GUY YOUR CLARIFICATION attn: chamakkam ji

[Guest guest]

Dear vinod ji ,

 

In my message # 1071 of wed, march 3,2004 I had written ..copied and

pasted...

 

 

 

Dear Guy,

 

There is a table which gives the placement of planets for birth

years. Make sure you have that table. All standard books on Lal Kitab

carry that table.

 

your 34th year placements are :

 

mesh :

brishabh : sun , mer

mithun : ketu

kark :

sinha :

kanya ; rahu

tula ; shani

vrish : guru , mangal

dhanu :

makar:

kumbha: chandra

meen : shukra

 

 

****************

 

Now the placements that you have given are exactly the same that I

had given. I don't see the difference.

 

You have said :

 

> Also the 34th year Placement by Mr. Upadhyaji seems to be some typo

error because Jup and mars in 5H in natal will go to Vrishchik if

Year consideration is 33 same with Sat, Sun+Merc,

 

{ for the 34th year the planets in the 5th stay in the 5th ie scorpio,

Saturn from natal mesh [10H]goes to tula [4H],similarly sun and merc

from makar [7H] go to brishabh [11H]. Thats what I had shown.

 

you have further said :

 

 

 

Ven in Meen and Moon in Kumbha can not be as per 34th year

 

{ Natal venus from dhanu[6H]moves to meen [9H]and natal moon brishabh

[11H] moves to kumbha [8H]....that's exactly the 34th year placement.

 

I don't quite see where did I go wrong.?

 

sincerely,

 

upadhyay

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

lalkitab , vinod kumar <chamakkam2003>

wrote:

>

> Dear Guy:

>

> Your Birth particulars are 5 Feb 1971 (5.2.1971) 4:46 pm, Chennai

>

> As per this your Natal chart would be:

>

> Lagna---Cancer

>

> 1H---Nil

>

> 2H—Ketu

>

> 3H—Nil

>

> 4H—Nil

>

> 5H—Jup and Mars

>

> 6H—Ven

>

> 7H—Sun and Merc

>

> 8H—Rahu

>

> 9H—Nil

>

> 10H—Sat

>

> 11H—Moon

>

> 12H—Nil

>

> Annual Chart for 34 (Running year) as per Lal Kitab would be:

>

> 1H—Nil

>

> 2H—Nil

>

> 3H—Rahu

>

> 4H—Sat

>

> 5H—Jup and Mars

>

> 6H—Nil

>

> 7H—Nil

>

> 8H—Moon

>

> 9H—Ven

>

> 10H—Nil

>

> 11H—Sun and Merc

>

> 12H—Ketu

>

> Where you are doing mistake:

>

> You are taking sign as house like you are taking Ven in 9th Rashi

(sagitarious) and thus under coloumn of Annual chart for 34 Year

under coloum of 9 you have place Venus in 1 (Mesh rasi) where as take

Venus in 6H (From cancer lagna venus would be in 6H of course in 9

rasi) now if you see under the coloum of 6 you will find that Venus

would be in 9H.

>

> Take another example of Sun and Merc which is in 7H (10 rashi

capricorn) now again you have placed in Kataka because you have

considered Sun and Merc in 10H and not in 7H.So when you consider it

in 7H you will find the CORRECT position in 11H in 34 year Annual

chart.

>

> I think now it is clear where you are doing mistake.

>

> Also the 34th year Placement by Mr. Upadhyaji seems to be some typo

error because Jup and mars in 5H in natal will go to Vrishchik if

Year consideration is 33 same with Sat, Sun+Merc,

>

> Ven in Meen and Moon in Kumbha can not be as per 34th year

>

> Regards

>

>

>

> Vinod

>

>

>

>

>

> Search - Find what you're looking for faster.