding you) that you will not straight

> off

> > > make a call in categorising a particular planet either benefic

or

> > > malefic without examining (a) the various caveats incorporated

in

> > the

> > > text, and (b) the impact the planetary disposition is having on

> the

> > > individual.

> > >

> > > Insofar as the caveats in the text are concerned they can be

> checked

> > > for, by working out a check list so I wont ask you about that.

> > However

> > > I will be highly obliged if you will please comment upon your

> > > methodology for determining benefic/malefic disposition of a

> planet

> > by

> > > correlating it with prior events.

> > >

> > > If however I am failing to comprehend the right way to look at

> this

> > > entire issue I will be most grateful if you can show me the

right

> > > path.

> > >

> > >

> > > Warm Regards

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > > Rakesh Sahgal

> > >

> > > lalkitab , Rajinder Bhatia

> > > <rajinderbhatia2002> wrote:

> > > > Sir,

> > > > In the context of LalKitab, the lord of the lagna (or any

other

> > > house for that matter) carries absolutely no weight. Moon in the

> > > eighth is generally considered doubtful but one shouldn't make a

> > > judgement on its evil or benefic effects till other planetary

> > > positions have been considered. It can be a fantastic benefic if

> > > certain conditions are met in the horoscope.

> > > > Respectfully,

> > > > Rajinder Bhatia

> > > >

> > > > jyotish_mail <jyotish_mail> wrote:

> > > > Hi Mudit and other learned members of the group,

> > > >

> > > > If moon is alone in the eight house and also happens to be

the

> > lord

> > > > of the lagna what are the remedies and ways of strengthning

it.

> > > >

> > > > Regards

> > > > Siddharth

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > > Mail is new and improved - Check it out!

[Guest guest]

I see that more and more this group is becoming Hindi only. Can someone recomend another group in english where I can learn ?

 

Best Regards,

 

Alexandro De Montemayormudit982001 <mudit982001 wrote:

Respected bhuwan jiThanks,Meri hoslaa afzai ke liye shukriya. mudit982001 lalkitab , "bhuwanvashishtha" <bhuwanvashishtha> wrote:> Respected Mudit jee,> > there is nothing to apologise for. jyotish ke sabhi methods ek doosre > ke poorak hai. methods mein koi virodhabhas nahi hai. I believe that > a person has to know vedic astrology well in order to appreciate Lal > Kitab paddhati. Lal Kitab ka adhyan aur bhi sarthak aur rochak ho > jayaga yadi aap vedic astrology ki drishti se bhi dekhen. Respected > Upadhyay jee to aksar dono

vidhaon ko mila kar hi dekhte hain.> > vaise aap ki apni ruchi par bhi nirbhar hai.> > with respect to all the gurujan> > bhuwan> > > > > > > > > > > lalkitab , "mudit982001" <mudit982001> > wrote:> > All the members> > Sabse pahle main aap sabse mafi chahta hun kyonki maine bina arth > ki > > ek nyi bahas shuru kar di. > > Members respected sh.Bhatia ji absolutely right.I bow my head in > > front of him. Muje aur methods ko mix nahin karna chaiye tha. > >

sincerely> > mudit982001> > lalkitab , "rakeshsahgal" <rakeshsahgal> > > wrote:> > > Sir,> > > > > > When I joined the group and started going through the archives I > > came> > > across a mezssage from you which stated the benefic/malefic > > positions> > > of different planets in different houses which you reproduced for > > the> > > benefit of the group fromn the text(LK). > > > > > > However I have observed from your subsequent posts(please correct > me> >

> if I am erring in understanding you) that you will not straight > off> > > make a call in categorising a particular planet either benefic or> > > malefic without examining (a) the various caveats incorporated in > > the> > > text, and (b) the impact the planetary disposition is having on > the> > > individual. > > > > > > Insofar as the caveats in the text are concerned they can be > checked> > > for, by working out a check list so I wont ask you about that. > > However> > > I will be highly obliged if you will please comment upon your> > > methodology for determining benefic/malefic disposition of a > planet > > by> > > correlating it with prior events.> > > > > > If however I am failing to comprehend the right way to look at > this> > >

entire issue I will be most grateful if you can show me the right> > > path.> > > > > > > > > Warm Regards> > > > > > > > > > > > Rakesh Sahgal> > > > > > lalkitab , Rajinder Bhatia> > > <rajinderbhatia2002> wrote:> > > > Sir,> > > > In the context of LalKitab, the lord of the lagna (or any other> > > house for that matter) carries absolutely no weight. Moon in the> > > eighth is generally considered doubtful but one shouldn't make a> > > judgement on its evil or benefic effects till other planetary> > > positions have been considered. It can be a fantastic benefic if> > > certain conditions are met in the horoscope.> > > > Respectfully,> > > > Rajinder Bhatia> >

