lal kitab discussion kulbir singh jee

[Guest guest]

respected Kulbir Singh Jee,

 

aapne kaha hai, " on asking as to which of the two starts the 35 years

> cycle, he just smiled and said look for yourself. "

 

aapne kabhi socha ki us viddwan ne aisa kyon kaha? aap ko uttar kyon

nahi diya?... kabhi sochiye ?

 

With respect to all the gurus,

 

bhuwan

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

lalkitab , ceeta bains <ceetabains> wrote:

> Pandey ji,

> thanks for your reply but i was expecting something

> better from you. As advised I have gone through the

> message no 85 by mr. Bhatia. Just wish you, yoursel

> had read it before recommending. Does it makes any

> sense. Even a noice could have said better.Is it the

> stuff which one expects from a discussion forum of

> experts. I was looking for an eloborate and expert

> opininon. 35 sala chakra is an integral part of

> phaladesh of lal kitab. one of the experts in this

> field did tell me that the planet of birth time and

> the planet of birthday start this 35 sala chakra. on

> asking as to which of the two starts the 35 years

> cycle, he just smiled and said look for yourself. I

> have seen him using this system with great accuracy in

> predictions. that's why i was looking towards you for

> help. i have many many riddles from this divine book.

> I must say Mr. pandey you let me down. try to be

> honest, if you know guide me and if you don't know

> let's find it together. kindly lt me know if you have

> any better answer than this silly message no 85.

>

> sorry but let's call spade a spade.

> sincerely in quest

> Kulbir

>

> Punit Pandey <punitp@g...> wrote:

> > Kulbir ji,

> >

> > I want to request you to go through the archive of

> > this forum. You will find many interesting and

> > useful discussion there. The issue was raised

> > previously and answered by Bhatia ji. Instead of

> > writing my own version I want to quote him here

> > (message number 85) -

> >

> >

> > Unfortunately, none of the Lal Kitab editions goes

> > into too many details on this repetitive cycle of 35

> > years.

> > There are two distinct issues here. One is the 35

> > year repetitive cycle and the other is " mahadasha "

> > according to Lal Kitab. Interestingly, the number of

> > years of Mahadasha period for each planet is the

> > same as the classical Vinshottari dasha. In LK,

> > Mahadasha is used in somewhat negative connotation.

> > Perhaps the 1942 edition carries the most amount of

> > detail. Over the years, Pt Roop Chand ji stopped

> > emphasizing the importance of Mahadasha and used it

> > very rarely. The 35-year cycle was always used by

> > him and Pt Som Dutt uses it quite a bit.

> > Respectfully,

> > Rajinder Bhatia

> >

> > Hope you will find it useful.

> >

> > Regards,

> >

> > Punit Pandey

> >

> >

> >

> > Kulbir Singh Bains <ceetabains> wrote:

> >

> > Let's strat with

> > Topic no.1

> >

> > How do we know as to which planet is the starting

> > planet of 35 sala chakra

> >

> > It has been written in the para 4 page 10 Arun

> > sahinta lal kitab hare

> > krishan trust under title " 35 sala chakkar "

> > that this 35 year cycle may start i.e. from the

> > birth day with planet

> > jupiter and can also start with saturn in some other

> > cases (same is

> > written in all other books on al kitab including one

> > by vashisht)

> > my simple querry is that how do we conclude as to

> > which planet starts

> > the 35 year cycle from the birth day, is there any

> > methodology for it.

> >

> > I have been asking this question to many starwalts

> > but to no avail,

> > sincerely hope that you may help me out.

> >

> > In anticipation

> > kulbir

> >

> >

> >

> >