The Kulbir Bains Controversy

[Guest guest]

Respected Members

 

I am following the whole " KULBIR BAINS CONTROVERSY "

with a great interest. If on the one hand I am a firm

believer that the language in these sort of special

forums must be polite, on the other hand I must say

that if any member do not follow the principle of

using the polite language, there is no need to treat

him like a criminal, we can try to convince him/her

with the strong logics, by answering all his/her

queries, by removing all his/her doubts, by providing

him the authentic examples, and moreover by providing

him the correct answers.

 

Mr. Kubir has has not commited any crime by

eastablishing a so-called imaginary relation between

Holi and Shukra+Budh Mushtarka=Sun equation, why cant

we take it as a matter of research ?

 

Tell me how many people believed the theory of the

ancient scientists regarding the Ball type shape of

the earth ? Many of these scientists were punished and

even killed by the rulers of that time.

 

I have seen in this very forum that the recommended

remedial measure are sometime not conform to the

Lal-Kitab, but believe me they still works.

 

For example There is no refrence of Quantity of Lead

(Sikka) in the legendary Lal-kitab which we use to

immerse in the running water in Rahu in 11th house

scenario, Gurujan recommend 4-kgs and sometime 8-kgs.

Does this means they are wrong ? " NO " they are

certainly not because there is a lot of ambiguities in

that book as far as these sort of explanations are

concerned. (I have the Original Urdu copy of the

legendary Lal-Kitab with me, and I can read & write

Urdu better than Hindi or English)

 

The purpose of all what I have said is that the

experts have made certain standards in absence of

clear guidelines in the Lal-Kitab, thay have invented

so many new Karkas for various valid reasons through

their study of the subject and researchs.

 

I want to assure you I am not advocating anyone, what

I am trying to advocate is that if someone brought

about a new idea, new thought, new Karka, or a new

research he should be provided a chance to prove

himself not that he should be outrightly rejected,

discouraged, and condemned.

 

We may have the difference of opinon, but for what

these forms are for ? to discuss, to discuss and to

discuss.

 

I agree that Kulbir Singh's language was unacceptable

to many, but, what about the language of the others in

response to this matter ? Can Anybody justify that ?

 

I would like to request to all of the members to try

to understand the soul behind Mr. Kulbir Singhs

outburst. He seems to be a person of a strong

conviction although still needs some quality

education of the subject.

 

Finally, I will request all the learned members of the

forum to refrain themselve from these sort of

controversies and try to help the people who are

suffering due to one reason or another. One such

fellow Mr. Nekibur Rehman is requesting time and again

for your help but noone is seems to listening him. For

God sake Please listen him.

 

 

Yograj Prabhakar

(Patiala).

0175-5002279, 0175-3092768,98159-92768.