> > > > > > jyotish_mail <jyotish_mail> wrote:> > > > Hi Mudit and other learned members of the group,> > > > > > > > If moon is alone in the eight house and also happens to be the > > lord > > > > of the lagna what are the remedies and ways of strengthning it.> > > > > > > > Regards> > > > Siddharth> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Mail is new and improved - Check it out!

 

Mail is new and improved - Check it out!

[Guest guest]

It would be nice if could communicate in English more.

 

Just a request.

 

Regards

Siddharth

 

lalkitab , Alexandro de Montemayor

<alexandrodem> wrote:

> I see that more and more this group is becoming Hindi only. Can

someone recomend another group in english where I can learn ?

>

> Best Regards,

>

> Alexandro De Montemayor

>

> mudit982001 <mudit982001> wrote:

> Respected bhuwan ji

> Thanks,Meri hoslaa afzai ke liye shukriya.

> mudit982001

> lalkitab , " bhuwanvashishtha "

> <bhuwanvashishtha> wrote:

> > Respected Mudit jee,

> >

> > there is nothing to apologise for. jyotish ke sabhi methods ek

> doosre

> > ke poorak hai. methods mein koi virodhabhas nahi hai. I believe

> that

> > a person has to know vedic astrology well in order to appreciate

> Lal

> > Kitab paddhati. Lal Kitab ka adhyan aur bhi sarthak aur rochak

ho

> > jayaga yadi aap vedic astrology ki drishti se bhi dekhen.

Respected

> > Upadhyay jee to aksar dono vidhaon ko mila kar hi dekhte hain.

> >

> > vaise aap ki apni ruchi par bhi nirbhar hai.

> >

> > with respect to all the gurujan

> >

> > bhuwan

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > lalkitab , " mudit982001 "

<mudit982001>

> > wrote:

> > > All the members

> > > Sabse pahle main aap sabse mafi chahta hun kyonki maine bina

arth

> > ki

> > > ek nyi bahas shuru kar di.

> > > Members respected sh.Bhatia ji absolutely right.I bow my head

in

> > > front of him. Muje aur methods ko mix nahin karna chaiye tha.

> > > sincerely

> > > mudit982001

> > > lalkitab , " rakeshsahgal "

> <rakeshsahgal>

> > > wrote:

> > > > Sir,

> > > >

> > > > When I joined the group and started going through the

archives

> I

> > > came

> > > > across a mezssage from you which stated the benefic/malefic

> > > positions

> > > > of different planets in different houses which you

reproduced

> for

> > > the

> > > > benefit of the group fromn the text(LK).

> > > >

> > > > However I have observed from your subsequent posts(please

> correct

> > me

> > > > if I am erring in understanding you) that you will not

straight

> > off

> > > > make a call in categorising a particular planet either

benefic

> or

> > > > malefic without examining (a) the various caveats

incorporated

> in

> > > the

> > > > text, and (b) the impact the planetary disposition is having

on

> > the

> > > > individual.

> > > >

> > > > Insofar as the caveats in the text are concerned they can be

> > checked

> > > > for, by working out a check list so I wont ask you about

that.

> > > However

> > > > I will be highly obliged if you will please comment upon your

> > > > methodology for determining benefic/malefic disposition of a

> > planet

> > > by

> > > > correlating it with prior events.

> > > >

> > > > If however I am failing to comprehend the right way to look

at

> > this

> > > > entire issue I will be most grateful if you can show me the

> right

> > > > path.

> > > >

> > > >

> > > > Warm Regards

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > > Rakesh Sahgal

> > > >

> > > > lalkitab , Rajinder Bhatia

> > > > <rajinderbhatia2002> wrote:

> > > > > Sir,

> > > > > In the context of LalKitab, the lord of the lagna (or any

> other

> > > > house for that matter) carries absolutely no weight. Moon in

the

> > > > eighth is generally considered doubtful but one shouldn't

make a

> > > > judgement on its evil or benefic effects till other planetary

> > > > positions have been considered. It can be a fantastic

benefic if

> > > > certain conditions are met in the horoscope.

> > > > > Respectfully,

> > > > > Rajinder Bhatia

> > > > >

> > > > > jyotish_mail <jyotish_mail> wrote:

> > > > > Hi Mudit and other learned members of the group,

> > > > >

> > > > > If moon is alone in the eight house and also happens to be

> the

> > > lord

> > > > > of the lagna what are the remedies and ways of

strengthning

> it.

> > > > >

> > > > > Regards

> > > > > Siddharth

> > > > >

> > > > >

> > > > >

> > > > >

> > > > > Mail is new and improved - Check it out!

>

>

>

[Guest guest]

Bhuwan ji, Mudit ji,

 

Even I your view. I myself analyze horosocope based on KP, Lal Kitab and classical astrology. But for the sake of learning Lal Kitab, it would be great to stick to Lal Kitab priciples only.

 

Regards,

 

Punit Pandeybhuwanvashishtha <bhuwanvashishtha wrote:

Respected Mudit jee,there is nothing to apologise for. jyotish ke sabhi methods ek doosre ke poorak hai. methods mein koi virodhabhas nahi hai. I believe that a person has to know vedic astrology well in order to appreciate Lal Kitab paddhati. Lal Kitab ka adhyan aur bhi sarthak aur rochak ho jayaga yadi aap vedic astrology ki drishti se bhi dekhen. Respected Upadhyay jee to aksar dono vidhaon ko mila kar hi dekhte hain.vaise aap ki apni ruchi par bhi nirbhar hai.with respect to all the gurujanbhuwanlalkitab , "mudit982001" <mudit982001> wrote:> All the members> Sabse pahle main aap sabse mafi chahta hun kyonki maine bina arth ki > ek nyi bahas shuru kar di. > Members respected sh.Bhatia ji absolutely right.I bow my

head in > front of him. Muje aur methods ko mix nahin karna chaiye tha. > sincerely> mudit982001> lalkitab , "rakeshsahgal" <rakeshsahgal> > wrote:> > Sir,> > > > When I joined the group and started going through the archives I > came> > across a mezssage from you which stated the

benefic/malefic > positions> > of different planets in different houses which you reproduced for > the> > benefit of the group fromn the text(LK). > > > > However I have observed from your subsequent posts(please correct me> > if I am erring in understanding you) that you will not straight off> > make a call in categorising a particular planet either benefic or> > malefic without examining (a) the various caveats incorporated in > the> > text, and (b) the impact the planetary disposition is having on the> > individual. > > > > Insofar as the caveats in the text are concerned they can be checked> > for, by working out a check list so I wont ask you about that. > However> > I will be highly obliged if you will please comment upon your> > methodology for determining benefic/malefic disposition of a

planet > by> > correlating it with prior events.> > > > If however I am failing to comprehend the right way to look at this> > entire issue I will be most grateful if you can show me the right> > path.> > > > > > Warm Regards> > > > > > > > Rakesh Sahgal> > > > lalkitab , Rajinder Bhatia> > <rajinderbhatia2002> wrote:> > > Sir,> > > In the context of LalKitab, the lord of the lagna (or any other> > house for that matter) carries absolutely no weight. Moon in the> > eighth is generally considered doubtful but one shouldn't make a> > judgement on its evil or benefic effects till other planetary> > positions have been considered. It can be a fantastic benefic if> > certain conditions are met in the horoscope.>

> > Respectfully,> > > Rajinder Bhatia> > > > > > jyotish_mail <jyotish_mail> wrote:> > > Hi Mudit and other learned members of the group,> > > > > > If moon is alone in the eight house and also happens to be the > lord > > > of the lagna what are the remedies and ways of strengthning it.> > > > > > Regards> > > Siddharth> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Mail is new and improved - Check it out!